Free Letter - District Court of Delaware - Delaware

Case 1:06-cv-00593-JJF Document 47 Filed 05/28/2008 Page 1 of 1
R:c1—rARos, L.Avr0N 5. FENGER
A ?°l°20F“ESSlONAl. AS50Cl.•\"1‘lON
ONE F?0t:>NEv Sonoma
920 I\E0i=z·rH Keno STREET
CHAD M SHANDLER VVELMMINGTON, DELAWARE IQBOI
Danacron (BOE) ess l—77OCJ SHANDLERQDRLF COM
Fax (302) G5E—77C)l
WWW..RLF..COM
May 28, 2008
VIA HAND DELIVERY AND ELECTRONIC FILING
The Honorable Joseph J. Faman, Jr.
United States District Court
844 King Street
Wilmington, DE 19801
Re: 3V, Inc. v. CIBA Specialty Chemicals Corporation, C.A. No. 06-00593-JJF;
CIBA Specialty Chemicals Corporation v. 3V, Inc., C.A. No. 06—00629·JJF;
CIBA Specialty Chemicals Corporation v. 3V, Inc., C.A. No. 06~006'/2~·JJF
Dear Judge Farnan:
We respectfully refer the Court to ClBA"s Motion for Leave to File a Surreply
(the "Motion") (06-00593-.UF, D.I. #42; 06~O0626~JJF and 06—0O672-·JJF, D.I. #41), and 3V,
lnc.’s response thereto (06-00593-JJF, D.I. #46; 06——00626~.lJF and 06—0O672—JJF, D5. #45). It is
apparent from 3V’s response that it does not oppose ClBA’s Motion. See 3V’s Response at ll i
("3V sees little merit in opposing a tiling that has already been put before the Court.”); see also,
3V’s Response at ‘ll 7 ("3V respectfully requests that the Court put a stop to the seemingly
endless cycle of briefing and take very cautious consideration of the already—submitted
surreply."). While CIBA disagrees with many of the assertions contained in 3V’s response,
CIBA will consider its Motion unopposed and respectfully requests that the Court enter the
Order attached to the Motion.
Counsel will be prepared to address any questions that the Court may have during
the June 6, 2008 hearing, which is the time set for CIBA’s Motion Seeking Leave of Court to
Serve Limited Discovery Relating to 3V’s Disclaimer of its Patent Claims (06—00593»JJF, D.I.
#37; 06—00626~JJF and 06-O0672—JJF, D.I. #36).
Respectfully submitted,
/s/ C/md M Shcmdler
Chad M. Shandler (#3796)
CS:ps
ec: Clerk of Court (via e~filing)
Joseph Grey, Esq. (via hand delivery)
Alan J. Branigan, Esq. (via electronic mail)
attr-zzavzsz-z