Free Exhibit List - District Court of Colorado - Colorado

Case 1:01-cv-02089-MSK-CBS

Document 247

Filed 05/08/2006

Page 1 of 33

JOINT EXHIBIT LIST

Case No. 01-cv-2089-MSK-CBS Dean A. Bramlet v. Aspen Valley Hospital District
Exh. # 1 Witness Bramlet Description Curriculum Vitae of Dean A. Bramlet; BRAMD102105 Curriculum Vitae of Samar Khoury, M.D.; Dep. Ex. 84; BRAMD1956-1960 Stip Off er Rec' d Refus ed Ruling Reserved Comments/Infor mation

2

Cohen Kremer Middlebrook Gaul

3

Cohen Kremer Middlebrook Gaul

Curriculum Vitae of Edmund Gaulden, M.D., F.A.C.C.; Dep. Ex. 85; BRAMD1961-1963

4

Cohen Kremer Middlebrook Gaul

Curriculum Vitae of Abhishek Gaur, M.D; Dep. Ex. 86; BRAMD1964-1966

5

Cohen Kremer Middlebrook Gaul

Curriculum Vitae of Mirhassan Farivar, M.D., F.A.C.C.; Dep. Ex. 87; BRAMD1967-1971

6

Cohen Kremer Middlebrook Gaul

Curriculum Vitae of Sasan Ghaffari, M.D.; Dep. Ex. 88; BRAMD1972-1973

7

Cohen Kremer Middlebrook Gaul

Curriculum Vitae of Christine Villarino, M.D.; Dep. Ex. 89; BRAMD1974-1977

8

Cohen Kremer Middlebrook Gaul

Curriculum Vitae of Hamid Taheri, M.D.; Dep. Ex. 90; BRAMD1978-1981

9

Cohen Kremer Middlebrook Gaul

Curriculum Vitae of Faisal Wahid, M.D.; Dep. Ex. 91; BRAMD1983-1987

Case 1:01-cv-02089-MSK-CBS

Document 247

Filed 05/08/2006

Page 2 of 33

10

Bramlet Kremer Middlebrook Ayers Martinez

AVH Professional Code of Conduct for Physician and Allied Health Professionals of AVH, 2/4/98, BRAMD106 AVH Medical Staff Development Plan, Summary of Survey Results; Dep. Ex. 16; AVH/B 0423-0425; BRAMD908-910 Credentials Policy & Procedure Manual; Dep. Ex. 57; AVH/B 0067-0094; BRAMD587-614

11

Bramlet Kremer Middlebrok Cohen Bauer Bramlet Kremer Middlebrook Voigt Cohen Bramlet Kremer Middlebrook Cohen Bauer Bramlet Kremer Middlebrook Cohen Bauer Kremer Middlebrook

12

13

AVH Medical Staff Development Plan survey; Dep. Ex. 58; COH00680069 AVH Medical Staff Development Plan summary of total survey results; BRAMD160-162 AVH Medical Staff Committee Roster 1999/2000; BRAMD119120 AVH Physician/Allied Health Staff Policy Regarding Disruptive Conduct; Dep. Ex. 97; BRAMD203-204 Flowsheet for Physician/Allied Health Staff Policy regarding disruptive conduct, 2/7/97; Dep. Ex. 98; BRAMD205 AVH Form for Documenting Disruptive Behavior; BRAMD206-207 AVH reappointment application, 4/25/00; BRAMD229, 228, 227, 230, 233, 232, 231, 236, 235, 234; AVH/B 1884, 1885, 1861, 1895-1901 Principles of Agreement between AVH & Morris Cohen, M.D., 6/21/00; Dep. Ex. 55; BRAMD1849-1854; AVH/B 1396-1401

14

15

16

Bramlet Kremer Middlebrook Cohen Bramlet Kremer Middlebrook Cohen Bramlet Kremer Middlebrook Cohen Bramlet Kremer Middlebrook Ayers Martinez Kremer Middlebrook Cohen

17

18

19

20

Case 1:01-cv-02089-MSK-CBS

Document 247

Filed 05/08/2006

Page 3 of 33

21

Kremer Middlebrook Cohen

Principles of Agreement between AVH & Morris Cohen, M.D., 9/10/02; Dep. Ex. 56; BRAMD2204-2210 Principles of Agreement between AVH and Dr. Gerson, 8/14/00; Dep. Ex. 40; AVH/B 1368-1375 Principles of Agreement between AVH & Gerson, 6/1/03; BRAMD22192226; AVH/B 1599-1606 Principles of Agreement between Internal Medicine, AVH, Mass and Cohen; Dep. Ex. 63; BRAMD1761; AVH/B 1269 Agreement for Assignment of Medical Practice between Cohen and Borchers, 9/15/99; BRAMD2196-2198 AVH Medical Staff Development Plan Threshold Criteria Per Specialty; BRAMD424462 AVH Medical Staff Development Committee Specialty Needs Analysis, 9/01; Dep. Ex. 80;COH0046-0048; BRAMD1819-1821 Medical Staff Development Policy; Dep. Ex. 82; BRAMD19351947; AVH/B 1457-1469

22

Kremer Middlebrook Cohen Gerson Kremer Middlebrook Cohen Gerson Mass Cohen Kremer Middlebrook

23

24

25

Kremer Middlebrook Cohen

26

Kremer Middlebrook Cohen Ayers Martinez Kremer Middlebrook Cohen Ayers Martinez Kremer Middlebrook Cohen Ayers Martinez Kremer Middlebrook Cohen Ayers Martinez Kremer Middlebrook Cohen Ayers Martinez Kremer Middlebrook Cohen Ayers Martinez

27

28

29

MEC minutes, 2/4/98 (page 3); AVH/B 0122; BRAMD642

30

05/11/98 Medical Staff Development Committee of Aspen Valley Hospital Meeting Minutes (AVH/B 0452-0455) 08/05/98 MEC Meeting Minutes (AVH/0148-0154)

31

Case 1:01-cv-02089-MSK-CBS

Document 247

Filed 05/08/2006

Page 4 of 33

32

Kremer Middlebrook Cohen

08/25/98 Medical Staff Development Committee of Aspen Valley Hospital Meeting Minutes (AVH/B 0456-0458) BRAMD941943 11/04/98 MEC Meeting Minutes (AVH/B 01740182) BRAMD687-695

33

Kremer Middlebrook Ayers Cohen Martinez Kremer Middlebrook Ayers Martinez Kremer Middlebrook Ayers Martinez Kremer Middlebrook Ayers Martinez Kremer Middlebrook Ayers Martinez

34

AVH General Medical Staff meeting minutes, 12/15/98; BRAMD138-142 AVH MEC meeting minutes 1/6/99; Dep. Ex. 6; AVH/B 0193-0196; BRAMD562-565 AVH General Medical Staff Meeting Agenda, 3/16/99; BRAMD133 09/14/99 Medical Staff Development Committee of Aspen Valley Hospital Meeting Minutes (AVH/B 0469-0471) BRAMD954956 MSDC minutes (page 4), 9/14/99; AVH/B 0475; BRAMD962 10/06/99 MEC Meeting Minutes (AVH 0256-0263) BRAMD765-772

35

36

37

38

Kremer Middlebrook Ayers Martinez Kremer Middlebrook Ayers Martinez Kremer Middlebrook Ayers Martinez

39

40

11/02/99 Medicine Department of Aspen Valley Hospital Meeting Minutes (AVH/B 16421651) 11/08/99 Board of Directors of Aspen Valley Hospital Meeting Minutes (AVH/B 0624-0632) BRAMD1107-1114 12/03/99 Credentials Committee of Aspen Valley Hospital Meeting Minutes (AVH/B 0399)

