Document 267
Filed 04/23/2008
Page 1 of 50
i tv
"n {Ii- u tJ I~b
ST I\I'L:; "1) 1 <;T12'\ ( I C
6
(jI,
1(',
F
I tJ AN D 1=""0)Z. 11-1-1: D 1 STY leT OF
"bt't AWfI-1Z.
Vc; .
'< U~ AQ IN G5 AtJ'O
l~ s LA ~ y6R f
t:'~Hle, l'r)"
y:oR VV-fLJWllJAfL,j 1~:nI~tn6,J-IrZ
~ U.1l SL{A,Jt 1/l 'flO fL" CIJ ~* (p~
or \<'.'\ 611
otJ
O'im/Y>~
~1*·S-6~~1Z
'\) L· (
\\~\ pAtDocK \2.0
~ ~ ~tzjJA \)~
I
\q4'1'7
Case 1:04-cv-01350-GMS
Document 267
Filed 04/23/2008
Page 2 of 50
,S')
D_ (L
i
6l;··FtCe{2 s
A-JZ E'
S'TCC t::.fl' {. I N0
~$1?1 eAfllJ
<;lA;N()e(t.GUS '1r'('IOCN~ ·lt~OR~
~(.A1Nllff
tKfl1/Jff ~ I~ oeoelL 'ID O~fr-IJ ~ tA~
Ai) VItf'ITM'(~" '¥'-c- G'A1lP I ,jr,
t A,-t:1l ( A;L<;;/1l A-1t~~ I (
\)t:.1";1'J 4J~T~ i f . .e J r>, ~( 6 \/t-1l V) frN'O 1pL In N'O 'FF
( 1Vil_ COM gLA-r NT -r";'-~(l'fb
M A? './ST T-at 11 MA-s r
>;( "
e /'2
,
1 ~.,.-.
I
8rt!
,4-riV 1Lj rtf
u· r (A
V/0 L-!t1-cd;ls
I ~.~ Lr'? ctry
rz ~jf:~ " L A-t ~,~ '/..crJ ffli6A1L 14;tss(./,Jet ~ C{flll $ DOU6/f-'f2T'1 I /tN p 1) IJJ H,J e \l6'f7TP7Z 'fO (2. '2- 4 /1lJUTZ f ~ tJ <; AA CIt-t. d A-tJb H.,I.f#J 0 ((;{.~ .
-\:70
r ~)
''fhJZI'D
A~
tf1~
till oc-e
Cf"vEL
,~. 6fL ltJ Itll H STAi?Jt1J
---nc"
-ro -112 Afk: l=fl ~ L I}-I N1l ~'
C-C~l WL ',- 011:1'1,
11 J q tJ 7 .
I
I
Case 1:04-cv-01350-GMS
Document 267
Filed 04/23/2008
Page 3 of 50
r "1) ~ l Pn fJ nw> ~ ,llX cw ~11L"
\)u-c
"0t:~bAfJr> Y~lLII-1G ~ ~-it~ () ItN t) 6JL
kN 0
S(A'~$'\ A-Jl\1
t,/C"
~ v-oct:S> "\Lt' /+-TJ lJ~~\i co L ~V i \)~/ 'T75
"-rc
CCrJQOl'T
~" ("{!(YlfL.wrc-~y
/tfJ
6 r-Pt (' l ftl (C Lt ~,- 6 {2JJ-(~ ,
fU\,tJ·\\'ff' \\A> N6! ~"f?1\i 'O£-"C-4'Y/c""O (c(Y\~~( '\0 0e >L(flJrL..:crt O ',0 '9" C c. (j~ 11 / Itf /01 ,!+-tIt) J \ftOlAn:P H1 S llfJf:.'ffl'lliJl1'le-sr '\0 iZ"£?ct?l \IE -nL~~ffiT'
'(p 17,f 2;'f11 JIf '111 u ~ (/I
I
Iu' /C)LA-77c;rv
iJl cLttrl6 N Ot-
11 Pel C-. J ~ 5"2> I
b >17
I~)
()b! \"L Il~ rh- -ntt: t>. 1>" C J ~"\' L f k-eo l)O fZ-.f2 I ~ ~tJ \) C/O :!'t::l Li 'Yft:" c i~oC\l'-e"() '
IDt
SD -.,-0 liD Fe'ET
~
LU
It" I1'H..
r
.
TU6611vG
HA-"1V 0
ot1
("lii FP~
5 HA r ll·u·;~
ItN 0
"
J11+0(jf-f-" d'lAST ('%($P
co nf u 5
elf 'J (0 t-A11 tJ tl
\jID~Jr1l0J of i I D~ C /.psg'S
/
~s31o '5-Z~_
..I
Case 1:04-cv-01350-GMS
Document 267
Filed 04/23/2008
Page 4 of 50
\q-)
1'rh:--
\~~6~Dflf\k( CC)Ll1l1 ,0 'Cc>~L~IO'C"f.-· 'f.2~st'OtJrJ"JG m0776(j~)
~ tt\1tJ'fWr l~a:C(?~' ~f~fSC '11tl5.
J MYYlr5St6t"S
A-s ~OIt1ll"1-S1 '\) ISC~Vf:1\1
t~
\Cb) \'Yl ~. G If?>6s: AfiOI.Jcf' ~lA II\! nr;>f
10
c'f20E1l--
~L ft{~ \:lA1tJ'q'ff' IrJ 'n1~ W l16L'f l~ouJ,J6
D'g. 4 Cit '" ~//,( £1 6rJ Lj"l.7 /0 g ,11'i STTlU(R-1J ~~
It\.! t Tl-t-
C~ t--1 \J t?fl $1 tJ (;
SAlt)
ltJAs:-
,;-..1 VlOLAildN 0f D·( (
I
J
S. (J'( of'
/
-t4
"2 L/
lkJt5
.
cr'Ve t
.
'1 Lj I-/C)u (ls- Lc-1l[~~ 'Z, '2-4}tfZ5 Lf:1/f;l?
lJJ 111 (H ~~ Ul.V l·iltVt: tz-'l?7vrt.°vrtO
HIlS' ltV f'L LJ 1-~ 1Z
/
G, ~~S Atf1 I tJ S~,ttcntlJ A-~ VVtCN-rA-L HfA-t::nl 'W~/frrYTE1JT ft1" 0
~~~ Hf\1\lQCVl:pft;t> ~ St1:A
VI'ClI"tV
J'Vt,(l
$'klO I~~) Of-1.J/
+ S; E'c/(.( fl,'T-Y
,
""'~?-
-2
4
~~.
'5iAJlU.:f1'J lf0'rz l >1-
PttJ It~ -
$Ll
fif) 01 S It' IjllJ~clL
Q,4>TF
ft1V9 .
L6lAfeJl
'~~ I. '-rHfl~rsJJ6 \(~~ t~(p'll>
{)j1L"~ 1
tt,'f1.I U ~ (A V/ tJ LA(16,J/ c/i/IL 1}554ulT!1NO ~y VJoL,4;'1lluJ Qf if O'L t bS-SS- f.,S-d S-, 6 r3i 'r;;; V
f
I
I
/
Case 1:04-cv-01350-GMS
Document 267
Filed 04/23/2008
Page 5 of 50
J 0'') .Tf-ff
'\(tklfi'n(~
OCr:~tJ on-f'/t.> "PL t: ADltJ0> $\ A-TE
\IJ It $
TH A-r
D'fK~ND$[-o ~ W()T I1A-V/#J6 AtJ ~ meo /CIt L t l,"eA-S'es mb#J HI ~ OE I ~ Pro M 1/fEV \Nn -nte 0- (C IJ?l f(' vY\Af2 J DJ /'2-1 i4/ l3uT(J~ l '2 l"'Llf J ()'7 i316 ~:e~-c---e'f1\{ Cf t A--eo fL-ft'"m 1lits;. trJ II IC~~ lli,Lfr t,
vY\t/f)/Cki L
i
fJ,
j
~ LIMN 11 t~·s
-$'
r ;tJ b·C1L.
Wit.$" IN -"ECTr'"1/
r
v·J //If H--e-fhlY
Gf2{)~vn-l o~ 6E-rA
1f"t;--:yyl6 L
Ync
0
.~ ~rn=1J B .
tt It)
1) 15 eA s f' WAs.- ~ A--U sc~o
'I
'--n1~ FIL 711 '/ f?'{\O M
'\A:ffN Ot11J\5 ~ l ~ ~L A1 N11'f"F I~ I t=='6 R L-J HIe I-f- W A-S"'
eO\JL~ wrnt i'~l:;--S. LA.f2-,tJc . l-te-P1OLV'n (' S'~--P-13
, I
g. A-c'fC1l4 A- J' yyt u c tl S -- f Jf -e-'t ." ,-,/L S "'-1 to TZtXHv'l 1-\A-.s N () ~ ;,.J ~ -TO W !\ ~ It 'H AN 4) > 6-e-:F--o 1le A1\I 0 61- /t1~ wrEitlS . D~ (ATlLi,ttJt) .~;> ~ j}-tcLC (~~ ~uxffl- , A-tJO~ D~4)~~rr 1)qJ tC/Q ~LtrtJ-n'ffS \1t.Cfttt7rl -ro w~,t
..
\ s Hlt1JrJ~·
ANI1 (Siont'"s
I
tLitJl>A fVly(!/J!+NO Bfk'11zrn1
W-t:~ ~fl:r;'S~C(ltOC~
1)u.'l?' '10 11ft:. 5rElZ~t' lA>Iv~S <1 F
'-r1\e UJr~-no~' , rIfE t/irJ~C~ I S DiSCt1l.~lzeOi ~tNi)Ll.efIJ j
~[(J ~~-MJ'1L'''' -nf12~ 6.> LAl '11~ {A1N
l6 rtf u. seA
V /(J~,1t114;J
/ ) 1
\f 16 l.trnDU Of \ \ (Jet C ;fS ~5' 3 f:,
~ <;'(J Y '~-l) d
Case 1:04-cv-01350-GMS
Document 267
Filed 04/23/2008
Page 6 of 50
~ &)
~~. ~s.l\2It-ctJ I riG 6'lZ Of 1Z O,J 'Pt~ Qf\'lJT)
12~G:ulr-~J ~oJZ-
ft-tJ
1m (Y\ tf)l~ O'TLV"E)L
(5)klJ \W\Yy1CD1f>r1"E OPOt17- 'f~fL \NW~~f2i<;O,J lr -n::rZ S'TIf1F il-z ~ $ 'ff(l '-yo fJ ~r t'~ A 0 JZ- VA- .
Cf4) L-O
(0
rY\ 'Q
t'Yt/tllo,J
\)OllA1z~
ItJ
~UtJ/ll'Vf-1
c:rJ s ftro f2 YI ~y... t:1'Yl ~L /+12 i 0 fr1Y1ttG ~ ~'6r2 t
~)") ~6fL 5A-10 it.bv\N (nON
5V\~PllvYrf~
-ro
~c
'Ot:1:'meO
\?lt~/tJ6>
dd)~Otz ~
()-1Zl,Iff
Crz./tNTlN0 A ~@\- :;Cltc-1)~
"f O~ D (;- eIJ VU" I I r4J (Ef2:12. L\GNrOf"l IE> I
jJdJ YVlI ~>((J N<; I WTl' rTBJ'J' ~-e1 0 $: ,.no J 1
;) }7fD~ AtJ
lMmeOI/rTE OFOEfL '~e TtlAN'r'PEfZ 1lJ \'V1fN\1K \1eA-cjtf- 'FAC/L)'-r\! C)L,(T {l'F ST/JrE '<{E N 0 i N~ A ~ All 1N ~ Ttz() tV1 ,l-b s: I1-GN() f.A>( l:' ccu e r t2:( c:, MZ 0 I Jr; "llZ'cf\-1,11 t:fIJ'T AN "0 CD'vt nt tTTYl't:-1..}-rs .
Case 1:04-cv-01350-GMS
Document 267
Filed 04/23/2008
Page 7 of 50
2. cf)
OefeN oA1lr~ 'f4iLr~ ·m ~f'll1d J ftoN \/71fIN6 ~OU.I -r*11l. NaT- h Pr\IJ~ AtJ 6 f/fr ( I kL
-t~W\ Ope 10
~01Z--
Co
t>cc
G;J }-L/I
,\2
w/hclf \)'/As. \)()tJt:oTO CAaJ~ ~(,A-rNTlW Jlt'\?Ai41"t3L~ \-\A12 VV1 ''ft> \2- r1 CI J 6 (I \I)t ('() f'Y\ t Lf-rAJr \ > ) ~ Tl1 I (p T1~ ftNP ILl 111- U; (,f Vi ~L-A17~IV'
r
;L
1) (t 17l \ ~E
l;J((1l?
D0 f(fll~ Af\t 0
tit)
Sell' ffB
S4[LVeJLAtvtc
C/ttA(;f1r(J,J VtOEO _
A- ~ 5 I}CtL11lJ(: ~ L Jh ~
itJ n-fe
t) . ( {
1 W\ 1\1 reEl} Ail Af,L E H1H7 VYl ·:fe) fZ ir £1 tJ G C{\J It (' C rY) ~ LAnJO, 1 S T ,0 n/ ' I171 A1J 0 {Q71.f (,~ ~ (.A VloLAr7(J;.j Ii I .
/
~. I J
() 1l rJr:'"tL-ro
-rt
(kUc;~~
d-1.) t>, C
\-{)1Z \;(S:'/l·l-f (j~~E:T2"lt1ldJ L--t?'Vt1.- l f 1.. ~ l~U.12.c ~ c. t?v't?L· "7.. 1 L 4 t.trz S LNa S. ~.~ f-H'2J.
L-J?VFL Y l ? t/ NT2 $ p'j >( i+A12 Gt·- .
L.
>CJ 'Y
°
I
I
/
Case 1:04-cv-01350-GMS
Document 267
Filed 04/23/2008
Page 8 of 50
~t') Lr :r1rYJC?~ >1f-rft-~·tIFLP HII5 feW51;1:~~i
']) (1'1 Jeo 111(( /1/;fI L t!. JiotJr ('A-t~{ Ifrre:1L
~ LA-7 Nllff ~ 120 uI(Jet) 117 ryJ (,N'I'n! IJl~ml?/ldU£"
L(-61!L- ·P/foll./E (~-l/ ~;eO-blt'fT' <;Ci pi. I 'fORm ~f3
.3 /) ?£iL ~r2. ltt.J\lto~'1 \)ONfHtue D, ~
\)t:~tJ!)ANr$ _
~ L.Art IJn ~
C ,090t(2,
t+t6 If ltv'et 6'17
\?t t.' N fa
r~',1cl+
DtL'IOC~'L'/1)c-tJ/eo ~("'~1\ff
o,&c;eYL\fftTl(.)r! \)u:e
n
.
