Free Motion for Attorney Fees - District Court of Arizona - Arizona

RAILWAY COMPANY Schrum v. BNSF
DATE 03/04/04 TIMEKEEPER PROFESSIONAL SERVICES Thorpe, William Review summons, complaint, letter L. from Mr. Hoferer to Mr. Wysoglad's office, memorandum from Mr. Newell about [REDACTED], and letter from Mr. Merritt about [REDACTED]. Rivera, Sal J. Memorandum to and from W. Thorpe regarding [REDACTED]. Rivera, Sal J. Draft and implement pretrial strategy. Rivera, Sal J. Review plaintiffs' complaint (.1); telephone conference with plaintiff's counsel regarding status of lawsuit and refiling of lawsuit (.1). Murphy, Ruth Telephone conferences with Mr. Brugess re status of transfer of case to Arizona (.2); telephone conference with Maricopa County Superior Court re status of filing of complaint (.2). Thorpe, William Review email about [REDACTED] L. and email to R. Murphy about [REDACTED]. Rivera, Sal J. Review memorandum regarding [REDACTED]. Houston, Charles Telephone conferences with BNSF's counsel of record in this matter, J. Newell of the Wysoglad firm in Illinois, about [REDACTED] (.4); prepare application for substitution of counsel in this matter and email [REDACTED] (1.2). Houston, Charles Telephone conference with J. Newell re: [REDACTED] (.1); edit same (.2). Houston, Charles Telephone conference with S. Rhoden re: [REDACTED] (.1); edit consent form and email [REDACTED] (.2). TIME 0.50 AMOUNT 90.00

03/17/04 03/18/04 03/22/04

0.10 0.20 0.20

18.00 36.00 36.00

03/30/04

0.40

46.00

03/30/04

0.10

18.00

03/30/04 04/08/04

0.10 1.60

18.00 224.00

04/09/04

0.30

42.00

04/12/04

0.30

42.00

1
1928756.1/83510.398

Case 2:04-cv-00619-RCB

Document 132-4

Filed 06/22/2007

Page 1 of 168

04/13/04

04/14/04

04/15/04

04/21/04

04/25/04 04/28/04

04/29/04

05/06/04

Houston, Charles Review plaintiff's complaint and begin preparing BNSF's answer (2.4); prepare BNSF's application for substitution of counsel and proposed order (.7). Houston, Charles Edit and file Fennemore Craig's application for substitution of counsel (.6); prepare letter to counsel informing them that application for substitution of counsel has been filed (.2). Houston, Charles Review district court PACER website to determine [REDACTED] (.2). Houston, Charles Review order from Court confirming substitution of Fennemore Craig as counsel for BNSF in this matter (.1); prepare letter to counsel informing them of the substitution and requesting that all correspondence and pleadings be directed to B. Thorpe (.3). Houston, Charles Work on BNSF's answer. Houston, Charles Review, edit and file BNSF's Answer (2.6); review interrogatories and requests for production served by plaintiffs (.6); prepare interrogatories and requests for production to be served by BNSF on plaintiff (1.6); prepare letter to opposing counsel informing him that BNSF's time for responding to plaintiffs' discovery will not begin to run until the parties have conferred as required by Fed. R. Civ. P. 26(d) (.3). Thorpe, William Review substitution of counsel L. approved by Judge Broomfield and letter to adverse counsel about same. Murphy, Ruth Review and analyze file and calendar deadlines for responses to plaintiff's discovery, filing date for joint report and scheduling conference with Judge Broomfield (.2); prepare memo re [REDACTED] (.1).

3.10

434.00

0.80

112.00

0.40

56.00

0.40

56.00

0.10 5.10

14.00 714.00

0.10

18.00

0.30

34.50

2
1928756.1/83510.398

Case 2:04-cv-00619-RCB

Document 132-4

Filed 06/22/2007

Page 2 of 168

05/06/04

05/06/04

05/11/04

05/12/04

05/14/04 05/17/04

05/20/04 05/20/04

05/26/04 05/26/04

Houston, Charles Review website of [REDACTED] (.4); respond to S. Rivera's email regarding [REDACTED] (.3). Rivera, Sal J. Review comprehensive minute entry setting forth pretrial deadlines (.1); memorandum regarding same (.1); begin outlining [REDACTED] (.1). Houston, Charles Email responding to plaintiff's counsel George Brugess' email regarding position on BNSF's answer relating to attorneys' fees, declining his request that we depose plaintiff the same week of the parties' Rule 16 scheduling conference, and setting a date for the parties' Rule 26(f) discovery conference (.3); email to S. Rivera and B. Thorpe [REDACTED] (.2). Thorpe, William Review lengthy order from court L. about preparation of case management order. Rivera, Sal J. Prepare discovery plan. Thorpe, William Review plaintiff's request for L. production of documents and interrogatories (.2); review letter to plaintiff's counsel about comprehensive pretrial conference requirement and impact on discovery (.1). Thorpe, William Memorandum to C. Houston about L. [REDACTED]. Houston, Charles Telephone conference with George Brugess' office re: the parties' scheduled 26(f) conference. Houston, Charles Prepare for tomorrow's Rule 26(f) conference with plaintiff's counsel. Thorpe, William Review order from Judge L. Broomfield about status conference (.1); review voice mail from CNA adjuster about claim and memorandum to S. Rivera about [REDACTED] (.1).

0.70

98.00

0.30

54.00

0.50

70.00

0.10

18.00

0.20 0.30

36.00 54.00

0.20 0.20

36.00 28.00

0.60 0.20

84.00 36.00

3
1928756.1/83510.398

Case 2:04-cv-00619-RCB

Document 132-4

Filed 06/22/2007

Page 3 of 168

05/27/04

06/03/04 06/04/04

06/07/04

06/07/04 06/14/04

06/17/04 06/17/04

06/18/04

06/21/04

06/23/04

Houston, Charles Prepare for telephonic Rule 26(f) conference with plaintiff's counsel George Brugess (1.0); participate in telephonic Rule 26(f) conference setting discovery schedule (.7); review drafts of proposed scheduling order and discovery deadlines (.4). Rivera, Sal J. Draft memorandum regarding [REDACTED]. Murphy, Ruth Review court's minute rescheduling the Rule 16 Scheduling Conference and calendar same (.1). Houston, Charles Review and analyze interrogatories and requests for production propounded by plaintiffs (.2); review 6/2/04 minute entry from court rescheduling parties Rule 16 conference (.1). Rivera, Sal J. Work on discovery responses. Houston, Charles Review and edit parties' Joint Scheduling Report and proposed Scheduling Order (.6); review BNSF claims file to [REDACTED] (.4). Houston, Charles Review claims file to determine facts surrounding [REDACTED]. Rivera, Sal J. Telephone conference with adjuster for Chemical Lime regarding status of litigation and preliminary information known about same (.1); memorandum to file regarding [REDACTED] (.1); review memorandum from client regarding [REDACTED] (.1). Houston, Charles Revise and edit parties' proposed scheduling order and joint report (.5); memorandum re: [REDACTED] (.1); review plaintiff's requests for production and interrogatories and begin preparing responses thereto (.6). Rivera, Sal J. Draft and revise non-uniform interrogatories and requests for production of documents. Houston, Charles Telephone conference with opposing counsel re: plaintiff's motion to allow plaintiff's attorney to appear telephonically (.2). 4