41

Kremer Middlebrook Cohen

42

Kremer Middlebrook Ayers Martinez

43

Kremer Middlebrook Ayers Martinez Cohen

Recommendation of the MSDC to the Board, 12/18/99; Dep. Ex. 78; COH0043; BRAMD1818; AVH/B 1268

Case 1:01-cv-02089-MSK-CBS

Document 247

Filed 05/08/2006

Page 5 of 33

44

Kremer Middlebrook Cohen Kremer Middlebrook Cohen Ayers Martinez Kremer Middlebrook Cohen

Consent Agenda from 1999 Board minutes regarding Bramlet's status; BRAMD143-146 Medicine Department Meeting minutes, 1/4/00; AVH/B 1292-1293; BRAMD1197-1198 01/10/00 Board of Directors of Aspen Valley Hospital Meeting Minutes (AVH/B 0645-0650) Medical Staff Appointments 1998-2000 Chart (AVH/B 0426-0448) 1-28-00 Credentials Committee of Aspen Valley Hospital Meeting Minutes (AVH/B 0400) 02/09/00 MEC Meeting Minutes (excerpts) (AVH/B 0294a & AVH/B 0297)

45

46

47

Kremer Middlebrook Cohen Kremer Middlebrook Ayers Martinez Kremer Middlebrook Ayers Martinez Cohen Kremer Middlebrook Cohen

48

49

50

02/14/00 Board of Directors of Aspen Valley Hospital Meeting Minutes (AVH/B 0651-0656) BRAMD1134-1139 03/01/00 MEC Meeting Minutes (AVH/B 03000310) BRAMD809-818

51

Kremer Middlebrook Cohen Ayers Martinez Kremer Middlebrook Cohen

52

Minutes of the AVH BOD meeting 3/13/00; AVH/B 0658-0663; BRAMD11411146 AVH General Medical Staff Meeting Minutes, 3/21/00; Dep. Ex. 106; AVH/B 2419-2424

53

Kremer Middlebrook Cohen Ayers Martinez Kremer Middlebrook Cohen Ayers Martinez Kremer Middlebrook Cohen Ayers Martinez

54

03/23/00 Medical Staff Development Committee of Aspen Valley Hospital Meeting Minutes (AVH/B 0476-0479) BRAMD963966 04/04/00 Medicine Department of Aspen Valley Hospital Meeting Minutes (AVH/B 12941295)

55

Case 1:01-cv-02089-MSK-CBS

Document 247

Filed 05/08/2006

Page 6 of 33

56

Kremer Middlebrook Cohen Ayers Martinez Kremer Middlebrook Cohen

AVH MEC meeting minutes, 4/4/00; Dep. Ex. 7; AVH/B 0311-0320; BRAMD566-575 04/10/00 Board of Directors of Aspen Valley Hospital Meeting Minutes (AVH/B 0664-0669) BRAMD1147-1152 04/13/00 Medical Staff Development Committee of Aspen Valley Hospital Meeting Minutes (AVH/B 0480-0482) BRAMD967-969 05/03/00 MEC Meeting Minutes (AVH/B 03210329) BRAMD819-827

57

58

Kremer Middlebrook Cohen

59

Kremer Middlebrook Cohen Ayers Martinez Kremer Middlebrook Cohen

60

Minutes of the AVH BOD meeting 5/8/00; Dep. Ex. 22; AVH/B 0671-0676; BRAMD1154-1159 05/26/00 Credentials Committee of Aspen Valley Hospital Meeting Minutes (AVH/B 0403) 06/07/00 MEC Meeting Minutes (AVH/B 03300340) BRAMD828-837

61

Kremer Middlebrook Ayers Martinez Kremer Middlebrook Cohen Ayers Martinez Kremer Middlebrook Cohen

62

63

06/22/00 Medical Staff Development Committee of Aspen Valley Hospital Meeting Minutes (AVH/B 0483-0484) BRAMD970971 07/05/00 MEC Meeting Minutes (AVH/B 03410353) BRAMD838-850

64

Kremer Middlebrook Cohen Ayers Martinez Kremer Middlebrook Cohen

65

07/20/00 Medical Staff Development Committee of Aspen Valley Hospital Meeting Minutes (AVH/B 0485-0486) BRAMD972973 08/02/00 MEC Meeting Minutes (AVH/B 03540364) BRAMD851-861

66

Kremer Middlebrook Cohen

Case 1:01-cv-02089-MSK-CBS

Document 247

Filed 05/08/2006

Page 7 of 33

67

Kremer Middlebrook Cohen Ayers Martinez Kremer Middlebrook Cohen Kremer Middlebrook Cohen

08/30/00 Credentials Committee of Aspen Valley Hospital Meeting Minutes (AVH/B 04080410) 09/06/00 MEC Meeting Minutes (AVH/B 03650374) BRAMD862-871 9/11/00 Board of Directors of Aspen Valley Hospital Meeting Minutes (AVH/B 0690-0695) BRAMD1173-1177 10/03/00 MEC Meeting Minutes (AVH/B 03750382) BRAMD872-879

68

69

70

Kremer Middlebrook Cohen

71

Kremer Middlebrook Cohen

11/15/00 Medical Staff Development Committee of Aspen Valley Hospital Meeting Minutes (AVH/B 0487-0490) BRAMD974977 Minutes (page 3); AVH/B 0673; BRAMD1899

72

Kremer Middlebrook Cohen Kremer Middlebrook Cohen

73

Medical Staff Bylaws (1999) and various resolutions adopting amendments; BRAMD242-305; AVH/B 0001-0064 Fair Hearing Plan of AVH BRAMD537-554; AVH/B 1300-1317 AVH Medical Staff Development Plan Needs Analysis Per Specialty; BRAMD463-500 Medical Staff Development Policy, 1997; BRAMD1917-1934; AVH/B 1439-1456 Letter from Cohen to Borchers, 11/1/97; Dep. Ex. 52; COH0014-0015; BRAMD1812-1813 Letter from Cohen to Borchers, 3/13/98; Dep. Ex. 53; COHO0016-0018; BRAMD1814-1816 Letter from Cirillo to Bramlet regarding interview, 10/5/98; BRAMD107

74

Kremer Middlebrook Ayers Martinez Kremer Middlebrook Cohen Ayers Martinez Kremer Middlebrook Cohen Kremer Middlebrook Cohen Kremer Middlebrook Cohen Kremer Middlebrook Cohen

75

76

77

78

79

Case 1:01-cv-02089-MSK-CBS

Document 247

Filed 05/08/2006

Page 8 of 33

80

Mass Bramlet

Letter from Mass to Dr. Mink regarding position as physician evaluator, 10/15/98; BRAMD108 11/02/98 Board of Directors of Aspen Valley Hospital Meeting Minutes (AVH/B 0543-0545) BRAMD1028-1030 AVH letter to Bramlet regarding appointment as Assoc. Staff, 11/4/98; BRAMD109 Memo from Purnell to Medical Staff regarding Upcoming General Medical Staff Meeting, 12/3/98; BRAMD123-125 Memo from Pevny to Medical Staff regarding Proposed Amendments to Bylaws, 12/4/98; Dep. Ex. 94; BRAMD1901 Memo to AVH Doctors regarding internal medicine emergency call and coverage, 12/7/98; BRAMD110, (Dep. Ex. 70) Memo from Kremer to Medical Staff regarding Staff Meeting, 12/8/98; BRAMD130 Letter from Bramlet to AVH Chief of Medicine Department regarding allegations of Dr. Cohen, 12/14/98; Dep. Ex. 72; BRAMD111 Letter from Bramlet to Middlebrook regarding Emergency Call//Coverage, 12/15/98; BRAMD112 Memo from Cohen to Medical Staff regarding call schedule, 12/98; Dep. Ex. 74; BRAMD118 Letter from Bramlet to Middlebrook regarding development loan for new members, 12/15/98; BRAMD113