Ci J I L c:-c 1l")'\ '1 L Ar tJr
.
I ~T/ Bn+
,krJ 0 1'417-1 U.r C ,4 VIOL ft~6rJ Vl6l1rt76,J Df I ( Ot'L C to ~;)5- h C; d-J~ bSd-ti ,J / /
_50) Tift r·~C{g/~'~ {1/vIT O'PFcNOE;L D~C(A Men- . .>IfcllAi $ -t'1Z /fNsr-f, S n"2(J m ()6-t./L '5 -rD teLL. 7 / f) A- IE Z. / 7. 1/ D Y /
ttJ /l(Jet(' U
LtJI!-,t /f
IS
(;v11fr:-1'i (Jt, ~ ,K.BIY/ ~ tf
I--/1!s
{leo.
Case 1:04-cv-01350-GMS
Document 267
Filed 04/23/2008
Page 9 of 50
~';-J
fU'!tN [~
~() flO L eY l>t~Jotft/T £1./t- N6 DS-- ()J3 61115
I
~;-At~tcA11?O lol.1()Ut.T ~/~C'?Of~1O GAuJ UNf~~
·
~ T fl-A-TtE6' I c Ai) V tttlr-~ ~ I
It ~ tJ",eL~ Ac; -m . . HAil trs 5 -If te ~L-A-1fJn-t?F .
Cn~Nlev ~'-I ~LA1Jn·~·).
j"
~(
I
!1-NO
,~m u seA
V/6l!tndJ
VlfJLA1l0,J Df llOfL
t:.S-3b
-' cf) ,·v
.. 11ft:
U. ( ( ~ () ~ .t:D~ ~'~e {~ D~set \It;n(j '2.~, Hll~ ~( pS'''cf{ (i)~~e1f(~llA-lIOtJ U"TlFL I '2 Y Ifrz SLE' v c;'L L I 'Z (/ l-r-rl ) GFVeL 3 ' .
~.~1;D\l"· \Qtkl~T"iF~'
T) e'17 t
(\(. 0 1fN)s-
W t) (A L1)
H-.4-1JC 'f(JLl 0 f\.!c1:/
J
\S
ALL~iNr:.7JlO (OIffTZ~'>Ir'PPTY,
U 5 ('A- J IOL Am (J tJ \j , c LJt":r7 (J 0 FIl£X~i (! Lc 5"'35 .
t!6rtt
tl
s.,.- ~ WA-S 4f;tt: -to 12'eO f'~-cr rnrv1 8,A<·1(- fVjn
1-tt sA;<~I "Ne'O ~ et.. L I VLA1 tJ'nrr; wA.5 t:o ~'c--rJ 11'/16
(tU- to kJt t: k \N'\:>O f2 W/t"'V JlV! cNT ttL Ht I/"t: 'n..J
AN 1J ~e~c.~tf 1'1'1 'J}+ A--r 1 AVt/A TH1tf-1tT '10 11' tVl
~ "3') ,.? t A:1 Ni1 \?f~-
DFN ,·t~
n~-M
rY71:'Nl Ai. f-ief1t1tt
+e'
!Iv ft-5
rut t I DM ~ I e) >[/[.. P kN rJ 6flfE:rtS"".
I
Case 1:04-cv-01350-GMS
Document 267
Filed 04/23/2008
Page 10 of 50
37 J
AQ1?oJ s. A-s. <;f~O ey Df?PfJV{)ftJIT t tJ Tlfe-, e- -rc-A; (76 J II.J 0 YV\lJ11 0 Ii $ / V I gftTC? Vlfu #Jll r=F Q frt
?tk1tJrlffs
Nt>T
s\-toulD
&~~tJ PE:-ruTlNEV TO ·11~ 0 ( ( \;Jll1fex..tT At-! 61~;;[(',IA-t- Net ~CA~e1-l6 ~ c6V1rzr oKO efl- I {JUT? ofb 'V f1:-£Jlv~rs Qc'1?Tn dJf.. '? tAt wn W
(bcJ.tA-V'DfL /t$ tJkQ()f2~~,?jlM1? ,%10 P l L TZ ULe:-sl\1Jo f,"(-() ut L 4'n 6~ r .
A VI6L/Tf7()J dF
~ LA1 Nl I W
-> r---e'
/tJ
t> IS" (
llf(L,1 t{~~
'1 tt1 ~1l) \2 '\( dt~
0" C C .
~ I1f I~ r7! U ({·A v/0 [, 'rill) rJ
v/{)tlrnolJ' DP it t>eL~, 1J,531 ~5-L5"/ (P>2-t.(/frJ 5 3f.t:,.
A-tJp
J
50
be'f~4\1() /t1J r1'\~ cU (2£ 'Tl'l f7~'~~O NOONE i-hl. t,l(1 iZc:'o NI N8 VVlI !'JUre~ I (' Acu ,,;c'O f Llr-IIJ nPF ~,)1A All
I
tlJ
---rb \It?1tilIOf2. k"rt?
~u~ fD -r{fe tlZ \)'E L i ~1l~
\N\)lr/f"~~Nce I ?L4-ltJnr/f.?
~e~ ~1L'~ (031 b52
(fJuLD
HA1It fJ?c/f-rJ
t-bM q~At;lT.
\V(l.:('\? fW-~l-e \\A12 f'l\t?V , f><.t-e"1'3 ~+N71ff ffU~
A.-NrJ Q~ -If- lD3 ~lc~7 -n~' fi fLsr I r 'f1Mt:1J Ai 10: t 1 Ptm AND 111'C "5 ~,o NP (~11 rY7f:'rJ f1'I l f : L5 A1Y1 \ ~r J f> 11-+ A--N t? Iqnf u ~ ( AV {oL!t71tJJ./
<
V/tJUrnt!J 6 f
l \ 'Vi:'L (, (P5 ().5"/ ~,s /7 ~5B J;bS 5~
1
Case 1:04-cv-01350-GMS
Document 267
Filed 04/23/2008
Page 11 of 50
~ I)
VV1fL
GI ~~5 G6f
HIe; d/lOt/lS lJll2ffrL(
FF6r;1
OTZ frfJ-nforJlj tMlJut 1 (JtJ 1-/1-1/tJ f 7 /ffer?e--pCf(ZF 1)/2. 4 C NtlLI i r ( J fftSL1? 41\1
46) (y
Df?(~orr~tT!. r~rt'c::-vc--o r)LA J~l1 ~ Wk1 J mA-LilJ~t)?if.l~ t vJJ--..1 Ole o~C-- ~ p~Ycl+t/ffJ2lST r\ . 'DTZ ·1( rm be'12 L YW A;-!-6 J ~"t:~~ ~ L A1 /'I' n t;Jf oJ. t:(i c 1+ D(1S61l if A'TIdJ IrJ .~- &) C( I iJr:11ZWl~ _ . _ rl U---V t? /1 I~ f- ·7 ~vft::1c r . .t1
I
51) f)f2-,
1)e«'lI'>C
L/z-'6 / cn
mc--rll (I/-L \Z8'Of2'.oT
._ e~lh($JI(vyJ), C' t,~ff~ ~ ; ~ c. e
rz l [ ltoUf2- W1Tl{ ~/-rk·l{~e
'!f:; ~m2() A-/ ~ C lA ~r () rZT S \1tlt-rN'll rf CLAtrYl' op ~C---TN6 dL/ft:.k&J'ieO f?;g..
$l~ 'f.7LA1 J nrf wA-.$'
MJQ 1+Ai!VlUffl.
3~) lyq~OAflI "\) I ~~ pt IN fh2"1
U+ilf-Y ~fWMF c (,t/l1VeRO r~-ft1 flf -J/-- I (J rg & 7 ~
.~ 11 ~ tv' M\Je ttL
:5 [HAC 11T oW
MfrAt.
IJ()T ~ 0 U, ITT~
(3.trA-us-e OF' Cl V/l PrG 1t1lJ>f lfl fY)
CCyY}ptIHIv'l ~LIh;IT'~L(;';)
,two 141]~ II ~ fA Vl(Jl,.l+ttdU
VI DLA--n v'iJ or \l OL~ (' ~~~3S
l
ST
Case 1:04-cv-01350-GMS
Document 267
Filed 04/23/2008
Page 12 of 50
tj ~) ~ LkUjftr--r-~ N cv'e~·
4l> \ ~ 1 l'L
Pc't'sotJkLl- \j' ;vtr?7-. s-c-'121J Otz ,A l k£~ \tJ tTl-\ brz, t(A--~rJ ~6 vIi c tC \?lllOfl
f
I0 ,
NoR-
~~
t 1 '11 107
l/ ?J)
ftI
tJ s-eQ
'O.,J
1-1kf
g..' ;)-7/ 0 ~'
1). ( (
ftT
01L
Pr&JLtl
~~ 00 A W1
fN'T7J
.
.~
'0 fl - MJnfoN '-I CA,tJ IJ t) L- J
vY1ll ~ G(613)
A-) A Vf.tl'i J {~~ liJ $TrlUcntJr;
m1l. G((SeS
f)C:(
-ro
(!l \j
T)(t!'y -tl~ 1JlA-HJ71Ff Af)MI~~16J
11*-
tNf'1fvY\A-f\Y f j#J Ho?e VLfr1N1lPf ~,,~ tA/..';; Sl(r~1l lflflet?!fRAeL-c
\1ihIWl
It
\·hs '1I£JJ I ~L- ,(3-ecA-QJf' ,:L kliJ1\ Ff 't(tLtfJ tOWl~LA1Jr rWArU51 J+1 fY1
we "10
\ ~-rJ ~nI
kNO l4'11f uscA \JlC,LAmD~$
\i loL,~(JtJ> O'p ~,\ O1::t C $' lDS-1-S{ (p53 1J &;S-31o ~'5 j ~:)tJ 2.. / ~S'Od . ...,
L"
I
l/ ~'; l)er~rJo/1fJK
\)u1'\/.trr ~ s;
fZ'
G(Be! f1'20 W1
'r-}1 ~
H1A
\J.NlfS 16t?CMst~
11+r-y' ~N6vJ In)
V'v\t"fJrAt. ~tpf l~ SiTlUro6l..!) DC"1~ tNt?· l)t:'tl &1l!fft?
~Olr~~' AkJD -Dc~1J l?4#T) 'P4tL4~:r \0
or~ COflfl~er-, bec.4-u ~t- ~l- 4-rNl1 Pf Yf(".f/t!
-nzAcrJ f+cT C{ vtL (cm~LltVr
j
l5'~ Q'nf
USeA VI Olk110rJ
~ ftJ~1'1I (oS-Ie- {,<>3foj 0~g,t I ~S-6"L6<;-o-1. Q'-'/ I"""
\J loLfL-.noN 6¥ l\ pee n,11
Case 1:04-cv-01350-GMS
Document 267
Filed 04/23/2008
Page 13 of 50
~")11\'GLtSt\: '" ~ 1ttQb-c. ML1?»1t»J .
b~te{) '~fL CliVf\}J rJAu. (US ~j l1/ t> ., tvtOno tJ -rO T£Il1Jsf15jz..
pt41rJllW'W l). Pc ~ 'ro~ A Co 'rAf(f:iBlCV fV/rG
AtJ I>~~(l. tf15 VefLV tJili,J Wi?tL ~ElfJGI wileN
II be1l1'i LNn..6"
1/) A-TYflctr!- ~!10; ;'c161'11P1CANr If4fq:;s/fJp
'-1 b I .fr12/Jt?1 I Z I t./ d? C{ P 71J lYrr--r::-.
DLlC-rD )~q)A1m'Vlc)LA1ltJ'\?LA-Im~ ...
