Free Memorandum in Opposition to Motion - District Court of Connecticut - Connecticut

Case 3:00-cv-00705-CFD 4 Document 137-3 Filed 03/11/2005 Page 1 014
·· ai 1 C
‘ 1 IN THE UN:c1·m>.sTA1·Es _¤Is1·m:c·r cotmm _·‘. ·
` I 2 Fon THE m:sTm:c•1· OF CONNECTICUT _
; 4 In 4re ~PE Corporation Securities Litigation _ _
ia . 5 · .· Master File No. 3:00CV705(CFD)’ I `
A - _ _ l · 1
I { ———-———-——-——~———— 2 1 1
6 -· 1 " ` I
I 7 DEPOSITION OF·‘ROBERT H. wmmzszrou, M.D., Ph.D. . ·_
` 4 8 . 4 4 4
· . 9 Taken on behalf of the Plaintiff 4
I I 10 August 17, 2004l _ 4 Z I
~ · l' . h ` I _ · I
` 2 - 12 _ CA VBE IT REMEMBERED `THAT, pursuant to the Washington Rules of .
i> ° @{ ,13 Civil Procedure, the deposition of ROBERT H. WATERSTQN, _
` 14 · M.D., Ph.D. was taken before Kathleen Knowlton, a 1
° 15 Certified Shorthand Reporter, # 29906, and a Notary Fublic
· 16 l for the State of Washington, on August 1,7, 2004, .
{ n 17 commencing at the hour of 9:22 a.m. , the proceedings being · *
f 18 _ · reportedat 1001 Fourth Avenue, Suite 25504,ASeatt1e,' -
_, _ 19 4 ` ` Washington} 1 4
4220,44_4,4 —. · . —
L 21 _ _ A ‘ 4 .
. n 24 l S _ · .
i;__4;4 25 » 4. - _
n SPHERION DE1·0sm0N smzvrczs
— (212) 490-3430

1 Case 3:00-cv-00705-CFD Document 137-3 Filed 03/11/2005 Page 2 of 4
· . 2;
1 Z 2 Y 4 ` _ Zi L
· 1 ' 1 xunsxwowxmusup
- 1 5 €éE£“-¢`5?? ’ - 1 111**2*;...1...1.%..1..111,, ::11 . 1 1-
- MILBERG WEISS " ': 2'lD¤=l999 . 1 _
1 1 o¤¤1·¤¤¤y1m1¤1·1m · A Q _41 1 _ _ _ _·
1 NcwYork,NewY¤rk 10119 · — g I6 ·s1¤¤·¤1»¤;¤¥;•§;11»¤»¤1¤1¤s¤¤1 ’70· -;·.
4 (2l2)594-5300 • . . ‘
1 Appenringonbchalfofthe rumen · ‘ " ,,‘*""'_,_,,,1,{*,°,:,,',,*'”°“,,,,°°"“‘,,,, ‘°°°" `”
~ 5
‘ §’鑧`¢‘1I“s‘$Eu%‘~ »?°'”`“·········“"·'?-Y'?"··»$’·’»»$°"’“"°"°"’“
411 1 SlMPSONTHACHER&BARTl.I?I'1;,l.I.P ` ' ’ *’ c*·“[:·_·{_°:¤*g"m·¤,,,,°F¤** 1* ° ‘ _ "
" _ 4 _-1A25Le•1i¤gw¤Avenug 1 · _ _ _ _ _ _ _ l gg · ·
1 8 ·NewY¤:k,N¤wY¤rk·l00l7 · U 20 l·1andwr1t|¤¤& 1:
· (2l2)455-2205 - 1 °’
