Free Sur-Reply Brief - District Court of Delaware - Delaware

Case 1:04-cv-01211-MPT

Document 70-2

Filed 07/25/2008

Page 1 of 162

EXHIBIT A

Case 1:04-cv-01211-MPT

Document 70-2

Filed 07/25/2008

Page 2 of 162

Explanation of Exhibit B (Time Calculations) 1. Table at Exhibit B-1 (complete list of all entries). a. The time entries submitted by The Neuberger Firm and The Law Offices of John M. LaRosa, Esq., were combined into a single table, sorted in ascending chronological order. Each line item was assigned an Item Number for cross-referencing.

b. 2.

The columns in the table represent, in order from left to right, a. b. c. d. e. f. g. The Item Number discussed above; The Billing Attorney's initials; The Date of the Entry; The Description of the activity taken verbatim from counsel's submissions; The Amount of Time sought for the activity; The Billing Attorney's requested hourly rate; and The Fee, which equals the dollar value of the time billed multiplied by the hourly rate.

3.

The final column, "Previously Listed," reflects any time entry that was eliminated in a prior table. a. b. For example, some of the entries eliminated as "clerical" in Exhibit B-3 are also "duplicative" in Exhibit B-7. The purpose of this column is to ensure that amounts are not removed from the total more than once while still providing the data needed if the requested amounts are recalculated.

4. 5.

The Subtotal represents the total number of hours claimed by the requested hourly rate. The Total reflects the Subtotal less any amounts from the Previously Listed column. Example: Thomas S. Neuberger's entry for July 9, 2007, (Exhibit B-6, line 357), "telephone with client," is unspecific (II.E); should have been delegated to a paralegal (III.A); constitutes excessive activity during the judicial stay (III.D); and represents duplicative billing (III.E). This time entry has been eliminated only once--in the "Unspecific" category. While the entry is included in the other categories t demonstrate the billing errors, previously listed entries are noted in the far right column and have not been calculated more than once.

Case 1:04-cv-01211-MPT

Document 70-2

Filed 07/25/2008

Page 3 of 162

EXHIBIT B

Case 1:04-cv-01211-MPT

Document 70-2

Filed 07/25/2008

Page 4 of 162

TAB 1

Case 1:04-cv-01211-MPT

Document 70-2

Filed 07/25/2008

Page 5 of 162

Exhibit B
Item # ATTY Date Description

All Entries by Date
Time Rate

Tab 1
Fee

1

JML

07/08/03

Initial consultation with client

1.4

$250

$350

2

TSN

07/29/03

Meeting with JLR to discuss his possible case and the facts.

0.5

$450

$225

3

JML

07/30/03

Meeting with TSN regarding facts from initial consultation 2d Meeting with TSN re: facts and documents needed to establish claim of 1st Amendment retaliation Telephone to client regarding promotion procedures and illegal reasons for his denied promotion

0.5

$250

$125

4

JML

07/31/03

0.5

$250

$125

5

JML

08/06/03

0.2

$250

$50

6

TSN

08/18/03

Meet with JLR to discuss the facts for a retaliation claim.

0.3

$450

$135

7

JML

09/25/03

3d Meeting with TSN regarding First Amendment retaliation and other potential claims

0.4

$250

$100

8

JML

10/10/03

Review deposition of Colonel Cunningham regarding promotions in NCC PD

0.3

$250

$75

9

JML

10/10/03

Memo to TSN regarding Cunningham deposition testimony regarding NCC PD promotions

0.8

$250

$200

10

TSN

10/15/03

Review fact memo from JLR.

0.1

$450

$45

11

SJN

10/21/03

Conference with TSN, JLR, MDH to discuss conflict issues.

0.5

$250

$125

12

TSN

10/21/03

Meet with JLR, MH, SJN about conflict of interest issues and the respresentation.

0.5

$450

$225

Page 1 of 43

Case 1:04-cv-01211-MPT

Document 70-2

Filed 07/25/2008

Page 6 of 162

Exhibit B
Item # ATTY Date Description

All Entries by Date
Time Rate

Tab 1
Fee

13

JML

10/22/03

Review file and prepare for today's meeting with TSN

0.4

$250

$100

14

TSN

11/10/03

Meet with JLR about the case.

0.1

$450

$45

15

TSN

12/09/03

Meet with JLR to discuss the timing of the case.

0.1

$450

$45

16

JML

12/19/03

Telephone from client regarding newest promotions

0.3

$250

$75

17

JML

02/04/04

Telephone from client regarding new job postings and denial of 2 additional promotions

0.2

$250

$50

18

JML

02/04/04

Memo to TSN regarding today's telephone call from client

0.5

$250

$125

19

JML

02/25/04

Telephone to client regarding other County officers

0.1

$250

$25

20

JML

03/08/04

Telephone from client regarding documents for him to sign at today's meeting

0.1

$250

$25

21

JML

03/08/04

Legal research regarding potential immunity of local government

0.3

$250

$75

22

JML

03/08/04

Meeting with client to review new factual documents from him Telephone from client regarding new promotion to Captain and memo to TSN regarding advice on new Captain vacancy Telephone from client regarding information on eligible candidates for December 2003 Lt. and Captain promotions

1.0

$250

$250

23

JML

03/29/04

0.7

$250

$175

24

JML

03/31/04

0.2

$250

$50

Page 2 of 43

Case 1:04-cv-01211-MPT

Document 70-2

Filed 07/25/2008

Page 7 of 162

Exhibit B
Item # ATTY Date Description

All Entries by Date
Time Rate

Tab 1
Fee

25

JML

04/02/04

Meeting with client regarding additional information on promotions and eligibility lists and other promotion candidates

0.7

$250

$175

26

TSN

04/08/04

Review JLR letter to EEOC.

0.1

$450

$45

27

TSN

04/10/04

Review memo from JLR.

0.1

$450

$45

28

TSN

04/21/04

Meet with JLR on status of the case.

0.1

$450

$45

29

JML

04/26/04

Telephone from client regarding new Captain promotion and memo to TSN regarding same E-mail to TSN regarding our strategy regarding First Amendment retaliation claims in light of retaliatory re-posting of a Captain promotion after prior promotion list expired Review fact memo from JLR and respond.

0.7

$250

$175

30

JML

04/28/04

0.2

$250

$50

31

TSN

04/28/04

0.2

$450

$90

32

TSN

05/03/04

Review status report from JLR.

0.1

$450

$45

33

JML

05/27/04

Telephone to client and memo to TSN regarding retaliation: lowered ranking, denied promotion, and Middletown transfer

0.8

$250

$200

34

TSN

06/08/04

Review status report from JLR.

0.1

$450

$45

35

JML

06/10/04

Meeting with law clerk regarding statute of limitations issue

0.1

$250

$25

36

TSN

06/10/04

Discuss with JLR the EEOC timeliness issue.

0.1

$450

$45

Page 3 of 43

Case 1:04-cv-01211-MPT

Document 70-2

Filed 07/25/2008

Page 8 of 162

Exhibit B
Item # ATTY Date Description

All Entries by Date
Time Rate

Tab 1
Fee

37

JML

06/15/04

Meeting with TSN and SJN regarding filing the First Amendment Complaint

0.5

$250

$125

38

SJN

06/15/04

Meeting TSN and JLR.

0.1

$250

$25

39

TSN

06/15/04

Meet with JLR to discuss legal theories and decide to file the case now.

0.5

$450

$225

40

JML

06/17/04

Review law clerk's legal research memo regarding statute of limitations

0.3

$250

$75

41

TSN

06/22/04

Review SOL resesarch memo.

0.1

$450

$45

42

TSN

07/26/04

Meet with JLR about drafting the complaint for filing.

0.2

$450

$90

43

TSN

07/26/04

Try to reach my client about filing the case.

0.1

$450

$45

44

TSN

07/26/04

Telephone with client to set appointment.

0.1

$450

$45

45

JML

07/27/04

Meeting with TSN and client regarding lawsuit content and strategy

2.0

$250

$500

46

SJN

07/27/04

Meeting with TSN.

0.1

$250

$25

47

TSN

07/27/04

Meet with JLR and client to discuss facts, law and filing his case in the next month, our two main legal theories.

1.8

$450

$810

48

TSN

07/27/04

Meeting with SJN.

0.1

$450

$45

Page 4 of 43

Case 1:04-cv-01211-MPT

Document 70-2

Filed 07/25/2008

Page 9 of 162

Exhibit B
Item # ATTY Date Description

All Entries by Date
Time Rate

Tab 1
Fee

49

JML

07/28/04

Draft Complaint: Caption, Parties, Jurisdiction, and Wherefore Clause

1.5

$250

$375

50

JML

07/28/04

Telephone from client regarding dates of his protected activity

0.1

$250

$25

51

JML

07/29/04

Meeting with TSN regarding defendants to name and allegations to make in the Complaint

0.2

$250

$50

52

TSN

07/29/04

Meet with JLR about draft complaint and the parties defendant.