2.10

294.00

0.30 0.10

54.00 11.50

0.30

42.00

0.20 1.00

36.00 140.00

1.40 0.30

196.00 54.00

1.20

168.00

0.30

54.00

0.20

28.00

1928756.1/83510.398

Case 2:04-cv-00619-RCB

Document 132-4

Filed 06/22/2007

Page 4 of 168

06/25/04

Murphy, Ruth

06/30/04 06/30/04 07/01/04 07/06/04 07/07/04 07/07/04 07/08/04

Thorpe, William L. Houston, Charles Rivera, Sal J. Murphy, Ruth Rivera, Sal J. Houston, Charles Thorpe, William L. Houston, Charles

07/12/04

07/13/04 07/14/04

Rivera, Sal J. Houston, Charles

07/16/04 07/19/04

Thorpe, William L. Houston, Charles

Review plaintiff's motion to withdraw appearances of attorneys and calendar deadline for our response. Work on proposed case management order and report to Court. Edit and file Joint Report and Proposed Scheduling Order. Draft and review memorandum [REDACTED]. Prepare memo noting upcoming deadlines and tasks. Draft discovery requests and outline discovery strategy. Analyze case status and determine strategy for going forward. Review notice to withdraw filed by several members of Hoey and Farina (.1). Telephone conferences with G. Brugess re: parties' agreed-upon discovery schedule and Rule 26(f) report (.3); prepare for and attend this afternoon's scheduling conference before Judge Broomfield (2.4). Work on discovery. Draft interrogatories, requests for production and requests for admissions (2.4); draft BNSF's initial disclosure statement (2.3). Review order from court following scheduling conference. Review plaintiff's initial disclosure statement and attached documents (.6); prepare BNSF's initial disclosure statement (3.0); review correspondence from plaintiff's attorney indicating that plaintiff wishes to return to work (.1); draft letter to BNSF Medical and Environmental Health Manager R. Folley enclosing [REDACTED] (.1); review docket entry granting plaintiff's motion to allow withdrawal of plaintiff's counsel (.1).

0.10

11.50

0.70 0.50 0.10 0.10 0.30 0.30 0.10

126.00 70.00 18.00 11.50 54.00 42.00 18.00

2.70

378.00

0.10 4.70

18.00 658.00

0.20 3.90

36.00 546.00

5
1928756.1/83510.398

Case 2:04-cv-00619-RCB

Document 132-4

Filed 06/22/2007

Page 5 of 168

07/20/04 07/23/04 07/26/04 07/27/04

07/28/04 07/28/04 07/28/04 07/28/04 07/29/04 07/30/04 08/05/04 08/05/04

08/06/04

08/06/04 08/09/04 08/09/04 08/20/04

Thorpe, William Review correspondence concerning L. [REDACTED]. Houston, Charles Prepare BNSF's initial disclosure statement. Houston, Charles Prepare BNSF's initial disclosure statement. Murphy, Ruth Review court's order, calendar deadlines and prepare memo regarding deadlines. Murphy, Ruth Prepare chart depicting tasks to do. Rivera, Sal J. Communicate with R. Folley regarding [REDACTED]. Thorpe, William Memorandum to C. Houston L. outlining [REDACTED]. Houston, Charles Prepare BNSF's initial disclosure statement (4.5). Houston, Charles Prepare BNSF's initial disclosure statement (2.0); [REDACTED] (.5). Houston, Charles Revise BNSF's initial disclosure statement (.4). Houston, Charles Review and edit BNSF's initial disclosure statement. Thorpe, William Study plaintiff's initial disclosure L. statement and affiliated documents, including statements from supporting witnesses, medical records, correspondence, transcript of formal investigation, material data safety sheets, reports concerning air quality violations at Chem Lime plant served by BNSF, and other materials. Houston, Charles Review documents to be disclosed with BNSF's disclosure statement for privilege. Murphy, Ruth Review claims file and begin preparing case summary. Rivera, Sal J. Work on disclosure statement. Murphy, Ruth Complete review of file and preparation of case summary. Houston, Charles Review documents to be disclosed with BNSF's initial disclosure statement for privilege.

0.20 3.50 1.50 0.80

36.00 490.00 210.00 92.00

0.10 0.30 0.30 4.50 2.50 0.40 0.50 1.60

11.50 54.00 54.00 630.00 350.00 56.00 70.00 288.00

1.40

196.00

2.30 0.10 0.50 1.40

264.50 18.00 57.50 196.00

6
1928756.1/83510.398

Case 2:04-cv-00619-RCB

Document 132-4

Filed 06/22/2007

Page 6 of 168

08/23/04

08/23/04

08/23/04

08/24/04

08/24/04 08/24/04

08/25/04 08/25/04

08/27/04

08/27/04

08/27/04

08/28/04

Houston, Charles Edit BNSF's initial disclosure statement (1.3); review documents to be disclosed with BNSF's initial disclosure statement for privilege (3.4). Rivera, Sal J. Draft and revise disclosure statement and review documents to be disclosed with same. Murphy, Ruth Review file re status of discovery, disclosure and upcoming deadlines and prepare memo re same. Houston, Charles Edit BNSF's initial disclosure statement to incorporate S. Rivera's edits and suggestions (1.5); review documents contained in BNSF claims file and assess applicability of attorney-client and/or work-product privileges (2.5). Rivera, Sal J. Work on disclosure statement. Thorpe, William Review materials concerning L. discovery status and direct further inquiry about [REDACTED]. Murphy, Ruth Prepare chart depicting tasks to do. Houston, Charles Review documents to be disclosed with BNSF's initial disclosure statement for privilege. Murphy, Ruth Review claims file and plaintiff's disclosure statement for medical providers and prepare HIPAAcompliant medical authorizations (1.5); prepare medical records chart (.2). Houston, Charles Review documents to be disclosed with BNSF's initial disclosure statement for privilege. Rivera, Sal J. Work on disclosure statement (.5); review and analyze plaintiff's disclosure statement and documents attached to same (.5); memorandum regarding [REDACTED] (.2); memorandum regarding [REDACTED] (.1); memorandum regarding [REDACTED] (.1); draft memorandum regarding [REDACTED] (.1). Thorpe, William Review and respond to email from S. L. Rivera about [REDACTED]. 7

4.70

658.00

1.50

270.00

0.20

23.00

4.00

560.00

0.30 0.20

54.00 36.00

0.20 2.30

23.00 322.00

1.70

195.50

2.40

336.00

1.50

270.00

0.10

18.00

1928756.1/83510.398

Case 2:04-cv-00619-RCB

Document 132-4

Filed 06/22/2007

Page 7 of 168

08/30/04

Murphy, Ruth

08/30/04

Houston, Charles

08/30/04 08/31/04 09/01/04

Rivera, Sal J. Murphy, Ruth Houston, Charles

09/07/04

Houston, Charles

09/08/04

Houston, Charles

09/09/04 09/09/04

Thorpe, William L. Houston, Charles

09/10/04

Thorpe, William L.

09/10/04

Houston, Charles

09/12/04

Thorpe, William L.