1 1% Appearing on behalf ofthebefendants · lz 2] com '€"“::°u$;;°:9'°°‘°°°°l"°° 99
ALSO rxxasmm ·1·0mr·r1nn1a·rrs,1na¤»g1¤pn¤ B Z w..¤¤E°;11'TE°&» °° W ·
1 11 14
1 1 12 B E»•1nil|i¤¤1B¤hW•¤¤¤¤¤¤¤Fa¤¤is IM
`S T 13 1 1 _1 ». _ , 1: 24,, 110
' nz-¤ns¤¤1= ·c¤n· Jdm 112 -
1 {$ 18 ” s.1....¤m‘E»“ "“‘° . ·
1 18 19 26 1s-¤»ns¤¤'m¤¤sc¤111¤»»n.;u- 111
. 19 . vi-- 1 ~ ·· 20 * 1
1 3) 21 wmmmnnmo W f
1 22 28 Bm•ll§om_Fn¤¤isCol1i1xs•¤Bob 12I
. 1 22 wmmnmsrazom _ 1
· 2.3 _ 23
‘ 24 _ 2* . 1
‘ 1 zs 25 - 1 1
-1 1 __ _ _ 3 Us ‘ _
1 1 ¤l*¤¤< - ` - ' ` 1 `SEALITLE, WASHTNGTON; TUESDAY, AUGUST -17; 2004: 1 t
z uummax nmcnumou mcs
1 s 1 a¤¤11¤¤¤.1umsu¤¤¤» .-2.4 _ 1 4 2 9:224.M. »
1 A ‘g1;*;*g7§,Y’*“°'**"*°"*•“* ‘ ‘ ‘ 2 THEV1DEOGRAPHER:W¢:nreonthcrecord. This
1 1 5 2 MN;¢:h•¢;:T;¤¤“€¤l¤¤¤*•¤¤ 28 4 isasmtementforavideodeposidon. lamthc 1 1
4 e ` ‘ 1 5 videogtapher. MynameisTc¤yT¤1betts. Pmhereon ·
, ’ 1 §;';_°g;_¤, Z? 1 V l _ 6 be11alfo1`Naegc1iRep0rtingCu1pomti0n,60lUnicnSu·eet, 1
1 x W1/99 _ ` · 7 Su1te 1624, Seattle, Washmgton.
_ 1 4 _ M¤11¤r¢:S•nmny¤fC¤¤1r¤¤1iou.s 33 _ 8 This videotaped dq>0$1110¤ hlsbwllloticcdby _: -
1 1;;.- ·*·;L*·;;·_§·*·,1g*__{,§·{,°_;’1?____ 10 1 ,6 9 · ¤m>¤1¢yL¤¤w¤a$&;1vs·be1¤g mam August 17, 2004, j 1
il H 10 9:22 mm. The locauonnsthelaw offices ofMi1b¤·g
12 s I 40 ·‘· - " · ·1l WeissBershad, 1001 4111 Avenue, Suit1e2550,Se¤ttlc, _ _
1 i=*@**·‘ *¤“ 12 wasnmgmn. · ‘
1 U 1 1a·¤as¤¤:Im1I»::‘»¤•;m 45 ‘ 13 ’1'hecasecapt1onisinre1’1E»(Qo1·pp1ution _ _ 1
S I ,5 , vF;_mM,,,,, ,,¤,,,, 48 14 SecuritiesLitigationintheUnitedSt:§tesDislrictCo1¤‘t I ' 1 "
* ""‘“‘”’“" 15 f¤rtheDistrictofConnecticut,case number `
1 16 -
` U 9 F·¤¤¤f~¤¤ki¤$¤\¤¤»·m 53 16 300CV705(CFD). Thedep0nentisRob¤tWatc:st0n,l\11.D.,
4 1 ymyggg ' 17 Ph.D. Would counsel and allpresesxtpleaseiderntify 1 _
` 1 '“ I0 Bmumnwwmnmbrmds 55 18 yourselvcsnndstntewhomyoureprsmn l ·
· gz H Cgmmmg mm 57 19 MR.WE1SS:LeeWciss,Mi1b¤·gWe1ssBe:shadan¢1 `
— I h¤,“,¤,;||,q119g c 20 Shlllmhufcflhcplainifli.