0.2

$450

$90

53

JML

08/03/04

Review TSN memo regarding meeting with client

0.1

$250

$25

54

JML

08/04/04

Complaint preparation

0.1

$250

$25

55

JML

08/04/04

Revise Complaint Caption, Parties, and Wherefore Clause Complaint preparation: Draft facts relating to employment history and circumstantial evidence of retaliation Complaint preparation: Draft allegations regarding defendants' conduct

0.2

$250

$50

56

JML

08/04/04

1.5

$250

$375

57

JML

08/04/04

0.3

$250

$75

58

JML

08/04/04

Draft Counts I and II: Free Speech and Petition Clause violations

0.3

$250

$75

59

JML

08/04/04

Draft facts relating to individual defendants' decision making and less qualified successful candidate

0.5

$250

$125

60

JML

08/09/04

Continue drafting Complaint: Plaintiff's Injuries

0.5

$250

$125

Page 5 of 43

Case 1:04-cv-01211-MPT

Document 70-2

Filed 07/25/2008

Page 10 of 162

Exhibit B
Item # ATTY Date Description

All Entries by Date
Time Rate

Tab 1
Fee

61

JML

08/14/04

Draft facts regarding cover up of accident

1.2

$250

$300

62

JML

08/14/04

Draft facts regarding campaign and election improprieties

1.3

$250

$325

63

JML

08/16/04

Draft Civil Cover Sheet and Summons and revise Complaint

0.6

$250

$150

64

JML

08/16/04

Complaint preparation: Draft Injunctive relief

0.5

$250

$125

65

JML

08/17/04

Telephone to client regarding content of his protected speech, retaliatory transfer, and injury to reputation Continue drafting Complaint: content of protected speech, retaliatory transfer, and injury to reputation

0.6

$250

$150

66

JML

08/17/04

3.0

$250

$750

67

JML

08/17/04

Revise Summons of John Cunningham

0.1

$250

$25

68

JML

08/17/04

2d telephone call to client regarding his additional information on accident and the continued retaliation Telephone to client regarding TSN revision of Complaint

0.3

$250

$75

69

JML

08/20/04

0.3

$250

$75

70

JML

08/23/04

Revise Complaint based on Friday's conversation with client

0.1

$250

$25

71

TSN

08/23/04

Work on second draft of complaint.

1.2

$450

$540

72

TSN

08/23/04

Second draft of the complaint.

2.5

$450

$1,125

Page 6 of 43

Case 1:04-cv-01211-MPT

Document 70-2

Filed 07/25/2008

Page 11 of 162

Exhibit B
Item # ATTY Date Description

All Entries by Date
Time Rate

Tab 1
Fee

73

JML

08/24/04

Continue revising of Complaint and telephone to client regarding same

0.4

$250

$100

74

SJN

08/24/04

Review and edit draft 0.2 of complaint

0.4

$250

$100

75

TSN

08/24/04

Telephone with client about his draft complaint and his need to review it for factual accuracy and whether he wishes to hold a press conference.

0.1

$450

$45

76

TSN

08/25/04

Draft 3 of the complaint.

1.9

$450

$855

77

JML

08/26/04

Telephone to client regarding revised Complaint

0.3

$250

$75

78

JML

08/27/04

Review TSN's draft Complaint

0.3

$250

$75

79

SJN

08/27/04

Meeting with TSN.

0.3

$250

$75

80

TSN

08/27/04

Meeting with Steve

0.3

$450

$135

81

TSN

08/27/04

Document drafting, copy counsel to review.

0.3

$450

$135

82

TSN

08/27/04

Telephone from the AP.

0.1

$450

$45

83

SJN

08/29/04

Review and edit draft 3 of complaint.

0.6

$250

$150

84

JML

08/30/04

Review and revise draft Complaint

0.2

$250

$50

Page 7 of 43

Case 1:04-cv-01211-MPT

Document 70-2

Filed 07/25/2008

Page 12 of 162

Exhibit B
Item # ATTY Date Description

All Entries by Date
Time Rate

Tab 1
Fee

85

JML

08/30/04

Meeting with TSN and client regarding pending lawsuit

1.0

$250

$250

86

JML

08/30/04

Revise Civil Cover Sheet

0.2

$250

$50

87

TSN

08/30/04

Meet with client to review facts of the complaint and make revisions.

1.0

$450

$450

88

TSN

08/30/04

Final draft of complaint.

2.5

$450

$1,125

89

SJN

08/31/04

Meeting with TSN re filing and related issues.

0.3

$250

$75

90

SJN

08/31/04

Review latest draft of complaint.

0.3

$250

$75

91

TSN

08/31/04

Finalize complaint.

0.7

$450

$315

92

TSN

08/31/04

Draft press release.

0.6

$450

$270

93

TSN

08/31/04

Meeting with SJN re filing and related issues.

0.3

$450

$135

94

SJN

09/02/04

Press conference.

1.0

$250

$250

95

SJN

09/02/04

Fact investigation and meeting with client.

1.3

$250

$325

96

SJN

09/02/04

Fact investigation re: other incidents where Freebery's has done this.

0.3

$250

$75

Page 8 of 43

Case 1:04-cv-01211-MPT

Document 70-2

Filed 07/25/2008

Page 13 of 162

Exhibit B
Item # ATTY Date Description

All Entries by Date
Time Rate

Tab 1
Fee

97

SJN

09/02/04

Respond to media inquiries.

0.5

$250

$125

98

SJN

09/02/04

Telephone with Hank.

0.1

$250

$25

99

SJN

09/02/04

Telephone calls with Tom.

0.2

$250

$50

100

SJN

09/02/04

Fact investigation.

0.5

$250

$125

101

SJN

09/02/04

Calls with Steve.

0.2

$250

$50

102

TSN

09/02/04

Meeting with client about facts.

1.0

$450

$450

103

TSN

09/02/04

Attend press conference for client, preparation.

1.4

$450

$630

104

SJN

09/03/04

Telephone with TSN.

0.1

$250

$25

105

SJN

09/03/04

Call to Hank.

0.1

$250

$25

106

SJN

09/03/04

Fact investigation.

0.3

$250

$75

107

SJN

09/03/04

E-mail to TSN & JLR.

0.1

$250

$25

108

SJN

09/03/04

Phone call to investigate the facts of the police report being doctored.

0.1

$250

$25

Page 9 of 43

Case 1:04-cv-01211-MPT

Document 70-2

Filed 07/25/2008

Page 14 of 162

Exhibit B
Item # ATTY Date Description

All Entries by Date
Time Rate

Tab 1
Fee

109

SJN

09/03/04

E-mail to TSN & JLR re: Freebery order via Janet Smith to alter police report.

0.1

$250

$25

110

SJN

09/03/04

Calls with Steve.

0.2

$250

$50

111

SJN

09/07/04

Fact investigation.

0.2

$250

$50

112

SJN

09/08/04

Meeting with TSN.

0.3

$250

$75

113

TSN

09/08/04

Review fact statements by parties.

0.2

$450

$90

114

TSN

09/08/04

Review witness statements and email client.

0.4

$450

$180

115

TSN

09/08/04

Call from M. Allen about the police report claims.

0.2

$450

$90

116

TSN

09/08/04

E-mail JLR with things to do.

0.2

$450

$90

117

TSN

09/08/04

Meeting with Steve.

0.3

$450

$135

118

TSN

09/09/04

Review two e-mails from client and reply.

0.2

$450

$90

119

TSN

09/09/04

Investigate facts given by client.

0.2

$450

$90

120

SJN

09/10/04

Fact investigation.

0.1

$250

$25

Page 10 of 43

Case 1:04-cv-01211-MPT

Document 70-2

Filed 07/25/2008

Page 15 of 162

Exhibit B
Item # ATTY Date Description

All Entries by Date
Time Rate

Tab 1
Fee

121

SJN

09/13/04

Review e-mails.

0.1

$250

$25

122

TSN

09/13/04

Email to client about preparing rule 26 disclosures.

0.2

$450

$90

123

SJN

09/30/04

Return call to Bowser re: extension of time on Answer.

0.1

$250

$25

124

SJN

10/01/04

Meeting with TSN.

0.1

$250

$25

125

SJN

10/01/04

E-mail to Bowser re: extension of time to file Answer and conflict of interest.

0.1

$250

$25

126

TSN

10/01/04

Meeting with SJN.

0.1

$450

$45

127

JML

10/06/04

Telephone from client regarding accident and potential discipline and advise regarding his rights of appeal Review e-mail from client on damages and disparate punishment.

0.1

$250

$25

128

TSN

10/07/04

0.1

$450

$45

129

JML

10/28/04

E-mail to client regarding his potential new employment and its impact on the case

0.2

$250

$50

130

TSN

11/03/04

Review two e-mails from the client.

0.1

$450

$45

131

SJN

11/05/04

Meeting with TSN re: D's filing answer or motion for a stay.

0.1

$250

$25

132

TSN

11/05/04

Meeting with SJN re: D's filing answer or motion for a stay.

0.1

$450

$45

Page 11 of 43

Case 1:04-cv-01211-MPT

Document 70-2

Filed 07/25/2008

Page 16 of 162

Exhibit B
Item # ATTY Date Description

All Entries by Date
Time Rate

Tab 1
Fee

133

TSN

11/09/04

Review their stay brief and e-mail JLR about a response.

0.2

$450

$90

134

SJN

11/10/04

Meeting with TSN re: settlement.

0.2

$250

$50

135

TSN

11/10/04

Discuss with JLR settlement strategy for the case.

0.5

$450

$225

136

TSN

11/10/04

Meeting with SJN re: settlement.

0.2

$450

$90

137

JML

11/15/04

E-mail to client regarding health status report

0.1

$250

$25

138

JML

11/16/04

Telephone and e-mail to client regarding damages information

0.4

$250

$100

139

JML

11/16/04

E-mail to plaintiff's counsel regarding our Response to Motion to Stay

0.1

$250

$25

140

SJN

11/16/04

Motion to stay briefing.

0.2

$250

$50

141

JML

11/22/04

Begin drafting Memo in Opposition to Motion to Stay

2.2

$250

$550

142

JML

11/24/04

Continue drafting Response to Motion to Stay

2.1

$250

$525

143

JML

11/24/04

Continue drafting Response to Motion to Stay

3.5

$250

$875

144

JML

11/26/04

Finalize Response to Motion to Stay and e-mail to TSN regarding same

1.3

$250

$325

Page 12 of 43

Case 1:04-cv-01211-MPT

Document 70-2

Filed 07/25/2008

Page 17 of 162

Exhibit B
Item # ATTY Date Description

All Entries by Date
Time Rate

Tab 1
Fee

145

SJN

11/29/04

Review our AB.