f'
A&ktNf( IftS WiLL I WI11 t'/-tl?SSL vt f(J f2lG 6AeJ'-1lJ D{( IN I (Hour fit)-( ~M[ DUCll,J q A ~ f'Il ~ f?(L-f! { 11£A1l1 '"(, ArJ0 .01l 0 ~k1tJr "f0 A1J a Pf{cJt-L· CO L,t ~r- (j /21) [1<- -f?tJ h1 ~PG1? Mte'WlA'fJ )0 N~ bg050/0q"~J NeC- S"C'l U~~~Al'.,.e; V(AQ,t?O ?tftJtJ11 rf uJ -me ~ I-HA ~1{J'rHdL1r c~ t·tO v.tr1 iJ ~ A I~ ~ -ro (>.fZ6 Vll~e 111m w tJfl J rlaJ tTll
1)(~t:¥rNr.r OtJ III t4 10 11RAfJ~~--rJ ~LA1tinf'f
NnTJctr ~a N'lNG He N'A$ f1~e1lU:NcltJ6 <;:t1llCHA.5' l::YYt6Th1~(ft Oi Sf1ZC--5> t.'J..PlrG""r'l-Geler tWo 'Df5~At!-, tt.J 0 wits tGffa I/J "'G lJ28m'v1flJ1i?>rc m--rne ~ D pc, 4tio PlA~ev ~LAJWfltr- . ItJ Sj-fttl r!r(l-k}Lif ~ 'fUJI '"6 'l1ZC~r1fNr l+c ~\l.1r ~ Ifi Air; [+1 D P(I ,!+uilD ~YI f+12rTJIerllrry, 1t1J6~ fYI4N~1t/ltif/ fS'yc!fP/t?tzIrPV rtorn P5!CI/tff771IS/j{"d (1;11t T1/fflItfYI '
i C.C)l(N.5'fZ4 iJr;/ ~ IlC~ '77fefl4(7 l'R1llltiteolfiJ 11I?+PfjZC Pf21$C
~EI(AlftJI/fCIT'I;
O.4-lcl ~cfftJ()()J2- /l-EFC//IlGH p~·Tl:tN W(;erAflI/f1l Drc'1j fIfI{{I WEt{IffT~4tA/f'" tlNLtlc& IIerce4-r 171e1,) C ~~S/It,(
6GC/l-tU~ A'LerJ CII/ll (tJPJ
Pcf-rNj-
I
~11It fJ1l1 ~'l/rJ/ it {LA V/6L/mt/JJ ,
'v"J dl,4-11"P aP 1/ VR [1 ~(~) '7 I ~s- 2-() I hS-6V/ 6S'JJ
STI
Case 1:04-cv-01350-GMS
Document 267
Filed 04/23/2008
Page 14 of 50
tP \ (/7 J '~L41I(Trpp> ctlkf/l1//lncMta ("NtfJ <; ¥EttA. A/-k;t30; fA IV IT 1C1J JZ- Y 'IE/f£- flif1
E--';rM(lstIW lhJ)1 ~rt:LTOJ Lt~T(\/ 1/Ji17l1:::f/: ,,?JlIOfL to /fls f?£J;.iG 17Zt}1fGlEY) III ;t? 'f C 6,Jb J fe / D1 IhJD DeFC-tVtJfftv73 5!fcUL () IfttvE
Lt1N41CTL~
4
l~tNG
rp;zo v1Q£A/6
PLA-tP1LfP Wfllf
\t.Iflt qeJ IAIma/ 't:7Z PKlO~ 70 ~lt1eIN6 IhlYl
IN 5 Ijtl, WI-n{-oLI! 'r7?E/f71~-tv"f~U~$:. [-I kF
on+c/Z 11'1 ~. wt/o lr1~tJ flffl.Jfl;/ -piltffYl ope
Ger .1J2:t~ ON Gl3l/erzA-c Vl1 Ptt (/f77 'ri tJlt 5A1t( ~ TlIcf--/tj 77( tt s e4 vItJLttrttJlJ
lIVfF ')
tNOll'TdCNCE /::7erc--,.l~f1JJT3 ·p·/lJ Nor ?eTJ77oN"m 77IE c#u/ZT rtJ(L /ft~/ftlL 1)~>tlhl(1/lIC 0 fS~-ezt/l+71(j;/6 F y({A:1Nnffj OttE70 77lEtR- FA-/u(ec 171 {#Jt ~TM!lLIZz; lftlyl ~ 5(J D/Hflrl77IE'r!syc/! ~iVJl 1;/ p.c C Il\lPJflm~~ /rl /ftc O!2iJ1MfTO J).(( S-,Op.. <5/f10 f/t1..LlJtf2-6 C/H),setJ f\ill-rN7Tif!+rlf1t;fc +>I'#!F' e/fNI/¥}rllJsl/lp Ci rJf {j S CA VI #( 177 tJN V, 0 l-1r77 dtJ !IOCi c.. foS>-J..-S- / 6s-30 ) 6 ~"'17
J)r{g. TO
PEli~
or
Case 1:04-cv-01350-GMS
Document 267
Filed 04/23/2008
Page 15 of 50
~~,,) -nh \?LIt1~~ 1)10 tJDfs--c-c4-rtJ ~
l[lve'fk~6Lt H~Wl
¥ LJ q.)
~0
\(
~l IIIIrf (
'WI
O$,ftltJt:O lltus" 'FAiZ ""J::Orz TH1> I-}aN~T2hLc Cou1Zr -r6 ofl4NT PLA--ltJll~ ~~OEt? \(LfS/tOI,J({S t:=drz
I fJ:ru rJcn d
It'
-ro
~lA1f.h1~.
H-
F\fJ l}r--{'i l',£
'M- It s
(l'C~
Su
'e WI 11teV IfN () d"g_
I
~ IJ kiL As ~cr;.
~ so )lX-fL~'f)1tWts 'l)uT2/~ E11fZt'f Mfllt '-003 TS~FJ A-;~/GIJI,.I6 11- AM 1"0
O~eN(JG bOOrz. -Ceu.. 5" I~ l1fe. $!-/ (J j ~ l ru'u ty1$~71 M· f )~tJJC · '"f1.h ~ ~ WI TJf 11k jWm ~ IN' Ho w As -rJ2AtJs~ ~ D c. C IIJf1 Rm.IrfZ-/, fllOtYl S' H-tl I /
~ !lbet-efllA- i f 'PLt" IlJ I~ At. fJiReYJJ,J6 I e~..,-- -n+e 'NIVI~~15fl'lI(JJ2/C.. Sj'5.;t:AYJ a~IGr:r -n¥ ~ ~ I S.,4'11,16 INtrJA-r'E D,w
1:> Itt? -rn
~L Co( rJ'-r ~IlC&' "ttl Arv1 A -rn ~ ~p,/ ~ ~ /fLl:t:~t
'I
~-vJ
'U fllJr 6,J
klV (l)"e
T 6N'IA
eDLL tNS .
iltos-e
O~U~ /tlt:e tJdJ OtJ PU/'I 11..-ro?5 ~;-ru 17.
S(2/ WI LL I/}-M s / SUS u/H, L( Ilk: BUll/)I/>/C .t"6/27,v /)ufy'.
Case 1:04-cv-01350-GMS
Document 267
Filed 04/23/2008
Page 16 of 50
*')I.}
M
VI f)t?O <; U ~ V~ l...tWc:E tJDr un (,/zet;' tv H--eJ f?J(rTlAe71r1() A:f.;l~eO Llt!rzuu.,y ,JfY1l\-}f ~YYl !ts<;,6NEtJ ~~ wH-o A1Ze ,J s-H-u 11 ArJ 0 s I+tt ~ 1'? fb R- Vv~Itt(t+ -ruW.s 1,J1-o A Y'Y\~ O~ crzeVI 61U'1'-/ (;J'ltt~ eL~m~ ~ ~MJe.
,s
~5Lj VI~ SL\~,,~lP(tJa IS Un~lf:() 1N~J ~Tf2ItCf1.J~ ;ttl ktte-GtV U N·~t L'I ,N m~ 'f1l('j rVl. A--5-S-t G"I\.IO? et?f,A 4;\J 1+0 kftr? ,,J s H1..t l)i"" o,J t u (\/) -r , , L A5c I'FI-e1? 1Z> ~
otJ
~rz6~llW U{S"TOP"/ .
~s31
~ ~'OA1'P H~ ~lhtetJ
~ '\(J2l)~ ~ Cti~~'4
Tn
/
\?f2tJV,ve
IZ' S;uvrq>tt~1
~()(,ICJ
---t").ffTZ C LAH'~S"
A- ~ $"'A-rEt/
f
J nfen~
~-e-:J fd tv"t:.? I
lJeerJW
10 b~2fV\,~
f-r 11 te'I J-I-kJt?
\I10~kre'O 'Tft't;? PLA-1I1n 'fF.
U.TIl--IUNG"
*7-1)
>JNle
'( ~ '/c/J.h A-w ( ~I J'O vvtF~ -n+m--~ ~L 1'o,JI\"'f"P \ '!' Nt') ~"Syc 1-\'011'-- A-'N'O 01Z- SUI (,10 A'L, $(,.\ ~'fOJ?T51+15 ~(;.4tms1{elZeltJ
~ ~LA1rtrlf'f?S \) i tJG'
,/z.zltJ~ l-n~ (f)~NO~
"'0 ses- orz- rVl At- ,rl6c;!-1 tJ
(?
.~ M ~,f c
»
* S5')
/1+t;;
~Ur:::/fo/'" -rT-fA-7- 1lf'e1 I+~ NdT ~t I ~ t41e7--''1
~ r~ ~fY1 ~L-A ~(l o..,-yn Je: c u r;1tJ() ,,/ 'Vt IIr/~ ~ec4ast= ,,,,-is' E ~t f?1l- "t1J
P~4fJT.s. 1+1- rle
NfJT 5<4emrtJeK7
c,Jrase -ptA7N'nff 1.rt~/ttJtl/l~ ~A1Zrn
/'7 /JrNfJ
OJ
~~ :;lif1i Utl'1"5;
l1.
Case 1:04-cv-01350-GMS
Document 267
Filed 04/23/2008
Page 17 of 50
*')~) D~OPr1VTS H-A:Vt? Mee;s
~{ZEjV101(t1] (j'J e-vJ{)~e:e ,J
VI A- ~ m / ~ "F ?"I ~-rc---m ~
~l t"'Ai) nJ;) / fE:1. 111 b
I
TO
j
~L. /11N"11ff=S
N f)T ~
SA-rO
rs- I yY\ ()TI d N ~
~ Ofh/ JTS' "
W IlrL
11115 rtof\kJRA'&cCO~mrn~ t'v\~ ~
IW --r1fe'J
lfi\L1U.J~
-=# n ') ~--rIO/lt-trS
S IfolALO fJ.£ t'1}J'E1J r; M
~-I
ty/() {\It:Tl'/f
-Jt 5- g:J \1.1
tJ -r1fi?
>' UU
~~,JG
'I
~lA.'H6fT
"L-T
('lIU
fl~ or- ~Xf1lA-cnJ;
II I
J
~t?'"l""t-t-11'fz6"Ej/ , tJ,J
6'F
~"-"nl""ri S~ C(J~(J'J
Ott- !tb6UT
AL
J () tzOe1l.·-m
TTl /t.,j!'T~
IN WI ~
DfA//\'{B PO.,err::~
.$A-7// I IV111 A-f1F
M~t \~/() ~
1?J >(jLJ-rItfl~ ~N'~tlc-m.FAlT,Ai sHu
~LA1tJl1~ VeJZ-$O,Jft"LY 'fIJIJ1'IBSF-O
\?C>11.~·'1C IN If, S"
Irt ~ L(NII:/ 771e Lr V'. fc.>,2~ 1~/C'fC- INtYlA-!-e
S-,r--et..-~· tx>t1~ I
YA<"t? "'-'111+- rf. s
1f
rNl11L'( ),.1 MAfe :e0tz,-c-Tl- GJAS '-~/1J6 oJ -n.f:£ ~O(JlL S;+kC lLf;cO ,kfJO H-AJOCl.tfTk:O ~t(~S~e-tJn7j lI..JrYl~ \:>It'fIr/Ne ~ () (Z~. (IVIrs firlk.JtLet/ Avv P J-tA1'lO CIA ffeO
WI1W b.LA;{/ILbo~
I
~t:f- Lf f611~et
'(1.(1L11ft?'t1t1Otze". CI "pc~'1L .~ fZ.Be? Al >~
5
rzes\?6}J S l Bet
t1>1L <;'"l1-4~kL~ M() ~'At00 C\Aff1~ A\(~A-£-. H4~5EtJ'eL~ td-tYl <; \)Ou.f2 G~-f\'/, A?fEtz- "£s~\o1Z.nN'6 n+t:~ TO
#it>
~ \A, L ". tJ 6 t ~
S 1ft{ (j. WJ t
ri
)
),
Case 1:04-cv-01350-GMS
Document 267
Filed 04/23/2008
Page 18 of 50
Jf; 51 -ryfe f{L ,fINl1fP H/t-s.4 Ll s cA r-t r; Jf1 TtJ W11J(
/rNo 01Z- ~t?CVt? ' 6-c--t;r?lZ YY1't~ 0/ (==-}($~{A-ti/"; bUT?
\
J
'" ff15 ,<~etJr- ~U5TlJOIANS
Sf?T2vltJ6
Htrn S:fOi~
¥oeD;, MJLOr?weO 'f?60D J ·~or?
r]l:C~'t3J77~f>wlT1-f,4-tJO
-r/t$.p#J6 LA~ CLeA-N/JG cl+ervJlcfrts', CJ;J ~ ~s11+ R'r Ale & rz; 'Y7 rn. y wlT7f ::> t , I'VJ n--( If1./o oR Di 12 rY /YI/fll~ ..
~0~) T::>fYgJ4J~
CA-N05 6~~/7(g1Y1$)1 04-13-$6 @ms; Arvo 6$ -Ol3@m-», ff-AVE3"" ~~ fl1 AfJe 'fa LCy /1--1'v/f1ze oP Q.l A7,1n fF> meal C+£-; A-N 0 mft./* Ht?1r-LJrf- COJreJn6N! f! A·s M?!C f1-' ~y WYrI cfP Wfl/J.;.eJ tJ{)'17t71dt1>, ~(c /LC/ft£ ru:~T>L' Pf , ~1- v"JhLJ/' ~f?PT~ ?l,tJr!11 ~ -e-x ~L t1IJttJrQ /HL tJ'f? 'firs
VIA
Yhe1\1'"r~ H-e~11.f ;f1Vk? ()fl- m1?0/('!rt- eo~1l0N'S.
~)
utiJ{r/fSaUfr/;;l:e
u,wrl
tf-.f-e
Tln-,"e
MvJl?t, l- "f-s
AroN£-c,A;> U1FYJI3C:~'>I/Y?e7
pt.{ T/~"6 .
;4r
#-'" I)
-n!r D. (' C- 1 . .so' 0 . f to SeA, f6fl1771etl:F Cll(l/J1;
;'" VtdLA!ldJJ tJ'F
QePE'~
-n.ft
t!!'- rJL{)
rAt cPO 7LJ ~(ZJJ VI tJEO ~fJ'-l~tJ rafL ~$VC H () 6)i?T<-VA77cJ~ ~ 2i 3,
HAv'f:
-rrIA-'r 71fE
Y~ 1Vd'/
.
,'eLAJiv/11 pp:r () f C A-
/ZIt: #'f:J
,A1V 0 dfl- uI'!t>eJZ-
tc IJ r- Srkr'E
L /I-Wj
Case 1:04-cv-01350-GMS
Document 267
Filed 04/23/2008
Page 19 of 50
4\-~ q) 7)t?PG",Jo~ #-A-t/£ A- r)1>~l~JNltrlI1W/t1lH~'
FA1{,eo T7J
iNl
(it VE
PLI1-rtJT1tt=
n+/AJ
3 76 "7 Olf-/r /
j
Mff?1\/l E"t'J1l6 PI Nm e l f7.-( U 1Y1> -r1J-NC-H 'H 1C w /flc Ii VI dL!tTB 111 S 'f(Z6CC-1?U £4G 4rJ 0 ~
r .
