Free Sur-Reply Brief - District Court of Delaware - Delaware


File Size: 44.4 kB
Pages: 2
Date: March 1, 2007
File Format: PDF
State: Delaware
Category: District Court of Delaware
Author: unknown
Word Count: 323 Words, 2,197 Characters
Page Size: 612 x 794 pts
URL

https://www.findforms.com/pdf_files/ded/37215/28.pdf

Download Sur-Reply Brief - District Court of Delaware ( 44.4 kB)


Preview Sur-Reply Brief - District Court of Delaware
Ca€e1seO6t@;6·—©D6B'B£E3TI\AS*-LPBoc1JDrumru1r12én2 28 Fi|é`ci||®2AE’/%)’QIZ>O7 Pa§’a@0T bf 2
IN THE UNITED STATES DISTRICT COURT
FOR THE DISTRICT OF DELAWARE
STKK€(‘i"i§i§T"€x?"fK§“E”r@‘RiiE €”TvT" )
)
Plaintiff, )
)
v. ) C. A. No. 06-627 (***)
)
)
CIF LICENSING, LLC, D/BJA GE LICENSING )
)
Defendant, )
V- )
)
STMTCROELECTRONICS, INC. )
)
Cross-Claim Defendant. )
,,,,, MTL, ,.,,,, l
VALEO’S SURREPLY T0 STM’S REPLY ON ITS RULE 12(b)(6)
MOTION TO DISMKSS VALEO’S FKRST AMENDED COMPLAINT
Plaintiff Valeo Sistemas Electricos SA. de C.V. ("Valeo") submits this short surreply to
address a new factual argument made in STl\/Ps reply. Therein STM asserts that (D.], 23, at 4 ri.
2),
Although not material to this [STM’s] motion, it is worth noting that
STMicroelectronics did not provide VSE {Valeo] with the voltage
regulators in the accused alternators. it provided only the chips to be
incorporated into the voltage regulators.
This factual assertion is incorrect. indeed, STM asserted/admitted in its opening brief (DJ. 19 at
3) that this chip is the "voltage regulator" referred to in Valeo’s complaint — "STl\/licroelectronios
manufactures various semiconductor component parts for use in other products, including a
semiconductor component part characterized as rz ‘v0lmge regulation in VSE’s [Valeo’s]
complaint (the ‘Cornplaint’)." (emphasis added).

Ca€e1QeO6z@;6·—©D6B'B£E3TI\AS*-LPBOc1JDrumru1r12én2 28 Fi|é`ci||®2AE’/%)’QDO7 Pa§a@e¤2 bf 2
MORRIS, NICHOLS, ARSHT & "1`UNNELL LLP
/s/ Karen Jacobs Lcaden
Jack B. Blumenfeld (#1014)
Karen Jacobs Lcuden (#2881)
1<[email protected]
OF COUNSEL: 1201 N. Market Street
P.O. Box 1347
Arthur 1. Neustadt Wilmington, DE 19801
.Iean—1’au1 Lavaileye (302) 65 8—9200
Aarti Shah Atfarneysfar Plafntw
Richard T. Matthews Vafea Sistemas Elecrricas SA. de C. V
OBLON, SPIVAK, MCCLELLAND,
MAIER & NBUSTADT, P.C.
13940 Duke Street
Alexandria, VA 22314
(703) 4138000
February 28, 2007
752536.1
2