0.2

$250

$50

146

TSN

11/30/04

Review our stay brief.

0.1

$450

$45

147

TSN

11/30/04

E-mail to JLR.

0.1

$450

$45

148

TSN

12/05/04

Fact investigation on expected changes in County government in January and effect on this case.

0.5

$450

$225

149

JML

12/08/04

Telephone to economist regarding retaining him for an expert report

0.3

$250

$75

150

JML

12/16/04

Telephone from client regarding motion to stay

0.1

$250

$25

151

TSN

12/19/04

Review stay decision by the court.

0.1

$450

$45

152

SJN

12/21/04

Meeting with TSN re: settlement strategy.

0.1

$250

$25

153

TSN

12/21/04

Meet with JLR about settlement strategy.

0.3

$450

$135

154

TSN

12/21/04

Meeting with SJN re: settlement strategy.

0.1

$450

$45

155

JML

12/22/04

Telephone to client regarding economist's follow up questions

0.3

$250

$75

156

JML

12/22/04

Letter to economist regarding follow up data from today's conversation with client

0.4

$250

$100

Page 13 of 43

Case 1:04-cv-01211-MPT

Document 70-2

Filed 07/25/2008

Page 18 of 162

Exhibit B
Item # ATTY Date Description

All Entries by Date
Time Rate

Tab 1
Fee

157

JML

12/23/04

Review cardiologist medical records and end of year pay stubs for 2001-2004

0.5

$250

$125

158

JML

12/23/04

Draft letter to economist regarding additional pension documents

0.1

$250

$25

159

JML

12/29/04

E-mail to economist regarding his initial draft report

0.1

$250

$25

160

JML

12/30/04

Telephone to client and 2 calls from client regarding salary range for Lt. Colonel, date of pay increase to Captain QW, and date of promotion to Major Draft letter to economist regarding additional information and documents and 4 scenarios of denied promotions and pay increases E-mail to Dr. Black regarding 3rd denied promotion scenario

0.3

$250

$75

161

JML

12/30/04

0.5

$250

$125

162

JML

12/31/04

0.2

$250

$50

163

JML

01/03/05

Review second draft economic report from Dr. Black

0.4

$250

$100

164

JML

01/03/05

E-mail to economist regarding corrections to latest draft of report

0.1

$250

$25

165

JML

01/03/05

E-mail from and to economist regarding title page of his report

0.2

$250

$50

166

SJN

01/05/05

Review TSN settlement concept e-mail.

0.1

$250

$25

167

TSN

01/05/05

Review Dr. Black report and outline demand package.

0.6

$450

$270

168

TSN

01/13/05

E-mail to JLR about economic report.

0.1

$450

$45

Page 14 of 43

Case 1:04-cv-01211-MPT

Document 70-2

Filed 07/25/2008

Page 19 of 162

Exhibit B
Item # ATTY Date Description

All Entries by Date
Time Rate

Tab 1
Fee

169

JML

01/14/05

Telephone to Dr. Black regarding revising his economic report to include tax effect

0.1

$250

$25

170

TSN

01/16/05

E-mail to JLR about settlement and Monell issues.

0.3

$450

$135

171

JML

01/17/05

Telephone to client regarding additional information to update economic report to add income tax effect of lump sum recovery Contact economist regarding additional documents for him to review

0.1

$250

$25

172

JML

01/18/05

0.1

$250

$25

173

JML

01/20/05

Begin drafting Settlement package

2.0

$250

$500

174

TSN

01/26/05

Review revised economic expert report.

0.3

$450

$135

175

TSN

01/27/05

Telephone with Jeff Goddess.

0.1

$450

$45

176

TSN

01/27/05

E-mail to JLR>

0.1

$450

$45

177

TSN

01/29/05

E-mail to JLR.

0.1

$450

$45

178

TSN

02/02/05

E-mail JLR on Coons transition actions.

0.2

$450

$90

179

TSN

02/04/05

Meet with KM about NCCPD promotion process.

0.6

$450

$270

180

JML

02/07/05

E-mail from TSN and to client regarding demand letter

0.2

$250

$50

Page 15 of 43

Case 1:04-cv-01211-MPT

Document 70-2

Filed 07/25/2008

Page 20 of 162

Exhibit B
Item # ATTY Date Description

All Entries by Date
Time Rate

Tab 1
Fee

181

TSN

02/07/05

E-mail JLR on timing of settlement demand.

0.1

$450

$45

182

TSN

02/09/05

Gather facts on county finances.

0.1

$450

$45

183

TSN

02/09/05

Think about recusal decision by the court.

0.2

$450

$90

184

SJN

02/10/05

Meeting with TSN and JLR re: case strategy.

0.4

$250

$100

185

TSN

02/10/05

Meeting with SJN and JLR re: case strategy.

0.4

$450

$180

186

JML

02/11/05

Review TSN-SJN draft settlement demand in NCC case

1.5

$250

$375

187

JML

02/11/05

Continue drafting settlement package

1.4

$250

$350

188

TSN

02/11/05

File memo on recusal.

0.2

$450

$90

189

JML

02/14/05

Continue drafting settlement package: Statement of Facts Continue drafting settlement demand: Fact Witnesses and Expert Witnesses and Physical Injuries Continue drafting settlement demand: Damages, Injuries, Relief, Attorneys' Fees, and Punitives

1.6

$250

$400

190

JML

02/16/05

1.5

$250

$375

191

JML

02/16/05

1.9

$250

$475

192

JML

02/17/05

Continue drafting settlement package: Argument Section I

1.5

$250

$375

Page 16 of 43

Case 1:04-cv-01211-MPT

Document 70-2

Filed 07/25/2008

Page 21 of 162

Exhibit B
Item # ATTY Date Description

All Entries by Date
Time Rate

Tab 1
Fee

193

JML

02/17/05

Continue drafting settlement package: Argument Section II

1.5

$250

$375

194

JML

02/17/05

Continue drafting settlement package: Argument Section III

1.5

$250

$375

195

JML

02/18/05

Continue drafting settlement package: Finish Argument Section III

0.1

$250

$25

196

JML

02/18/05

Continue drafting Settlement package: Argument Section IV

1.4

$250

$350

197

JML

02/18/05

Continue drafting Settlement package: Argument Section V

1.4

$250

$350

198

JML

02/18/05

Legal research regarding Indemnification Law

0.5

$250

$125

199

JML

02/18/05

Continue drafting Settlement package: Argument Sections VI and VII

2.0

$250

$500

200

JML

02/18/05

Continue drafting settlement package: Settlement Proposal

1.0

$250

$250

201

JML

02/18/05

Review and revise entire 70 page settlement package

1.9

$250

$475

202

TSN

02/19/05

E-mail on settlement.

0.1

$450

$45

203

SJN

02/20/05

Review and revise settlement proposal. Memorandum to client regarding economic, compensatory, and punitive damages, his economic report, settlement demand package, Dr. Black, and detail report

0.8

$250

$200

204

JML

03/03/05

1.0

$250

$250

Page 17 of 43

Case 1:04-cv-01211-MPT

Document 70-2

Filed 07/25/2008

Page 22 of 162

Exhibit B
Item # ATTY Date Description

All Entries by Date
Time Rate

Tab 1
Fee

205

TSN

03/03/05

Meet with JLR about the case.

0.2

$450

$90

206

JML

03/08/05

Telephone to client regarding further retaliatory transfer back to Minquedale for shift work

0.1

$250

$25

207

JML

03/08/05

Memo to TSN regarding further retaliatory transfer back to Minquedale for shift work

0.2

$250

$50

208

TSN

03/08/05

Review memo on his additional transfer to a new assignment.

0.1

$450

$45

209

JML

03/14/05

Review litigation report from NCC

0.1

$250

$25

210

JML

03/14/05

Prepare for today's briefing of TSN for his meeting tomorrow with the County attorney Update settlement package to include new developments in the case: Transfer to Patrol Squad B, additional defense attorneys' fees, etc E-mail to TSN regarding updated settlement package

1.5

$250

$375

211

JML

03/14/05

0.9

$250

$225

212

JML

03/14/05

0.1

$250

$25

213

SJN

03/15/05

Meet with TSN and Greg Wilson about settlement the case.

0.2

$250

$50

214

TSN

03/15/05

Meet with Greg Wison and SNJ about settling the case.

0.2

$450

$90

215

TSN

03/15/05

E-mail to JLR.

0.1

$450

$45

216

JML

03/16/05

Review e-mail from TSN and send e-mail to client regarding TSN meeting with County attorney

0.1

$250

$25

Page 18 of 43

Case 1:04-cv-01211-MPT

Document 70-2

Filed 07/25/2008

Page 23 of 162

Exhibit B
Item # ATTY Date Description

All Entries by Date
Time Rate

Tab 1
Fee

217

SJN

03/18/05

Meet with TSN about the settlement package.

0.3

$250

$75

218

TSN

03/18/05

meet with SJN about the settlement package.