Prepare correspondence to Mr. Brugess enclosing medical authorizations for plaintiff's signature (.2); update medical records chart (.1). Edit and finalize BNSF's initial disclosure statement (2.5); brief telephone conference with S. Rhoden [REDACTED] (.1). Draft and revise memoranda regarding [REDACTED]. Telephone conference with [REDACTED]. Teleph conference with S. Rhoden re: [REDACTED] (.2); telephone conference with Jamie Johnson of BNSF's [REDACTED] (.2). Telephone conference with R. Shelton re: [REDACTED] (.1); review lease between ATSF and Flintkote (.2); review [REDACTED] (.1). Telephone conferences with Kevin Burrin of BNSF's [REDACTED] (.4); review spreadsheet from BNSF showing current and past contracts (.2). Analyse issues relating to [REDACTED] (.2). Research requirements to [REDACTED] (2.5); analyze [REDACTED] (.5); prepare outline of motion to amend complaint [REDACTED] (.7). Review and revise proposed amended complaint and third party complaint naming Lime Company as additional defendant and motion for leave to amend (.6); review and comment upon [REDACTED] (.2). Draft motion to amend complaint to add Chemical Lime as third party defendant. Study BNSF's initial Rule 26 disclosure statement and documents produced with it.

0.30

34.50

2.60

364.00

0.40 0.20 0.40

72.00 23.00 56.00

0.40

56.00

0.60

84.00

0.20 3.70

36.00 518.00

0.80

144.00

7.50

1050.00

0.60

108.00

8
1928756.1/83510.398

Case 2:04-cv-00619-RCB

Document 132-4

Filed 06/22/2007

Page 8 of 168

09/14/04

Murphy, Ruth

09/15/04 09/16/04

09/18/04 09/20/04 09/21/04 09/22/04

09/29/04 09/30/04 10/01/04 10/01/04 10/01/04

10/01/04 10/04/04

10/04/04 10/05/04 10/05/04

10/05/04

Review BNSF's answer and thirdparty complaint (.2); update case summary (.1). Rivera, Sal J. Draft and review memorandum regarding [REDACTED]. Rivera, Sal J. Investigate alleged inhalation issues involved in lawsuit and [REDACTED]. Thorpe, William Memorandum to C. Houston about L. [REDACTED]. Houston, Charles Respond to email from B. Thorpe inquiring re: [REDACTED]. Houston, Charles Analyze case status and determine [REDACTED]. Thorpe, William Review and respond to memorandum from D. Minore about L. [REDACTED]. Murphy, Ruth Organize medical records for medical chronology. Sloan, Walter Review medical records and prepare initial medical chronology(.6) Murphy, Ruth Telephone conferences with [REDACTED]. Sloan, Walter Continue analysis of medical records and add to chronology (4.2). Rivera, Sal J. Background investigation into [REDACTED] (.3); draft memorandum regarding [REDACTED] (.1). Thorpe, William Telephone conference with Mr. L. Shelton about [REDACTED] (.2). Murphy, Ruth Review file re status and prepare memo re same (.2); meet with [REDACTED] (.6). Rivera, Sal J. Investigate issues related to [REDACTED]. Thorpe, William Review issues relating to L. [REDACTED]. Sloan, Walter Complete review of medical records and updating medical chronology (1.5). Rivera, Sal J. Review file and draft memorandum regarding [REDACTED] (.3).

0.30

34.50

0.20 0.60

36.00 108.00

0.10 0.10 0.30 0.10

18.00 14.00 42.00 18.00

0.20 0.60 0.40 4.20 0.40

23.00 69.00 46.00 483.00 72.00

0.20 0.80

36.00 92.00

0.20 0.40 1.50

36.00 72.00 172.50

0.30

54.00

9
1928756.1/83510.398

Case 2:04-cv-00619-RCB

Document 132-4

Filed 06/22/2007

Page 9 of 168

10/06/04

Murphy, Ruth

10/06/04 10/09/04

Thorpe, William L. Thorpe, William L. Rivera, Sal J.

10/20/04

10/21/04

Rivera, Sal J.

10/22/04 10/22/04

Thorpe, William L. Murphy, Ruth

Prepare correspondence to [REDACTED] (.1); prepare followup letter to Mr. Brugess re providing signed medical authorizations and enclose another set of authorizations (.2); update medical records chart (.1). Telephone conference with Messrs. [REDACTED] (.2). Study report and materials obtained during [REDACTED] and other pertinent matters (.6). Work on written discovery requests (.3); review and analyze plaintiff's medical records (.8); research regarding [REDACTED] (.5). Review and analyze medical records (1.8); memorandum regarding [REDACTED] (.1). Memorandum about [REDACTED].

0.40

46.00

0.20 0.60

36.00 108.00

1.60

288.00

1.90

342.00

0.20 0.20

36.00 23.00

10/22/04

10/22/04 10/25/04

10/27/04

10/29/04 11/01/04

Review file status of discovery, disclosure and upcoming deadline and prepare memo re same. Rivera, Sal J. Review and analyze plaintiff's medical records (.5); memorandum [REDACTED] (.1); communicate with opposing counsel regarding same (.1); memorandum regarding [REDACTED] (.1). Houston, Charles Draft discovery requests. Houston, Charles Prepare BNSF's discovery responses (.4); revise BNSF's interrogatories, requests for production and requests for admission (.7). Houston, Charles Revise BNSF's interrogatories, requests for production and requests for admission. Rivera, Sal J. Draft discovery requests. Rivera, Sal J. Draft and revise written requests for production of documents, nonuniform interrogatories and requests for admissions (.3); review results of [REDACTED] (.2); review pleadings related to criminal charges filed against plaintiff. (.3).

0.80

144.00

0.20 1.10

28.00 154.00

2.00

280.00

0.80 0.80

144.00 144.00

10
1928756.1/83510.398

Case 2:04-cv-00619-RCB

Document 132-4

Filed 06/22/2007

Page 10 of 168

11/02/04

Murphy, Ruth

11/03/04

11/10/04 11/10/04 11/11/04 11/11/04

11/15/04 11/16/04

11/16/04

11/16/04

11/17/04 11/18/04

11/23/04

11/24/04 11/29/04

Review correspondence from Mr. Brugess enclosing plaintiff's medical authorizations (.1); update medical records chart (.1). Houston, Charles Prepare and file Proposed Order granting leave to amend BNSF's answer to assert third party claim against Chemical Lime. Murphy, Ruth Review file re [REDACTED] and prepare memo re same. Thorpe, William Review minute entry granting BNSF L. leave to file third party complaint. Thorpe, William Memorandum to C. Houston about L. [REDACTED] (.2). Rivera, Sal J. Memorandum regarding [REDACTED] (.2); memorandum regarding [REDACTED] (.1). Murphy, Ruth Review file re [REDACTED]. Murphy, Ruth Update case summary re bates number index and criminal charges against plaintiff. Rawlinson, Memo from S. Rivera regarding Melissa [REDACTED] (.1); memo from R. Murphy regarding [REDACTED] (.1). Rivera, Sal J. Draft memorandum regarding [REDACTED] (.2); draft discovery requests (.3); communicate with client regarding [REDACTED] (.1). Rawlinson, Draft discovery responses (.4). Melissa Rawlinson, Draft discovery responses (.8); Melissa review and edit discovery requests to plaintiff (.3). Rivera, Sal J. Draft and revise requests for admissions and non-uniform interrogatories (.6); draft memorandum regarding [REDACTED] (.3). Rivera, Sal J. Draft discovery requests. Rawlinson, Review and analyze plaintiffs' Melissa discovery requests.

0.20

23.00

0.20

28.00

0.30 0.10 0.20 0.30

34.50 18.00 36.00 54.00

0.60 0.30

69.00 34.50

0.20

28.00

0.60

108.00

0.40 1.10

56.00 154.00

0.90

162.00

0.20 0.50

36.00 70.00

11
1928756.1/83510.398

Case 2:04-cv-00619-RCB

Document 132-4

Filed 06/22/2007

Page 11 of 168

11/30/04

Rawlinson, Melissa

11/30/04

Murphy, Ruth

11/30/04 12/01/04 12/01/04 12/01/04 12/01/04

Rivera, Sal J. Murphy, Ruth Rawlinson, Melissa Rawlinson, Melissa Rivera, Sal J.