. 1 2 I2 cE?fm;;;~b9w“mnm&”ds 60 _ 2 Bm] MRIj' c\71*lu1iamt;{egan, Simpson Thachcrand
` .’°“ 1 1 1 °“» N °
1 Z " c",;;',§’,°,i'ff,,,“{1",j,°°“,,,,'”"°""‘°’ " zz MILBOURQUE: 1z¤1»¤m¤1¤q¤¤, Simps0nThachcr,
14 Erl1lZl·1B‘0¤\F|II1¢1$C0111HS\0FIEd$ 65 24 an dc&ndams` _ _ _ _ I
zs c¤11a1¤,¤»1.¤¤1 12/111211 25 T1-IEVIDEOGRAPHER: Thcdcp0s1t10n1sbc1ngtaken
I
1 2 (Pages 2 to 5) - 1
` · 1 SPHERION DEPOSITION SERVICES
(212) 490-3430

Case 3:00-cv-00705-CFD Document 137-3 Filed 03/11/2005 Page 3 of 4
- · 14 16 _
A ·` ' . 1 University? ·` 1 A. Sciugtificmeetings. :1 · _ ‘_ _ - (
____ _ 2 ·A; Iwa$·thedi1·eqtor`0f111egenomeeeQ11t¤in 2 - `Waslgetypicallypresentingatttnesemeeégrgsor `
_ ' `_A: ·` . 3 I
E 4 '=Q·"W¤i6‘w¤·év§1¤=¤¤¤¤1¤i>¤t<§¤t§¤T¤¤dB¤>f1¤¤" 4 1 . .1 ·... `
1 `s Hxi¤1.u¤d¤·j€éé§111eb}e£é16f1t1¤g¤ur»me" `"euntéat. 5 `· A.‘Typip¤11x%iew¤e-v}ewd¤bc¤npx¤m¤¤g_' f' .` `. ·
1 = 6 ·mr,ma1z141¤ao1su¢·1s1¤a¤rm¤g¤1¤¤¤¤q11¤¤ ,6·11¤¤16¤q1g¤¤1z¤a6¤¢»¤1§pr1¤6¤a¤g¤,.w11;¤1.1.¤$1;.11y 1
· 1 Baylor. 1 _ "7 MM · -»`. .1 ‘ 1··’ -
1- g ·Q; -w11¤w1;4u1z;1¤a¢1_p¤g¤11¤r·p¤¤¤é$°f¤iu1é"_ 8 Q.- Did¤i¢i¤¤¤¤i¤i6m6wb¤=v¤¤i¤m¤¤•i¤¤1· . tl ‘
*1 _. 9 ·· ·, - 9_Mr.Ve11¢g·vhswb1ki11k011qequ¤1ei¤gd1ehqh1mgmo11ie? ·' ·
` 10 ‘A.- ;· . 10_. `w11x¤£¢¤i1.‘_ _· Q ·
. I1 mmm ll TI1EW¤'N!i$=S¤m¤¤¤i¤z11i1?h¢.¤1¤sw¤rt11<=. ` -
· 12 Q. whowuetineleaciindividnsalsinvolvedforthé 12 · N · ;.:`, - ¥
‘ ns s¤¤g¤·1¤s11m1¤?·‘ A · ’ 13 1MP¢.RBG4N?`Y¢¤1?¢.: ‘ - I A . l 1
- - · · ‘ 14 A. 16u¤s¤1¤6¤ymm¤u11s¤>1¤;,¤;1aJ5¤ek¤g¤¤ ` 14 _ _1111z;wrr111zss£_u¢·-¢1me¤¤,¤¤¤&¤6m¢1¤q1¤-‘ · `
W ‘ 15 rA¤11»¤1r»qi¤ém1113;‘1s¢¤1;1·a11;. V __ ‘ 15 1¤11ie·s0s_1»p;1¤r1q11s¤q¤¤1zshg11¤1¤¤¤15N1xA¤a-1¤a °
" ‘ 16 rQ;··A¤a·w1s¤¢»wa§i11¢1m1v¤1ge¤ém·1xq;1¤¤1a¤”o¤16m _16 ¤¤11w¤s1¤vp1veu@»qq¤¢1¤;¤;;11¤u¤m¤6g¤16mea1u1a1 __
· °' 11‘·1>¤»5é&6r¤1¢w¤11¤¤m`· °· ·6¤1w¤;t11·;y111v61v¤a 17 am, · .--· " —· ‘ - . j
‘ _ ns wmsmgw 1 T 18 _ BYMILWHSS: U 4.
_ __ 19 _ ‘ ‘ 1 19 _ Q. Did`§ouevq·_11tte11dt11emeetingswheke11g· _ 1 4 .