0.3

$450

$135

219

TSN

03/18/05

Email to co-counsel

0.1

$450

$45

220

JML

03/22/05

E-mail from TSN and send e-mail to client regarding Coons' speech of 3/16/05

0.1

$250

$25

221

TSN

03/22/05

E-mail to JLR

0.1

$450

$45

222

SJN

03/23/05

Working on settlement package

0.5

$250

$125

223

JML

03/24/05

E-mail to Dr. Black regarding expert report

0.1

$250

$25

224

SJN

03/24/05

Meet with TSN about settlement proposal

0.2

$250

$50

225

SJN

03/24/05

Revising settlement package

1.1

$250

$275

226

TSN

03/24/05

Meet with SJN re: draft settlement proposal

0.2

$450

$90

227

TSN

04/05/05

Fact investigation on new public safety director

0.2

$450

$90

228

TSN

04/05/05

Fact investigation on new public safety director

0.2

$450

$90

Page 19 of 43

Case 1:04-cv-01211-MPT

Document 70-2

Filed 07/25/2008

Page 24 of 162

Exhibit B
Item # ATTY Date Description

All Entries by Date
Time Rate

Tab 1
Fee

229

TSN

04/06/05

Discuss with SJN status of the police dept.

0.2

$450

$90

230

TSN

04/06/05

Review letter on settlement from client

0.1

$450

$45

231

JML

04/15/05

Telephone to client regarding demand, meeting, and delivery of settlement package E-mail from TSN regarding demand, meeting, and delivery of settlement package and e-mails to and from co-counsel regarding cover letter for settlement package Revise draft demand package

0.1

$250

$25

232

JML

04/15/05

0.1

$250

$25

233

TSN

04/15/05

1.1

$450

$495

234

TSN

04/15/05

Finish revision of demand package

1.5

$450

$675

235

JML

04/16/05

Begin revising settlement package: pages 1-17

1.0

$250

$250

236

JML

04/18/05

Continue revising settlement package: pp. 19-65

1.4

$250

$350

237

JML

04/18/05

Continue revising settlement package: pp. 19-65

1.0

$250

$250

238

JML

04/18/05

Continue drafting 67 page settlement package

1.0

$250

$250

239

JML

04/18/05

Begin drafting letter to County attorney regarding settlement package

0.2

$250

$50

240

SJN

04/18/05

Meeting with TSN re: settlement package

0.1

$250

$25

Page 20 of 43

Case 1:04-cv-01211-MPT

Document 70-2

Filed 07/25/2008

Page 25 of 162

Exhibit B
Item # ATTY Date Description

All Entries by Date
Time Rate

Tab 1
Fee

241

TSN

04/18/05

E-mails from JLR

0.1

$450

$45

242

TSN

04/18/05

Meeting with SJN re: settlement package

0.1

$450

$45

243

JML

04/19/05

Finalize letter to county attorney regarding settlement package

0.1

$250

$25

244

JML

04/19/05

Revise settlement package

0.3

$250

$75

245

SJN

04/19/05

E-mail from JLR re: retaliatory transfer

0.1

$250

$25

246

JML

04/21/05

Draft section on Plaintiff's superior qualifications

0.7

$250

$175

247

JML

04/21/05

Review and finalize 67 page demand package

1.5

$250

$375

248

JML

04/21/05

E-mail to TSN regarding demand package

0.1

$250

$25

249

JML

04/22/05

Finalize demand package with most recent revisions and e-mail to The Neuberger Firm regarding same Meeting with SJN re: status of case, and planning out discovery and trial

0.2

$250

$50

250

SJN

04/22/05

0.3

$250

$75

251

TSN

04/22/05

Meeting with TSN re: status of case, and planning out discovery and trial

0.3

$450

$135

252

TSN

04/22/05

Review and approve settlement documents

0.4

$450

$180

Page 21 of 43

Case 1:04-cv-01211-MPT

Document 70-2

Filed 07/25/2008

Page 26 of 162

Exhibit B
Item # ATTY Date Description

All Entries by Date
Time Rate

Tab 1
Fee

253

TSN

04/22/05

Meet with client to review and obtain approval of demand package and our negotiating strategy

1.5

$450

$675

254

TSN

04/22/05

E-mail to co-counsel

0.1

$450

$45

255

JML

04/26/05

Telephone to client and e-mail to TSN regarding delivery of demand package

0.1

$250

$25

256

TSN

05/12/05

E-mail on witnesses

0.1

$450

$45

257

TSN

05/19/05

Review e-mail from client

0.1

$450

$45

258

JML

05/20/05

Telephone to client regarding demand response and e-mail to TSN regarding same

0.2

$250

$50

259

TSN

05/20/05

Meet with JLR about failure of settlement efforts

0.1

$450

$45

260

TSN

05/26/05

E-mail to client

0.2

$450

$90

261

TSN

06/07/05

E-mail from client and reply on his medical condition and damages

0.4

$450

$180

262

TSN

06/07/05

E-mail to client

0.2

$450

$90

263

TSN

06/07/05

E-mail from JLR and respond

0.1

$450

$45

264

TSN

06/08/05

Speak with JLR about the facts

0.1

$450

$45

Page 22 of 43

Case 1:04-cv-01211-MPT

Document 70-2

Filed 07/25/2008

Page 27 of 162

Exhibit B
Item # ATTY Date Description

All Entries by Date
Time Rate

Tab 1
Fee

265

TSN

06/25/05

Telephone with client

0.1

$450

$45

266

TSN

06/25/05

Speak with client about status of the case

0.3

$450

$135

267

TSN

06/27/05

E-mail on removal of the Chief

0.5

$450

$225

268

TSN

06/28/05

Fact investigation

0.3

$450

$135

269

JML

07/05/05

Review e-mail from TSN and e-mail to client regarding County's reported financial deficit

0.1

$250

$25

270

JML

07/18/05

Telephone to client regarding County's reported financial deficit

0.1

$250

$25

271

TSN

07/21/05

E-mail from client and respond

0.2

$450

$90

272

TSN

08/23/05

Discuss status of the case with JLR

0.1

$450

$45

273

TSN

08/25/05

Letter to client

0.2

$450

$90

274

TSN

09/09/05

E-mail to co-counsel

0.1

$450

$45

275

TSN

10/04/05

E-mail from client and respond

0.1

$450

$45

276

TSN

12/30/05

E-mail from client and reply on status of the case

0.3

$450

$135

Page 23 of 43

Case 1:04-cv-01211-MPT

Document 70-2

Filed 07/25/2008

Page 28 of 162

Exhibit B
Item # ATTY Date Description

All Entries by Date
Time Rate

Tab 1
Fee

277

TSN

01/31/06

Reply to clients e-mail on his damages

0.2

$450

$90

278

TSN

03/18/06

E-mail from client and respond

0.1

$450

$45

279

TSN

06/01/06

E-mail from client and respond

0.1

$450

$45

280

TSN

06/22/06

E-mail from client and reply

0.1

$450

$45

281

TSN

06/22/06

E-mail from client and reply

0.1

$450

$45

282

SJN

07/05/06

Meeting with TSN re: impact of Garcetti

0.1

$250

$25

283

TSN

07/05/06

Meeting with SJN re: impact of Garcetti

0.1

$450

$45

284

JML

07/25/06

Meeting with TSN regarding case in light of new SCt case

0.2

$250

$50

285

TSN

07/25/06

Meet with JLR about status of the case

0.2

$450

$90

286

TSN

08/10/06

Call from client

0.1

$450

$45

287

TSN

08/10/06

E-mail to JLR and client

0.1

$450

$45

288

JML

08/14/06

Telephone to client and e-mail to TSN regarding Supreme Court decision

0.2

$250

$50

Page 24 of 43

Case 1:04-cv-01211-MPT

Document 70-2

Filed 07/25/2008

Page 29 of 162

Exhibit B
Item # ATTY Date Description

All Entries by Date
Time Rate

Tab 1
Fee

289

JML

08/14/06

Review Garcetti decision and analyze its impact on the case

1.0

$250

$250

290

JML

08/14/06

Review TSN brief regarding Garcetti case law affecting this case

0.5

$250

$125

291

JML

08/15/06

Telephone to client and e-mail to TSN regarding S.Ct. decision

0.2

$250

$50

292

TSN

08/29/06

Review file

0.4

$450

$180

293

JML

08/30/06

Meeting with TSN and client regarding new settlement strategy

1.1

$250

$275

294

JML

08/30/06

Draft Memo to TSN regarding today's meeting

0.6

$250

$150

295

SJN

08/30/06

Meeting with TSN re: settlement issues

0.2

$250

$50

296

TSN

08/30/06

Meet with client and JLR about settlement authority

1.3

$450

$585

297

TSN

08/30/06

Meeeting with SJN re: settlement issues

0.2

$450

$90

298

JML

09/13/06

E-mail to co-counsel regarding settlement initiatives

0.1

$250

$25

299

JML

09/14/06

Meeting with co-counsel regarding NCC settlement initiatives

0.5

$250

$125

300

JML

09/26/06

E-mail to co-counsel regarding NCC settlement talks

0.1

$250

$25

Page 25 of 43

Case 1:04-cv-01211-MPT

Document 70-2

Filed 07/25/2008

Page 30 of 162

Exhibit B
Item # ATTY Date Description

All Entries by Date
Time Rate

Tab 1
Fee

301

JML

09/28/06

Telephone from co-counsel regarding status of settlement talks

0.1

$250

$25

302

JML

10/02/06

Draft renewed settlement demand letter

2.5

$250

$625

303

TSN

10/02/06

Edit demand letter

0.2

$450

$90

304

JML

10/03/06

Finalize renewed demand letter

1.8

$250

$450

305

TSN

10/06/06

Meet with JLR on status of the case

0.1

$450

$45

306

JML

11/10/06

Telephone to client regarding his case status

0.1

$250

$25

307

TSN

11/10/06

Meet with JLR about status of negotiations

0.1

$450

$45

308

TSN

12/06/06

Meet with JLR about settlement strategy

0.1

$450

$45

309

SJN

12/16/06

Pleadings review

0.1

$250

$25

310

TSN

01/02/07

Telephone with the USM about the case

0.1

$450

$45

311

TSN

01/09/07

Try to reach my client

0.1

$450

$45

312

TSN

01/09/07

Telephone with client

0.1

$450

$45

Page 26 of 43

Case 1:04-cv-01211-MPT

Document 70-2

Filed 07/25/2008

Page 31 of 162

Exhibit B
Item # ATTY Date Description

All Entries by Date
Time Rate

Tab 1
Fee

313

SJN

01/11/07

Meeting with Hank re: settlement and case status

2.0

$250

$500

314

TSN

01/12/07

Review e-mail

0.1

$450

$45

315

TSN

03/08/07

E-mail from client and respond

0.1

$450

$45

316

TSN

05/02/07

E-mail to co-counsel on settlement

0.1

$450

$45

317

SJN

05/03/07

E-mail from JLR

0.1

$250

$25

318

TSN

05/29/07

E-mail on interview fact witnesses

0.2

$450

$90

319

TSN

05/29/07

Fact investigation, attend the deposition of Maloney & Rendina on the operation of NCC