* 1D)
j>c
pJ.(~ I~L ''''~ }fc~N6
"b~OAtJ"r.$ I{A1IE
t1tTCttl '17J
wf1}fl,J
er
eI fl,...C U IYlsrt1fv~ 9 FOIL
GIlle ,?L-+rN1lFf? / ~ MY~ I 11-'rerJ/
Wf/7cl-f
VldL,1r{;-s
H-t 5:
~(2~ c-E7XiR If-t. !J-rv'1J £'(.,(~.frAtJ 71 vr-
put:
t?f2~C~~f
fZl '1m /!1-NfJ
l)
6 I \Ie's fl.;c-MtJ;J wIN AtL OF T7f? VLA-r"l1~ 5fttJfno~ ~ll-otALJ) 15r? p.;erc,JJPe7J f)/AE ~ Vld44r!dAC af ~ ikuJrt'PPS )4 -nf U > c It- ~{ C HrJ 11'J Jft> fLl Ctt"7? UN IJ7?Il
V~ e ~~3S/~S
103'1101.07 f.tr/D
tP-f IO?'6~SZ)~
~ 1/) Lr /C~ H-ItNJ4A1s fhJp l,T v-lI-tYler s/f71C~ JfA-1/e
'>,l.A:eo
,$"
1Yl£~fl.ftp/oLJ
1l1.f
t>eFlJJltJ6 L Idet-
/rG~Ai>1 ~ L ,+tIV7lW, FtJfl- .r",4--pF' 10 ~ ItOI\ff? CALLS 4No 1C:L:VJSttJrJ ~ ,If1"O o'ft'{l- -r1fe1yI
712~1t-'r
+.JLMOL-#- J .1f4t1fd beN'I luf1Mnt1Z ~'E'trt..
~
/l-£ 077fefL /;..Jh1 ~, 6ff4{tfE -t-ILr-1? CiVIL- c~q~/tr7I1t> Mktl.I$r \)~OfWTS,
kf'io 1417f LI .{' l A- lJld'-4fldA/.
\I1()~lrno;J~ OF I ( beL ~ / 6~t.f, (,J~ z. / 6S/7
VlfJ U
r LkrNfl fF
Case 1:04-cv-01350-GMS
Document 267
Filed 04/23/2008
Page 20 of 50
4f 11.) b~o/1fvi:f
H/f1IE FIt1l ro /J-cr/ e"~~-i.?C/
,zeG/HlOIA16 BKI,~,J CriGR47YI rlk' Lff1\/' 1,1 g.~RItt-rJ'
-m
/IS!:I rrM6i I
/-f~ /
l:-)
rk/~I.I~'E 1tJ
pfZ'J vlOE
fLA7 t1rr·ff wmJ rl2d~ ~A<.PI,,;f7IiTiFF
/flJZFflfp.,44t£
/
~jZ WlfTct!C/j-&{SFO
l)etJlfft--- Or Ins' FrJeST
?()rtz~(\/VICTlP,J"1d'T7tJ/./ 1
(Oet- Off /Z / 'UJo(,.). bJZI4-N {?fI/(l/O}M F~t.-t?IO 7rl \!f2t> v1 P c- (lL.4-1 /'Ill f"F" tv 1771- r;/fOIO Co ~ ~E-S .4N1J /?1 A-rllAi{ ~(~f'ftIH /I/;rt--I e-x'f?OI/rrF m/fIJtVE1l- /;} /CEQ/tPor 70
/'tI4t1J1
s: c-, /
Lt;?IVl.r
v· .sr.fr7C
I
'ZlJo~f)Et t~ /1
6sY /
pru V/I)II'f~
1/70/1 wl77I
I
ft1-TO {.c6'!ft. m~{/ft- 7WtJ
~ ~(~I- to D~~llJe /h'IP (jt0NO ;.-11m W77CZ ()F VEML' ,we A/tiO fltf /NM/lI7'l77) Ol5r,fr,J J1?A--tl.-ldc
.$/l-ro F#lt u!2C tzes'c.( '-rev IAi ?L-1-TAJ 71 Pr5 Ap!'b1l. 6£lAi; ()E1J1m .~ UIJ77mc:L~ (~~ CtJtJ-trr.!T/dlJ)/ r-tJfC- W/17clf wlllLI:) f#t;c
OUF TtJ ffl.r JtVOI('CAiT sr/'hU$·
~~SHD pl."I7/77'FFf C~Nt/lc-77()tl/. CTlle-tl/11Vces ~ fiLet=>. / f I U fcA 12{(J/fl ill(J11H/O,J
~'1 'tP'-/e~
v I ot./r71();J op II
I} (?f. C
g ~S'I'~
(p ·5'02 I
b 5{) r/
Case 1:04-cv-01350-GMS
Document 267
Filed 04/23/2008
Page 21 of 50
dF13
INJ7/IfZtES
i
C,tf-a~r1) i3y f)~o~ t/t'tI/-170;}Sdr
it OC-t C' S 0S/7//d5-3~1 l:JSOJ.: fo6tJt/. b~-dS
/') -;,8
rOUND
fflfl(Jt't,
ANo
Oue 16 ~/(NI?I ~ JI,ffLOrll7f·
Wf?15,/
W~CI/r ~~f!"
gnl-(j5( A- RI61f1 Vlal/lil(j,J:
2..) SWetA-/;..J6,(J
,J
~"£; b r j (S/ItJ/;i-OEJ2 '~Lcrr;) ,
>l..l
~c-O J)i.sK
,AI NtfC/C-
klVO u~ ~AelL. I I
4.J
$.)
'P(JrRA;tJ~/,4
I
7)Ef..,.U! J/OtJS /
1-I*weIAl'/tT7d0
~ VJdLl-W 1OAlYIA~... CfrtlflNC $(JEt1c1f
'
38
~.)
·~u 8lt: 6f2E477r16 ;4-tVo 'O't77Nt; . ~OcANO.5 w~6ffr Ld>~ IN c;a IJltis.
I
I
l!JtOm pf?{l?7'l~.j. -e J tevJDJ'VJsm
f;erfk1/1()/l-
7. \ ANrl- Sf> C' I A-t
Q~) ~~ -- fl-JAIfl//r;.
10 ;
s~
-F1YlOTlotJ/Ii
'{OvtllTJ
/)iJT72E'sr /
W0(lfT
L~ J>
/,-e;
/f-l
f~
oIlYJ
Case 1:04-cv-01350-GMS
Document 267
Filed 04/23/2008
Page 22 of 50
/3.J
38
h11L-O AJUTflI 71 tJN"I 0Uc- ~
c4U~/J6
i./tJlYt/1TIAfr; / f'J/fU f Et4 1 ~()()"NO Wt/61t/ Ld rs, .
p~SI tJ;../OU.r rocJ() L~ff OF ArpC7l71:.
IS -)
/~ IferzAil/t. I () LI /IV/tL
J
i)
"'1 .slOti 61 ~/ t!lZ/lCkaJ ;rF7/eJZEt.. Y
/ t·)
lAi{1ft--mWt~E) ?JW7Cf~ 7Jcn~/tJJCY. gB \='OfAAfO Wf31~1f7 [.aff ~JJ tjd bH.!"
t..4-CT7f$E"
}q,') £~ev wterrr i/C(;Er/f1ll~ j . ../.
Pert WqJC'Y;
3}J "'? {j (fl NO flJf1 (, HI,-- ~
IN
<;;
\2~Te/J I rI CJ () Mys.
dD .)
17 S5U'E £/lEmt4
'huE TO 1+/t1VI} CAA fFf.
111M/os MO ~Ecll Bt*/~t3tJX r!+A-eKi.-es ¥O
Case 1:04-cv-01350-GMS
Document 267
Filed 04/23/2008
Page 23 of 50
).1. )
~J.) lite II /ftJXIf?T'/.
~3.)
:J-LJ.)
:) S.) ~
DilE It)
Cc IJ()~t/fh7d~, //-t!m/(,IA-nd
rltl(,.J/f2~ 77J
f)C-(7f2A-lJI+174N ' j
.s C:-6'~C:(j /!77dtl;- /)ISC~/rvJl;'./.If776;J
NJ
:
rf2d
VIOC'
(fF~~
/Z~rE-tC'77ve ~C?/Nh;../~e-tvI .su.c/14~
wo;t!C /Cc-LC?I't-S"E7 /
~ IJ U)
t!!')
G~*- efJpfAlA-r7I/N;
I 1Z
~ ("f/I'YJI"Y!E~ C~<...
e-
L.c--,/'C-L
;).(p.)
L Ire
FMUNb VI JIIJ~ DU"E TO Pd6U/
tfS)a~,
rJ. r;.) IIZJZe-PffRf+I:;L ~ 1f/lk1 t,AtlS"EtJ 8-/
·UhJ
L"/~I2!ffll4-tJI ~t?C 1F /c:1
I~/)../.
d-~') ~Btt/G Pttl~/?1~G¢//KIft3S eO;/!il+tVff'0 p ,:.erLWr> M PISC1J L1J ICfJ I}7v1J f)tf "PfJ/l..-I'UerJ '
Case 1:04-cv-01350-GMS
Document 267
Filed 04/23/2008
Page 24 of 50
~ 11.l)
5C--rJ7C1'ICtJl6' (JRf)~ ~rA8Llrfl HIs ['f 6eTl'T"j IIJ7fl;ftr JZ( f fir T1J f.:;E' r(~ til iJl?t? f/Vrnl- Y);1 etI/T,4---L /%4-<-TJI -rJ.fEYl~ VI (,,17/tI ScIi ~ /6'1fT )
Der-oJO~5
..
~15~
-,-0
INJf7L-c·flIt: (lL.4-lIvnrr WIf5 5-lll/ek-Lc-z? AfJO
IfA:N()(uppL-tJ //vI77-/- &.Ae/C&Y'/.. ) Ik '~L I7J
,
.
PLoOf<- liTVv"/CE /;'
/ I
J
w/f8J -fIE T!ZtEr:J
7lJ
U?
vl-/7?!J ~l. 4//lJnff /---feR-r Ihs NFCf'C A1VO L() VVt?fL ~ K.. &111 fA fC/j- ViO(./mtJ;.j, VltJL~J OF II bEL C ~ t:,~/'~ 0$02/ h6t:J ~ 65cJ-S ) b'G~ ~3"
77-/15
rr,4tlIJ '
IS
4"-1fe)
lD
~\z- 't)'\21-eND ~ [)eLi ~ 1) t?Lk-/ A-J,-.I 0 0 (l y A-ll.. U
~en-~IZ. C>f2J)~ o-r
crt)
"DML'/
ViIl(Jt-lC?rA'fZiAtJ~
I'2E
l-\c/{l:elrJ (3"i 'Tl1's \-\1' "-\o~l15 ~C-<,U t2-T t!J p J 15~. 60., "fOlL ~A--cH- D~ '~~J)A;tJrs A'fZ.t uJ CiJ~~'~YZ .
-jf 11.)
1).
Itt> ~
MY
fHVD ~~A-Lt o~efZ--$" ~ vt'YVll.'C\t::::'I:1
~
G
oPFt t.et2-
G rt'f?Gore'-l 1: I t!1ZCC
suJcc
t/2. z..JtJ ~
I
I
/ttllltv4t 16 s lfi,t Ll, A"4l-!lr J If,4s L~A1ct-f'elo A 't) I ug-~CA1'Vlfft it;,J f-\6 k1N,,- tz L. Jt1~ 'f{ FF, 1=0~~VANi5 In
C¥\M1tJft<-LY c-\f~ ~fl\-l(j'nff "~'(L . 't). ( c. \U~~IJ>
C;:itJL~ &f\ ~t.A1~t1'2s
~A1ZOte5> 4)'f 1).~, t- <;. 0 .
r
CCJ~~l-Alt~;-S ~A1N~,-~~"fe,vOt>r"'~ I ( SeE Di$L\()ttNlt~-y ~6(l7T .if l818b'i'l At'O ~ If) ~<;~ h 7 ) I , ty11t, J. -?i AriD gnt u S" {A -\2 Lb l f l VI{}Lk(1t>N>. . \Jl 6 lfn16N> of \\ (Jet- c ~ ~5:3fc I (is-oz I fJJ$oL{ I' fo~1'7 V ~5gl (;,S-c2c1. C I
I
CO ue
-rB
l'LkuJl1 r p 'f1l·1 ~ t
l 1/l L
Case 1:04-cv-01350-GMS
Document 267
Filed 04/23/2008
Page 25 of 50
~ 1 ~.) ~IAj l'£ ~ ~L+tIJ11t?F.s -m~11$YC12- 'f>Ac-K -ro \). C c '\"'\Z-orv~\). ? .( (l)J \"L I , l/ 10, ,1) fL , MJ 'Df.-~ 'Do~f-<.lF \-\-4--S" ~EC-J ,~~c-o ~6t'V\ \). Q.C- 'J 'vue --;0 ~ 'DE--LI8'E12'J'hT f~OLr=pe--ecvI21?
O~ MM.~, tJt:-eLt?c-T M'-$-rrze~13VI A:-tJO A-s>({/fLr .
I
\)\ ~C(l H;EO
lJ n('e lDO 012- ~f2E 612ff:?1! ttrJc~ n L1?O ~v .11fe \?l4--tlJ1\~ DGlJl,tJ<; til~ fD I ~ I(jt -n-hztA t~II'-I1 tJ7 <;r-A-Y k -,-tfe I). f., C } 'F~rz~A-1N'1 ~ flL1 N6 CI \IIi- ~m(LA-tI"\ c/Jr ...rt>. 0'-1 - ,.~so Co /)1 $) . MA-1i1~, 1). 'S?!. )~~ yY1<::-M e~r a I ~T . 811+ u- $"./cA V(tJl+11aJ<; ,CiVIL A-~S'4-ul.rMQ
l
*
~~~f
I
I
t 1if)
rz..er-~~EV om rvtd ~uf"1) i2 ~L-A-11V"11~ '~ ~ ?sit~ 66~~VA-n(),J ltJ ~ D. (C ,tJt1rzmNr'l CJ~ Z.}21 /f)g f
bepetJOftt./TS"
g
I
H-A-s'
~ ~ ()ptiZ/J;rco,J/t-L
1>OC>lZj'T1t4-1 V\I\l.(S'"l~ 6P~
VV\AtJt.Af\1J...\./ ,As lNtlL M Mt1J1l\L t~tft-TH ~-etJr"T111f=1
wC>U LV ~ A- t/E- ~Af" l Ltx:'"1Q ~LJ1"1;J1l ffZ I CitJ 11 l'l1l fll> (ECf1 ve c-u ~O'l
~/rc
()P
~6l!f1Ne'tl1'flJ)) ~
e
t ~ ()J
4~ J ":)
LfJ"IO
~L'otJTl~
r:c T2 At-l
lrY\MetJ I kTl?
oJ
~-1L 'In ~l A. c:e
\N 1'TlJ'lCS'S
Il-\--E
ttVftlAL
'?1WTC-enOtJ
~T,ffUr.
U~CO\K-1l~ kND
-n~
1).