. : 20k` .` `· `_* . 20 r1is¤¤s§¤ii·h`i¥=v¤r1<66£eqii¤1¢in1;-ii¤¢=|i¤¤¤1¤¤z1¥¤¤1>¤¤¢? ‘ '
· .. 21 ébiectihsirto · 21·· o1>j¤¤¢1k»1h¤r黤¤L.· "T ., ·
1 22 meson y6u·‘¤1ig6’¤11q121ma¤1;w¤m¢qt»6su¤¤ zz _ ’[1·IE·W1TNESS: H6-—Il¤&|'1,·hé 1£lt _ »
4 f 23 o6jEE1;¤¤‘1¤1n¤r¤¤111 __ _ 23 ‘s¢v¤¤1m6¤111ig; 1‘a6¤·1;--1m¤a11,m1¤·;¤_¤¤¤;1;1q111¤¤ `- 1,
:—2Q1‘ ‘1111111&1wy¤éu11‘t1` · ·_ _ __ _ 24 t‘¤mm."A;1d11espq¤e:1¤6g;u1ree_ggsme1s(p11;1¤¤1ie),11‘¢1r ‘· .
g 25 "1'HEWHNESSi‘Ok¤yi ’1'11eWel1co¤1eTnist\1vast11e 25 insta11ee,andrepo1·tedbx1t11¤tir1t1iemid‘90s`or - " ; j_ » V
1 Nw 1s_ · 17i ?
_ 1 l11.q0I'.h111d€.9fd\¤ SQ.Dg¤'C¤1t¤`. 1 sqmetiiingzlijcethat. 1 ‘ ` ~- .
°‘‘· ‘ ·" 5 2 BY`MR;WEI§S: 1 _ - 2 · BYMR.-WEISS5 _ -· · 1
I 3 Q. And do youkuow who theicadpason orpersons 3 ‘Q. P1·iortoDece11f¤•:r1999,didyo1111z1vea¤y 1 l
1 % 4 W¤¢fQ[(h8W6u¤0l21ZéT!U§? ‘ _A 4 COml11I.¤li¢8.1.10I1SW111l.MI.v¤X1¢d' 0d1¤'@8t·d1¢$6 ; · 1 g
- ` 5 5 sciezxtiiicmeetingstlgagyouwerlisunssedi ‘ _ . · ,
._ / .· X 6 Idon‘t , 6 A. _1-qofor§¥1`wasig1ivas·a·eo-organiier _ ” Z
” ` . 7 remc1r1be1*W1iot11e11e¤@140t‘t11§:#11le11e9meTr11stwasatt11e 7 of·#ofamectingvgit11'b£m;1t11ink,tyvsgyea1*sn11111i¤g. 1
. _ 84 time,whether·itwhs—Idot1’tre1n¤nbet. ‘_ _ 8 Andsowehadvaij1l:i11soom111uuiéatio¤saboutthes11mmd` .
_ 5 9 Q.·"1`hereeo¤1eatimewhczeyo11met‘a11indi1giduz11 9_ substzmeeofthat-iioftbht meetipgi lkioiftkuow. l _ _
` 10 ¤8m¢dC12igV@t¢f?4 '“ A ` A 10"I11e1·ew¤·e,youk11ovyQ.vnrious1iho11ec:11lsos§0giatedwit11g
_ U 11 _ Ai. Yes; Imq1C¤igpr¤1;2b1yi¤·1»9812;·'89,-·-··’= 1 11 1b¤¢.··$1‘11¤·¤$i¤epmb3`.1111yo111¤r¤>;¤1i¤¤gqs.w111¤ _` ·
· ¤2‘¤¢f1¤·¢¢1»i¤s¤t¤¤=‘¤·¤¢. ‘;·· .:*3 · ; rz =·»1»s¤·1·=¤<»1¤»¤=¤1¤·»1>,1.;1··‘·"‘,.,1 ,·.1 » ¤ - A ~ .1
. _ ‘ 13 `·Q:4‘A1ra*¢ai1yai111§;p¤1·11ej1u¤”¤n¤1m$¤¤‘ ‘‘‘‘_· i‘é66f:@jhcn_ 1s·=··jq..1·r16a·‘11;1>¤¤¤¤11»·¤j_"_ "_19ss;a111yq&:¤ve1:g11;11¤1a1¤ ·· ·_
· — 14 y¤¤sm¤1¤‘r11¤.v¤i¢az2¤·- ·1j~‘·¤‘j ‘ ·_ 14 m¤p1¤1¤¤·gs1au1qm¤;¢y¤r.¤1¤q»Au¤aq16g9 · 1-
1 15 A. Acu1a11y,1‘m1iotéure.f1`1ii£1·c1ir¤·eaco1i;i1c ' 15 MrLVeute1·¥vasusi11gt¤1£eq11¤1ceh1111:z1t1DNA? __ l