1.4

$450

$630

320

JML

06/01/07

Telephone from client and e-mail to TSN regarding police report of Freeberry accident

0.3

$250

$75

321

TSN

06/01/07

E-mail from JLR and reply

0.1

$450

$45

322

TSN

06/01/07

E-mail to JLR about IA inquire to client

0.1

$450

$45

323

TSN

06/03/07

E-mail to Maloney statements

0.1

$450

$45

324

RW

06/05/07

Attend Wilmington Hospitality v. NCC with Maloney and Rendina/witnesses

0.7

$170

$119

Page 27 of 43

Case 1:04-cv-01211-MPT

Document 70-2

Filed 07/25/2008

Page 32 of 162

Exhibit B
Item # ATTY Date Description

All Entries by Date
Time Rate

Tab 1
Fee

325

RW

06/06/07

Attend Wilmington Hospitality v. NCC with Maloney and Rendina/witnesses

0.5

$170

$85

326

RW

06/06/07

Memo to TSN re: Maloney/Rendina testimony in Wilmington Hospitality case

0.8

$170

$136

327

TSN

06/06/07

E-mail on lifting the stay

0.2

$450

$90

328

JML

06/07/07

Legal and factual analysis: review e-mail from TSN, Complaint, and send e-mail to TSN regarding defendant Gordon

1.3

$250

$325

329

TSN

06/07/07

E-mail on evidence issue

0.2

$450

$90

330

TSN

06/14/07

Meet with Maloney and Rendina about the facts of the case

1.0

$450

$450

331

TSN

06/15/07

Telephone with JLR about fact investigation

0.2

$450

$90

332

JML

06/18/07

E-mail to RW regarding depositions of LM and MR and to CAH regarding affidavits of LM and MR

0.2

$250

$50

333

SJN

06/18/07

Meeting with TSN re: amending complaint

0.1

$250

$25

334

TSN

06/18/07

Meeting with SJN re: amending complaint

0.1

$450

$45

335

TSN

06/18/07

E-mail from client and reply

0.2

$450

$90

336

TSN

06/18/07

E-mail on the stay

0.1

$450

$45

Page 28 of 43

Case 1:04-cv-01211-MPT

Document 70-2

Filed 07/25/2008

Page 33 of 162

Exhibit B
Item # ATTY Date Description

All Entries by Date
Time Rate

Tab 1
Fee

337

JML

06/19/07

E-mail to TSN regarding no Answer filed and amending the Complaint

0.1

$250

$25

338

JML

06/19/07

Review Complaint and deposition testimony of LM in County case

1.5

$250

$375

339

JML

06/19/07

Review deposition testimony of MR in County case

0.1

$250

$25

340

JML

06/19/07

Review memo from RW regarding trial testimony of LM and MR in NCC case

0.3

$250

$75

341

JML

06/19/07

Review deposition of defendant Freeberry in County police case

2.0

$250

$500

342

JML

06/19/07

Prepare questions for interviews of witnesses LM and MR

1.0

$250

$250

343

JML

06/20/07

Continue preparing interview questions

0.5

$250

$125

344

JML

06/20/07

Telephone to LM regarding interview

0.1

$250

$25

345

JML

06/20/07

Draft letter to LM and MR regarding interview

0.3

$250

$75

346

JML

06/21/07

E-mail to witness regarding interviews

0.2

$250

$50

347

SJN

06/24/07

Legal research - speech to grand jury still protect post-Garcetti cases

0.2

$250

$50

348

JML

06/27/07

Interview MR regarding case

2.0

$250

$500

Page 29 of 43

Case 1:04-cv-01211-MPT

Document 70-2

Filed 07/25/2008

Page 34 of 162

Exhibit B
Item # ATTY Date Description

All Entries by Date
Time Rate

Tab 1
Fee

349

JML

06/27/07

Interview LM regarding case

2.2

$250

$550

350

CAS

07/02/07

E-mail to JLR regarding affidavits and plea agreement

0.2

$170

$34

351

CAS

07/09/07

Review e-mail from TSN regarding client's new job

0.1

$170

$17

352

JML

07/09/07

Draft Declaration of LM

3.0

$250

$750

353

JML

07/09/07

Telephone to TSN regarding case status

0.3

$250

$75

354

JML

07/09/07

E-mail to TSN regarding damages

0.4

$250

$100

355

SJN

07/09/07

Call from TSN

0.2

$250

$50

356

SJN

07/09/07

Review draft declaration and send amended complaint and unstaying letter to JLR

0.2

$250

$50

357

TSN

07/09/07

Telephone with client

0.2

$450

$90

358

TSN

07/09/07

Review L. Maloney declaration

0.2

$450

$90

359

TSN

07/09/07

Discuss lifting the stay with JLR and strategy

0.3

$450

$135

360

TSN

07/09/07

Telephone with SJN on strategy

0.2

$450

$90

Page 30 of 43

Case 1:04-cv-01211-MPT

Document 70-2

Filed 07/25/2008

Page 35 of 162

Exhibit B
Item # ATTY Date Description

All Entries by Date
Time Rate

Tab 1
Fee

361

JML

07/10/07

Draft Declaration of MR

3.0

$250

$750

362

JML

07/10/07

Telephone to LM regarding additional facts for Declaration

0.1

$250

$25

363

TSN

07/10/07

Telephone with client, return call from media

0.2

$450

$90

364

JML

07/11/07

Review Riddel original and first amended complaints for our First Amended Complaint

