Case 1:04-cv-01339-SLR
Document 172-10
EXHIBIT I
Filed 05/20/2008
Page 1 of 1
Section III.B - Excessive Hours Spent on Letter Identifying 36 Documents for In Camera Review
Entries from April 18-19, 2007 Entry Hours 7.0 Hours Claimed 1.0 1.0
Date
Attorney
Description
Hourly Rate $621.00
Total
4/18/2007 Sparks PTO; order to compel; preparation Sparks Total Revise PTO, confirm facts in PTO, conference calls re PTO, review privileges re MTC Order, draft letter, revise PTO Finalize PTO, finish letter to Court re privilege log, review new Weil documents, respond to Boyle e-mail re letters to Court,
Objections Arbitrary allocation of time and description is too vague to determine if $621.00 allocation is reasonable (§ II.C). $621.00
4/18/2007
Hirzel
11.1
3.0
$280.00
Arbitrary allocation of time and description is too vague to determine if $840.00 allocation is reasonable (§ II.C).
4/19/2007 Hirzel Total
Hirzel
8.2
2.0 5.0
$280.00
$560.00 Arbitrary allocation of time (§ II.C). $1,400.00
Timekeeper A. Gilchrist Sparks III Samuel T. Hirzel II Total
Hours Claimed Total 1.0 $ 621.00 5.0 $ 1,400.00 6.0 $2,021.00
264931
1 of 1