_ 16 different oeeasious W‘1¤lI—l`111`¤Qt§1fCW11id1 one ‘ 16 MR.REGAN:0bjecti611t9the1"o1*1not;t11e _
» 17 00C1|HOdHfSt.:]II.0l\¢¢8S§II11dh1!11BK‘8D10§(.1¤g,3Dd 17 question. " 1
18 a11ot11¤·easeI~visited1:1is1aboutsidcof—¢;utsideof 18 THEW1TNESS:Soatth~€ti111e,yo11mea¤d1e _
. 19 Washingtoh. P · ""· - ‘ 19 mcth011sthathewasusi11gin1999?' · ·
` · .f 20 Q. Andwh¤1isthene1tttime$¤ou contact 20 BYMR.WE1SS:· _ - A ` l
‘ - 1 21 with Mr. V¤1tg;1·a&ertyo11re;rly1i1eetings·1rzit11hiu1? " 21 Q. Correct. O1·atur1ytimep1iorthei·eto. l A
1 D A. 0h?Ica111einco11tactwid1hi1u,youknow,tw0 or 22 We1l,11eusedY11va1iety0fdii}`erentmcth0¢1s ` - · `
I 23 threetimw iycarforsometi1net11ereait`tc1*atmeeti1igs of 23 ovcrtheyeors. ADd··8|IdId10I.1§1t tliecarlymethods l
| 24 various kinds, mostly. __ ’ ‘ " " 24 thathewasusing didrfttakeadvantage ofthe ébilityto
` ‘ .25 Q. Andwhzrt tyyjes of meetings werethese? 25 assemble complicated DNA. Andsohe exaggerated the I
··-··· ‘ ’ · . 5(Pagw 141017)
— SPHERION DEPOSITION SERVICES .
(212)490-3430

Case 3:00-cv-00705-CFD Document 137-3 Filed 03/11/2005 Page 4 of 4
= . V I .v ·. . _ ~ M _ J. ` . - ._ _ I .. ·_: . .._ _ rrd.,
1 . 18 ‘ zo ` 1 _ ·
1 1 natuncofthcproblmns. _ _ ‘ _ 1 BYMR.WE1SS: 1 ·
1 2 Byl999·hcw4satt¢mptingtod11w1101cf¤10mc 2 Q. '¤l¤'¢¤0l'I\¤I.&II1¢1D_I1IQ‘9'0S,i1]_t])¢]8t¢‘90$ ‘: _ __
1 s ¤1»1g1m,·¤¤das11.¤-.16£m¢y1¤1¤gq1amg;¤4-ma1 s w1¤¤y¤au¤¤m¤s¤v¤1v¤a111¢nqq»ss1¤p¤»&;;111¤q1¤¤¤¤°1Q
1 4 4 111eg·wid1od1¢1·m¤¤b¤s¤fd1¤1111;hanG¤i1¢111e1¤1;¤j¤¤- 1 .
1 5 pat11toaocxnpl¤tc1md{inishgdhumnng¤1¢1x¤€`£cqud1cc.; S; ; · H
1 6 Q. Wdst11¢w1161égq1o1pes[1otg;mn1qi1iod_di£f¤¤1t 6 1
- v_1=mmu1¤1¤e111¤au¤¢u1e1~1¤¤sa1¤c¢n¤m¤r165p¢1wqs ‘ 7 qucEliouagain?` · ‘ ·
1 8 ¤¤mg¤£¤gd1e¤¤qu¤1cing_qfth¤h1¤ngn;¤1om.;? 8 .Q.,1)idt11qco¤mca_timci1;t11¤1agg‘90s·9vh¤=`you '
1 9 ` - 9 1»¤m¤1¤v¤1v¤a·1&1u1ms¤1¤¤i»;11111»1ng»m¤qup¤¤¤ru1¢ :
1 . 10 nmwnNz5s:.1¢msL1¤1¤s¢,$;s;¤11yme _ 1¤·.n¤¤1¤¤cgmqm5¤¤¤g¤aa¤g.;pqs¤1‘¤1¤qpu¤p¤¤¤¤a_ 1 ·
' 11 wswwormepmceswakmqsugg Y51111;g1_1¤¤k¤¤NA, 11 w1u114n.V¤11¤·¤p¤mp;¤y1__’ _ ‘ . ‘ ·
1 12 btéakitujiinionrnailllbiisindgdindividnxinlsoqumqc ·_ 12 ` ·A; Yea. .· `; "" - __ " ’ . .