1.0

$250

$250

365

JML

07/11/07

Begin drafting First Amended Complaint

1.2

$250

$300

366

JML

07/11/07

Revise draft 1 of First Amended Complaint and email to TSN regarding same

1.5

$250

$375

367

JML

07/12/07

Revise First Amended Complaint

0.4

$250

$100

368

JML

07/12/07

Telephone to MR regarding facts

1.4

$250

$350

369

TSN

07/12/07

Review amended complaint

0.2

$450

$90

370

JML

07/13/07

Revise MR Declaration

1.1

$250

$275

371

JML

07/13/07

Revise Declaration of LM

1.4

$250

$350

372

SJN

07/14/07

Review and revise first amended complaint

0.7

$250

$175

Page 31 of 43

Case 1:04-cv-01211-MPT

Document 70-2

Filed 07/25/2008

Page 36 of 162

Exhibit B
Item # ATTY Date Description

All Entries by Date
Time Rate

Tab 1
Fee

373

CAS

07/16/07

E-mail from TSN regarding amended complaint and stay

0.1

$170

$17

374

JML

07/23/07

Finalize Declaration of LM

0.4

$250

$100

375

JML

07/24/07

Finalize First Amended Complaint

1.5

$250

$375

376

JML

07/24/07

Draft letter to USM regarding lifting stay

0.5

$250

$125

377

SJN

07/25/07

Pleadings review

0.1

$250

$25

378

JML

07/26/07

E-mail to co-counsel regarding Declarations and other NCC material

0.1

$250

$25

379

JML

08/23/07

E-mail to MR regarding her declaration

0.1

$250

$25

380

JML

08/27/07

Finalize declaration of MR and e-mail to witness regarding same

1.0

$250

$250

381

CAS

08/28/07

Review e-mail from JLR regarding status

0.1

$170

$17

382

TSN

08/28/07

E-mail on status

0.1

$450

$45

383

CAS

08/31/07

E-mails from TSN

0.1

$170

$17

384

TSN

08/31/07

E-mail to client

0.2

$450

$90

Page 32 of 43

Case 1:04-cv-01211-MPT

Document 70-2

Filed 07/25/2008

Page 37 of 162

Exhibit B
Item # ATTY Date Description

All Entries by Date
Time Rate

Tab 1
Fee

385

TSN

08/31/07

E-mail to client

0.2

$450

$90

386

CAS

09/05/07

E-mail from TSN to client regarding settlement

0.1

$170

$17

387

TSN

09/05/07

E-mail from client and respond

0.2

$450

$90

388

JML

09/12/07

Telephone to client regarding case status

0.4

$250

$100

389

JML

09/13/07

Meeting with client regarding settlement

1.3

$250

$325

390

JML

09/13/07

E-mail to client regarding today's meeting

0.3

$250

$75

391

TSN

09/13/07

Meet with client about settlement

1.3

$450

$585

392

JML

09/24/07

Draft new demand letter to NCC

1.5

$250

$375

393

JML

09/24/07

E-mail to TSN regarding draft demand letter

0.2

$250

$50

394

JML

09/25/07

Revise demand letter

0.3

$250

$75

395

TSN

09/25/07

E-mail from JLR

0.1

$450

$45

396

TSN

09/25/07

Review and edit settlement demand

0.4

$450

$180

Page 33 of 43

Case 1:04-cv-01211-MPT

Document 70-2

Filed 07/25/2008

Page 38 of 162

Exhibit B
Item # ATTY Date Description

All Entries by Date
Time Rate

Tab 1
Fee

397

JML

09/26/07

Review and finalize settlement demand 3

0.3

$250

$75

398

TSN

10/09/07

Meet with MH

0.1

$450

$45

399

JML

10/25/07

Meeting with co-counsel regarding settlement

1.5

$250

$375

400

JML

10/25/07

E-mail to client regarding sending settlement letter to the judge

0.1

$250

$25

401

TSN

10/25/07

Meet with MH re: the case

0.1

$450

$45

402

JML

11/06/07

Draft letter to USM regarding settlement offer

0.4

$250

$100

403

JML

11/09/07

Finalize letter to USM

0.2

$250

$50

404

JML

11/15/07

Meeting with TSN regarding case status

0.5

$250

$125

405

JML

11/15/07

Telephone to client regarding consent to magistrate's jurisdiction

0.2

$250

$50

406

JML

11/15/07

E-mail to TSN regarding consent to Magistrate's jurisdiction

0.2

$250

$50

407

JML

11/15/07

Draft letter to counsel regarding Scheduling Order

0.5

$250

$125

408

JML

11/15/07

Draft Join Proposed Scheduling Order

1.4

$250

$350

Page 34 of 43

Case 1:04-cv-01211-MPT

Document 70-2

Filed 07/25/2008

Page 39 of 162

Exhibit B
Item # ATTY Date Description

All Entries by Date
Time Rate

Tab 1
Fee

409

JML

11/15/07

E-mail to TSN regarding joint proposed scheduling order

0.1

$250

$25

410

SJN

11/15/07

Pleadings review

0.1

$250

$25

411

TSN

11/15/07

Discuss case with MH

0.2

$450

$90

412

TSN

11/15/07

Meet with JLR about discovery and trial

0.3

$450

$135

413

JML

11/17/07

Finalize letter to counsel regarding scheduling order

0.5

$250

$125

414

CAS

11/26/07

Review e-mail from defense counsel

0.1

$170

$17

415

JML

11/26/07

Meeting with TSN regarding defendants attempt to delay case with a briefing schedule

0.3

$250

$75

416

JML

11/26/07

E-mail to counsel regarding its demand for briefing schedule

0.1

$250

$25

417

TSN

11/26/07

Meet with JLR about Rule 16 opposition by defense

0.2

$450

$90

418

JML

11/28/07

Draft letter to USM regarding scheduling teleconference

0.5

$250

$125

419

TSN

11/28/07

Review letter to court

0.1

$450

$45

420

JML

11/29/07

Finalize letter to Court regarding scheduling order

0.4

$250

$100

Page 35 of 43

Case 1:04-cv-01211-MPT

Document 70-2

Filed 07/25/2008

Page 40 of 162

Exhibit B
Item # ATTY Date Description

All Entries by Date
Time Rate

Tab 1
Fee

421

TSN

12/03/07

E-mail on Rule 16 conf.

0.2

$450

$90

422

SJN

12/04/07

Legal research - grand jury speech protected postGarcetti

1.0

$250

$250

423

SJN

12/04/07

E-mails and telephone calls from and to TSN re: Garcetti issues

0.4

$250

$100

424

CAS

12/05/07

Review e-mails from SJN and TSN

0.1

$170

$17

425

CAS

12/05/07

Review e-mail to defense counsel from SJN

0.1

$170

$17

426

SJN

12/05/07

Review amended complaint

0.1

$250

$25

427

SJN

12/05/07

E-mail to defense counsel, responding on Garcetti issues

0.8

$250

$200

428

CAS

12/06/07

Locate proposed Rule 16 order

0.4

$170

$68

429

CAS

12/06/07

Meeting with SJN re: Rule 16 order

0.1

$170

$17

430

SJN

12/06/07

Speak with CAH re: Rule 16 order

0.1

$250

$25

431

SJN

12/06/07

Review and prepare for Rule 16 teleconference on briefing

1.0

$250

$250

432

JML

12/07/07

Prepare for teleconference

1.0

$250

$250

Page 36 of 43

Case 1:04-cv-01211-MPT

Document 70-2

Filed 07/25/2008

Page 41 of 162

Exhibit B
Item # ATTY Date Description

All Entries by Date
Time Rate

Tab 1
Fee

433

JML

12/07/07

Rule 16 Teleconference with USM regarding scheduling and consent to USM

0.7

$250

$175

434

JML

12/07/07

Draft Consent to USM jurisdiction and e-mail to TSN regarding the same

0.8

$250

$200

435

SJN

12/07/07

E-mails to co-counsel

0.1

$250

$25

436

SJN

12/07/07

Review and prep for teleconference

0.3

$250

$75

437

SJN

12/07/07

Rule 16 teleconference with Court

0.7

$250

$175

438

SJN

12/07/07

Call to TSN re: status update and Rule 16

0.4

$250

$100

439

TSN

12/07/07

Telepohone with SJN re: conference with the court today

0.3

$450

$135

440

SJN

12/08/07

Review draft stips

0.1

$250

$25

441

SJN

12/08/07

E-mails to JLR

0.1

$250

$25

442

SJN

12/08/07

Pleadings review

0.1

$250

$25

443

TSN

12/08/07

E-mail to co-counsel

0.2

$450

$90

444

SJN

12/10/07

E-mails from and to defense counsel

0.1

$250

$25

Page 37 of 43

Case 1:04-cv-01211-MPT

Document 70-2

Filed 07/25/2008

Page 42 of 162

Exhibit B
Item # ATTY Date Description

All Entries by Date
Time Rate

Tab 1
Fee

445

SJN

12/10/07

Pleadings review

0.1

$250

$25

446

JML

12/11/07

Draft form of order for lifting the stay and e-mail to counsel regarding same

0.4

$250

$100

447

SJN

12/12/07

E-mail from JLR

0.1

$250

$25

448

TSN

12/12/07

Telephone with client about further proceedings in his case and discovery and trial

0.4

$450

$180

449

SJN

12/30/07

Legal research - post-Garcetti-whistleblowing - new CofA authority

0.3

$250

$75

450

JML

01/08/08

E-mail to SJN regarding briefing

0.1

$250

$25

451

SJN

01/08/08

Pleadings review

0.1

$250

$25

452

SJN

01/13/08

Legal research - grand jury speech and Garcetti

0.2

$250

$50

453

CAS

01/17/08

Handle overbilling of conference call

0.2

$170

$34

454

CAS

01/17/08

Draft memo re: teleconference billing issue

0.1

$170

$17

455

TSN

02/01/08

E-mail to JLR about offer to judgment

0.2

$450

$90

456

SJN

02/02/08

Drafting M to D AB

0.3

$250

$75

Page 38 of 43

Case 1:04-cv-01211-MPT

Document 70-2

Filed 07/25/2008

Page 43 of 162

Exhibit B
Item # ATTY Date Description

All Entries by Date
Time Rate

Tab 1
Fee

457

TSN

02/02/08

Analyze offer of judgment

0.2

$450

$90

458

TSN

02/02/08

Analyze offer of judgment

0.2

$450

$90

459

SJN

02/03/08

Drafting M to D AB

5.4

$250

$1,350

460

JML

02/04/08

Meeting with TSN regarding offer of judgment

0.1

$250

$25

461

JML

02/04/08

Telephone to client regarding offer of judgment

0.4

$250

$100

462

JML

02/04/08

Memo to TSN regarding conversation with client

0.4

$250

$100

463

SJN

02/04/08

Drafting M to D AB

7.0

$250

$1,750

464

TSN

02/04/08

Review e-mail on settlement

0.2

$450

$90

465

CAS

02/05/08

E-mail to law clerk re: bluebooking

0.1

$170

$17

466

JML

02/05/08

Review and revise SJN Brief draft 1

1.5

$250

$375

467

SJN

02/05/08

Drafting M to D AB

3.1

$250

$775

468

TSN

02/05/08

Review current draft of our opposition brief

0.2

$450

$90

Page 39 of 43

Case 1:04-cv-01211-MPT

Document 70-2

Filed 07/25/2008

Page 44 of 162

Exhibit B
Item # ATTY Date Description

All Entries by Date
Time Rate

Tab 1
Fee

469

JML

02/06/08

Revise SJN brief draft 2

1.3

$250

$325

470

JML

02/06/08

Revise SJN brief draft 3

0.5

$250

$125

471

SJN

02/06/08

Meeting with TSN re: briefing

0.3

$250

$75

472

SJN

02/06/08

Finalizing M to D AB

8.3

$250

$2,075

473

TSN

02/06/08

Meeting with SJN re: briefing

0.3

$450

$135

474

TSN

02/06/08

Draft 4 of brief

1.3

$450

$585

475

TSN

02/06/08

Revise petition clause section of brief

0.2

$450

$90

476

CAS

02/07/08

File brief and serve copy on court

0.2

$170

$34

477

CAS

02/08/08

Review e-mails from TSN

0.1

$170

$17

478

JML

02/08/08

Telephone to client regarding offer of judgment

0.1

$250

$25

479

JML

02/08/08

Telephone from client regarding settlement decision

0.2

$250

$50

480

JML

02/08/08

Memo to TSN regarding brief, offer of judgment, and settlement decision

0.5

$250

$125

Page 40 of 43

Case 1:04-cv-01211-MPT

Document 70-2

Filed 07/25/2008

Page 45 of 162

Exhibit B
Item # ATTY Date Description

All Entries by Date
Time Rate

Tab 1
Fee

481

JML

02/08/08

E-mail to TSN regarding client's portion of offer of judgment

0.1

$250

$25

482

TSN

02/08/08

Review clients instructions on settlement and e-mail approval

0.2

$450

$90

483

CAS

02/09/08

Review various e-mails

0.1

$170

$17

484

JML

02/09/08

Draft Notice of Acceptance of Offer of Judgment to opposing counsel

0.1

$250

$25

485

JML

02/09/08

Draft letter to Court regarding acceptance of offer of judgment

0.4

$250

$100

486

TSN

02/09/08

Telephone meeting with client about settlement decision

0.6

$450

$270

487

CAS

02/10/08

Review e-mails from TSN

0.1

$170

$17

488

RW

02/10/08

E-mail from TSN

0.1

$170

$17

489

JML

02/11/08

Teleconference with the Court regarding acceptance of offer of judgment and draft order of judgment to be submitted to the Court