81

Kremer Middlebrook Cohen

82

Kremer Middlebrook Bramlet Kremer Middlebrook Bramlet

83

84

Kremer Middlebrook Bramlet

85

Kremer Middlebrook Bramlet Cohen

86

Kremer Middlebrook Bramlet Bramlet

87

88

Bramlet

89

Bramlet Cohen Middlebrook Kremer Bramlet

90

Case 1:01-cv-02089-MSK-CBS

Document 247

Filed 05/08/2006

Page 9 of 33

91

Bramlet Mass Kremer Middlebrook Mass Bramlet Cohen Middlebrook Kremer

Memo from Mass to Bramlet regarding cardiology coverage at AVH, 12/16/98; Dep. Ex. 73; BRAMD116 Memo from Mass and Middlebrook to Bramlet and Cohen, regarding proposal for cardiology coverage, 12/21/98; Dep. Ex. 75; COH0021; BRAMD1783 Memo from Mass to Diagnostic Radiology Dept., Middlebrook, Bramlet and Cohen, 12/31/98; Dep. Ex. 76; COH0067; BRAMD1790 Memo from Mass to Bramlet, Cohen and Middlebrook regarding cardiology graphics reading schedule at AVH, 12/31/98; Dep. Ex. 77; COH0020; BRAMD1782 Memo from Glissman/Martinez to Medical Staff regarding competitive issues in medicine seminar, 4/13/99; BRAMD222 Letter from Bramlet to Kramer (sic) regarding patient coverage, 5/21/99; BRAMD134 Letter from Ferguson to Bramlet regarding end of provisional period, 8/22/99; BRAMD135; AVH/B 0111 Memo to Bramlet from Libby Barlau regarding medical staff credential file, 8/30/99; BRAMD136; AVH/B 0110 Letter from Middlebrook to Bramlet regarding internist secondary call coverage, 9/23/99; BRAMD137 Letter from Melody Durham to Bramlet, 10/14/99; AVH/B 0492; Dep. Ex. 15 Fax from Kremer to NEJM Advertising re: Ad to be placed for physician recruitment, with attached ad, 11/10/99;AVH/B 14701472; BRAMD1948-1950

92

93

Mass Bramlet Cohen Middlebrook Kremer Mass Bramlet Middlebrook Kremer

94

95

Martinez Bramlet Mass

96

Bramlet

97

Middlebrook Kremer Bramlet

98

Bramlet Kremer Middlebrook

99

Middlebrook Kremer Bramlet Cohen Bramlet Middlebrook Kremer Kremer Middlebrook Bramlet Cohen

100

101

Case 1:01-cv-02089-MSK-CBS

Document 247

Filed 05/08/2006

Page 10 of 33

102

Kremer Middlebrook Bramlet Cohen

Fax from Kremer to Janet/CMS Advertising re: Ad for Decmeber (sic) issue, 11/10/99; AVH/B 1476 & 1475; BRAMD1954& 1953 Letter from Martinez to Bramlet regarding appointment as member of Pharmacy and Therapeutics Committee, 11/12/99; BRAMD152 Memo from Cohen to Kramer (sic), 12/2/99; Dep. Ex. 59; COH0063; BRAMD1826 Letter from Ayers to Bramlet regarding Care Plan, 1/1/00; BRAMD154 Typed notes from Ann Mass regarding Bramlet/cardiology coverage at AVH; BRAMD1828-1829; COH0065-66 Letter from Martinez to Bramlet regarding general medical staff attendance roster, 1/3/00; BRAMD157 Hand-written letter from Bramlet to Martinez regarding Aspen residency, 1/4/00; BRAMD158 & BRAMD1904 Letter from Jaffrey, Bramlet and Scheuer regarding medical staff development policy, 1/6/00; BRAMD159 Letter from Bramlet to Middlebrook regarding copies of bylaws, 1/7/00; BRAMD163 Handwritten letter from Bramlet to Middlebrook regarding Board meeting agenda, 1/7/00; BRAMD164 Letter from Bramlet to AVH Governing Board regarding permanent staff status, 1/10/00; BRAMD165-166

103

Martinez Middlebrook Kremer Bramlet

104

Cohen Kremer Middlebrook Bramlet Ayers Bramlet Kremer Middlebrook Mass Bramlet Cohen

105

106

107

Martinez Kremer Bramlet Bramlet Martinez Kremer Middlebrook

108

109

Bramlet

110

Bramlet

111

Bramlet Middlebrook

112

Bramlet Kremer Middlebrook Cohen

Case 1:01-cv-02089-MSK-CBS

Document 247

Filed 05/08/2006

Page 11 of 33

113

Martinez Bramlet Middlebrook Kremer

Letter from Martinez to Bramlet regarding reappointment and request to change status, 1/13/00; Dep. Ex. 104;BRAMD167 Letter from Kotz to Bramlet regarding medical development meeting, 1/14/00; Dep. Ex. 83; BRAMD1903 Letter from Martinez to Bramlet regarding reappointment and request to change status, 1/19/00; BRAMD169 Letter from Bramlet to Ayers regarding response to January 1 letter, 1-2000; BRAMD170 Interoffice memo from Todd to Bramlet regarding monthly fees, 1-21-00; BRAMD173-187 Letter from Bramlet to Kremer regarding documentation of residency requirements, 121-00; BRAMD171-172; BRAMD166 Letter from Martinez to Haynes, 1-29-00; Dep. Ex. 2; AVH/B 0408-0410; BRAMD534-536 Letter from Martinez to Haynes, 1-29-00; unsigned, Dep. Ex. 105; AVH/B 1853-1855 Letter to Dr. Bramlet from Dr. Martinez dated 1/31/00 re: residency; AVH/B 0411; BRAMD188 Letter from Bramlet to Middlebrook regarding reappointment process, 2/10/00; Dep. Ex. 30; BRAMD189-192 Letter from Mary Carter regarding schedule books, 2/11/00; AVH/B 0711; BRAMD193; BRAMD1194 Letter from Martinez to Bramlet re: application for reappointment, 2/15/00; Dep. Ex. 95; BRAMD 197 & BRAMD1907

114

Bramlet Kremer Cohen

115

Martinez Bramlet Kremer Middlebrook Bramlet

116

117

Bramlet Kremer

118

Bramlet

119

Martinez Kremer Middlebrook

120

Martinez Kremer Middlebrook

121

Bramlet

122

Bramlet

123

Bramlet Kremer

124

Martinez Kremer Bramlet

Case 1:01-cv-02089-MSK-CBS

Document 247

Filed 05/08/2006

Page 12 of 33

125

Ayers Kremer Bramlet Bramlet Kremer

Letter from Ayers to Bramlet regarding approval of care plan, 2/16/00; BRAMD198 Letter from Kotz to Bramlet, 2/18/00 and subsequent list; Dep. Ex. 99; BRAMD199-200, 201202; AVH/B2185-2186, 2189-2190 02/24/00 Letter to Chris Martinez, M.D. from Dean Bramlet, M.D. with photo copies of Dr. Bramlet's office schedule for July 1999-January 2000 and Calendar for January 1999-January 2000 (AVH/B 0709-1262) Letter from Martinez to Bramlet regarding application completed/incomplete, 3/2/00; BRAMD210; AVH/B 4376 Letter from Middlebrook to Bramlet regarding Bylaws, 3/2/00; Dep. Ex. 33; BRAMD211 Letter from Bramlet to Kotz regarding complaints, 3/8/00; BRAMD212-215 & BRAMD1910-1913 Letter from Bramlet to Phillips, 3/8/00; BRAMD2077-2078 Letter of commendation from Gail Douglas to AVH, 3/9/00; BRAMD216 Memo from Ayers to Martinez re: Evaluation of Materials submitted by Dr. Bramlet Regarding Residency Requirement, 3/12/00; AVH/B 17791801 Letter from Kotz to Bramlet regarding Disruptive Physician Policy, 3/14/00; BRAMD217 Letter from Kienle to Kotz regarding administrative leave, 4/4/00; BRAMD218