12/01/04

Rivera, Sal J.

12/02/04

Rawlinson, Melissa

12/02/04

Rivera, Sal J.

12/03/04

Thorpe, William L.

Draft responses to plaintiff's request for production and interrogatories (2.6); voice mail message for George Brugess regarding medical authorizations (.1); voice mail for Steve Rhoden regarding [REDACTED] (.1); voice mail message for Rick Folley regarding [REDACTED] (.1) Review file re status of discovery, disclosure and upcoming deadlines and prepare memo re [REDACTED]. Work on discovery responses (.4); draft discovery requests (.4). Prepare chart depicting outstanding tasks. Conference with S. Rhoden regarding [REDACTED]. Memoranda to/from S. Rivera, B. Thorpe regarding [REDACTED]. Memorandum regarding [REDACTED] (.3); analyze issues related to same (.3). Draft responses to plaintiff's discovery (.1); draft discovery requests (.1); memorandum regarding [REDACTED] (.1); investigate whether [REDACTED] (.1); review [REDACTED] (.2). Conversation with George Brugess regarding medical authorizations (.2); memorandum S. Rivera regarding [REDACTED] (.2). Work on discovery responses; analyze [REDACTED] (.8); identify possible [REDACTED] (.3); review memorandum [REDACTED] (.1); memorandum regarding [REDACTED] (.1). Review email concerning Mr. Rhoden's [REDACTED].

2.90

406.00

0.20

23.00

0.80 0.20 0.50 0.30 0.60

144.00 23.00 70.00 42.00 108.00

0.60

108.00

0.40

56.00

1.30

234.00

0.10

18.00

12
1928756.1/83510.398

Case 2:04-cv-00619-RCB

Document 132-4

Filed 06/22/2007

Page 12 of 168

12/03/04

Rawlinson, Melissa

12/03/04

Rivera, Sal J.

12/06/04

Rivera, Sal J.

12/07/04

Rawlinson, Melissa

12/07/04

Rivera, Sal J.

Draft letter to G. Brugess regarding medical authorizations (.2); communiation with Bob Attridge regarding [REDACTED] (.1); communiation with Rick Folley (.1); telephone conversation with Steve Rhoden (.2); edit discovery responses (1.6); telephone conversation with Bob Attridge regarding [REDACTED] (.2); telephone conversation with Rick Folley regarding [REDACTED] (.2); review file from Rick Folley (.2); memo to R. Murphy regarding [REDACTED] (.1). Draft letter to opposing counsel regarding possible settlement offer and medical authorizations (.3); review and analyze conditions purportedly imposed by plaintiff on use of medical authorizations (.2); draft letter to opposing counsel regarding plaintiff's experts and depositions of same (.2); review memorandum regarding [REDACTED] (.2). Review and analyze plaintiff's medical records and medical treatment chronology and analyze issues related to same (1.7); draft correspondence regarding expert deposition (.2); background research regarding [REDACTED] (.5); draft letter regarding plaintiff's deposition (.2); review detailed memorandum [REDACTED] (.3); draft additional discovery requests (.6). Edit discovery responses (.3); telephone conversation with [REDACTED], BNSF, regarding [REDACTED] (.1); email to [REDACTED] (.1); telephone conversation with [REDACTED] (.2). Memorandum regarding [REDACTED].

2.90

406.00

0.90

162.00

3.50

630.00

0.70

98.00

0.30

54.00

13
1928756.1/83510.398

Case 2:04-cv-00619-RCB

Document 132-4

Filed 06/22/2007

Page 13 of 168

12/08/04 12/08/04 12/09/04

Rawlinson, Melissa Rivera, Sal J. Murphy, Ruth

12/09/04

Rawlinson, Melissa

12/09/04

Rivera, Sal J.

12/10/04

Murphy, Ruth

12/10/04

Rawlinson, Melissa Rivera, Sal J.

12/10/04

12/13/04

Murphy, Ruth

12/13/04

Rawlinson, Melissa

Review letter regarding expert deposition dates. Review and analyze plaintiff's medical records. Review file from Rick Folley and redact privileged material and bates label for production (.8); prepare letters to health care providers enclosing authorizations for records (.5); update medical records chart (.1). Memorandum to R. Murphy regarding [REDACTED] (.1); memorandum to S. Rivera regarding [REDACTED] (.1); memorandum to S. Rivera regarding [REDACTED] (.2); edit discovery responses (.7); draft letter to plaintiff's counsel enclosing discovery responses (.3). Draft and revise discovery responses and investigation issues related to same. Prepare subpoena duces tecum and letters to custodians of records for medical records to Mayo Clinic, Mayo Clinic Hospital and Dr. Richard Riedy (.7); update medical records chart and calendar date due date for responses to subpoenas duces tecum (.2). Conversation with [REDACTED] (.1); review fax from [REDACTED] (.1). Draft and revise discovery requests (.4); draft and revise third party complaint (.6). Final subpoenas duces tecum to Mayo Clinic, Mayo Hospital and Dr. Reidy. Memo from R. Murphy regarding [REDACTED] (.1); review subpoenas (.1); review seniority roster information from Steve Rhoden (.1).

0.10 0.30 1.40

14.00 54.00 161.00

1.40

196.00

0.50

90.00

0.90

103.50

0.20

28.00

1.00

180.00

0.20

23.00

0.30

42.00

14
1928756.1/83510.398

Case 2:04-cv-00619-RCB

Document 132-4

Filed 06/22/2007

Page 14 of 168

12/13/04

Rivera, Sal J.

12/14/04

Rivera, Sal J.

12/15/04

Murphy, Ruth

12/15/04

Rawlinson, Melissa

12/15/04

Rivera, Sal J.

12/16/04

Thorpe, William L.

Review correspondence from opposing counsel regarding various matters (.1); review communications and documents related to vocational rehabilitation issues (.4). Review letter from opposing counsel regarding deposition of plaintiff's liability expert (.1); draft letter to opposing counsel regarding same (.3); review requirements for adequate disclosure of expert opinions to identify deficiencies with plaintiff's disclosure (.3). Review file re [REDACTED] prepare memo re same (.2); review plaintiff's expert's report, curriculum vitae and list of testimony (.3); update case summary (.1). Memo to R. Murphy regarding [REDACTED] (.1); memo to S. Rivera regarding [REDACTED] (.1); review letter from George Brugess regarding expert report;(.1) memorandum from S. Rivera regarding [REDACTED] (.1). Review and analyze further correspondence from opposing counsel (.2); legal research related to [REDACTED] (.4); review and analyze [REDACTED] (.8); identify [REDACTED] (.4); draft memorandum [REDACTED] (.4); review plaintiffs' medical records and analyze plaintiffs' legal theories (.4); work on third party complaint and memorandum regarding [REDACTED] (.2). Memorandum to R. Murphy about [REDACTED] (.1); memorandum to S. Rivera about [REDACTED] (.2); review report prepared by plaintiff's liability witness and [REDACTED] (.5).

0.50

90.00

0.70

126.00

0.60

69.00

0.60

84.00

2.80

504.00

0.80

144.00

15
1928756.1/83510.398

Case 2:04-cv-00619-RCB

Document 132-4

Filed 06/22/2007

Page 15 of 168

12/16/04

Rawlinson, Melissa

12/16/04

Murphy, Ruth

12/16/04

Rivera, Sal J.