0.3

$250

$75

490

RW

02/11/08

E-mail press release

0.1

$170

$17

491

TSN

02/11/08

Attend telephone conference with the court about resolution of the case and a fee application

0.2

$450

$90

492

CAS

02/12/08

Pleadings review and distribution

0.1

$170

$17

Page 41 of 43

Case 1:04-cv-01211-MPT

Document 70-2

Filed 07/25/2008

Page 46 of 162

Exhibit B
Item # ATTY Date Description

All Entries by Date
Time Rate

Tab 1
Fee

493

JML

02/14/08

Telephone from client regarding pension issue

0.1

$250

$25

494

JML

02/15/08

Telephone to counsel regarding pension issue and draft Order of Judgment E-mail to counsel regarding pension and Order of Judgment and e-mail to client regarding pension issue E-mail to TSN regarding defendants' 2d draft proposed form of order of judgment

0.1

$250

$25

495

JML

02/15/08

0.2

$250

$50

496

JML

02/19/08

0.1

$250

$25

497

JML

02/19/08

2d e-mail to TSN regarding counsel's 2d draft form of Order of Judgment E-mail from opposing counsel and to opposing counsel regarding her 2d draft order of judgment and our pending filing with the Court Draft letter to magistrate regarding proposed form of order

0.1

$250

$25

498

JML

02/20/08

0.1

$250

$25

499

JML

02/21/08

0.1

$250

$25

500

JML

02/21/08

E-mail to TSN regarding draft letter to USM regarding draft form of judgment order

0.1

$250

$25

501

JML

02/22/08

E-mail to SJN regarding my letter to the Judge

0.2

$250

$50

502

SJN

02/22/08

Attempts to log into Pacer to see filings

0.2

$250

$50

503

TSN

02/22/08

Review DI 28

0.1

$450

$45

504

SJN

02/25/08

Pleadings review

0.1

$250

$25

Page 42 of 43

Case 1:04-cv-01211-MPT

Document 70-2

Filed 07/25/2008

Page 47 of 162

Exhibit B
Item # ATTY Date Description

All Entries by Date
Time Rate

Tab 1
Fee

505

TSN

02/25/08

Analyze and create 5 documents to support our fee application. Create a .... [entry stops]

2.5

$450

$1,125

Total

247.6

$72,664

Page 43 of 43

Case 1:04-cv-01211-MPT

Document 70-2

Filed 07/25/2008

Page 48 of 162

TAB 2

Case 1:04-cv-01211-MPT

Document 70-2

Filed 07/25/2008

Page 49 of 162

Exhibit B
Item # ATTY Date

Attorneys Herzog and Warner
Description Time Rate Fee

Tab 2
Prev'ly Listed

324

RW

06/05/07

Attend Wilmington Hospitality v. NCC with Maloney and Rendina/witnesses

0.7

$170

$119

325

RW

06/06/07

Attend Wilmington Hospitality v. NCC with Maloney and Rendina/witnesses

0.5

$170

$85

326

RW

06/06/07

Memo to TSN re: Maloney/Rendina testimony in Wilmington Hospitality case

0.8

$170

$136

350

CAS

07/02/07

E-mail to JLR regarding affidavits and plea agreement

0.2

$170

$34

351

CAS

07/09/07

Review e-mail from TSN regarding client's new job

0.1

$170

$17

373

CAS

07/16/07

E-mail from TSN regarding amended complaint and stay

0.1

$170

$17

381

CAS

08/28/07

Review e-mail from JLR regarding status

0.1

$170

$17

383

CAS

08/31/07

E-mails from TSN

0.1

$170

$17

386

CAS

09/05/07

E-mail from TSN to client regarding settlement

0.1

$170

$17

414

CAS

11/26/07

Review e-mail from defense counsel

0.1

$170

$17

424

CAS

12/05/07

Review e-mails from SJN and TSN

0.1

$170

$17

425

CAS

12/05/07

Review e-mail to defense counsel from SJN

0.1

$170

$17

Page 1 of 3

Case 1:04-cv-01211-MPT

Document 70-2

Filed 07/25/2008

Page 50 of 162

Exhibit B
Item # ATTY Date

Attorneys Herzog and Warner
Description Time Rate Fee

Tab 2
Prev'ly Listed

428

CAS

12/06/07

Locate proposed Rule 16 order

0.4

$170

$68

429

CAS

12/06/07

Meeting with SJN re: Rule 16 order

0.1

$170

$17

453

CAS

01/17/08

Handle overbilling of conference call

0.2

$170

$34

454

CAS

01/17/08

Draft memo re: teleconference billing issue

0.1

$170

$17

465

CAS

02/05/08

E-mail to law clerk re: bluebooking

0.1

$170

$17

476

CAS

02/07/08

File brief and serve copy on court

0.2

$170

$34

477

CAS

02/08/08

Review e-mails from TSN

0.1

$170

$17

483

CAS

02/09/08

Review various e-mails

0.1

$170

$17

487

CAS

02/10/08

Review e-mails from TSN

0.1

$170

$17

488

RW

02/10/08

E-mail from TSN

0.1

$170

$17

490

RW

02/11/08

E-mail press release

0.1

$170

$17

492

CAS

02/12/08

Pleadings review and distribution

0.1

$170

$17

Page 2 of 3

Case 1:04-cv-01211-MPT

Document 70-2

Filed 07/25/2008

Page 51 of 162

Exhibit B
Item # ATTY Date

Attorneys Herzog and Warner
Description Time Rate Fee

Tab 2
Prev'ly Listed

Subtotal

4.7

$799

$0

Total Warner & Herzog (Non-Compensable)

$799

Page 3 of 3

Case 1:04-cv-01211-MPT

Document 70-2

Filed 07/25/2008

Page 52 of 162

TAB 3

Case 1:04-cv-01211-MPT

Document 70-2

Filed 07/25/2008

Page 53 of 162

Exhibit B
Item # ATTY Date Description

Clerical Activities
Time Rate Fee

Tab 3
Prev'ly Listed

11

SJN

10/21/03

Conference with TSN, JLR, MDH to discuss conflict issues.

0.5

$250

$125

12

TSN

10/21/03

Meet with JLR, MH, SJN about conflict of interest issues and the respresentation.

0.5

$450

$225

67

JML

08/17/04

Revise Summons of John Cunningham

0.1

$250

$25

86

JML

08/30/04

Revise Civil Cover Sheet

0.2

$250

$50

116

TSN

09/08/04

E-mail JLR with things to do.

0.2

$450

$90

453

CAS

01/17/08

Handle overbilling of conference call

0.2

$170

$34

$34

454

CAS

01/17/08

Draft memo re: teleconference billing issue

0.1

$170

$17

$17

465

CAS

02/05/08

E-mail to law clerk re: bluebooking

0.1

$170

$17

$17

476

CAS

02/07/08

File brief and serve copy on court

0.2

$170

$34

$34

Subtotal

2.1

$617

$102

Total Clerical (NonCompensable)

1.5

$515

Page 1 of 1

Case 1:04-cv-01211-MPT

Document 70-2

Filed 07/25/2008

Page 54 of 162

TAB 4

Case 1:04-cv-01211-MPT

Document 70-2

Filed 07/25/2008

Page 55 of 162

Exhibit B
Item # ATTY Date

Press-Related Activities
Description Time Rate Fee

Tab 4
Prev'ly Listed

82

TSN

08/27/04

Telephone from the AP.

0.1

$450

$45

92

TSN

08/31/04

Draft press release.

0.6

$450

$270

94

SJN

09/02/04

Press conference.

1.0

$250

$250

97

SJN

09/02/04

Respond to media inquiries.

0.5

$250

$125

103

TSN

09/02/04

Attend press conference for client, preparation.

1.4

$450

$630

363

TSN

07/10/07

Telephone with client, return call from media

0.2

$450

$90

490

RW

02/11/08

E-mail press release

0.1

$170

$17

$17

Subtotal

3.9

$1,427

$17

Total Press (NonCompensable)

3.8

$1,410

Page 1 of 1

Case 1:04-cv-01211-MPT

Document 70-2

Filed 07/25/2008

Page 56 of 162

TAB 5

Case 1:04-cv-01211-MPT

Document 70-2

Filed 07/25/2008

Page 57 of 162

Exhibit B

Unrelated Activities

Tab 5

EEOC Hearing
Item # ATTY Date Description Time Rate Fee Prev'ly Listed

26

TSN

04/08/04

Review JLR letter to EEOC.

0.1

$450

$45

27

TSN

04/10/04

Review memo from JLR.

0.1

$450

$45

35

JML

06/10/04

Meeting with law clerk regarding statute of limitations issue

0.1

$250

$25

36

TSN

06/10/04

Discuss with JLR the EEOC timeliness issue.