1 13 I¤dS§U\'¤Ih¢8!I18ub1B,IlId-l¤d:8!Idl!SS$l]?léuldIL _. 13 Q. Wh¤•d0y0uGrstr¤¤11lh3xving_1l10sg:; .1; .
1 14 14 _. X _ _ "
$ 15 15 `A."1`hcy—t11cycamcup`atyqriousju1;c1¤:cs.1i1¤m ,.. 1 `
-i:» 16 ¤1¤;=b¤u1use.ss¤¤¤·1;1y1¤1¤i¤1¤1s61a1p1;¢a1¤é1¤¤e1a1;g .=.‘ ,16 111qg¤;1u¤1¤q¤1;.ppk¢•q11¤gi1i;1p.-p¤g;¤¤;1¤r . · · _ _
· 17 ¤¤aa¤1mgw1u1_¤1y»&1*ns¤qu¤1°· ""-tpm b1exL " · 11"»q¤¤¤¤¤,·" __ _a11a114e11_mmp¤¤_f·n¤uy.mg;1¤a¤¢;1g»1¤-._ , ._
1 18 BYMR.WE1SS: _ _; ; .. - 18'1n1hcfa1l"df'99. “ V ` _· __
1 19 Q._¤¤y¤¤1¤¤»111ru1¤¤»;·¤ev¤1uq1¤.111·1999 ‘ _ 19 Q. 1>¤y¤¤m111_1»qw11w¤¤¤mb»¤11g1118y¤a1· _ _
- 20 wh¤¤lMr,Vq1t¤;madc§ub1i€:i12tdu¤1ts.1¤g§tdingwbathc` 20 . ' I
1 21 hadaccc1uj>lishcd·wit11¢h&wb61cg¤1b1ncsh<§g§un“méti11odan 21 consid¤·ingnc0lhbg;p1ibi{11rid1'Mn°1l¤16¤’s-éompmy7'- 1 · .
‘ 22 yvuihwghtdiat-thatbisclaimswiichacdjiuw? · zz MKRBGAN: 01»5¤pag¤F1p111¤t¤¤m‘ _· : »
za MR.1;1zGAN;..01>5¤¤11¤¤1¤111¤·£¤1¤11¢1%¤1¤11¤¤_ za “‘1·111;w1rN1éss:Z.1‘¢a11*11111111¤g1»;1¤s¤;ta¤1i·¤ .;_ 1 .
. _ 24 ov¤bmad,{i1np¤ss1'blp-to-an;wq·.,qnxéstion..It_¤b¤ns ` _24 thinkyouéantallciboint mtqing .
» 25 unfair.'I1i§;wholcg¤16nié_x11¢j;gunmpd1o1j.i§amct11odthat .intoac011q1:go1;a1i0n.Imc§1x;·I‘¤in11n¢_-es0I'mu0tsux1c _ ? _` · .
Z : " .
g 1 GraigVcntcrmayhavcuti1iz¤dinpa:tic111arpointsjn 1 w11at—1m¤m,arcy0uta1kingabout—P1nnq¢sumwho Z
1 2 timc,tlmtCclcramayhavcuti1izo¢1—atp1i1·1ic111arpoi111s 2 youwanttu-whoycnhcwordqdnbouglngin l _ 3
Y 3 in1im¤._ihs¤tCs=l5·»11am¤yh¤vp11gspdatdii1’¢zmtpoi¤xsi¤ 3 BYMR.WE1SS:_ _` " . 1 _
‘ _ 4_ 4 timqf0rdiffq·cntgcn¤1ncs,bé'itI)1j¤sophi1bort11ch1m1an 4 Q. w¢l1,I'mD0fW0lT1¤i8\20l1|i§!l)f4?h¢. 1nthq_ . P
1 5 gcnom¤0rC.<;1cgnns. · . _. " 5 fa11—y0u1p¤11ioned1hcfa11qt;1999ankl·np0ss1'bl¢ ; .