12/17/04

Thorpe, William L. Rawlinson, Melissa Rawlinson, Melissa

12/17/04

12/19/04

Memoranda to/from W. Thorpe, S. Rivera regarding [REDACTED] (.4); memo to Ruth Murphy regarding [REDACTED] (.2); memorandum to R. Murphy, W. Thorpe, and S. Rivera regarding [REDACTED] (.2); memorandum from Sal Rivera regarding [REDACTED] (.1); memo to/from S. Rivera regarding [REDACTED] (.2). Prepare subpoena duces tecum to plaintiff's expert Frank Burg (.3); prepare correspondence to Mr. G. Brugess re accepting subpoena duces tecum on Mr. Burg (.2); prepare chart depicting tasks to do (.3); review correspondence from United Health Care re plaintiff's medical expenses (.2). Draft letter to R. Attridge regarding [REDACTED] (.2); draft letter to L. Robbins regarding [REDACTED] (.2); revise letter to opposing counsel (.3); draft and revise responses to non-uniform interrogatories and requests for production of documents (1.4); review and analyze documents in BNSF's vocational rehabilitation file (.8); draft memorandum [REDACTED] (.4); draft memorandum regarding [REDACTED] (.3); memorandum regarding [REDACTED] (.2); review memorandum [REDACTED] (.1). Review memorandum and attachments from M. Rawlinson about [REDACTED] (.2). Memo from S. Rivera regarding [REDACTED] (.2); edit discovery responses (.5). Review expert disclosure statement.

1.10

154.00

1.00

115.00

3.90

702.00

0.20

36.00

0.70

98.00

0.30

42.00

16
1928756.1/83510.398

Case 2:04-cv-00619-RCB

Document 132-4

Filed 06/22/2007

Page 16 of 168

12/20/04

Rawlinson, Melissa

12/20/04

Rivera, Sal J.

12/21/04

Murphy, Ruth

12/21/04

Rawlinson, Melissa

12/21/04

Rivera, Sal J.

12/22/04 12/23/04

Thorpe, William L. Murphy, Ruth

Prepare documents for production with responses to plaintiff's discovery requests (.3); edit discovery responses (1.5); telephone conversation with Rick Folley regarding [REDACTED] (.2). Review documents from [REDACTED] (.5); review documents from client and memorandum [REDACTED] (.4). Receive medical records from Desert Pulmonology, Inc. and Mayo Clinic and update medical records chart (.2); bates label medical records for production to plaintiff (.3); prepare 1st supplemental disclosure statement and notice of service of same (.5); update case summary re bates number index (.2); prepare request for disbursement for payment of medical records from Desert Pulmonology (.1); assist with compiling documents to produce to plaintiff in response to discovery request (.2). Memo to R. Murphy regarding [REDACTED] (.1); edit discovery responses (.4); edit letter to G. Brugess enclosing discovery responses; (.1); memo from S. Rivera regarding [REDACTED] (.1); edit first supplemental disclosure statement (.1); memo from S. Rivera regarding [REDACTED] (.1). Draft discovery responses (.2); draft third party complaint (.2); draft letter to opposing counsel regarding issues with plaintiff's disclosure statement (.2); memorandum regarding [REDACTED] (.2). Additional review of materials provided [REDACTED] (.5). Prepare correspondence to Desert Pulmonology enclosing payment for copies of medical records and update medical records chart. 17

2.00

280.00

0.90

162.00

1.50

172.50

0.90

126.00

0.80

144.00

0.50 0.20

90.00 23.00

1928756.1/83510.398

Case 2:04-cv-00619-RCB

Document 132-4

Filed 06/22/2007

Page 17 of 168

12/23/04

Murphy, Ruth

12/28/04

Murphy, Ruth

12/29/04

Thorpe, William L. Murphy, Ruth

12/29/04

01/01/05

Rawlinson, Melissa

01/03/05

Thorpe, William L.

01/03/05

Murphy, Ruth

Receive plaintiff's radiographic films from Mayo Clinic and update medical records chart. Telephone conferences with Dr. Reidy's office re providing plaintiff's medical records (.2); review medical records from Dr. Reidy and update medical records chart (.2); update medical record chronology (1.5). Review revised medical chronology relating to plaintiff's [REDACTED] (.5). Prepare 2nd supplemental disclosure statement, notice of service and organize attachments (.8); prepare medical expense summary (.3); receive and review medical records from Charles Lindsay, DO and update medical records chart (.1); update medical records chronology (3.0). Review and edit second supplemental disclosure statement (.1); memo to/from R. Murphy regarding [REDACTED] (.1); review Schrum updated medical chronology (.1); draft letter to plaintiff's counsel regarding expert report (.1). Review and revise letter to plaintiff's counsel about return to work issues and complying with MEH requests (.1). Finalize 2nd supplemental disclosure statement for service and update medical records chart and case summary (.2); work on scheduling plaintiff's expert witness deposition (.1).

0.10

11.50

1.90

218.50

0.50

90.00

4.20

483.00

0.40

56.00

0.10

18.00

0.30

37.50

18
1928756.1/83510.398

Case 2:04-cv-00619-RCB

Document 132-4

Filed 06/22/2007

Page 18 of 168

01/03/05

Rawlinson, Melissa

01/03/05

Rivera, Sal J.

01/04/05

Thorpe, William L. Rawlinson, Melissa

01/04/05

01/04/05

Rivera, Sal J.

01/05/05

Murphy, Ruth

Draft letter to Brugess regarding insufficiency of expert report (.2); memo from S. Rivera regarding [REDACTED] (.1); memo from S. Rivera regarding [REDACTED] (.1); memo from R. Murphy regarding [REDACTED] (.1); memo to S. Rivera regarding [REDACTED] (.1); email from S. Rivera regarding [REDACTED] (.1). Draft supplemental disclosure statement and review information to be disclosed with same (.3); memorandum regarding [REDACTED] (.2); revise subpoena duces tecum to same (.1); revise letter to opposing counsel regarding deposition (.2); revise letter to opposing counsel documenting BNSF's efforts to help plaintiff return to work (.3); additional research regarding [REDACTED] (.5); communicate with [REDACTED] (.3); draft [REDACTED] (.4). Review subpoena duces tecum issued to one of plaintiff's experts, Frank Burg (.1). Memo from S. Rivera regarding [REDACTED] (.1); memo to/from S. Rivera regarding [REDACTED] (.2); edit letter to plaintiff's counsel regarding plaintiff's return to work (.1); edit letter to G. Brugess regarding expert report of Frank Burg (.6). Draft deposition questions for plaintiffs' expert (.6); draft memorandum regarding [REDACTED] (.1). Work on scheduling deposition of plaintiff's expert Frank Burg (.5); telephone conference with Dr. Fernando's office re consulting on matter (.2).

0.70

98.00

2.30

414.00

0.10

18.00

1.00

140.00

0.70

126.00

0.70

87.50

19
1928756.1/83510.398

Case 2:04-cv-00619-RCB

Document 132-4

Filed 06/22/2007

Page 19 of 168

01/05/05 01/05/05 01/05/05 01/06/05

Thorpe, William L. Rawlinson, Melissa Rivera, Sal J. Murphy, Ruth

01/06/05 01/06/05

Rawlinson, Melissa Rivera, Sal J.

01/07/05

Murphy, Ruth

01/07/05

Rawlinson, Melissa

01/07/05

Rivera, Sal J.

01/09/05

Thorpe, William L.

