Free Motion for Attorney Fees - District Court of California - California

Case 3:08-cv-00082-IEG-RBB

Document 8-3

Filed 03/20/2008

Page 1 of 12

LYNN HUBBARD, III, SBN 69773 SCOTTLYNN J HUBBARD IV, SBN 212970 2 DISABLED ADVOCACY GROUP, APLC 12 Williamsburg Lane 3 Chico, CA 95926 Telephone: (530) 895-3252 4 Fax: (530) 894-8244
1 5 6 7 8 9 10 11 12 13 14 15 16 17 18 19 20 21 22 23 24 25 26 27 28
Declaration of Lynn Hubbard, III, in Support of Kohler's M otion for Attorneys' Fees

Attorneys for Plaintiff Chris Kohler

UNITED STATES DISTRICT COURT SOUTHERN DISTRICT OF CALIFORNIA CHRIS KOHLER, Plaintiff, v. THE VONS COMPANIES, INC., Defendant. / Case No. 08cv0082 IEG (RBB) Declaration of Lynn Hubbard, III, in Support of Kohler's Motion for Attorneys' Fees and Costs Date: April 28, 2008 Time: 10:30 a.m. Ctrm: 1, 4th Floor Honorable Irma E. Gonzalez [No Oral Argument Requested by the Court] Unless

-1-

Kohler v. The Vons Companies, Inc. 08cv0082 IEG (RBB)

Case 3:08-cv-00082-IEG-RBB

Document 8-3

Filed 03/20/2008

Page 2 of 12

1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 9 10 11 12 13 14 15 16 17 18 19 20 21 22 23 24 25 26 27 28

I, Lynn Hubbard, III, declare that I am duly licensed to practice in all the courts in the State of California, and if called as a witness and duly sworn, I would and could competently testify to the following based on my own personal knowledge: SUMMARY OF THE CASE 1. This is a civil rights case for denial of access to a place of public

accommodation and for failure to remove architectural barriers in violation of the Americans with Disabilities Act of 1990 (ADA), and California state laws. Plaintiff Chris Kohler ("plaintiff") sought injunctive relief, damages and attorneys' fees including litigation expenses and costs, pursuant to the ADA, 42 U.S.C. §12101, et seq., California Civil Code §§51, 51.5, and §§54, et seq., and California Health & Safety Code §19955, et seq. 2. I am familiar with the procedure for entering time and cost entries at the

Disabled Advocacy Group, APLC, viz., a software program called TimeSlips. Attorneys and paralegals are instructed to record their time spent on a file immediately (or as soon as they are able). PLAINTIFF'S FEE REQUEST 3. Plaintiff's attorneys' fees and costs calculate to $7,008.50. This amount

includes $6,625.50 in attorney and paralegal fees and $383.00 in costs. These fees and costs were actually incurred, and were reasonable and necessary to effectively prosecute this case. 4. In achieving the relief described above, plaintiff's counsel spent a total

of 23.75 hours, as follows: Lynn Hubbard Scottlynn Hubbard Paralegals 16.95 hours @ $350/hr = 0.60 hours @ $225/hr = 6.20 hours @ $90/hr = Total 5. $ 5,932.50 $ $ 135.00 558.00

$ 6,625.50

Attached hereto as Exhibit "A" is an itemization of attorney and
-2Kohler v. The Vons Companies, Inc. 08cv0082 IEG (RBB)

Declaration of Lynn Hubbard, III, in Support of Kohler's M otion for Attorneys' Fees