126

127

Bramlet

128

Martinez Bramlet Kremer

129

Martinez Bramlet Kremer Bramlet

130

131

Bramlet

132

Bramlet Kremer Ayers Martinez Bramlet Kremer Middlebrook

133

134

Bramlet Kremer Middlebrook Ayers Kienle Kremer

135

Case 1:01-cv-02089-MSK-CBS

Document 247

Filed 05/08/2006

Page 13 of 33

136

Bramlet

Letter from Bramlet to Kotz regarding leave of absence, 4/5/00; BRAMD219,; AVH/B 0095 Letter from Bramlet to Ayers regarding change in category status, 4/11/00; Dep. Ex. 31; BRAMD220 Letter from Kienle to Ayers regarding recommendation for Bramlet, 4/11/00; BRAMD221 Letter to AVH Internists from Middlebrook, 4/20/00; BRAMD1756; AVH/B 1263 Memo from Hunter to Medical Staff Members re: Survey regarding Residency Requirement, 4/21/00; Dep. Ex. 96; BRAMD223-224 Letter from Middlebrook to Bramlet, 4/21/00; AVH/B 0096; BRAMD225 Letter from Bramlet to Martinez regarding withdrawal of request for leave, 4/24/00; Dep. Ex. 26; AVH/B 0097; BRAMD226 Letter from Kienle to Martinez recommending Bramlet to consulting staff, 4/25/00; BRAMD1802 Letter from Mass to Martinez recommending Bramlet, 4/25/00; BRAMD237 & BRAMD1801 Memo from Bramlet to Kremer regarding medical staff application, 5/2/00; Dep. Ex. 27; AVH/B 0098; BRAMD618 Letter from Bramlet to Kotz regarding Board vote on credentials, 5/5/00; Dep. Ex. 28; AVH/B 0099 Letter from Martinez to Bramlet regarding consulting staff/temporary privileges, 5/5/00; BRAMD240; AVH/B 0100

137

Bramlet

138

Kienle Ayers

139

Middlebrook Bramlet Cohen Mass Middlebrook Kremer Cohen Bramlet

140

141

Middlebrook Bramlet Bramlet

142

143

Kienle

144

Mass Bramlet Kremer

145

Bramlet

146

Bramlet

147

Martinez Bramlet Kremer Middlebrook

Case 1:01-cv-02089-MSK-CBS

Document 247

Filed 05/08/2006

Page 14 of 33

148

Middlebrook Bramlet Kremer

Letter from Middlebrook to Bramlet regarding directors meeting granting leave of absence, 5/12/00; BRAMD334-335 & BRAMD621 Letter to Dr. Bramlet from Dr. Ayers dated 6/05/00 re: consulting staff privileges; BRAMD336 Letter from Cohen to Martinez, 6/5/00; Dep. Ex. 64 Letter from Middlebrook to Bramlet clarifying Board of Directors action regarding leave of absence, 6/19/00; AVH/B 0102; BRAMD337

149

Bramlet

150

Cohen Bramlet Martinez Middlebrook Kremer Bramlet Cohen

151

152

Bramlet

Letter from Bramlet to Ayers regarding leave from Florida hospital, 6/26/00; BRAMD340 Memo from Middlebrook to Medical Staff regarding Cohen receiving privileges, 6/26/00; Dep. Ex. 65; & BRAMD1915 AVH Press Release `AVH Cardiology Services', 6/27/00; Dep. Ex. 66; AVH/B 1841; BRAMD1759 Handwritten notes, 6/27/00; Dep. Ex. 79; BRAMD1788 Fax from Kremer to John Wiley, re: Contract, 6/29/00; AVH/B 14731475; BRAMD1951-1953 Memo from MEC to AVH Board of Directors re: Medical Staff Appointments, 7/6/00; AVH/B 0683; BRAMD1166 Letter from Middlebrook to Bramlet regarding cardiologist recruitment, 7/10/00; BRAMD342; AVH/B 0112 Letter from Ayers to Bramlet regarding Credentials Committee letter/leave of absence, 7/11/00; AVH/B 0103; BRAMD345

153

Middlebrook Kremer Cohen Bramlet Middlebrook Kremer Cohen Bramlet Gerson Bramlet Middlebrook Cohen Kremer

154

155

156

157

Kremer Middlebrook Bramlet

158

Middlebrook Kremer Bramlet

159

Ayers Kremer Middlebrook Bramlet

Case 1:01-cv-02089-MSK-CBS

Document 247

Filed 05/08/2006

Page 15 of 33

160

Gerson Kremer Cohen Middlebrook

Fax cover sheet from Merritt, Hawkins & Associates to Middlebrook with attached Curriculum Vitae of Gordon Gerson, M.D., 7/21/00; Dep. Ex. 37; AVH/B 1526-1527; BRAMD2004-2005 Fax cover sheet from Merritt, Hawkins & Associates to Middlebrook with attached 2nd reference on Dr. Gerson, 7/27/00; AVH/B 15321535; BRAMD2010-2013 Letter from Bramlet to Ayers regarding conclusion of leave of absence, 7/27/00; Dep. Ex. 114; AVH/B 0104; BRAMD346 Letter from Bramlet to Ayers regarding updating care plan, 7/27/00; BRAMD347 Fax cover sheet from Merrritt, Hawkins & Associates to Middlebrook w/attached Reference of Dr. Gerson, 7/27/00; AVH/B 1528-1531; BRAMD2006-2009 Cover sheet and letter from Merritt, Hawkins and Assoc. to Gerson, 7/28/00; Dep. Ex. 45; AVH/B 1536-1540; BRAMD2014-2018 Letter from Bramlet to Kotz regarding disruptive physician policy, 8/1/00; Dep. Ex. 100; BRAMD348 Letter from Merritt, Hawkins and Assoc. To Gerson, 8/3/00; Dep. Ex. 39; AVH/B 1545; BRAMD2023 Letter from Kotz to Bramlet regarding disruptive physician policy, 8/14/00; Dep. Ex. 101; BRAMD349 Letter from Ayers to Bramlet regarding Credentials Committee Meeting (termination of leave of absence), 8/15/00; BRAMD358

161

Gerson Kremer Cohen Middlebrook

162

Bramlet

163

Bramlet

164

Kremer Middlebrook Gerson Cohen

165

Kremer Middlebrook Gerson Cohen

166

Bramlet

167

Kremer Middlebrook Gerson Cohen Kremer Middlebrook Bramlet Ayers Martinez Bramlet Ayers Kremer Cohen