Memorandum from S. Rivera about [REDACTED]. Memo from R. Murphy regarding expert deposition. Draft and review memoranda regarding [REDACTED]. Work on scheduling deposition of plaintiff's expert witness Frank Burg (.4); telephone conferences with Mr. M. Goodman at BNSF Claims re [REDACTED] (.2); perform internet research re [REDACTED] (.3); leave message for attorney Roland Miller re [REDACTED] (.1); review curriculum vitae and fee schedule of [REDACTED] (.2); telephone conferences with [REDACTED] (.2). Memo from S. Rivera regarding [REDACTED]. Draft memorandum regarding [REDACTED] (.1); draft stipulation to extend time to complete same (.1); draft and review memoranda regarding (.1); review and analyze information from potential expert (.1). Work on scheduling deposition of plaintiff's expert witness and prepare notice of deposition. Edit letter to George Brugess regarding expert report of Frank Burg (.1); memo to S. Rivera regarding [REDACTED] (.1). Draft notice of deposition (.1); memorandum regarding [REDACTED] (.1); draft additional questions for deposition of plaintiff's expert (.1). Review letter regarding potential indemnity obligation BNSF sent to Chemical Lime and email to R. Murphy about [REDACTED] (.1).

0.10 0.10 0.30 1.40

18.00 14.00 54.00 175.00

0.10 0.40

14.00 72.00

0.50

62.50

0.20

28.00

0.30

54.00

0.10

18.00

20
1928756.1/83510.398

Case 2:04-cv-00619-RCB

Document 132-4

Filed 06/22/2007

Page 20 of 168

01/10/05

Murphy, Ruth

01/10/05 01/10/05

Thorpe, William L. Rawlinson, Melissa

01/10/05 01/11/05

Rivera, Sal J. Murphy, Ruth

01/11/05

Thorpe, William L.

01/12/05

Murphy, Ruth

01/12/05 01/14/05 01/17/05

Rawlinson, Melissa Rawlinson, Melissa Rawlinson, Melissa

Review claims file for response to S. Rhoden's indemnity letter to Chemical Lime (.2); review plaintiff's medical records from Mayo Clinic for additional providers (.4); update medical records chart (.1); prepare 3rd supplemental disclosure statement and notice of service of same (.5); update case summary (.1); prepare correspondence to Health Information Services enclosing payment for Mayo Clinic records (.1). Review email from R. Murphy following up on [REDACTED] (.1). Memo to/from R. Murphy regarding [REDACTED] (.2); review and edit BNSF's third supplemental disclosure statement (.1); memo to S. Rivera regarding [REDACTED] (.1). Revise third party complaint. Overview of Mayo Clinic records and prepare short summary for Mr. W. Thorpe (1.3); work on obtaining plaintiff's health insurance records (.2). Review supplemental disclosure statement and email to R. Murphy about [REDACTED] (.2); review summary of Mayo records prepared by R. Murphy (.2). Telephone conferences with Mr. Roland Miller's office re obtaining deposition transcript of plaintiff's expert Frank Burg in case of Hamm v. BNSF. Memo to S. Rivera regarding [REDACTED]. Memo from S. Rivera regarding [REDACTED]. Draft stipulation to extend time for taking of plaintiff's expert deposition (.4); draft order extending time for taking of plaintiff's expert deposition. (.1). 21

1.40

175.00

0.10 0.40

18.00 56.00

0.20 1.50

36.00 187.50

0.40

72.00

0.20

25.00

0.10 0.10 0.50

14.00 14.00 70.00

1928756.1/83510.398

Case 2:04-cv-00619-RCB

Document 132-4

Filed 06/22/2007

Page 21 of 168

01/17/05 01/18/05

Rivera, Sal J. Murphy, Ruth

01/18/05

Rawlinson, Melissa

01/18/05

Rivera, Sal J.

01/19/05

Murphy, Ruth

01/19/05

Rawlinson, Melissa Rivera, Sal J. Rivera, Sal J.

01/19/05 01/19/05

01/20/05 01/20/05 01/21/05

Rawlinson, Melissa Rivera, Sal J. Rawlinson, Melissa Rawlinson, Melissa

Draft and revise amended complaint and third party. Review file re discovery, disclosure and upcoming deadlines (.3); prepare memo re same (.2); update case summary (.2). Edit third party complaint (1.0); memo to S. Rivera regarding [REDACTED] (.1); memo from S. Rivera regarding [REDACTED] (.1). Draft and revise amended answer and third party complaint and analyze legal and factual issues related to same. Review and complete authorization from United Healthcare for plaintiff's records (.1); prepare correspondence to Mr. Brugess enclosing authorization (.1); update medical records chart (.1); prepare chart depicting tasks to do (.3). Memo to S. Rivera, W. Thorpe regarding [REDACTED] (.3); draft status report (.3). Draft and revise third party complaint. Memorandum regarding [REDACTED] (.2); memorandum regarding issues [REDACTED] (.2). Draft status update to client. Revise third party complaint. Draft status update to client (.9); review previous deposition testimony of Frank Burg (.4). Memo from S. Rivera regarding [REDACTED] (.1); memo from S. Rivera regarding [REDACTED] (.1). Revise letter to opposing counsel regarding deficiencies in report of plaintiff's expert (.2); memorandum regarding [REDACTED] (.1).

0.20 0.70

36.00 87.50

1.20

168.00

1.10

198.00

0.60

75.00

0.60

84.00

0.60 0.40

108.00 72.00

1.00 0.30 1.30

140.00 54.00 182.00

01/23/05

0.20

28.00

01/23/05

Rivera, Sal J.

0.50

90.00

22
1928756.1/83510.398

Case 2:04-cv-00619-RCB

Document 132-4

Filed 06/22/2007

Page 22 of 168

01/24/05

Rawlinson, Melissa

01/24/05

Rivera, Sal J.

01/25/05

Murphy, Ruth

01/25/05

Rawlinson, Melissa

01/26/05

Rawlinson, Melissa

01/26/05

Rivera, Sal J.

01/27/05 01/28/05

Rawlinson, Melissa Rawlinson, Melissa

Voice mail message for George Brugess regarding stipulation to extend time (.1); draft letter to Brugess enclosing draft stipulation to extend time for filing responses (.2); fax from G. Brugess enclosing signed stipulation (.1); memo to Sal Rivera regarding [REDACTED] (.1); edit status report and [REDACTED] (.4); memo to S. Rivera regarding [REDACTED] (.1); edit letter to Brugess regarding expert report (.1); memo to R. Murphy regarding [REDACTED] (.1). Communicate with opposing counsel regarding depositions (.1); memorandum [REDACTED] (.1). Telephone conference with Mr. Brugess' office re status of discovery and scheduling depositions of plaintiff and lay witnesses (.3); prepare notice of deposition (.1); telephone conference with Mr. S. Rhoden re [REDACTED] (.1). Memo from S. Rivera regarding [REDACTED] (.1); memo to/from R. Murphy regarding [REDACTED] (.2); edit notice of deposition of Steve Schrum (.1). Edit [REDACTED] (.2); edit [REDACTED] to client (.4); memo from S. Rivera regarding [REDACTED] (.1); edit third-party complaint (.5); determine appropriate agents [REDACTED] (1.0). Draft and revise third party complaint (.5); memorandum regarding [REDACTED] (.2); review order regarding expert deposition (.1). Review summons, service of process issues. Edit [REDACTED] to client to include [REDACTED]; Memo to S. Rivera regarding [REDACTED]. 23

1.20

168.00

0.20

36.00

0.50

62.50

0.40

56.00

2.10

294.00

0.80

144.00

0.10 0.20

14.00 28.00

1928756.1/83510.398

Case 2:04-cv-00619-RCB

Document 132-4

Filed 06/22/2007

Page 23 of 168

02/01/05

Murphy, Ruth

02/01/05

Rawlinson, Melissa Murphy, Ruth

02/02/05

02/02/05

Rawlinson, Melissa

02/03/05

Murphy, Ruth

02/03/05

Rawlinson, Melissa

02/04/05

Murphy, Ruth

02/04/05 02/04/05

Rivera, Sal J. Rawlinson, Melissa

02/04/05 02/05/05

Rivera, Sal J. Thorpe, William L.