Case 3:08-cv-00082-IEG-RBB

Document 8-3

Filed 03/20/2008

Page 3 of 12

1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 9 10 11 12 13 14 15 16 17 18 19 20 21 22 23 24 25 26 27 28

paralegal time. This exhibit accurately reports the itemized tasks performed by counsel and counsel's personnel as contemporaneously recorded and maintained by the Disabled Advocacy Group, APLC. 6. As the Court may be aware, compensatory damage awards in disability

access litigation are traditionally small in comparison to the equitable results achieved; as such, statutory attorneys' fees are essential to enforce anti-discrimination statutes. Recovery of statutory public interest attorneys' fees is a primary source of income for this office. 7. My billing rate for services performed in non-complex litigation is $350

per hour. This rate is based upon my education, knowledge and experience as a litigation strategist and trial lawyer, my years of practice, and my success rate. I charge $175 per hour for travel time. QUALIFICATIONS OF PLAINTIFF'S COUNSEL 8. I graduated from Western State University College of Law and was

admitted to the California bar in 1976. 9. 10. 11. I have been a trial attorney for over 30 years. I have conducted in excess of 250 jury trials during my career. I have received recognition from the California Trial Lawyers

Association (1986) as a "plaintiff's personal injury" and "experienced trial" attorney. 12. In 1982 and 1987, I was certified by the State Bar California as a

specialist in the field of criminal law. 13. 14. I have over eight published decisions. I have litigated in excess of 500 ADA/Title 24 cases. My office

represents the disabled in the Eastern, Central and Southern Districts of California. 15. For the last eight years, more than 95% of my practice is and has been

dedicated to protecting the rights of the disabled. The balance of my practice (5%) is devoted to selective cases wherein I feel the rights of an individual or a group of individuals have been adversely affected through no fault of their own. The 5%
Declaration of Lynn Hubbard, III, in Support of Kohler's M otion for Attorneys' Fees Kohler v. The Vons Companies, Inc. 08cv0082 IEG (RBB)

-3-

Case 3:08-cv-00082-IEG-RBB

Document 8-3

Filed 03/20/2008

Page 4 of 12

1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 9 10 11 12 13 14 15 16 17 18 19 20 21 22 23 24 25 26 27 28

balance of my practice rarely leads to the recovery of fees and/or costs. 16. Our office has handled over 500 access actions resulting in the removal

of architectural barriers to make the public accommodation accessible. 17. I have authored videotapes and related workbooks on the preparation of

plaintiffs for depositions. 18. My office is currently comprised of myself, two associate attorneys, one

paralegal, a receptionist and a financial officer. 19. While my office is small, the hiring of associate attorneys and paralegal

staff in today's highly competitive legal marketplace has increased my office's financial burdens. Rising salaries demanded by associates in California, along with paralegal staff, affect the cost burden associated with the overall legal community in Chico, California. 20. A summary of the qualifications of my associates and paralegals who

worked on the case is as follows: Paralegals: The individuals listed below meet either of two criteria under Business and Professions Code Section 6450 for paralegals: (1) They hold a baccalaureate degree or an advanced degree in any subject, and have a minimum of one year of law-related experience under the supervision of an attorney who has been an active member of the State Bar of California for at least the preceding three years or who has practiced in the federal courts of California for at least the preceding three years; or (2) They are a high school graduate and have a minimum of three years of law-related experience under the supervision of an attorney who has been an active member of the State Bar of California for at least the preceding three years or who has practiced in the federal courts of California for at least the preceding three years. These individuals are qualified to perform paralegal tasks, and I bill $90 per hour for their time.
Declaration of Lynn Hubbard, III, in Support of Kohler's M otion for Attorneys' Fees Kohler v. The Vons Companies, Inc. 08cv0082 IEG (RBB)

-4-

Case 3:08-cv-00082-IEG-RBB

Document 8-3

Filed 03/20/2008

Page 5 of 12

1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 9 10 11 12 13 14 15 16 17 18 19 20 21 22 23 24 25 26 27 28