_,» . 6 Anda¤yqt;1t¢mc1itst11a{C1€11igV;n£cr11iad¤in 6Q co11abomtionWithC17aig'sco1npan3non+1w(1n0w;p11ldbct11c- - _ *
A 1 v 1999·b¢¤¢·1m¤p¤1u¤1»1¤¤m¤u1qa1paj41n¤¤¤1¢g¤»¤m¢s, 1 p¤¢¤1e1¤1¤¢11¤¤¤m¤¤¤1¤¤y¢¤v1¤¢¤¤i¤»ki1¤z6£2.°" ; _
Z ·8 ifsjust-so 8 MR.1§EGAN:·01§oi=;i¤n`tod1cfm£11. Z; Y " ‘ _
1 9 couldinsweqehequesrion. _` _ 91 `THE§v1‘1"NESS;1·mpa1;,icdidn't4-i;•iid¤’¢' ·
; _1o _ "MR.WElSS:.‘I§}ou1q1ndvi§q,you`éwhy'¢1on‘tyou 10* ·m¤uy°r1ga¤¤1¤wau.m¤ s¤1u11¤1;u1m1a¤4.1r1__ · . · _
1 `11 ,x¤¢11:11qg¤¤g11..¤11vq¤•11¤_. _ 11 ¤¤a¤may;¤¤-1r1m¤;¤¤a¢1¤.u1¤1»;¤;u1q1. _- 1
1 12 qu¢s1i¤¤,rmmé11¤·u1éuu¤.°_‘g_;."‘-_ 1, .' 4 l 12 qm11m,111¤Lu11s.:u1¤g¤s¤p¤rnyq1111g11¤§gy,qg,_ f 1 . A
9 1 13.-:1!e¢¤=¤&¤fi¤¥>€.i»&2¤%¤12111>1i¤=¤”¢¢*!¤¤*¥Y{¤¢!vx**·¤¤*’
* = 1 ‘l4 hnyspegiiiq 14 `éallsi And-ai1é11hésu15je¢téémeji1p_i11'-g_j11q¤1;¤f:'. e `
· -15·¤bo¤t‘~;bd¤t111¢m¤u1c¢¤1¤gy,5j111¤;@v;g;1e,;‘u1¤y`w¤-¤1;y IS 11m$¤P1m¤¤1n11qw_;¤11 I ‘_ _ .
1 16 .. ".\ . ‘ 16 nvmnwxsrss; __ ;
17 BYMRIWEISS: -, 17 _ Q. Doy0urqca11wh01i1·strais•qd.thcs11bj;=5=t‘l_ _ 5; ·
T 18 Q. Doyourocall- . 1 ·_ z` - 18 A. No,I‘nhn0tsu1·¢._I-d9n#t-—}1£:au't:¤x1¤nbcr._1 ._
I 19 -A. —pr0je¢.icns.‘ ‘ · ;.*~~. ._ ' · 19 fo1·sur¤1ltwas—I'don1ybcgucssing. - ., ·_ » f
' 20 Q. D0you1·eca11auy—mysin1i1tiouwh¤§e 20_ Q. Inthcfa1lpt'1999,whow¤ethctypi¢:a1_ ·
21 Mr.V¤1t¤n1adcaforvw;:1·d-1ooking$tatexumt,aud you _ 21 participanfsin thcwcckly phone calls?. 1. ._ ' . -
. 22 tl10ught111at§l1¢predicdq1fwas nnglilnclyio éometiuc? _, 22 A. 'l`11¤¤w¤c1hchcad§0ft11é—of§11c6ycmaj0r ·_ .
. 23 ‘ 'MKREGAN: Objec1ion,0vcrbroad:mdin·elcva¤L 23 ,scqu¤ncing ocntqs, a1ong with Francis Collins and Michaql 1
24 THE WITNESS: Ican‘t-I110¤'t remember any 24 Morgan,aswc1laskcyn1¤nbersot'111cStn1i`0fal10f `
, 25 particular instance i 25 th0scccut¤s,and·aswcllasNHCiR1sta§`an;1od1¤s. 1
_ · ' 6(Pagcsl8to21) ‘~
· . SPHERION DEPOSITIONSERVICES
(212) 490-3430-- A