02/06/05

Rivera, Sal J.

Continue review of plaintiff's medical records and update medical chronology. Review correspondence from plaintiff's counsel regarding available jobs at BNSF for plaintiff. Continue review of plaintiff's medical records and update medical chronology. Memo to S. Rivera regarding [REDACTED] (.1); receipt of confirmation of service on Chemical Lime (.1). Continue review of plaintiff's medical records and update medical chronology. Draft discovery requests to Chemical Lime (1.5); memo from S. Rivera regarding [REDACTED] (.1); memo to/from S. Rivera regarding [REDACTED] (.2); draft letter to Chemical Lime enclosing complaint (.2); email to R. Folley [REDACTED] (.1). Complete review of plaintiff's medical records and update medical chronology (1.8); compile documents for review by experts Dr. Goad and Dr. Fernando (1.5). Memoranda regarding [REDACTED]. Memo to/from R. Murphy/S. Rivera regarding [REDACTED] (.2); memo to/from R. Murphy regarding [REDACTED] (.2); draft letter to Brugess regarding discovery responses (.1); review affidavit of service on Chemical Lime (.1). Memorandum regarding [REDACTED] (.1). Review order from Court extending date on which to depose plaintiff's experts (.1); review letter from Mr. Burgess about job availability for plaintiff at BNSF (.1). Memorandum regarding [REDACTED]. 24

4.70

587.50

0.10

14.00

2.40

300.00

0.20

28.00

0.80

100.00

2.10

294.00

3.30

412.50

0.20 0.60

36.00 84.00

0.10 0.20

18.00 36.00

0.20

36.00

1928756.1/83510.398

Case 2:04-cv-00619-RCB

Document 132-4

Filed 06/22/2007

Page 24 of 168

02/07/05

Rivera, Sal J.

02/07/05

Murphy, Ruth

02/07/05

Rawlinson, Melissa

02/08/05 02/08/05

Rivera, Sal J. Rawlinson, Melissa

02/08/05

Murphy, Ruth

Review medical records and other information [REDACTED]; review memorandum regarding [REDACTED]. Prepare correspondence to expert witnesses Dr. Fernando and Dr. Goad and organize documents for their review (.9); continue review of attachments to plaintiff's initial disclosure statement and update medical chronology (.9). Memo to/from S. Rivera regarding [REDACTED] (.2); memo to/from S. Rivera regarding [REDACTED] (.2); memo from R. Murphy regarding [REDACTED] (.2); voice mail message for R. Folley regarding [REDACTED] (.1); memo to R. Murphy regarding [REDACTED] (.1); memo to R. Murphy regarding [REDACTED] (.1); memo to S. Rivera regarding [REDACTED] (.1); edit letter to Brugess regarding discovery responses (.2); memo to/from S. Rivera, R. Murphy regarding [REDACTED] (.2). Memorandum regarding [REDACTED]. Edit initial discovery requests to Chemical Lime (.2); memo from R. Murphy regarding [REDACTED] (.1); memo from S. Rivera regarding [REDACTED] (.1); voice mail message from R. Folley regarding [REDACTED] (.1); voice mail message from G. Brugess regarding depositions (.1); memo to S. Rivera regarding [REDACTED] (.1). Telephone conference with Dr. Goad's office re consulting on matter (.1); continue review of plaintiff's medical records and updating medical chronology (.7).

0.10

18.00

1.80

225.00

1.40

196.00

0.10 0.70

18.00 98.00

0.80

100.00

25
1928756.1/83510.398

Case 2:04-cv-00619-RCB

Document 132-4

Filed 06/22/2007

Page 25 of 168

02/09/05

Murphy, Ruth

02/09/05

Rawlinson, Melissa

02/09/05

Rivera, Sal J.

02/10/05

Murphy, Ruth

02/10/05

Rawlinson, Melissa

02/11/05

Rawlinson, Melissa

Telephone conference with Dr. Goad re providing materials for review (.2); final packet to send to Dr. Goad (.3); review file for materials to provide to expert economist P. Gregg Curry (.8); draft letter to Mr. Curry enclosing materials (.2); finish update of plaintiff's medical chronology (2.2). Memo to/from R. Murphy regarding [REDACTED] (.2); memo to/from R. Murphy regarding [REDACTED]; (.1) voice mail message for R. Folley (.1); draft deposition outline for Frank Burg (3.0); memo to S. Rivera regarding [REDACTED] (.1); memo to R. Murphy regarding [REDACTED] (.1); telephone conversation with Rick Folley regarding [REDACTED] (.2); email to R. Folley regarding [REDACTED] (.1). Telephone conference with opposing counsel regarding deposition of plaintiff's expert. Telephone conference with vocational rehabilitation expert Mr. Mayer re [REDACTED] (.2); prepare correspondence to Mr. Mayer and organize documents for review (.4) review plaintiff's motion to extend discovery and calendar deadline for response (.1); review file re status of discovery, disclosure and upcoming deadlines and prepare [REDACTED] (.3). Memo from R. Murphy regarding [REDACTED] (.1); review Brugess's motion for discovery continuance (.1). Memo to S. Rivera regarding [REDACTED] (.1); review correspondence from Chemical Lime counsel regarding case (.1).

3.70

462.50

3.80

532.00

0.30

54.00

1.00

125.00

0.20

28.00

0.20

28.00

26
1928756.1/83510.398

Case 2:04-cv-00619-RCB

Document 132-4

Filed 06/22/2007

Page 26 of 168

02/11/05

Rivera, Sal J.

02/12/05

Thorpe, William L.

02/12/05

Rivera, Sal J.

02/13/05

Rawlinson, Melissa

02/14/05 02/14/05

Rawlinson, Melissa Rivera, Sal J.

02/15/05

Rawlinson, Melissa

Telephone conference with new counsel for chemical lime (.1); collect and provide information requested by same (.1); review correspondence from counsel for Chemical Lime (.1). Review plaintiff's motion to extend discovery dates in light of third party complaint filed against Chemical Lime (.3); email message to S. Rivera about [REDACTED] (.1); review letter from Chemical Lime's counsel about his unavailability for plaintiff's expert's deposition (.1). Review correspondence from counsel for Chemical Lime (.1); draft letter regarding upcoming depositions (.1); draft notice of no opposition to plaintiff's motion to continue (.1); memorandum regarding [REDACTED] (.1); review memorandum regarding [REDACTED] (.1). Memo to/from S. Rivera regarding [REDACTED] (.2); memo from S. Rivera regarding [REDACTED] (.1); draft notice of non-opposition to plaintiff's motion to extend discovery (.2); memo to S. Rivera regarding [REDACTED]. (.1); edit deposition outline for Frank Burg deposition (.3). Memo from S. Rivera regarding [REDACTED]. Draft letter to opposing counsel regarding deposition (.2); review memorandum regarding [REDACTED] (.1); memoranda regarding [REDACTED] (.1); work on expert disclosure statement (.2). Message from Chemical Lime's attorney regarding copy of original complaint (.1); memo regarding [REDACTED] (.1).