168

169

Case 1:01-cv-02089-MSK-CBS

Document 247

Filed 05/08/2006

Page 16 of 33

170

Bramlet

Letter from Bramlet to Ayers regarding application discrepancies, 8/28/00; BRAMD361 Fax from Bramlet to Barlau re: Credentials Committee Response with attachments, 8/28/00; BRAMD362, 360 & 359 Letter from Ayers to Bramlet, 8/30/00; AVH/B 0105; BRAMD625 Letter from Bramlet to Ayers, 9/1/00; Dep. Ex. 116; AVH/B 0106-0107; BRAMD366-368 Handwritten receipt from Libby Barlau acknowledging receipt of two letters from Bramlet, 9/5/00; BRAMD369 Letter from Middlebrook to Bramlet regarding rejection for contracted position as cardiologist, 9/6/00; Dep. Ex. 32; AVH/B 0113; BRAMD633 Letter from Middlebrook to Bramlet regarding request for consulting staff membership, 9/18/00; AVH/B 0108-0109; BRAMD371-372 Memo from AVH Medical Executive Committee to AVH Board of Directors, Subject: Medical staff reappointments for review, 11/8/00; Dep. Ex. 67; AVH/B 1421; BRAMD1874 Letter from Middlebrook to Bramlet, 11/20/00; Dep. Ex. 25; AVH/B 0114; BRAMD634 Letter from Middlebrook to Cohen, 12/8/00; Dep. Ex. 69 Letter from Holly Jones, Palms of Pasadena Hospital, to Bramlet, 1/9/03; BRAMD2080 Letter from Holly Jones, Palms of Pasadena Hospital, to Bramlet, 7/9/04; BRAMD2179

171

Bramlet

172

Ayers Kremer Bramlet Bramlet

173

174

Kremer Middlebrook Bramlet

175

Middlebrook Kremer Bramlet Cohen

176

Middlebrook Kremer Bramlet

177

Middlebrook Kremer

178

Kremer Middlebrook Bramlet Middlebrook Kremer Cohen Bramlet Kremer Ayers Bramlet Kremer Ayers

179

180

181

Case 1:01-cv-02089-MSK-CBS

Document 247

Filed 05/08/2006

Page 17 of 33

182

Bramlet Kremer Ayers

Letter from Behrouz Madani, Pasco Regional Medical Center to Bramlet, 7/15/04; BRAMD2178 Email from Emilio Dominguez to AspenDocs, 7/27/04; BRAMD2217 Letter from Stephen Hunter to Dean A. Bramlet, M.D., 2/17/06; BRAMD3439 Letter from Joseph Pino, M.D. to Dean A. Bramlet, M.D., 3/1/06; BRAMD3438 Handwritten note; Dep. Ex. 62; COH0070

183

Bramlet Kremer

184

Bramlet Kremer

185

Bramlet Kremer Bramlet Middlebrook Kremer Bramlet

186

187

Handwritten letter to Dr. Martinez; Dep. Ex. 107; AVH/B 2187-2188 Handwritten notes; Dep. Ex. 110; AVH/B2330-2331 01/21/00 letter to Kremer from Bramlet with copy of Dr. Bramlet's voter's registration card, etc. (AVH/B4382-4396) Palms of Pasadena Hospital Reference Request, 8/21/00; Dep. Ex. 113; AVH/B 2296 Interview Schedule Dr. Dean Bramlet Thursday, July 26, 2001; BRAMD2079 Merritt, Hawkins & Associates July 2000 Progress Reports; AVH/B 1525; BRAMD2003 Employer's Position Statement, 8/13/01; BRAMD392-402 Snowmass Village Sun article "Dr. Cohen Plucked out of Retirement, Heads Back to the Table", 8/9/00; BRAMD1817 Aspen Daily News article "Dr. Cohen won't seek third term on hospital board', 1-20-04; Dep. Ex. 68; BRAMD520-521

188

Bramlet Middlebrook Kremer Bramlet Kremer

189

190

Bramlet Kremer Ayers Martinez Bramlet Kremer Middlebrook Cohen Kremer Middlebrook Cohen Kremer Middlebrook Cohen Cohen Kremer Middlebrook Bramlet Cohen Kremer Middlebrook Bramlet

191

192

193

194

195

Case 1:01-cv-02089-MSK-CBS

Document 247

Filed 05/08/2006

Page 18 of 33

196

Bauer

"The Colorado Ski Industry: Highlights of the 1997-1998 Season", Business Research Division, Graduate School of Business Administration, University of Colorado at Boulder, Boulder, CO; BRAMD3360-3403 Joint Commission on Accreditation of Healthcare Organizations Report Diplomate of Clinical Lipidology issued to Dean A. Bramlet, M.D., 12/6/05; BRAMD3437 Physician Socioeconomic Statistics 1999-2000, Table 48; BRAMD32073208 Physician Socioeconomic Statistics 1999-2000, Table 49; BRAMD3209 Physician Socioeconomic Statistics 1999-2000, Table 50; BRAMD3210 Physician Socioeconomic Statistics 1999-2000, Table 44; BRAMD3211 Physician Socioeconomic Statistics 1999-2000, Table 43; BRAMD3212 Physician Socioeconomic Statistics 1999-2000, Table 36; BRAMD3213 Medical Group Management Association, Physician Compensation and Survey Report, Median Compensation for Selected Specialties, 1999-2001; BRAMD3214 Medical Staff Development Policy; BRAMD501-513 Appointment calendar; AVH/B0712; Dep. Ex. 10 Various Physicians' summaries of time in Aspen, Colorado (AVH/B 0494-0499)

197

Voigt

198

Bramlet

199

Bauer

200

Bauer

201

Bauer

202

Bauer

203

Bauer

204

Bauer

205

Bauer

206

Kremer Middlewbrook Cohen Bramlet Bramlet Bramlet Kremer Middlebrook

207 208

Case 1:01-cv-02089-MSK-CBS

Document 247

Filed 05/08/2006

Page 19 of 33

209

Bramlet Kremer Middlebrook

Specific Consent to Conditions of Consideration for Appointment and Reappointment, 7/27/00; AVH/B 0493 and 2299; Dep. Ex. 12; BRAMD978 Gordon Martin Gerson, Jr., MD Medical License, 10/19/00; Dep. Ex. 34 Gerson's Application for Appointment to Medical Staff at AVH; Dep. Ex. 35 Itinerary for Gordon Martin Gerson, Jr., M.D., F.A.C.C.; Dep. Ex. 38; AVH/B 1438; BRAMD1891 Morris Cohen, M.D. tax documents 1996-1999; BRAMD2180-2191 Income tax returns for Dean A. Bramlet, M.D., P.A. 1992; BRAMD32463247 Income tax returns for Dean A. Bramlet, M.D., P.A. 1993; BRAMD32483250 Income tax returns for Dean A. Bramlet, M.D., P.A. 1994; BRAMD32513252 Income tax returns for Dean A. Bramlet, M.D., P.A. 1995; BRAMD32533256 Income tax returns for Dean A. Bramlet, M.D., P.A. 1996; BRAMD32573261 Income tax returns for Dean A. Bramlet, M.D., P.A. 1997; BRAMD32623274; BRAMD3298 Income tax returns for Dean A. Bramlet, M.D., P.A. 1998; BRAMD32753278 Income tax returns for Dean A. Bramlet, M.D., P.A. 1999; BRAMD32793282

210

Kremer Gerson Cohen Kremer Gerson Cohen Kremer Gerson Cohen

211

212

213

Cohen

214

Bramlet Bauer

215

Bramlet Bauer

216

Bramlet Bauer

217

Bramlet Bauer

218

Bramlet Bauer

219

Bramlet Bauer

220

Bramlet Bauer

221

Bramlet Bauer

Case 1:01-cv-02089-MSK-CBS

Document 247

Filed 05/08/2006

Page 20 of 33

222

Bramlet Bauer

Income tax returns for Dean A. Bramlet, M.D., P.A. 2000; BRAMD32853287, BRAMD3300-3301 Income tax returns for Dean A. Bramlet, M.D., P.A. 2001; BRAMD32903292, BRAMD3302-3303 Income tax returns for Dean A. Bramlet, M.D., P.A. 2002; BRAMD34403443, BRAMD3304-3305 Income tax returns for Dean A. Bramlet, M.D., P.A. 2003; BRAMD34443448, BRAMD3297 Income tax returns for Dean A. Bramlet, M.D., P.A. 2004; BRAMD34493453 Income tax returns for Dean A. Bramlet (1992) Income tax returns for Dean A. Bramlet (1993) Income tax returns for Dean A. Bramlet (1994) Income tax returns for Dean A. Bramlet (1995) Income tax returns for Dean A. Bramlet (1996) Income tax returns for Dean A. Bramlet (1997) Income tax returns for Dean A. Bramlet (1998) Income tax returns for Dean A. Bramlet (1999) Income tax returns for Dean A. Bramlet (2000) Income tax returns for Dean A. Bramlet (2001) Income tax returns for Dean A. Bramlet (2002) Income tax returns for Dean A. Bramlet (2003) Income tax returns for Dean A. Bramlet (2004) Form 1099s for Morris Cohen, M.D. 2000-2003; BRAMD2192-2195