C.DN>IOe1Z41ll\~ 'n+-£ MD~
"Vv\1tJnff ~~~ ~r"R'(L'lltJ5 Ho~1lJr&Le (O\.f? r TO ,Me
~ .r- I \ ~ e} DC-1-W/tflf b ,l'c. J 1:.f)01.I tJ SU.ppc1(t ItelZ~/J · 1)(.('t=:.fl' T"l.fe ~~'(l-tf\1 d~ ~~A-t~rr~ cL,+t'YJ fJ.j@IJG {qLEO \?f2llJ~ -rs 11ft: .fet'eTlAt- \#JfM-t~ AlCO 61tt/£ 1~~IGm-:\1S ~A-t() ulta« I~~
t
-n+AJ ~o u·(.( A \110LkntJrJS fZC1'6rt~ ($\/-rltC fet>C~ t~irzV ~()J P4tJW oJ
Case 1:04-cv-01350-GMS
Document 267
Filed 04/23/2008
Page 26 of 50
~ ~i) AYO~ g~~
Aof1\·Tf':1)-tO 11{E
\? cc \~~1Z-Mk1'l" t:'J l 1./14 I~71
\'lAAh"\ff '\2C-dlv:e~rt-1J A ~6lf ~flo16tJ htC'\,~--c'\'Z- \CeO ~ V~~erA'fl.ll\fJs f ~ $U 1lE ~+e'lt Lilt ~ JtAiLE" l ft?4fJlAl~12- ItJ ~ TFtW dF (26) Me""- I M 0 A II tJ~ 4 bPr'j If 111/111 n>fZ- '11-\"t ~u ~?b> E --t"" -f'D1Z-'fll ' i+t ~ ~L " l(JUS D6l-1(; A-i'ldJ M 0 1:6 fL· ?f?-O ~ ~I~ tJ ~U\~~uyY)~ltnoJ, 1)12.- 0 bt.t·R'~G:r~ ?.bof( A-~P(loveo $1r-iD
J
Awl? w~ A ~'fOf2- ~LA1tJl1~ t n+/t1 D(?fENlJ/tt'ITS rzr~-u >~ TO AL·Ll) tAl T1-f£ D IC-n c/~ TO O~-P-c:-O
'Due 115 ~ Cl
'F~~,
J
\lLJ\1 tJllff l( A \~g1ZL""\I lS"TZE-ttu ~ t G-C?E t/'2-J/~9; /'£~Th w~). 1 sri ~ nf I ~ "tl/- U~'S C A \11() llr;l();}:;./ ($g ffJUIJ 9w-er"Hf l.OS! ,,J ql) o!f\/r). VI 0 L.A-'710NS Of" It Off C e- /.ps-/ '7, (,s-oz ftJsoL!j b S-Z" ~s 2.. 'I "5"3 I / ' I
\f' L C6 h'\l'L /ttt-JIS:
\fe
fiLEV
A-G.4-1 '"Sf ~ ·
-r
-rF f2.6~
AJ
1M r'Yl c.:O ,
~ of2QEf2- 'R> 12- A 1+1 G1+ ~OTE7,J DI rr
ftt'iO.s u~ pW IYl t:1VT ,f-L
I
1 f?N$'V1TZES: PItIL"~
1... Ytee V, 'Tl1-tVl, ,J DAi L"'I ) 'FO JC flet.1 6 t OlAS ~ ~1Z ~netJ MJo k{V1'fTlttJ JPrL ,
VEA-tv'U/ ~-L It-J~fEtro OF \a:P rY1f5A1/ D~ ~~ H: ~-(Atl C:A<:lf meAL Mo A- C),Jt;; A- D,+-v/
AtJ ()120l?12 Grz/t1'¥11l'i 6 TIhs HorJaTlM<..E It) ~oJouCJ A r--etJfT2-AL lJG.utfl'l,n ,rJVC--ffiG'/l1C: -nf1: pr1'1frE <1F'
11-f-E ~t. kl Nll r;;p A-~ flVetL A- S (D G12 A-tV"I ~ 6 1Nf;(Z- OF krrn rz.Jei
-ro '~LA1wn~ I PA1A6'/f1~t / LPrf-oV4- :JOlftJ<;O,J Mo JA-tvt~~t{fiS()~
-rlH2
I'
~ ~1f)
'~f2 A1-L Or H"l~ ~ef\4D',J, ~IV1L ctJP\~'-f+tNTS t-Pr ND'.s D4-1~50@.,y!SJ // I tJlc -~1 ~ ~IY)S), 65 ·-f}13 ~M5) I 64J ~ J--S ~-tG m $" ') Mv~
()4 .- I ~ I () (6 N\ S) ; .
Case 1:04-cv-01350-GMS
Document 267
Filed 04/23/2008
Page 27 of 50
-tr ~ 50 11ft 1tk~t1~~'W?tJ NIAMc~u~ (!k;e: IN l71tnrr: ~ rzrs
At---n1? .0 ~ l
t, .. r-O'IZ WH ,~Jt I
l1"t? 'f) tl) ltA-vl? 'Ttl prt! pOSTAL ~l- 'bur ~os-rAi ~~J g~l~' ~t?' ~ -n-IE "timE) VI A 5'rA;-1F YV\,Mt.- e.d'12lm c.;;Ef(.Vl {PI ~(A·r ~f)~ D~~OAvJt! FitUtll\t l~rrIlJf"w riLCl/ ~t \II t ~4rvlf~A-/~r/J6A-1«1jr ~1~ C?tY\~o'k"~J' l'flfr/'"\{ rAAPt!~ '11fe SlATE" rY\,AIL [61'(llc;e S£1?VltE lAtJAVAtLA-6ttf 1L> ~tA1~l1ft? CftU.fINC 'ftAIMn~ ~ ~ft" ~l>mrL' fC~ IN "11-(6(.(, A;t(6tJl~ ~Lk1(U\l ~ 16 GCZieve skiD tltAtJl1E ,.J ?() s-r Itf., TZu L-~-rJ \JIA \' L ~A I 6Uf Ct>N1lNtte 10 Ul1L-I'ze ~/tU) s'~ W\k/t CJJL(ltetL~t/lU: ~ [email protected] ve~. -0 t?\---L-N OANT.> ~Tf(),J S J Itt 0N6 IJ.J i 'rr{ vL/fej f\i6 lfr m ,fJ , \
11e w~ arl"IJL~ ifJlt<; CA:Q5~ ~£"ArNllrF~ &6XMC? WT/tlL~1 ,tJ()I(Wr ~ rrJ {).~ lr6l~ --rt) 0 ~ 1/t7 Ii ~o tY1 M15!'!t'f2'~l., IJ C-N <;,,~~s- 't T·- ) li; fl- r "'i ~ l jq? bt1~ uJ tV\,kf12.> /tAiUJ 11~ cA-«se1J If I m /tTy ~,ckt (bvO
I
f.JO'
ftvH1L:c
~eGt2e6'/f17{)J y ~ln+o(A, yrztJVtIJIN6 1-h1'Y\ ilJJnfA ~t31 eveJ 7Hou6/f
SiGfllf!Cf\"1J, '\tA\lOS"'/ft f" 11h5 wlt1' (j)t;fff -Tn 1)/S"C OlA fMc ~L-k1tU"n~ ~ Wl (-et?1Ll~ tze1JfZB l' ~ IYl 11 ~ ClJU1-r,>, ;>EE- A-c.!O"'If 72
~4'l:elUi C s e-e
1
so.,
pL4-7Ml ~2-/7,; I tJ r;; NO 17t17 1rfT~1-k?I:? ~ ex/tfr "r)_ k1'lO It[ n+- u"' ~ CA- TZ r(;' f+r VI d' l-!Hld'A!i; .
0/
~fS',J 'ttZ-AN>'fe!L Ii) Ct~S'1 f1LkTTo,Joft'i"ce1l- Gr '11-fo~ se~(lp ,ANI' LltJOA- ~"'~ C'OlAtJset6l2.. /5\JrntJi A1'IptC/tL !rNO (16Nlf1tAAlrf.fttfll)Stflpr, Il~) ~o \{lsrTJ' slHt£ 6~;/(J lritkflCEt!rlW ~IJ Oet~41ze rl ~/t)gI P.ezNb >t4,B~
-"\6 ~t}JoftL DI ,cJZi fYl JtJtf110r'J \{~S$MC-1\JT I
:iF1~") ~t1 peg UJO ~ fltftN11 rP >V1~Wl~ A:tf tl (JrflDrJ -FofZ-t II'jEtZsT.f1t::
Gt:'1t-16
$().(l'Jl3<"rt=v
--m
I ~(l:Cf-A.f.A'8l:E
H-f\t2rn 6,/,;Jt'I\f'
~ 6fftCt(5 'QLi~1l> tttLltl6 ~LlJ/l ~()rv..~fruJrrJ !'JtJt f!;euJ 6
Lt;1ftL
11Lth~
tic""A"'- LrVef-; Of CdfV1rYl-IpV}EtJT/ g@,J' ~
{-
WI11f \)a1~1lA1\? \~OIf'fL~t~ ~"'J VVtE1)LC~
mL"lJTAt ltclf-Lnt
srJf-fr)t2tc .
L:r >,e~ ~,~Ol \'1:- ~~f1£ '11tr$ l S Go,iJC717J (J£ f)oJl~ p () f.1~1'tF.
is r e'jT1-f.¢- /411-1 US c A- VloLk(i()I.i, VIOC4:1l6iJ ()(2 I( DEL f, ~517I fG
Case 1:04-cv-01350-GMS
Document 267
Filed 04/23/2008
Page 28 of 50
-'* ~'iJ "\=iirt- A-J Vtlt}(1L-tn ~ll.dpu.le \.:r f~-1l-"~R~ \)1 sCl~utJ/rl2f
rzc;-c orz-o , DLA.-e' 1"1' lr 'Y<> £-(b"£S' 4 MJ uJ(? tr\'t: '" r E (j"~ ~ (? LlN'A-f4?-~i
\) l
l
~ lSI01Z-"I1 il1~ s: LA tft)R~ -n~ rt..A-1tJl1~ C L A-UVlS' ·
.{- ~ ~ .J
D ~l'fl_IIJG
-rHt:~l\·2. c 0..1"[1 ~~ENT A1 ~
e>P
t.CZc A-U~E O'P-
11t"£ 1 tt fl."E1) Ar~
A:-t ~W'\ c
A-US"~1:) -~
I,J
0,(( 1> (.
i
C
ItA $ YSC-c
-J
n-1~
1t.,A;-C-O
A<; oue
~
'TO \'
-yr...J
wa~s( t>~1$D~$
pJ
1l~ ()~ 11T-:t:) $T~
f;, . .Jflft:?
u, S
pe-tJt?1Zflt.,
~ \..I. ~E4-U o'P'" J"HJ~716A-1t q,J ,
*C61 0 ~
.-n+-e
2..001
f1:--OCfAt. lJ(1ullZV
Cd,JOUl11:--t)
P(r~
'1). (C $UreOlZTS
VAe-T 'Tl-\A-1'-nre- 'i)e'pc--tJ oAfJ"TS
I*A--Vt, f./OT ~ Pile '(Jeri. t)<:T7d J ~
fZc'l-fMI Llrftn:.z ·T1~~t.,41tJnPf" 'OUE'ID 'T\h!1R 01:"t f geRA--"~- ItJO 1~f2:E'-tJ~:p 'I J { ~
~c£(M,'C
Hf
fiLC'V CiVIL. c.tlW\"LAI~ AGA-ItJ~i1..fem.
c4-«S'E yLA1t-1-n¥f llZ-:(ll1!'t{2~"E \-\MzM / i:>u.c
-n OCK-N olt1't5 1JaJ')IIJ6 Pt-A1wnrf \-\1s fl-~-='ST ~f2- -:tncs '\l'(..4--1tJ 1tJ, I 6e1tA-Vlltf2. YYl6Q/f1CM10rJ~rz .4lleGEV
mA1J AiC-rY1E1'£ r I
c ( u. N$e-t-I ~ A-tw 0 T1ZE krt14 ~'I
I
v<'rz
tN 111~H ttJBilTl+e-;!W/L(
(tJPr\1rd{l(~ ~c'1iMlIOfl'l l+t c; J{ ~A12NltJfi CCIUI?SE q-C~t O(l \//A- U.$ eyOfTt41-)
MG ell
T1~ '11~ >·rA·"'f~· Of 'D{:>\..~ A-lZt:S CDtJG. flc-:s-rld,llk.. ee, Ylo'IfYl' tT"'&t.-c' IfA-~
~AO A1JMlA-f;Lt:"
,
'
'\?.fl 6(i.,z.ffr1 5 ,
J
r-o{t..
tVrvl utJOe(l C{)Lt>~ ef?
U,JOE1l- 11*
~fZC'ft~(JrJ o~
T1-tE U.S. c- , -f"'--6'f2
srA"rC lA-W,A-> IA./t-t.l. Its IiJ'.flCJU 1l+t?" t>~o~
\)@tc1) ~tPr' t-I\\ ff" ~ ~S;;~ ,n+ouT
~DIlLt?S'
Of?
~\'H I rA-e-r t--1f'iOING
AH E'" A12'1,J6 ~o VlO; ~ Wfl l nerJ a.A1tD,J~tJ 'prz~t:-rJrc-vloeJ~!?, ,,J l-rl~ 6W,J
OR ~~e/tL.
~~A-tf / co.rr1·U~ \t-ts
\i\{\;Ll
A
$);l?I--aJ UMIT ~c1 W v~Y ;
I1h~"- sA1 b \)t"~tf\t. ,~fZ{2'\it:1J15 ~L.Att-.Jn W "fi 61'\1 ~(Z.C-s-~nl\6 AS" A <)--rMl~ M'NOt.~ I L~ {tel O,,J6 i -rAy.. ffYilAJ' ,"rYl.A1?llfi'48u: C 11l'ZaJ w I~ l+e \$' ~-t:CAselO,AtJO "As btt!tcl1 vtAtN11r"fl1t ~iL;r/"1t) fl.!rT10tJ!ttlV{ttJo tze~ffi{LY N~ ~o~~ IO~lfli b tz.G .... 6fft:,J 0 ;~()$-efZ ~ISCPUIJ~'IlttS'·TlJlZ'-lI i tztM/f,j AL ~m~1
Case 1:04-cv-01350-GMS
Document 267
Filed 04/23/2008
Page 29 of 50
~ qO:) PrtJ
\HrtUT
eJRVeTL "FOf"2.-
A
1rJ t>elc-JOM'I l8i AL
A- ~s: t ~,-~U?
