Free Motion for Summary Judgment - District Court of Delaware - Delaware

Case 1 :04-cv-01416-JJF Document 70-19 Filed O1/30/2006 Page 1 0f 4
IN THE UNITED STATES DISTRICT COURT ’ I
FOR THE DISTRICT OF DELAWARE .
> 1
_ UNITED STATES OF AMERICA ) 1
for the Use and Benefit 0f )
JERSEY SHORE AUTOMATION, INC. ) ` .
> 1
Plaintifi )
) C. A. N0. O4-1416 (JJF)
vs. )
)
CHU GACH SUPPORT SERVICES, INC., et al. )
) .
Defendants )
)
EXHIBIT 8
TO ,
. BRIEF OF DEFENDANTS
CHUGACH SUPPORT SERVICES, INC. `
AND SAFECO INSURANCE COMPANY OF AMERICA
1 . IN SUPPORT OF SUPPLEMENTAL MOTION
1 FOR SUMMARY JUDGMENT ON THE COMPLAINT AND THE I
1 COUNTERCLAIM

. Case 1:04-cv-O1416¢JUlf Document 70-19 Filed O1/3072006 Page 2 of 4
IN THE UNITED STATES DISTRICT COURT
FOR THE DISTRICT OF DELAWARE
UNITED STATES OF AMERICA, for )
the Use and Benefit of JERSEY SHORE )
AUTOMATION, INC., a New Jersey )
l corporation, )
i ’
. A Plaintyjf ) C.A. NO. O4·l4l6 (UF)
) .
v. ) .
) .
CHUGACH SUPPORT SERVICES, )
INC., an Alaska corporation, and SAFECO ) .
INSURANCE COMPANY OF AMERICA, ) - l
a Washington corporation, )
) l
Ddendarzts. ) i
PLAINTIFF JERSEY SI~IORE’S RULE 26(a)(1)
FIRST SUPPLEMENTAL INITIAL DISCLOSURES
Pursuant to Fed. R. Civ. P. 26(a)(l), Plaintiff Jersey Shore Automation, Inc. ("JSA")
supplements its initial disclosures dated April 22, 2005. The disclosures made herein are limited
·--· ·- ·~ -··---·--·~---·-·-·· to-the-·information-~available···to-»J~SAat--theipresentrtime. ..... J SA..rnay.supplenient.and/or...amei1d...these .................... ................ ..
responses based upon additional information that it later obtains. JSA expressly and specifically i
does not waive any attorney—client privilege, work—product protection, or other applicable
privilege through these disclosures.
C. Damages
· l. $685,194.15 because Chugach incorrectly used RS Means cost data when it
_ should have used UPG cost data, which reflects local conditions, in estimating
and contracting for the work in issue.
2. $395,557.99 for work performed by JSA’s subcontractors and materials delivered i
by JSA’s suppliers, but not paid by Chugach. l

.. Case 1:04-cv-01 41 Document 70-19 Filed 01/3072006 Page 3 of 4 ,
`8 * ’ V.‘. ’
3. $281,767.38 for balance of unpaid percentage of work completed based ‘upon
- contract amount.
4. $22,3 60.21 for materials purchased and stored on site for use with work.
5. $132,000.00 based upon 50% of remaining contract value of services to be
provided directly by J SA.
6. Interest in an amount to be established at trial calculated at the rates specified in
the Master Subcontracting Agreement 11 4.2 for payments to JSA not in
A accordance with the payment terms. The most current rate is published in the
Federal Register, Volume 70, Ntunber 126, Page 38253, dated Friday, July 1,
2005. For complete rates see http://www.publicdebt.treas.gov/opd/opdpr1nt2.htm.
7. Interest in excess of $48,000 to date on obligations incurred by JSA by reason of

Chugach’s delays and defaults in payment which caused JSA to tinance the on- 1
. 1
going construction. {
· I
E. Reservation of Rights to Supplement Disclosures {
1
. . . . ._lS.A 1·€Sgpvg,g..thg..I:ig];t..tO..Supp]gm5nt.the$@..;7e,3pg;1g53., ...................................................................... . ............................... . ........... . . .. ....... E
y A CONNOLLY BOVE LODGE & HUTZ LLP
~
i /s/ James D. Heisman
James D. Heisman (# 2746)
M. Edward Danberg (# 2245)
1007 N. Orange Street
_ P. O. Box 2207
Wilmington, DE 19899 · ·
(302) 658-9141
Attomeysfor Jersey Shore Automcztiorz, Inc. i
Dated: August 25, 2005
— 2 - 413538

1
.· Case 1 :04-cv-01416¤JJF Document 70-19 Filed 01/3072006 Page 4 of 4
· ‘ ` l
CERTIFICATE OF SERVICE
1, James D. Heisman, hereby certify that on this 25m day of August, 2005, I caused a true
and correct copy ofthe foregoing Plaintiff Jersey Sh01·e’s Rule 26(a)(1) First Supplemental
Initial Disclosures to be served upon counsel of record in the manner indicated below:
Wa Hand-Delivery Via Facsimile & Email
Edmund D. Lyons, Jr., Esquire Harvey A. Levin, Esquire
· The Lyons Law Firm Birch, Horton, Bittner and Cherot _
j 1526 Gilpin Avenue 1 15 Connecticut Ave., N.W. `
J Wilmington, DE 19806 Suite 1200
r Washington, DC 20036
/s/ James D. Heisman
" James D. Heisman (# 2746) `
l
...... . ..... . ..... . ...... . ....................... . ...................... . ...........,.......................................................,......,,,,_.,__,,,,,_.,_____,_,_,_,_,,,___,_____,,_,,___ _ ,,__,,,,.,____, __,,____,_,__,_,__, , __,__ _____ _ ___, ____ __ __,____ _ ___,__,__,____ , ________,_,_,,_____ _ ,____ _ _____,______,__,_________,______________,______________________ _ ______________,_______ l
- 3 — 413538