223

Bramlet Bauer

224

Bramlet Bauer

225

Bramlet Bauer

226

Bramlet Bauer

227

Bramlet Bauer Bramlet Bauer Bramlet Bauer Bramlet Bauer Bramlet Bauer Bramlet Bauer Bramlet Bauer Bramlet Bauer Bramlet Bauer Bramlet Bauer Bramlet Bauer Bramlet Bauer Bramlet Bauer Cohen

228

229

230

231

232

233

234

235

236

237

238

239

240

Case 1:01-cv-02089-MSK-CBS

Document 247

Filed 05/08/2006

Page 21 of 33

241

Gerson Middlebrook

2000 Form 1099 from AVH to Gerson; Dep. Ex. 41; AVH/B 1546; BRAMD2024 2001 Form 1099 from AVH to Gerson; Dep. Ex. 42; AVH/B 1547; BRAMD2025 2002 Form 1099 from AVH to Gerson; Dep. Ex. 43; AVH/B 1548; BRAMD2026 2003 Form 1099 from AVH to Gerson; Dep. Ex. 44; AVH/B 1549; BRAMD2027 Classified Advertising by AVH for physician BRAMD 153 Bramlet Application for Appointment to Medical Staff AVH/B 1912-1918 12/29/99 Memorandum to MEC from Credentials Committee Re: Medical Staff Appointments (AVH/B 0117) 07/01/98 MEC Meeting Minutes (AVH/B 01440147) Objection: Hearsay. Authenticity and relevance Conceded Objection: Hearsay. Authenticity and relevance Conceded

242

Gerson Middlebrook

243

Gerson Middlebrook

244

Gerson Middlebrook

245

Kremer Middlebrook Cohen Bramlet Bramlet

246

247

248

249

04/07/99 MEC Meeting Minutes (AVH/B 02110217)

Objection: Hearsay. Authenticity and relevance Conceded

250 06/02/99 MEC Meeting Minutes (AVH/B 02250234) Objection: Hearsay. Authenticity and relevance Conceded 251 08/04/99 MEC Meeting Minutes (AVH/B 02350245) Objection: Hearsay. Authenticity and relevance Conceded

Case 1:01-cv-02089-MSK-CBS

Document 247

Filed 05/08/2006

Page 22 of 33

252

11/03/99 MEC Meeting Minutes (AVH/B 02640273)

Objection: Hearsay. Authenticity and relevance Conceded

253

01/05/00 MEC Meeting Minutes (AVH/B 02810289)

Objection: Hearsay. Authenticity and relevance Conceded

254

01/09/00 MEC Meeting Minutes (AVH/B 02900299)

Objection: Hearsay. Authenticity and relevance Conceded

255

11/01/00 MEC Meeting Minutes (AVH/B 03830392)

Objection: Hearsay. Authenticity and relevance Conceded Objection: Hearsay. Authenticity and relevance Conceded

256

12/06/00 MEC Meeting Minutes (AVH/B 03930398)

257

02/ 2 5 / 0 0 Credentials Committee of Aspen Valley Hospital Meeting Minutes (AVH/B 0401-0402)

Objection: Hearsay. Authenticity and relevance Conceded Objection: Hearsay. Authenticity and relevance Conceded Objection: Hearsay. Authenticity and relevance Conceded Objection: Hearsay. Authenticity and relevance Conceded Objection as to Hearsay, relevance and authenticity

258

0 6 / 2 3/00 Credential s Committee of Aspen Valley Hospital Meeting Minutes (AVH/B 0404)

259 0 7 / 2 8/00 Credential s Committee of Aspen Valley Hospital Meeting Minutes (AVH/B 0405) 260 01/29/00 Letter to Meg Haynes (AVH) from Chris Martinez, M.D. (AVH/B 0408-0410)

261

Letter to Randy Middlebrook from Brian and Cathy W i l s on and attachments (AVH/B 04120422)

Case 1:01-cv-02089-MSK-CBS

Document 247

Filed 05/08/2006

Page 23 of 33

262

10/05/98 Medical Staff Development Committee of Aspen Valley Hospital Meeting Minutes (AVH/B 0459-0461) 12/07/99 Medical Staff Development Committee of Aspen Valley Hospital Meeting Minutes (AVH/B 0472-0475) 12/07/98 Board of Directors of Aspen Valley Hospital Meeting Minutes (AVH/B 0551-0554)

Objection: Hearsay. Authenticity and relevance Conceded Objection: Hearsay. Authenticity and relevance Conceded Objection: Hearsay. Authenticity and relevance Conceded Objection: Hearsay. Authenticity and relevance Conceded Objection: Hearsay. Authenticity and relevance Conceded Objection: Hearsay. Authenticity and relevance Conceded Objection: Hearsay. Authenticity and relevance Conceded

263

264

265

06/12/00 Board of Directors of Aspen Valley Hospital Meeting Minutes (AVH/B 0677)

266 07/10/00 Board of Directors of Aspen Valley Hospital Meeting Minutes (AVH/B 0678-0682) 267 08/14/00 Board of Directors of Aspen Valley Hospital Meeting Minutes (AVH/B 0685-0689)

268

11/13/00 Board of Directors of Aspen Valley Hospital Meeting Minutes (AVH/B 0703-0708)

269

Physician/Practice Agreement between Joel Ehrenkranz, M.D. and Ann Mass, M.D. (entered 10/22/97) (AVH/B 12701276) Physician Agreement between AVH and David Borchers, M.D. (entered 07/10/98) (AVH/B 12771284)

X

270

X

Case 1:01-cv-02089-MSK-CBS

Document 247

Filed 05/08/2006

Page 24 of 33

271

Agreement among AVH and Linda Vieira, C.N.M., Teresa Hall, C.N.M. and Aspen Center for Women's Health (entered 09/16/98) (AVH/B 1285-1289) 1 1/0 2 / 9 8 M e d i c i ne Department of Aspen Valley Hospital Meeting Minutes (AVH/B 12901291) 09/05/00 Medicine Department of Aspen Valley Hospital Meeting Minutes (AVH/B 12961297) 1 0 /03 / 0 0 M e d i c i ne Department of Aspen Valley Hospital Meeting Minutes (AVH/B 12981299) Bylaws of Aspen Valley Hospital District (AVH/B 1376-1395) White Paper re: Cardiology Department from Medical Staff D e v e l opment Committee to Board of Directors and attachments (AVH/B 1402-1420) Agenda for 06/01/01 Medical Staff Development Committee Meeting (AVH/B 1422)

X

272

Objection: Hearsay. Authenticity and relevance Conceded Objection: Hearsay. Authenticity and relevance Conceded Objection: Hearsay. Authenticity and relevance Conceded X

273

274

275

276

Objection: Hearsay. Authenticity and relevance Conceded

277

X

278

04/20/01 Medical Staff Development Committee of Aspen Valley Hospital Meeting Minutes (AVH/B 1423-1426) 12/07/99 Medical Staff Development Committee of Aspen Valley Hospital Meeting Minutes (AVH/B 1428-1431) 05/14/01 Board of Directors of Aspen Valley Hospital Meeting Minutes (AVH/B 1432-1437)