~~OA-111U>
I
Gj2Gu.~ 0(2.. ¥\fZWl lTD ~S"I >1 ~lt\-1N11 PF' fh'\IO llJ ~A-1~.s' -PI LE
M'Yf?f+:L~ J ~ 'E"lCoJ",c:not.j tf17\'c:;tLs- I
~n'n 0 tJs
Wt2, ~ O{£
,fJ4P,eA-s C0 V--~ Ll ~
c l \i,L
f+-<
W£::t.L
~
co N 01 n
O~ t1F coJ ~NE-Yl?~
C6~~tJf>.
..t q,~)
,~rz- AtJ O'rz''r?f?1l- n
ALLO ~
~ I-+U
fhvo M Jfr) I,.JM~
<;;l{cH A5 ~(,.krN1lr+ ,10 T~ ~ G'?:O ~'/ ANO 77J
,-M--e C,l! U-ef?c C-' ~ «JC.-~e-s 4erZ.~ IftJ 0 V I A- £A. S fo rrlf1.- .
*' C(z.) "IT-te
C",J~notJ~
-ZOO, :FC-Vt~4t- (tJ~/fl'l s.u.Yr o1l'"f3.' 11~ '
/
A-r1
1 6 CS
f?'J6L--'f,,J6.
,.-EClffi()~(i ,j E't)U(k71ol'i,
/
c () WI W'J.-' ~ Sf'rfl
~'1 1,.1 PlA-ntJ-,} I IAi ~ n,-u nd,J :.w f> S,4t,M.J~ I IN 0; 6 ~c~
J
~ <: c A-flEJ ~o ~I '~L£?A-S''E' ckft.."E J MeN'ftt-L lfe4-1.'TH r;-lI/rt-t..(",TloJ /fNP 'TWA-r1YJt5tJr; Mt2'V1 <:-kL eli/rt..-U A.::r7tJtJ ftrrl '0 TTZ£/IrWIf\Ir'J T:> I ~ C pu tJ ~ l/ ~ fU>C-f?PfA. fl.CS )
'fT2-A-uJ6
J
/t-Cc?1?j
m~
I V6 (A:'l 0 JfrL-. 112- A-t Ai ,N6 I ?1le
C tt\-s $ I
A
CN..,-?6
J oF
,'" rn A-r~ .
:it q'3.)
.f6 fl-
~
DfZOerc FOJ2.
I
t>~ DA1'tT'( to
{"U-ntUJ, i
/
\,rw'V108' HJlt."Vlf;:
Ai>OtJ TW ~~A-ltJll~.r
\2t?LCA$E
fO'R ~Lt~eRv't>etJ ~u.. c:roO'-lJ ~rz-
rzaJT, 'n<--~~;;~otz\~ d cJ I
V'v1:eNTkL we-A1-111
\+1S ~e~",se 'fizoWl
-roO 0 I
VV\E1? i cAL
kV"J ro dfL
\\2NfltY\etJ-r
~12- Up 10 OtJE 'lEAiL ~
cv...~p" I~~ 6~ u'tJnL- HE
:SlJ...t't'1-VlS-en
c ArJ ~ ~ ~1U'1
\'1l() VIDe "fO'j2.- Htm$t~\?,
Case 1:04-cv-01350-GMS
Document 267
Filed 04/23/2008
Page 30 of 50
e S/Af,u s~ t
If.! f 8'''5/ I1fe EU?wrtNP" 6V <;tAVEfl-Y IrrJKJ
~LJ}
l~,hraL(/AlrMY ~ffTlV/TlJfJ)e,
11+t:" \,3'n+
U.~.('A-
?1tIOf(11)
~ COftt~L"ffioiJ trr A<'~~~l.f,tr:J\~ wlt'/
liAs A--tLowc-o
V\I\ A-rJ N'l?R J t, ta?
~~o~.,-t:)
-INITM
11 +tt.,t:='"A-r
t+t n1 JJ A \tJ HiA m ~
,4- suI, ow 6A-'rel:1
\'3~~"I Oy ~ur<:o~ - '+~O("(,\~fEt> - ~11Acltt--EO
t?LA-l~bo)( -CbtJ'
~o
Wl1fftJUr
,J t>t6~'r'I
A-Lt~A.:ort:O . ~t~Crz1W1I1JtfreO MIH~sTI
A--$ s:-rA-rc-O I-tc-R F / tJ ;, W1lrk/r1~ Pr
~~OWll L ~'1ZO ft"l 6r l1-t S C;; \It f.>"jU GA-1"CO 13£ fT-S'\t!fP (;i.J T
CDV\'\("el-6:? -ro VVA1r p rs-E S.vtgJfL~1? "fT) (le:-e lDI \J IStvl 6ceAu.se
Pt?mtJE1?
OVPfZ.C.-s'..' eD
Df'
'*
l \t \) E1..16r:?lt~ l f\J 0 lr-,,\..-c~a () F tl ~{,( ~I rJo ,0 nA-l ~ -
1""'P- eAr A'N 0
H
e-~'
(A
,J
~ E'-1-
·
I
C ~r?E
V'v1 It S LO W
s
t+r E1
i
';I'r /'fof'1()LlAw.. Uf}Vol4-t i., UJu/,~er / (CFVlh\.~ /PM'be\) u>m/b (.( '(lE~/~HTI PI(YIM~lJ.1.
1* \311+ fU.~ LA 1Jet.,='Os
TO
Be A-rvtt:=f'JOC-o 'Fd~ \-rs ~Le uJ
NOT
1)eN ~ I ~ 6 \> lJf1 tJl1 ~ ~ 11+ l( oS c A lZ-l G' f-tr; ;
'11K 13nf l{.~. c~ bl V~ tz~Aso~ WIN V"I! e tA-tJ'T
~O\ r;~OLVe
AfJo
tJ'IllL
\tJ
frcl_6rZJ'fTt.i~,e
Tb
VV\D{)CJl..tJ q-A-tJOAA.t'.5 ~ ~T~ }-JfatFl"'.
1t tl5')
'-n-\-e
~"-A==n1 ~
r6
jL
11M s Jf6
-rc:>
hJIO
e-o~ ~ lO~A1U1J tAtJD
t S$"Ut:
N" f2A"6Lc C'a LfT2r1cS"r~
.,-t)
?L ~ ,..tn ~s: f( pc,-- ~ c UlllAze 11-fE? VClZUvvt oop
11-\-A-T WH"L ,
(t>U\~"- 7
ALL
'tJ'C:
~l.\.DvJ .11\ 't,A1tSn,-? -ro Mf\1ls-l-\-A--t.-t.- DiS6.'> VC-rt'l Nec--o-el) -r-o
Vv'\MUS ~ -C6VV\~r:~~S'VPt lk'- 1ZUL,JG fGC-(J;&...O "JG A#y
(
PrtJ Q AlL
La r-.J·T\:.-,JTt-4J~
$JA-=1C--1'J 1~
",I..
*q~')
,,-o1l- A;tJ
rm
O~
\"b
\W\'MC-1)IML't->/-rtl-~~~VvfrtNn~
Q. 0 c..,
PLA, o'F ~ t)eLMJAfZe
Ar '\) -c.e-/ ltJ
{2c5GAeO.s
~ l-h s YU11l\.¢e \~~A1UeJl4nO~
~~tJ.
I
"fOrt ALL-- '11\1? flt?~tJ> STA1"f2'
Case 1:04-cv-01350-GMS
Document 267
Filed 04/23/2008
Page 31 of 50
Mt? -tnt J ~ l 'Jl.l U. m5~5 ) ~ 1Z- A-1" 'I ~ I ~c l ~ 1-' I../frfLV 4tJ t1~ (J t.J~ (+N 0
<; ftrJ~l1~ Wf ~ 1-tE: ~t?1-vr::v ~ , L. ) I ~ 107 /~ rz IN Iflc It
VroL!l-rEV ltIS QfZOCe1?U 11A-t ftr.{O 5CA6~TA1Jn \IE 'Ou.e ~~t.-~~
~~ IfTT / kNO 61 Vl-S ~ ~oJ Wlf'j A-tL Di $C(t'Llrlft1z{,( rtC"¥drz~
*q1~) \)ff~OA1J~
fJrrJ ()
s~{nl)T'f$
H-kV
\'re~\tJ f1 UJln-h~ ~ -- I
~ILeo
10 G: f VE 'Vt.-A-,kl W A \)1 >~\ttltJ~y IS DIf'/> McaJr E-Y-.:r{2(JolfJ/rf.Y
s:Mt>~uo ~{f flee" rJlJt--V
j(
VI ol.4-"rI"ti~ ap
/hJ 0 f?1.. 'Fl /tiN 6-;;:1) ,
\?t.rt C ~5..3 S AtJrJ f t1 n+ U -5 C A ,
1l2A-INltJG . ~1At... l+'r2 A-'L r-tl ,tNt)
7
-It:- q~ .) Du.e -ro TJ.\'E
/
~ l.AINfl \"fO$ t.A-l!~ or- "«£6 ~t
At1?Q e'»11 C /WC!ri1u/lft v1'leQ1 rift -TI£/t"tlYlerJr ANo e~u.fJ.$'tiLuJ~ I
uJ t+lS ~ A-t..l~GEO GfZill1/tJ(tl.-MTlV 1"P/ ~ 71fAlf (",A,V -ruOGe'leGGY L·Mte~ 11~ ~fll1'/ 1""D ~61V1rl'\"'1tE ~l~N1\ff 4t> Ilfe p -O.c. VI A ""THE O.C ( I WtTIt AtJ ~: t ~ ~fA. ptflJIJR (DUllT bT20eL "POfL 11+£ 11-0 l TO mM-c A \({Z6~-rz- 11-tte~ yr1t5 Cl>fl-1Zet:r It¥' G1Z12D'{Z~ O~ ~ LA-1 tI'1 \?FS 'tJI4t'I~" (Sur Iff:e Qc~o.ttJjS \)t?L-t 6eR~ ItJ rJ I f1~etJtE T)f:f1~:J' 111 M -r1fevJ l' No rz:c-O f12'1I/\if> 'TO
¥c--5LtLTC--1J
~ fLO~" A 11 t.~fT lD
Co (l. rz:g.q
'T"Ef7? ~LA'H,'n t~ t=:-f2 (ZW~(li w
frY5
trrJu ~ P;t:1-/A-VI()~S l"()UC:: TO T1fetrz- \+OLOI~ It1m c4f'n~,A-r treVt?L('S ) ~~ENT l1rzo perL 'nzA-uJ Il'i' I 1lZE~t1\IT ft1\I.-J
CiJ().tJ~atrJ6 (A~ $"TIn~{) Ifc1!f/J 1t 8q \#
/ ) I
/rfOj1:eMt:Nr7D~ wlr~ ItJ llteJ fL ~ \?126'VJO/~6 bT14elt ItJh1.~ W'Tl~ ~.,2t)(lC:1'L 1/lJ\1NuJ G ,.. T1'2.Ftf111'1C~f,fr\JO OR C"LHJ~al rJG" 'be1..-erJo~ t
CU)'T!J(}V.
~ Tlfe /tf;1~ 1T'-/, 'Due 'TO 'nfetJz
rN(.fc.,J
\)efC~OItMJ' \)~--Nleo ~Lf\1wn~'f)(,{E
'V16utrl6N~ O~ l srI 9 11/ VlSL/tnoNS OF \\ Ot~ C, ~~-'331 "'J~t1J /t)s-()t I 050t/J 66-Z5:'-'5z.c.f)~55J I~
-ro \-h.s ~u~ CIVIL frNO 14 nt u·.) cA 12-1 r, JhS
C1J~t L.4-t~~
Case 1:04-cv-01350-GMS
Document 267
Filed 04/23/2008
Page 32 of 50
*' qq.)
'(lJ\-"UJn W
Dl>rz~1VT
1-\ I'rJf 10 \-\ /Jr'J~
It ~1"" C116L~ I (,ft
\)(MfJD'>l S t1Z6W1 T(~
tl-l G16Ll2 roR T\t
J1t=
l..f!r5/J ~1l6~fttJ LI f!;{?fL ~I IN~r,
l
woJT4t tte-4t-n( <;-r~ 11) 13~ $~(1 At.- tJeel/.S UlI rr)) 'S,JU 1.1JJ1T)
$-IOD) 'forz..
AJ o~et
D~ c - C
'P6~ 'Vt?r~O~ 1?J ~~Vt~ 'n¥
t
/).CC
~\')e-t1kt- tJt:c-1J¢ UtJ'T Y6I"J~'1
* b\'J 1*
J
t$"
It ~~,ec-1), ~(,
GRCH).JD
to~
~MITUAt ~~Q112S"
'btL'; TO
Cf!;tJOlnotJS dV CaN"'A~T
';'iA"n:--D
tte--TlclJ IN 1f's qt.j~, ~q /-hJo
LT
q8 ,
17~
~l~i) oJ J../ /Z/ltJ r
~~l/JDIf\J
fJ~-nC:t
I
Cou.,)s~1..olZ- I llI'JOA- ~Wl~ MRupn Y TOCyJ<- ME Q FF
I ~ 1ZOft:""-cn \Ie:- C t.A. qcpy w rDfoLlT rH E ~A IN"T1 WS LNttl~ ~o~8\J"-, _ .kND OTZ wrl1-{ouT
If/M
n1oWl~
5E"AC J2(/
O
It1JD > IftJ
w;n-/ A
)re~/Nh -w
Gnlf: IfJm
W(z/~
(4 IJ071e/r cYF 'P!\crPtNr1/;J() TZ.lr1Jcd/f'.-, A e~HA--A1lt \b MVAL INS11ltiC1EO -JIt1 By 'bLtf ro -n.fE1iL P.;eJN6
wW 7
I
\)E'ft:~vANn
ro
'po $0 ./t-GMf-IST ~tA1A1Tl ffZS
·
WJl{.
.C~az MM
\l(alA11o~ ~"P lll)CLL tos31 fo~/7~ &!>tJ2 &501 I .J ' I
V l oL kJ,otJ OV L4 77f LC S:. c. ,A 't2.J Ei" Hi)
tIl
7,{)07
k'r~oMr, Alrtte-/tr?t; As Ei1h~rr-) ,.