0.1

$450

$45

40

JML

06/17/04

Review law clerk's legal research memo regarding statute of limitations

0.3

$250

$75

41

TSN

06/22/04

Review SOL resesarch memo.

0.1

$450

$45

Medical Records
157 JML 12/23/04 Review cardiologist medical records and end of year pay stubs for 2001-2004 0.5 $250 $125

Garcetti
282 SJN 07/05/06 Meeting with TSN re: impact of Garcetti 0.1 $250 $25

283

TSN

07/05/06

Meeting with SJN re: impact of Garcetti

0.1

$450

$45

284

JML

07/25/06

Meeting with TSN regarding case in light of new SCt case

0.2

$250

$50

Page 1 of 6

Case 1:04-cv-01211-MPT

Document 70-2

Filed 07/25/2008

Page 58 of 162

Exhibit B
Item # ATTY Date Description

Unrelated Activities
Time Rate Fee

Tab 5
Prev'ly Listed

288

JML

08/14/06

Telephone to client and e-mail to TSN regarding Supreme Court decision

0.2

$250

$50

289

JML

08/14/06

Review Garcetti decision and analyze its impact on the case

1.0

$250

$250

290

JML

08/14/06

Review TSN brief regarding Garcetti case law affecting this case

0.5

$250

$125

291

JML

08/15/06

Telephone to client and e-mail to TSN regarding S.Ct. decision

0.2

$250

$50

347

SJN

06/24/07

Legal research - speech to grand jury still protect post-Garcetti cases

0.2

$250

$50

Wilmington Hospitality v. NCC
324 RW 06/05/07 Attend Wilmington Hospitality v. NCC with Maloney and Rendina/witnesses 0.7 $170 $119 $119

325

RW

06/06/07

Attend Wilmington Hospitality v. NCC with Maloney and Rendina/witnesses

0.5

$170

$85

$85

326

RW

06/06/07

Memo to TSN re: Maloney/Rendina testimony in Wilmington Hospitality case

0.8

$170

$136

$136

340

JML

06/19/07

Review memo from RW regarding trial testimony of LM and MR in NCC case

0.3

$250

$75

Maloney v. NCC
323 TSN 06/03/07 E-mail to Maloney statements 0.1 $450 $45

330

TSN

06/14/07

Meet with Maloney and Rendina about the facts of the case

1.0

$450

$450

Page 2 of 6

Case 1:04-cv-01211-MPT

Document 70-2

Filed 07/25/2008

Page 59 of 162

Exhibit B
Item # ATTY Date Description

Unrelated Activities
Time Rate Fee

Tab 5
Prev'ly Listed

332

JML

06/18/07

E-mail to RW regarding depositions of LM and MR and to CAH regarding affidavits of LM and MR

0.2

$250

$50

338

JML

06/19/07

Review Complaint and deposition testimony of LM in County case

1.5

$250

$375

339

JML

06/19/07

Review deposition testimony of MR in County case

0.1

$250

$25

342

JML

06/19/07

Prepare questions for interviews of witnesses LM and MR

1.0

$250

$250

343

JML

06/20/07

Continue preparing interview questions

0.5

$250

$125

344

JML

06/20/07

Telephone to LM regarding interview

0.1

$250

$25

345

JML

06/20/07

Draft letter to LM and MR regarding interview

0.3

$250

$75

346

JML

06/21/07

E-mail to witness regarding interviews

0.2

$250

$50

348

JML

06/27/07

Interview MR regarding case

2.0

$250

$500

349

JML

06/27/07

Interview LM regarding case

2.2

$250

$550

350

CAS

07/02/07

E-mail to JLR regarding affidavits and plea agreement

0.2

$170

$34

$34

352

JML

07/09/07

Draft Declaration of LM

3.0

$250

$750

Page 3 of 6

Case 1:04-cv-01211-MPT

Document 70-2

Filed 07/25/2008

Page 60 of 162

Exhibit B
Item # ATTY Date Description

Unrelated Activities
Time Rate Fee

Tab 5
Prev'ly Listed

358

TSN

07/09/07

Review L. Maloney declaration

0.2

$450

$90

361

JML

07/10/07

Draft Declaration of MR

3.0

$250

$750

362

JML

07/10/07

Telephone to LM regarding additional facts for Declaration

0.1

$250

$25

368

JML

07/12/07

Telephone to MR regarding facts

1.4

$250

$350

370

JML

07/13/07

Revise MR Declaration

1.1

$250

$275

371

JML

07/13/07

Revise Declaration of LM

1.4

$250

$350

374

JML

07/23/07

Finalize Declaration of LM

0.4

$250

$100

378

JML

07/26/07

E-mail to co-counsel regarding Declarations and other NCC material

0.1

$250

$25

379

JML

08/23/07

E-mail to MR regarding her declaration

0.1

$250

$25

380

JML

08/27/07

Finalize declaration of MR and e-mail to witness regarding same

1.0

$250

$250

Frivolous Witnesses or Fact Gathering
8 JML 10/10/03 Review deposition of Colonel Cunningham regarding promotions in NCC PD 0.3 $250 $75

9

JML

10/10/03

Memo to TSN regarding Cunningham deposition testimony regarding NCC PD promotions

0.8

$250

$200

Page 4 of 6

Case 1:04-cv-01211-MPT

Document 70-2

Filed 07/25/2008

Page 61 of 162

Exhibit B
Item # ATTY Date Description

Unrelated Activities
Time Rate Fee

Tab 5
Prev'ly Listed

109

SJN

09/03/04

E-mail to TSN & JLR re: Freebery order via Janet Smith to alter police report.

0.1

$250

$25

179

TSN

02/04/05

Meet with KM about NCCPD promotion process.

0.6

$450

$270

319

TSN

05/29/07

Fact investigation, attend the deposition of Maloney & Rendina on the operation of NCC

1.4

$450

$630

115

TSN

09/08/04

Call from M. Allen about the police report claims.

0.2

$450

$90

Unknown Entries
115 TSN 09/08/04 Call from M. Allen about the police report claims. 0.2 $450 $90

175

TSN

01/27/05

Telephone with Jeff Goddess.

0.1

$450

$45

178

TSN

02/02/05

E-mail JLR on Coons transition actions.

0.2

$450

$90

183

TSN

02/09/05

Think about recusal decision by the court.

0.2

$450

$90

188

TSN

02/11/05

File memo on recusal.

0.2

$450

$90

227

TSN

04/05/05

Fact investigation on new public safety director

0.2

$450

$90

228

TSN

04/05/05

Fact investigation on new public safety director

0.2

$450

$90

228

TSN

04/05/05

Fact investigation on new public safety director

0.2

$450

$90

Page 5 of 6

Case 1:04-cv-01211-MPT

Document 70-2

Filed 07/25/2008

Page 62 of 162

Exhibit B
Item # ATTY Date Description

Unrelated Activities
Time Rate Fee

Tab 5
Prev'ly Listed

341

JML

06/19/07

Review deposition of defendant Freeberry in County police case

2.0

$250

$500

364

JML

07/11/07

Review Riddel original and first amended complaints for our First Amended Complaint

1.0

$250

$250

398

TSN

10/09/07

Meet with MH

0.1

$450

$45

401

TSN

10/25/07

Meet with MH re: the case

0.1

$450

$45

411

TSN

11/15/07

Discuss case with MH

0.2

$450

$90

Subtotal

35.6

$9,904

$374

Total Unrelated (NonCompensable)

33.0

$9,530

Page 6 of 6

Case 1:04-cv-01211-MPT

Document 70-2

Filed 07/25/2008

Page 63 of 162

TAB 6

Case 1:04-cv-01211-MPT

Document 70-2

Filed 07/25/2008

Page 64 of 162

Exhibit B
Item # ATTY Date Description

Unspecific Entries
Time Rate Fee

Tab 6
Prev'ly Listed

27

TSN

04/10/04

Review memo from JLR.

0.1

$450

$45

$45

28

TSN

04/21/04

Meet with JLR on status of the case.

0.1

$450

$45

79

SJN

08/27/04

Meeting with TSN.

0.3

$250

$75

80

TSN

08/27/04

Meeting with Steve

0.3

$450

$135

81

TSN

08/27/04

Document drafting, copy counsel to review.

0.3

$450

$135

98

SJN

09/02/04

Telephone with Hank.

0.1

$250

$25

99

SJN

09/02/04

Telephone calls with Tom.

0.2

$250

$50

100

SJN

09/02/04

Fact investigation.

0.5

$250

$125

101

SJN

09/02/04

Calls with Steve.

0.2

$250

$50

104

SJN

09/03/04

Telephone with TSN.

0.1

$250

$25

105

SJN

09/03/04

Call to Hank.

0.1

$250

$25

106

SJN

09/03/04

Fact investigation.

0.3

$250

$75

Page 1 of 7

Case 1:04-cv-01211-MPT

Document 70-2

Filed 07/25/2008

Page 65 of 162

Exhibit B
Item # ATTY Date Description

Unspecific Entries
Time Rate Fee

Tab 6
Prev'ly Listed

107

SJN

09/03/04

E-mail to TSN & JLR.

0.1

$250

$25

110

SJN

09/03/04

Calls with Steve.

0.2

$250

$50

111

SJN

09/07/04

Fact investigation.

0.2

$250

$50

112

SJN

09/08/04

Meeting with TSN.

0.3

$250

$75

117

TSN

09/08/04

Meeting with Steve.

0.3

$450

$135

118

TSN

09/09/04

Review two e-mails from client and reply.

0.2

$450

$90

119

TSN

09/09/04

Investigate facts given by client.

0.2

$450

$90

120

SJN

09/10/04

Fact investigation.

0.1

$250

$25

121

SJN

09/13/04

Review e-mails.