Objection: Hearsay. Authenticity and relevance Conceded Objection: Hearsay. Authenticity and relevance Conceded Objection: Hearsay. Authenticity and relevance Conceded

279

280

Case 1:01-cv-02089-MSK-CBS

Document 247

Filed 05/08/2006

Page 25 of 33

281

Physician Search A g r e e m e n t b e t w e en M e r ri t t , H a w k i ns & Associates and AVH (AVH/B 1510-1511) 07/13/00 Letter to Randy Middlebrook from James Shapard (Merritt, Hawkins & A s s o c i at e s ) wi t h Facsimile cover sheet re: 07/19/00 meeting (AVH/B 1512-1516) 07/13/00 Letter (2nd ) to Randy Middlebrook from James Shapard (Merritt, Hawkins & Associates) with Facsimile cover sheet re: 07/19/00 meeting (AVH/B 1517-1521) Missing 1522 &1523 Itineraries for 07/1999 m eeting w it h Ja m es Shapard (Merritt, Hawkins & Associates) at ACH (AVH/B 1522-1524) 0 8 / 0 2 / 0 0 F a cs i m il e Correspondence to Randy Middlebrook from Merritt, Hawkins & Associates with D r . G E R S O N 's 3 r d reference (AVH/B 15411544) Bylaws of the Medical Staff; (adopted by medical staff, 12/16/97) (approved by b o a r d o f d ir e c to r s , 01/26/98) (AVH/B 15501598) 0 2 / 0 2 / 9 9 M e d ic i n e Department of Aspen Valley Hospital Meeting Minutes (AVH/B 16071611) 02/09/99 Medicine Department of Aspen Valley Hospital Meeting Minutes (AVH/B 16121618) 04 / 0 6 / 9 9 M e d i c i ne Department of Aspen Valley Hospital Meeting Minutes (AVH/B 16191624)

X

282

X

283

X

284

X

285

X

286

X

287

Objection: Hearsay. Authenticity and relevance Conceded Objection: Hearsay. Authenticity and relevance Conceded Objection: Hearsay. Authenticity and relevance Conceded

288

289

Case 1:01-cv-02089-MSK-CBS

Document 247

Filed 05/08/2006

Page 26 of 33

290

08/03/99 Medicine Department of Aspen Valley Hospital Meeting Minutes (AVH/B 16251633) 09/07/99 Medicine Department of Aspen Valley Hospital Meeting Minutes (AVH/B 16341641) 0 1/0 4 / 0 0 M e d i c i ne Department of Aspen Valley Hospital Meeting Minutes (AVH/B 16521655) 04/04/00 Medicine Department of Aspen Valley Hospital Meeting Minutes (AVH/B 16561663) 0 9 /05 / 0 0 M e d i c i ne Department of Aspen Valley Hospital Meeting Minutes (AVH/B 1664-1675

Objection: Hearsay. Authenticity and relevance Conceded Objection: Hearsay. Authenticity and relevance Conceded Objection: Hearsay. Authenticity and relevance Conceded Objection: Hearsay. Authenticity and relevance Conceded Objection: Hearsay. Authenticity and relevance Conceded Objection: Hearsay. Authenticity and relevance Conceded Objection: Hearsay. Authenticity and relevance Conceded Objection: Hearsay. Authenticity and relevance Conceded Objection: Hearsay. Authenticity and relevance Conceded Objection: Hearsay. Authenticity and relevance Conceded

291

292

293

294

295

10/03/00 Medicine Department of Aspen Valley Hospital Meeting M i n u t e s ( R e d a c t e d) (AVH/B 1676-1680) 1 0 / 31/ 0 0 M e d i c i ne Department of Aspen Valley Hospital Meeting Minutes (AVH/B 16811683) 1 2/03/99 Creden t i a ls Committee of Aspen Valley Hospital Meeting Minutes (AVH/B 1684-1695)

296

297

298

01/28/00 Cr e d e n tials Committee of Aspen Valley Hospital Meeting Minutes (AVH/B 1696-1711)

299

02/25/0 0 C r edentials Committee of Aspen Valley Hospital Meeting Minutes (AVH/B 1712-1731)

Case 1:01-cv-02089-MSK-CBS

Document 247

Filed 05/08/2006

Page 27 of 33

300

05/ 2 6 / 0 0 Credentials Committee of Aspen Valley Hospital Meeting Minutes (AVH/B 1732-1742)

Objection: Hearsay. Authenticity and relevance Conceded Objection: Hearsay. Authenticity and relevance Conceded Objection: Hearsay. Authenticity and relevance Conceded Objection: Hearsay. Authenticity and relevance Conceded X

301

0 6 / 2 3/00 Credential s Committee of Aspen Valley Hospital Meeting Minutes (AVH/B 1743-1752)

302

0 7/28/00 Creden t i a ls Committee of Aspen Valley Hospital Meeting Minutes (AVH/B 1753-1766)

303

08/30/00 Cr e d e n tials Committee of Aspen Valley Hospital Meeting Minutes (AVH/B 1766-1778)

304

M e r ri t t , H a wk i n s & Associates PowerPoint slides (AVH/B 1809-1840) D r a f t P r i n c ip l e s of Agreement among AVH and Ann Mass, M.D., and Morris Cohen, M.D. (AVH/B 1842) 0 4 / 0 5 / 0 0 F a c s im i l e Transmittal Cover Sheet to Nettie Kremer from Dean Bramlet, M.D. (AVH/B 1843) 02/27/00 Letter to Randy Middlebrook from Chris Martinez, M.D. (AVH/B AVH/B 1844-1846)

305

X

306

X

307

Objection: Hearsay. Authenticity and relevance Conceded X

308

02/10/00 Letter to Randy Middlebrook from Dean Bramlet, M.D. (AVH/B AVH/B 1847-1850) 01/12/00 Letter to Meg H a y n e s f r o m D e an Bramlet, M.D. (AVH/B 1851-1852

309

X

Case 1:01-cv-02089-MSK-CBS

Document 247

Filed 05/08/2006

Page 28 of 33

310

NEED FROM AVH (have some documents but not all) NEED 2170 ONLY FROM AVH

Credentials File of Dr. Bramlet (AVH/B 18562169)

Objection as to hearsay and authenticity Relevancy conceded Objection as to hearsay and authenticity Relevancy conceded Objection as to hearsay and authenticity Relevancy conceded

311

Disruptive Physician file of Dr. Bramlet (AVH/B 21702201)

312

Need 2203 & 2204

Peer Review file of Dr. Bramlet (AVH/B 22022292)

313

A V H f i l e r e : c o m m u n ications with Palms of Pasadena re: Dr. Bramlet (AVH/B 22932333) 03/01/00 MEC Meeting Minutes (excerpts) (AVH/B 0306a)

X

314

Objection: Hearsay. Authenticity and relevance Conceded

315

03/01/00 MEC Meeting Minutes (excerpts) (AVH/B 0307a)

Objection: Hearsay. Authenticity and relevance Conceded

316

05/03/00 MEC Meeting Minutes (excerpts) (AVH/B 0327a)

Objection: Hearsay. Authenticity and relevance Conceded

317

NEED FROM AVH

06/07/00 MEC Meeting Minutes (excerpts) (AVH/B 0337a)

Objection: Hearsay. Authenticity and relevance Conceded

318

07/05/00 MEC Meeting Minutes (excerpts) (AVH/B 0349a)

Objection: Hearsay. Authenticity and relevance Conceded

319

01/22/96 U n r ed a c t ed Medical Staff Development Committee Meeting Minutes (AVH/B 23342336)