Case 1:04-cv-01350-GMS
Document 267
Filed 04/23/2008
Page 33 of 50
-r r IJ.h3 uN/Jr?/lSt G Mt-fJ f (/t7A/T7P(7 fAI;iJ!F J il11MI 'E ~/I t)(.t~ /~:d!;Y cenn'P1/ ~N'·nl1.f 22N4J aIrY Or /reglt.- /
CA:?R-
n 'P1 ~ () 'P
sere..· v1 C e
. J-t;og) 77~t: 010 M,fjL dUe /frV1J Co/t..p;cTCtJr?(
cr'
P{;Etf-Oil\f~3" tfTvO ?Xlfj6/lT i;/ Su PPtJJlI Or ;rtdTJdl'"
FOrt- P/l.£l'n1IN'~y IN:]UmCU # 1-I T>tt{Z)fAlt-tff-rtJ 11::0 1- Cil/ P#-h':>/ ~y' {j. ~ pCS7.4l / 1lJ E~/1 0"':
--rJf£ ft/lLC)l/ll../(i :
CLeTL~'&P71fe covtp(5ms)
t/w' S
WILW7
I)/~jCT LOU/Z
r
<{(jlj N./LiNG
J
>T; ta'/Ll3tJy l(j
J?I1J1E Eo. {)~ -BG 61V (/c. 1" f!Ik,/~ l,{ e /11 pNC >/
I,;vILfJ1/ ()~
Df 11gtJj
lerg,;/
eJ2/f;1 Y--rT0 ~s
()c,Jt1 7Y~/l1lR16C1Vetll'rL·
¥lCJ Ai pieJC/1 (p11l PL
WIL IYJ / 0
sr;
9rNn~~
~iJ t"1t <~()6(Pl.J
f)LC
ltg/ f(fO()tJek f(() <; fAYflNIt- P( 1ft; 77
/
Case 1:04-cv-01350-GMS
Document 267
Filed 04/23/2008
Page 34 of 50
IN THE SUPERIOR COURT OF THE STATE OF DELAWARE
IN AND FOR NEW CASTLE COUNTY
DELAWARE PSYCHIATRle CENTER, a FadliCy of and for and on behalf of, the Division of Substance Abuse and Mental Health, Delaware Health and Social Services, State of Delaware, Petitioner
v.
JAMES LEWIS Respondent AFFIDAVIT
I, Ulrike Greeley, MSN, APRN first duly sworn in accordance with law declare as follows:
1. I am the Assistant Director ofNursing at the Delaware Psychiatric Center, the petitioner in the above captioned matter; and
2. The facts alleged in the foregoing Complaint are true and correct to the best of my knowledge and belief.
SWORN TO AND SUBSCRIBED before me this 7th day of June 2007.
Elizabeth Ann Hurley Commission Expiration: 10/19/09
Case 1:04-cv-01350-GMS Document 267 DEPARTMENT OF HEAl.TH
AND SOCIAL SERVICES
DIVISION 0 .. ALCOHOLI:lM.
DRUCi AItUSE: AND MI:NTAL HI:ALTH
N. DlJPOloilY H'''"WAY
NEW CASTLE:, DI:LAWARIi: 197110
Filed 04/23/2008
Page 35 of 50
,itO,
(AdcfrS$$ograph Plate)'
... FOR
Po} "-16 ~/ ~2
CERTIFICATE FOR INVOLUNTARY ADMISSION OF PATIENT TO DELAWARE PSYCHIATRIC CENTER ANtJ/OM CERTIFIED TREATMENT FACILITY PURSUANT TO DELAWARE CODE CHAPTER so, TITLE 16
Title 16, Section 5003, Delaware Code
5003. Provisional Hospitalization by Psychiatrist's Certification. No person shall be involuntarily admitted to the Hospital as a patient except pursuant to the written certification of a psychiatrist that based upon the psychiatrist's examination of such person, such person suffers from a disease or condition which required him to be observed and tre.ated at a mental hospltal for his own wettare and which either renders such person unable to make respon sible decisions with respect to his hospitalization, or poses a present threat, based upon manifest indications, that such person is likely to commit or suffer serious harm to himself or others or to property, if not given immediate hospital care and treatment. The certificate shall state with par ticularity the behaVior and symptoms upon which the psychiatrist's opinion is based, shall include (where available) the name and address of the spouse or other nearest relative or person of close relationship to the alleged mentally ill person, and shall state that such person is not willing to accept hospital care and treatment on a voluntary basis or that he Is incapable or voluntarily con~ sentlng to sllch care and treatment.
PART 1. (to be completed by certifying psychiatrist)
The undersigned certifies that he is a physician licensed to practice medicine in the State of Dela ware and specializing in 'he field of psyehlatry and he has, examined,
-::::s-~ L--e-w 6
(;;G'
Religion
I;l{
Gte_Ie:
L {/.-Av6 _
J
Qm& of Patient
Age
---:;:3::;...0-,--_
Date of Sinh
11,·).S" ~
,
~c.
~
~
_
Patient's spouse, other nearest relative, or person of close relationship:
(Name)
(Relationship)
(Address)
(Telephone No.)
As a result of my examination of the patient, I am of the opinion that the patient suffers from a disease or condition which requires him (or her) to be OBSERVED and TREATED at a MENTAL HOSPITAL for his (or her) own welfare.
1
L /Case 1:04-cv-01350-GMS
renders the patient unable to make responsIble decisions with respeot to his hospitalization poses a present threat, based upon manifest indication, that the patient is likely to commit or suffer serious harm:
Document 267
Filed 04/23/2008
Page 36 of 50
L..---fu property
And further:
/tflB patient is not willing to accept hospital care and treatment on a voluntary basis.
-_\V-v/:... the patient is incapable of voluntarily consenting to hospital care and treatment.
Name of family physician or psychiatrist _ _ ~~~~~...--'-';"--...;;.....
~
_
Physical conditions which requires immediate or continuous attention:
~~c5\~,
(
~.
Signed:
c;}~ &26 =
hysiciBn Specializing in the Field of Psychiatry Namf> Printf>d
,M.D.
Case 1:04-cv-01350-GMS Document 267 Filed 04/23/2008 PART 2. (to be completed by Hospital staff after provisional admission)
NOTIFICATION OF RIGHTS
Page 37 of 50
I certify that I have this day delivered to a copy of 16 Del. C., Sec. 5161, Rights of Patients in Hospitals for the Mentally III, and other rights set forth in I1tle 16, Delaware Code.
--.~ ~ '-..,,4C:a--t:;> Received: -::l""'C:;'-~--~---=~"":;;'------
Name:
atient's si9nafura)
OR
Patient refused to sign _
Title:
_-"",5:...;"~~~=' ~----=::..W-,---,~~= ... t
_
Date~ _ _~.,p---:::--'=--..,..=.Go-f-!:L=-_o_C._).....:o7 _
~_
CERTIFICATION OF MENTAL ILLNESS AND NEED FOR TREATMENT (to be completed only when provisional admission was made on the certificate of a psYchiatrist not employed by DELAWARE PSYCHIATRIC CENTER) I have examined the Psychiatrist's Certificate for Involuntary Admission of Patient to Delaware Psychiatric Center in the case of
(Nama of Patient)
and have personally conducted a psychiatric examination of the patient; the behaviors and symptoms observed during my examination of the patient are as follows:
In my opinion, the patient: IS/IS NOT a mentally ill person requiring hospital confinement. (Strike One) DOES/DOES NOT require treatment pending judicial proceedings under provisions of 16 Idel. C. Ch. 50. (Strike One) IS/IS NOT capable of waiving procedural right including retention of counsel, retention of psychiatrist Or other qualified medical expert to testify in his behalf, and the hearing in Court.
S;9natlJre of Examining Psychiatrist
Date
3
Case 1:04-cv-01350-GMS LE:GAL REPRESENTATION
Based upon financial
Document 267
.
Filed 04/23/2008
Page 38 of 50
informatio,n~tainedfrom
i
n~u~L/].-/
Namfil of Informant
I am of the opinion that
$-~CA./L_-'
Patient's Name
£;
.
Relationship
Can afford to retain legal counsel.
_.......::~=- afford to retain legal counsel. c:nnot
___
~~:.;etain e psychiatrist or other qualified medica' expert.
.
Cannot afford to retain a psychia.trist or other qualified medical expert.
NamQ of Guarantor (if prlvato legal, medioal or psyohiatrio ropresentation is to be retained)
street
city
State
Zip Code
Telephone
Being unable to afford private representation, the patient respectfully prays the Court to appoint and assu!J1e financial responsibility for the services of / Legal Counsel
L
Psychiatrist or other qualified medical expert
APPROVED:
/!/ll .. '~ ljJ%k<.tt~_
/
HOSP~
Date
0
(;/ O)!2 6'() 7
Document No.: 35·06·004·98·03·05 Form 156
4
Case 1:04-cv-01350-GMS
Document 267
Filed 04/23/2008
Page 39 of 50
.er.\~. (chlliCk QII that aril)M:~ / / /
DDepl'Elsslve Ideation CJ S .fe/del ideation
~\eep disturbance
Anger management limited cognitive abilities Limited coping skills
Substance abuse/depet1dence
.
~tiOI1
0
0
[5;YR~clng thOLlghts
~USi()n$
tJHallucinattons
0
0
II;
S"t(@!lAtb! (check all that clpplyl:
o Stro'ng support syst~m
o Abl'e to nommunicate effectively
fJ Good InsirJht
[) Adequate eduCltlonal bad:grounrJ
[1 Willingness to participate in treatment
o Adequate vocational tdcWs
_
o Good judgment
o Other:
IiI. .b9~: ReduCl:l or rl'iminate problems noted above so thf.\t they do not impair Inmate's if ilyt. lctJcmfng.
tl¥Uil:YJ.Il,).!,.:ire.~~~· ~·tQ!I~!l:~:
lilrtkJip·~te in psycho cCl)cntion rAgarding mental illness, signs, sympl:om s , aM ttMtment
d
Develop 91Pintltedhnlque" for manag!~o/'
[g,pepress!\Ie Id.laliof!
[]R~el'
o Cognitive l..imifatio!i·.!i
~~ety
rg--§Itwational Stress
Lll3WtJrt
to/PMicipat'i:l in siJ·j)sJanoe abuse treatment adequate sleeping! t~ating patterns
fS}'R$port the reductJon/'1b!~eI'Geof AHNH
[J Pytictpete in sex O'ffel1de . I~ sue:: group Etfats.e psychotropic lnei:lIc; Itit ,ns 1 ~ prescrlbed ·~onsti"f.l~e organIzed t~ ,In dng . reality t.est
e:tf-~ate to transltionldl wllarg ': planning !9"Partidpate In hlbtiofr1erar'l
[J Partlclpa1e in at least dn,'.l p-oductive activity dally
o Oti1er
v.
CI partlcipataln Interact'leicHirnaling/engage in journallng
~
.
,-__...
----_."..---_.""-----,---..
_ __
...._.
.------~
...·
_-- --- _....._.. ..--
Iry thirty days
!~,.m MQrJifWe~: IndivIdual treatment t,y cUn i,:;ian at I~ast evelY thirty days Evaluation and treatmer;t tjl psychiatrist at least every 90 clays Mecllca'tlol1 monitorinp bV rr,II'slng daily
o o o
o Group treatment a1 least ml;e Er
[J Indepenc. ,nt inter1vK1HI'. f
o O;~~';t;) -rR.:I7··~-:Ik~r:::J._..k:1i~
~fi'J! ,'~ tli ~r"~NJ:; 1/
Time: .
/
~;.,;,;;.;,,~w.w~~"""""=:=./..,;;;,~j::._.j.-Da_.te_~,~-.~--" :2J..,:fi -:..'.. . _.,-.. . . .- ,.----
Inmate Number:
1.. __ ._ _ .. _.J
'---~-..."..------"""'""--fo -t...-"",.,~· D ,- C··~)/~~,."""'.-MlIllllllO;";;;;'-",-_,,,,,,,,,,,,, .....,"""' ... - , ........."",_.··~~~, ."...2 . r ,()1 .
2.=-
..
'l/oe
-1-"_0".'"' ' ' ' ' ' ' .
'j
. . . . "j
._"..........--. .· _-.~--- ................_,~......-.~-
----~- ...--.-.-'.... .....~- ...-.... .---.-~--..~~
"
,.. ,; ,\
Ia
: "II ·
Case 1:04-cv-01350-GMS
Document 267
5,
2003
Filed 04/23/2008
Page 40 of 50
SATURDAY, JULY
":im:itJ\".. ~~~1' ,\~
Three;injure~in:
,~~~;.
ump,
trom burning boat "
BRICK: Three people suffered minor bums and two others es caped. injury when all five jWl1ped from a boat that caught fire in the Barnegat Bay near the Me tedeconk River yesterday, Brick Township police said The boat was about 30 yards ou~ from an Ocean County rna· I nna about 4:30 p.rn. when flames engulfed the craft, possibly the result of an explosion, saW Sgt. Craig Lash. " 'All five boaters were rescued, "Lhe'sergeant said. The boat, I which was gutted, drifted to i sho,re and beached itself.
Public is,asked to help "find missing~ewark man
I the public's aSsistance in finding
I a city resident who suffers from schizophrenia and a bipolar dLs
INEW'ARK:Police are seeking
order. ; '" L ", Jimmie Lewis , 36: taueedJast . with his moLher by telephone on May" 19, but wa.sn't re ported missing I untu June 2S;said ,_ '';'''''\'.'';-::'.ii'~,,:: Lt. Derek Gle Ill11 3 . LEWISi(1'i' city police sp~kes· . : " '''r:~';' " '
Jr;
',"(,"/,
,:.- :
man, ~.",
:i,c' (~.,
· ',,; .
s~.:. ,:' ,~r , . Glenn said anyone with in[O[:i
mation shoUJd'~ortact pqliceat "
(973) 733-5172.