Crista Duncan - Crista Duncan graduated from Paradise High School in June of 2002, and immediately began working for the Law Offices of Chris Atherton (until June 2003). In July of 2003, Ms. Duncan was hired by the Law Offices of Lynn Hubbard, where she has held several positions of increasing responsibility. She completed the paralegal studies extension program at University of California - Davis (which program meets the paralegal requirements as outlined in Business & Professions Code Section 6450(c)(2)), and received her paralegal certificate in December 2005. During her tenure at my firm, she has been under my supervision, and is qualified to perform paralegal tasks. Kaina Murray-Schukei - Kaina Murray-Schukei graduated from Shasta High School in June of 2000. She was hired by the Law Offices of Lynn Hubbard in June of 2005 as a calendar clerk, working her way up to the position of legal secretary, and finally, to Paralegal. She completed the Paralegal Studies Program at the University of California at Davis (whose program meets the paralegal requirements as outlined in the Business & Professions Code Section 6450 (c)(2)), and received her paralegal certificate in May 2007. During her tenure at my firm, she has been under my supervision, and is qualified to perform paralegal tasks. 21. A true and accurate itemization of costs incurred by my office in the

prosecution of this matter are as follows: Court Fees Process Servers Total: 22. $350.00 $33.00 $383.00

Regarding the time and costs incurred on this case, a general

overview will be addressed below: Fees Incurred by Lead Attorney Lynn Hubbard, III Phone calls to client: At the start of the litigation, I insist on either a personal meeting or telephone call with the client. In this case it was a phone call because Mr. Kohler is a previous client of the firm. During that call, she provided me with specific details of the barriers she personally encountered at the Sheraton. Site Inspection, travel and note taking: It is my practice to travel to the site to view the facility and take notes in order to have first-hand knowledge of the accessibility issues that exist at the Facility.

Declaration of Lynn Hubbard, III, in Support of Kohler's M otion for Attorneys' Fees

-5-

Kohler v. The Vons Companies, Inc. 08cv0082 IEG (RBB)

Case 3:08-cv-00082-IEG-RBB

Document 8-3

Filed 03/20/2008

Page 6 of 12

1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 9 10 11 12 13 14 15 16 17 18 19 20 21 22 23 24 25 26 27 28

Review answer to complaint: Every answer must be reviewed. ADA litigation is unique, and lawyers unfamiliar with the law will often file answers lacking the specific defenses. Reviewing the answer tells me if we are dealing with an amateur or seasoned defense lawyer. In addition, even seasoned defense lawyers make mistakes in their pleadings, or include a defense that plaintiff may attempt to dismiss by way of motion. Preparation of Attorney Fee Motion: My staff and I expended time preparing this motion for attorneys' fees, litigation expenses and costs to present to the Court and anticipate expending time in drafting and filing a reply. Fees Incurred by Paralegals Courts deciding fee motions have repeatedly held that it is not reasonable for attorneys to perform and bill for a task that can be taken care of by para-professionals. Accordingly, this office delegates as many tasks as possible to para-professionals, whose qualifications were already summarized. I charge $90 per hour for paralegal time.

I declare under penalty of perjury that the foregoing is true and correct. Executed on this 20th day of March 2008, at Chico, California.

/s/ Lynn Hubbard, III Lynn Hubbard, III Attorney for Plaintiff, Chris Kohler

Declaration of Lynn Hubbard, III, in Support of Kohler's M otion for Attorneys' Fees

-6-

Kohler v. The Vons Companies, Inc. 08cv0082 IEG (RBB)

Case 3:08-cv-00082-IEG-RBB

Document 8-3

Filed 03/20/2008

Page 7 of 12

EXHIBIT A

Case 3:08-cv-00082-IEG-RBB

Document 8-3

Filed 03/20/2008

Page 8 of 12

Case 3:08-cv-00082-IEG-RBB

Document 8-3

Filed 03/20/2008

Page 9 of 12

Case 3:08-cv-00082-IEG-RBB

Document 8-3

Filed 03/20/2008

Page 10 of 12

Case 3:08-cv-00082-IEG-RBB

Document 8-3

Filed 03/20/2008

Page 11 of 12

Case 3:08-cv-00082-IEG-RBB

Document 8-3

Filed 03/20/2008

Page 12 of 12