Objection: Hearsay. Authenticity and relevance Conceded

Case 1:01-cv-02089-MSK-CBS

Document 247

Filed 05/08/2006

Page 29 of 33

320

05/11/98 Unred a c t ed Medical Staff Development C o m m i t t e e M e e t in g Minutes (AVH/B 23372340) 0 8 / 25/98 U n r ed a c te d Medical Staff Development C o m m i t te e M e e t i ng Minutes (AVH/B 23412343) 10/ 0 5 / 98 U n r ed a c t ed Medical Staff Development C o m m i t t e e M e e t i ng Minutes (AVH/B 23442346) 09/14/9 9 U nr e d a ct ed Medical Staff Development C o m m i t t ee M e e t i ng Minutes (AVH/B 23542356) 12/07/99 Un r e d ac t ed Medical Staff Development C o m m i t t e e Meeting Minutes (AVH/B 23572360) 0 3/23/00 Unreda c t ed Medical Staff Development C o mm ittee M e e t i ng Minutes (AVH/B 23612364) 0 4 / 13/00 U n r ed a c t ed Medical Staff Development Committee Meeting Minutes (AVH/B 23652367)

Objection: Hearsay. Authenticity and relevance Conceded Objection: Hearsay. Authenticity and relevance Conceded Objection: Hearsay. Authenticity and relevance Conceded Objection: Hearsay. Authenticity and relevance Conceded Objection: Hearsay. Authenticity and relevance Conceded Objection: Hearsay. Authenticity and relevance Conceded Objection: Hearsay. Authenticity and relevance Conceded Objection: Hearsay. Authenticity and relevance Conceded Objection: Hearsay. Authenticity and relevance Conceded

321

322

323

324

325

326

327 0 6 / 2 2 / 0 0U n r e da c t e d Medical Staff Development Committee Meeting Minutes (AVH/B 23682369) 328 07/20/00 U n r ed a c t ed Medical Staff Development Commit tee Meeting Minutes (AVH/B 23702371)

Case 1:01-cv-02089-MSK-CBS

Document 247

Filed 05/08/2006

Page 30 of 33

329

11/15/00 Unred a c t ed Medical Staff Development C o m m i t t e e M e e t in g Minutes (AVH/B 2372-2375)

Objection: Hearsay. Authenticity and relevance Conceded

330

C a r d i o l o g y S pecialt y Requirements and Needs Report, prepared in March 1997 (AVH/B 2376-2378)

X

331 12/13/00 Bylaws C o m m i t te e M e e t i ng Agendas and Meeting Minutes (AVH/B 23792383) 332 04/19/00 Bylaws C o m m i t t ee M e e t i ng Agendas and Meeting Minutes (AVH/B 23842386) 333 03/03/00 Bylaws C o m m i t t e e Meeting Agendas and Meeting Minutes (AVH/B 23872392) 03/20/01 General Medical Staff Meeting Minutes (AVH/B 2393-2396)

Objection: Hearsay. Authenticity and relevance Conceded Objection: Hearsay. Authenticity and relevance Conceded Objection: Hearsay. Authenticity and relevance Conceded Objection: Hearsay. Authenticity and relevance Conceded

334

335

01/09/01 General Medical Staff Meeting Minutes (AVH/B 2397-2402)

Objection: Hearsay. Authenticity and relevance Conceded

336

09/19/00 General Medical Staff Meeting Minutes (AVH/B2406-2409)

Objection: Hearsay. Authenticity and relevance Conceded

337

06/20/00 General Medical Staff Meeting Minutes (AVH/B 2410-2413)

Objection: Hearsay. Authenticity and relevance Conceded

Case 1:01-cv-02089-MSK-CBS

Document 247

Filed 05/08/2006

Page 31 of 33

338

04/28/00 General Medical Staff Meeting Minutes (AVH/B 2414-2418)

Objection: Hearsay. Authenticity and relevance Conceded

339

Results of Survey r e g a r d i n g R e s ide n c y Requirement at AHV (AVH/B 2425-2460)

Objection as to hearsay, relevancy and authenticity

340 Documents produced by Kos Pharmaceuticals, Inc. (pursuant to Subpoena) (AVH/B 2461-2523) 341 Documents produced by O p t i m a E d u c a t i o n al Solutions, Inc. (pursuant to Subpoena) (AVH/B 25242600) 342 Documents produced by the University of Florida (pursuant to Subpoena) (AVH/B 2601-2636) Documents produced by Merck & Co., Inc. (pursuant to Subpoena) (AVH/B 2637-2645) X

X

X

343

X

344 CV of Christine Mobley 345 CV of William Kaempfer

Objection as to hearsay and relevance Objection as to hearsay and relevance Objection as to hearsay and relevance Objection as to hearsay and relevance Objection as to relevance

346

CV of Karen Zeller

347

CV of Diane DeWitt

348

U n s i g n ed s e v e r a n c e agreement between Dr. Bramlet and Cardiology Consultants, 6/30/98 01/07/00 Handwritten letter to Randy Middlebrook from Dean Braml e t , M.D. (AVH/B 4374)

349

X

Case 1:01-cv-02089-MSK-CBS

Document 247

Filed 05/08/2006

Page 32 of 33

350 01/07/00 Handwritten letter to Randy Middlebrook from Dean Bramlet, M.D. (AVH/B 4375) 351 R.S.V.P. Sheet from Dean Bramlet re: 09/28/99 General Medical Staff Meeting (AVH/B 4377) X

X

352 09/18/00 Letter to Dean Bramlet, M.D., from Randy Middlebrook with certified mail and return requested receipts (AVH/B 43784381) 353 E m e r g e n c y R o o m / C o n s u l t a t i on Schedule (Call Schedule) 11/1998 through 05/2000 (AVH/B 4397-4415) Resolution approved by MEC on 02/21/01, (AVH/B 4416-4418) Morris C o h en , M . D. Contract, effective 10/23/00 (AVH/B 4419-4425) C a r d i o l o g y s u r v e ys completed by various staff members (AVH/B 44264480)

X

X

354

Objection: hearsay

355

X Objection as to relevancy, hearsay and authenticity

356

357 Payments to Dr. Bramlet, 1998-2000 (AVH/B 44814524) 358 Initial Application for Privileges of Gordon GERSON (AVH/B 45254563) (excluding 45644571 NPDB documents in privilege notebook) Need from AVH 1998 & 1999 1099 Misc Forms for Dr. Bramlet from AVH (BRAMD 2945) 10/06/00 Letter to Dr. Bramlet from E. Miller (BRAMD 2088) X

X

359

X

360

Objection as to relevancy, hearsay and authenticity

Case 1:01-cv-02089-MSK-CBS

Document 247

Filed 05/08/2006

Page 33 of 33

361

06/07/98 Release signed by Dr. Bramlet (AVH/B 1918) 07/28/00 Letter to L. Barlau from H. Jones (AVH/B 2295) Reference Request (AVH/B 2302) Need from AVH 02/02/00 Memo to Nettie Kremer from Dr. Bramlet Claim history (BRAMD359360) 08/30/00 Letter to Dr. Bramlet from Dr. Ayers (BRAMD 363)

X

362

Objection as to relevancy, hearsay and authenticity X

363

364

X Objection as to relevancy and hearsay Objection: Hearsay. Authenticity and relevance Conceded

365

366

367

Dr. Bramlet's severance agreement with Cardiology Consultants, dated 06/15/98

Ojection as to relevancy Authenticity conceded

368 07/05/00 Facsimile Transmittal Cover Sheet to Randy Middlebrook from John Wylie (Merritt, Hawkins & Associates) with 06/05/00 Letter to Randy Middlebrook from John Wylie (Merritt, Hawkins & Associates (AVH/B 18021808)

X