"He said Lev,i::, de~cribed as rn~cd~prcsslve, i56 feet 2 ' '
inches/weighs23Q pounciS:·haS
brown eyes, hlack'lJair and'a dark:
Case 1:04-cv-01350-GMS
Document 267
Filed 04/23/2008
Page 41 of 50
)
Detainee '5 Name: Charges:
\VILMINGTON DEPARTMENT OF POLICE
Detainee Assessment / Pfoperty Receipt
,
L. eiV r's J/
,I
-
'1A J1/!,'
t
j
'"
Case #: 30 -
0
J-
LaSI. Firsl Middle
{~v I~L /" (':oJ I( & U
,j:' J
A rr es tin g 0 ffi cer: _/:;::_:: Lr_'_~cI._vv_r'" '7-:-_ __ Additional Officer:
J ~n h.....,~
_
Detainee's Physical Condition:
Explain:
OK~
Other
0
(Body deformities/Bruises/Sutures) :
Medication:
Yes
'I--tJrA.-'Z-
,tJe- ,
~
No
0
I
Type:
;:'JfC.A...O;;-tJ(Jrc
,
De,/.Jc;-!L.oie
vi F7~/1 L
r/ FfJe:/,fl?--L
5£..---1 c /
Unusual Behavior:
V e.- ~ ,tJLe.. ? /~/e.f / Explain:
,,-__ ----:
/-0
'-"ff L~ 0;:
~
eft e.- (
7
IrC---IJ>r-e/cf)
10
,rvJ
o? c.
_ 0./'
F
/.r
D\:tainee's Property
Currency/Coin U,S, Currency: U.S. Coin: Total:
(H~ve
Seized as Evidence
~/~,_(}~O-:--_
t
q, 2-4'
.z..~
U.S. Currency: U.S. Coin:
Total:
detainee initial next to tOlals)
Jewelry:¥ec;le:-Lt!..ss'
C~,
~vlr/l e.~'j(-1110J (i2.L)S'~, 'Pe'.-VI£- I--(GIlN>
.v..../Jt>
e... 'Ie..
·
Miscellaneous:
3 ) ~'1<;;'
·
LiJtJ1?~C.1
or /~e Is
.
cetJslL'S
{o'lJe
'
5'('..7' V/ c 77 In S"
-.. " t
)
I
,
/5Y C1/ T<"e-e.- I::v' e/l;T ;:'{ //;U { ~ n-->1/tt.c/c 7~~<-1""/ 0C/c.. eT
7
_
() b ? (
Time
"8
r.
0'
,;C~
----T-im-e-- hours
-'-1_· have received the above property from the Wilmington Department of Police, which
hours. Date Time
was taken from me on the above date.
Case 1:04-cv-01350-GMS
Name Brown, Fred Bryant Waples Martin, Micheal Norman Banks Dale Stevenson Stanley King Wayne Thomas Brooks, Darren Bryan Selhorst Chapman, Tremaine Darius Johnson Dennis, Chris. Dixon, Kevin Dolan, Michael Drozdowski, Benard Flamer, Jerel Forrester, Chris Frank, Richard Glaze, Billy Godfrey, Clarence Hull, Robert Jimmy Lewis Lamar Trower Leonard Baylis Mathews, Willis Michael Chicosky Miller, Tyrone Minor, Samuel Murray, William Norris Durham Novello, William Quirico, Hector Roy Campbell Scott, Ronald Sheats, John Ternahan, John Williams, Willie Wright, Floyd Zickgraf, Steven
Document 267
Filed 04/23/2008
Page 42 of 50
Phase SNU Phase Report 8/28/06-9/3/06
2 2 2
Day Rec Only, No Evening Rec Day Rec Only, No Evening Rec Day Rec Only, No Evening Rec Day Rec Only, No Evening Rec
Ac3\
4 4 4 4 4 4 4 4 4 4 4 4 4 4 4 4 4 4 4 4 4 4 4 4 4 4 4 4 4 4 4 4 4 4
Community Leader News
Activity Leader
Community Leader/I Environmental
Case 1:04-cv-01350-GMS
Document 267
Filed 04/23/2008
Page 43 of 50
. Selhorst 1t Waples ,d Crosby artin, Micheal '.lorman Banks Lamar Trower Novello, William Sheats, John Brooks, Darren Brown, Fred Chapman, Tremaine Darius Johnson Dennis, Chris. Dixon, Kevin
Phase SNU Phase Report 8/7/06-8/13/06 Day Rec Only, No Evening Rec 2 Day Rec Only, No Evening Rec 2 Day Rec Only, No Evening Rec 2 Day Rec Only, No Evening Rec 2 Day Rec Only, No Evening Rec 2
3
Dolan, Michael
Drozdowski, Benard Flamer, Jerel Forrester, Chris Frank, Richard Glaze, Billy Godfrey, Clarence Hull, Robert
4
4
4
4
4
4
4
4
4
4
4
4
4
4
4
4
4
4
4
4
4
4
4
4
4
4
4
4
4
4
4
Community Leader News
,Jimmy Lewis Leonard Baylis Mathews, Willis
Michael Chicosky Miller, Tyrone Minor, Samuel Murray, William Norris Durham Quirico, Hector Roy Campbell Scott, Ronald
Activity Leader
Ternahan, John
Williams, Willie Wright, Floyd Zickgraf, Steven
Community Leader/I Environmental
Case 1:04-cv-01350-GMS
Document 267
Filed 04/23/2008
Page 44 of 50
Name Stevenson Dale Bridges, Travis Brophy Robert Chicosky Michael Godfrey Clarence Waples Bryan Baylis Leonard Blackburn John Brooks Darren Campbell Roy Chapman Tremayne Crosby, David Dennis Christopher Dickerson Louis Dixon Kevin Dolan Michael Durham Norris Flamer Jerel Glaze Billy Johnson Darius Miller Tyrone Minear Clayton Mitchell Jesse Murray William Nieves Luis Novello William Pierce Lyle Scott Ronald Williams Dana Williams Willie Zickgraf Steven
Phase
23-0 - SNU Phase Report 4/9/07 - 4/15/07
~ 3 3 3 3 3
4 4 4 4 4 4 4 4 4 4 4 4 4 4 4 4 4 4 4 4 4 4 4 4 4
Environmental Leader
Activity Leader Community Reporter/News
Case 1:04-cv-01350-GMS
I
Document 267
Filed 04/23/2008
Page 45 of 50
/
23DCLEANUP SCHEDULE
UPPER WILLIAM NOVELLO LEONARD BAYLIS LOUIS DICKERSON JEREL FLAMER MICHAEL DOLAN CLARENCE GODFREY DARREN BROOKS WILLIAM MURRAY DARIUS JOHNSON MICHAEL DOLAN WILLIAM NOVELLO CLAYTON MINEAR JIMMY LEWIS TYRONE MILLER KEVIN DIXON WILLIAM NOVELLO LEONARD BAYLIS LOUIS DICKERSON JEREL FLAMER JIMMY LEWIS CLARENCE GODFREY DARREN BROOKS WILLIAM MURRAY DARIUS JOHNSON MICHAEL DOLAN LOUIS DICKERSON CLAYTON MINEAR JIMMY LEWIS TYRONE MILLER KEVIN DIXON WILLIAM NOVELLO
MARCH
()7,
DATE
1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 9 10
11
12 13 14 15 16 17 18 19 20 21 22 23 24 25 26 27 28 29 30 31
Environmental Leader for MARCH John Blackburn LOWER LYLE PIERCE JESSIE MITCHELL RONALD SCOTT MICHAEL CHICOSKY ROY CAMPBELL DALE STEVENSON WILLIE WILLIAMS BILLY GLAZE TREMAYNE CHAPMAN NORRIS DURHAM BRYANT WAPLES LUIS NIEVES DANA WILLIAMS CHRISTOPHER DENNIS STEVEN ZICKGRAFT LYLE PIERCE JESSIE MITCHELL RONALD SCOTT MICHAEL CHICOSKY ROY CAMPBELL DALE STEVENSON WILLIE WILLIAMS BILLY GLAZE TREMAYNE CHAPMAN NORRIS DURHAM BRYANT WAPLES LUIS NIEVES DANA WILLIAMS CHRISTOPHER DENNIS
.T
~~
.A~
.l
~(c.JV\.
LYLE PIERCE
Participating in cleanup is considered a part of the Special Needs Unit Program. Each person is a part of the community and therefore should do their part to help keep the environment clean. *Ifyou choose not to help when it is your turn on the schedule, you will lose points, which will most likely affect your phase level. Acceptable excuses include being out for an appointment, visit, etc., or a valid sick call slip being submitted. Security staff will be given the schedule to know who to allow out during cleanup time. Staff will inform them of any substitutions for the day. *The Environmental Leader changes each month. They are to come out daily with those listed above to participate and lead the cleanup process.
'302 577 7849
PUBLIC DEFENDER WILM Case 1:04-cv-01350-GMS
Document 267
01 :00:07 p.m. 03-04-2008 Filed 04/23/2008 Page 46 of 50
2/3
PUBLIC DEFENDER OF THE STATE OF DELAWARE 900 N. KING STREET, SECOND FLOOR WILMINGTON, DELAWARE 19801
LAWRENCE M. SULLIVAN PUBLIC DEFENDER BRIAN J. BARTLEY CHIEF DEPUTY DAWN M. WILLIAMS ASSISTANT PUBLIC DEFENDER TELEPHONE (302) 577-6025 x 3011
March 3, 2008 The Honorable Alex J. Smalls Chief Judge Court of Common Pleas New Castle County Courthouse 500 N. King Street Wilmington, DE 19801
Re: State of Delaware v. Jimmy Lewis Case No. 0801012699
Dear Chief Judge Smalls: Our office represents Mr. Lewis on the above case currently pending in the Court of Corrunon Pleas. It was determined by Judge Welch, in agreement with myself and the State, that Mr. Lewis was in need of a psychiatric evaluation. He is presently being held at Delaware Correctional Center and the staff at DCC concur that he has mental health issues.
I
arn
Competency Lewis.
Lequesting Evaluation
Your Honor sign the enclosed Order for a at the Delaware Psychiatric Center for Mr. Your Honor has any questions or concerns
I am available if regarding this request.
./ t,1·'---__.- · ".
Michelle S. N Assistant Public MSN/mcg
Re~pectfullY s
Jl9
Case 1:04-cv-01350-GMS PUBLIC DEFENDER WllM
Document 267
01 :00: 17 p.m. Filed 04/23/2008
Page 47 of 50
Uj-U4-LUUO
IN THE COURT OF COMMON PLEAS FOR THE STATE OF DELAWARE IN AND FOR NEW CASTLE COUNTY
STATE OF DELAWARE v.
Case No. 0801012699
JIMMY LEWIS
Defendant
ORDEII
AND NOW,
TO WIT,
this
5b(
day of
A. D. ,
2008, hereby;
the
foregoing
having been heard and considered,
it is
ORDERED
that the defendant, Delaware Correctional a
Jimmy Lewis, Center to
be transferred the Delaware
from
the
Psychiatric' Center for
psychiatric and competency evaluation
to determine competency and obtain treatment for his own well being.
Date:
March 3, 2008
Case 1:04-cv-01350-GMS
Document 267
Filed 04/23/2008
Page 48 of 50
Page
1
COURT OF COMMON PLEAS CRIMINAL DOCKET ( as of 03/19/2008) State of Delaware v. JIMMY LEWIS State's Atty: , Esq. Defense Atty: DEFENDER PUBLIC , Esq.
DOB: 12/25/1966
AKA: EMMANUEL E ELDER
EMMANUEL E ELDER
Assigned Judge:
Charges:
Count 001 002 003 No. DUC# Crim.Action# MN08013012 MN08013013 MN08013014 Event Description DISORD CONDUCT
ASSAULT 3RD
ASSAULT 3RD
Judge Dispo. Dispo. Date
0801012699 0801012699 0801012699 Event Date
01/14/2008
CASE FILED ON 01/14/2008i ARREST DATE 01/11/2008
ARRAIGNMENT SCHEDULED FOR
SECURED BAIL-HELD 1,500.00
DEll1301001A MN08013012 DISORD CONDUCT MN08013013 DE1106110001 ASSAULT 3RD DE1106110001 MN08013014 ASSAULT 3RD 01/14/2008
ARRAIGNMENT SCHEDULED FOR 01/15/2008 AT 01:35 PM
SECURED BAIL-HELD 1,500.00
01/15/2008
DEFENDANT PLED NOT GUILTY AND DEMANDED JURY TRIAL.
SECURED BAIL-HELD 1,500.00
01/15/2008
JURY TRIAL SCHEDULED FOR 05/15/2008 AT 08:30 AM
02/27/2008
MOTION FOR PSYCHIATRIC EVALUATION SCHEDULED 3/14/2008
AT 08:30 AM
MOTION TO COMPEL DISCOVERY
03/14/2008 WELCH JOHN K.
MOTION WITHDRAWNi REQUESTED BY PUBLIC DEFENDER.
DISCOVERY RECEIVED.
*** END OF DOCKET LISTING AS OF
PRINTED BY: CCPKGOO
03/19/2008 ***
Case 1:04-cv-01350-GMS
Document 267
Filed 04/23/2008
Page 49 of 50
Page
COURT OF COMMON PLEAS CRIMINAL DOCKET ( as of 02/27/2008) State of Delaware v. JIMMY LEWIS State's Atty: , Esq. Defense Atty: DEFENDER PUBLIC, Esq.
1
DOB: 12/25/1966
AKA: EMMANUEL E ELDER
EMMANUEL E ELDER
Assigned Judge:
Charges:
Count 001 002 003 No. DUC# Crim.Action# MN08013012 MN08013013 MN08013014 Event Description DISORD CONDUCT
ASSAULT 3RD
ASSAULT 3RD
Judge Dispo. Dispo. Date
0801012699 0801012699 0801012699 Event Date
01/14/2008
CASE FILED ON 01/14/2008; ARREST DATE 01/11/2008
ARRAIGNMENT SCHEDULED FOR
SECURED BAIL-HELD 1,500.00
DEll1301001A DISORD CONDUCT MN08013012 DE1106110001 ASSAULT 3RD MN08013013 DE1106110001 MN08013014 ASSAULT 3RD 01/14/2008
ARRAIGNMENT SCHEDULED FOR 01/15/2008 AT 01:35 PM
SECURED BAIL-HELD 1,500.00
01/15/2008
DEFENDANT PLED NOT GUILTY AND DEMANDED JURY TRIAL.
SECURED BAIL-HELD 1,500.00
01/15/2008
JURY TRIAL SCHEDULED FOR 05/15/2008 AT 08:30 AM
*** END OF DOCKET LISTING AS OF
PRINTED BY: CCPKGOO
02/27/2008 ***
Case 1:04-cv-01350-GMS
Defenoant Name:
AKA;'
Document 267
Filed 04/23/2008
Judge:
Page 50 of 50
Pl A
treE:
Q
ID Number: Criminal Aftlon Number:
008:
6
(hClrge:
United States Free Forms
Canada Free Forms
United Kingdom Free Forms
Australia Free Forms