0.40

72.00

0.50

90.00

0.50

90.00

0.90

126.00

0.10 0.60

14.00 108.00

0.20

28.00

27
1928756.1/83510.398

Case 2:04-cv-00619-RCB

Document 132-4

Filed 06/22/2007

Page 27 of 168

02/15/05

Murphy, Ruth

02/16/05

Rawlinson, Melissa

02/17/05

Rawlinson, Melissa

02/21/05

Murphy, Ruth

02/21/05

Rawlinson, Melissa

02/21/05

Rivera, Sal J.

02/22/05

Murphy, Ruth

02/22/05

Rawlinson, Melissa

Review [REDACTED] (.5); telephone conference with Mr. Brugess' office re rescheduling Mr. Burg's deposition and status of discovery responses (.2). Voice mail message from Mark Musa, Navigant Consulting (.1); draft tender of defense letter to Chemical Lime's attorney (.8). Communicate with Mark Musa, Navigant Consulting, regarding expert testimony (.1); email to R. Folley [REDACTED] (.1); conversation with Mark Musa, Navigant Consulting regarding expert report on damages (.2); edit deposition outline for Frank Burg. (.1) Update case summary (.2); telephone conference with Mr. Onofry's office re rescheduling depositions of plaintiff and plaintiff's expert witness (.2). Memo to S. Rivera regarding [REDACTED] (.1); memo from R. Murphy regarding [REDACTED] (.1). Telephone conference with Dr. Goad regarding assistance with case (.1); telephone conference with Dr. Hewitt regarding same (.1); memorandum regarding [REDACTED] (.1). Telephone conference with Dr. Fernando's office re report for expert witness disclosure. Draft letter to Brugess regarding discovery responses and expert designation deadlines (.7); memo to S. Rivera regarding [REDACTED] (.1); memorandum regarding [REDACTED] (.1); edit tender of defense letter to Chemical Lime (.1).

0.70

87.50

0.90

126.00

0.50

70.00

0.40

50.00

0.20

28.00

0.20

36.00

0.20

25.00

1.00

140.00

28
1928756.1/83510.398

Case 2:04-cv-00619-RCB

Document 132-4

Filed 06/22/2007

Page 28 of 168

02/23/05

Murphy, Ruth

02/23/05

Rawlinson, Melissa

02/23/05

Thorpe, William L. Rivera, Sal J.

02/23/05

Review file re status of disclosure, discovery and upcoming deadlines (.2); prepare memo re [REDACTED] (.1); telephone conference with Mr. Onofry's office re rescheduling depositions of plaintiff and plaintiff's expert witness (.2); telephone call to [REDACTED] (.1). Communicate with Mark Musa regarding expert report (.1); communicate with Rick Folley regarding [REDACTED] (.1); edit letter to G. Brugess regarding expert reports (.1); memo to R. Murphy regarding [REDACTED] (.1); telephone conversation with [REDACTED] (.1); review Chemical Lime's answer to third party complaint (.1); memo from R. Murphy regarding [REDACTED] (.1); memo from R. Murphy regarding [REDACTED] (.1); memo from S. Rivera regarding [REDACTED] (.1); memo from S. Rivera regarding [REDACTED] (.1); telephone conversation with R. Folley regarding [REDACTED] (.2); draft letter to Brugess regarding vocational rehabilitation efforts (.5). Review answer to BNSF's third party complaint (.2); review and respond to memos about [REDACTED] (.2). Begin reviewing response to third party complaint (.2); draft letter to opposing counsel regarding discovery responses (.3); memoranda regarding [REDACTED] (.1); draft and revise notice of non-objection to plaintiffs' motion to continue (.1); communicate with expert's office regarding expert report and disclosure (.1); draft memorandum regarding [REDACTED] (.2).

0.60

75.00

1.70

238.00

0.40

72.00

1.00

180.00

29
1928756.1/83510.398

Case 2:04-cv-00619-RCB

Document 132-4

Filed 06/22/2007

Page 29 of 168

02/24/05

Murphy, Ruth

02/24/05

Rawlinson, Melissa

02/28/05

Rawlinson, Melissa

02/28/05 03/01/05

Rivera, Sal J. Murphy, Ruth

03/01/05

Rawlinson, Melissa

03/01/05 03/01/05 03/02/05

Thorpe, William L. Rivera, Sal J. Murphy, Ruth

Schedule telephonic conference for Mr. S. Rivera and [REDACTED] (.2); prepare memorandum depicting outstanding tasks (.3). Draft letter to Brugess regarding jobs available for plaintiff (.6); memo to/from W. Thorpe, S. Rivera regarding [REDACTED] (.4); draft letter to counsel regarding deposition deadlines (.2); memo to R. Murphy, S. Rivera regarding [REDACTED] (.2). Conversation with Larry Meyer regarding vocational rehabilitation report (.2); memo to/from S. Rivera regarding [REDACTED] (.2). Work on expert disclosure statement. Telephone conference with Mr. Mayer re providing fee schedule for expert disclosure. Telephone conversation with Wendy Reynolds, George Brugess's assistant, regarding extension for disclosure of experts (.2); draft stipulation to extend discovery deadlines (.2); telephone conversation with [REDACTED] (.1); memo to/from R. Murphy regarding [REDACTED] (.2); review court order extending deadline for plaintiff to produce expert for deposition (.1). Review order from Court extending discovery deadlines (.1). Work on expert issues. Compile disclosure statements and discovery responses to provide to counsel for Chemical Lime (.3); telephone conferences with [REDACTED] (.2).

0.50

62.50

1.40

196.00

0.40

56.00

0.30 0.10

54.00 12.50

0.80

112.00

0.10 0.20 0.50

18.00 36.00 62.50

30
1928756.1/83510.398

Case 2:04-cv-00619-RCB

Document 132-4

Filed 06/22/2007

Page 30 of 168

03/02/05

Rawlinson, Melissa

03/02/05

Rivera, Sal J.

Telephone conversation with Charles Onofry's assistant regarding stipulation to extend time for disclosure of BNSF witnesses (.1); memo to S. Rivera regarding [REDACTED] (.1); edit stipulation and order to extend time (.3); voice mail message for G. Brugess regarding same (.1); telephone conversation with Wendy, Brugess's assistant, regarding same (.1); memo from S. Rivera regarding [REDACTED] (.1); draft expert disclosure statement (2.6); telephone conversation with Mark Musa, Navigant Ansulting regarding disclosure of expert report (.2); voice mail message for [REDACTED] (.1); voice mail message from G. Brugess regarding pleadings from third-party defendant and stipulation to extend time (.1); memo from R. Murphy regarding [REDACTED] (.1); forward copy of Chemical Lime's Answer to Third-Party Complaint to G. Brugess (.1). Work on expert issues.

4.00

560.00

0.20

36.00

31
1928756.1/83510.398

Case 2:04-cv-00619-RCB

Document 132-4

Filed 06/22/2007

Page 31 of 168

03/03/05

Murphy, Ruth

03/03/05

Rawlinson, Melissa

03/03/05

Rivera, Sal J.

Telephone conference with Dr. Fernando's office re rescheduling telephone conference and providing fee schedule and list of testimony for expert witness disclosure (.2); telephone conference with Dr. Hewitt's office re providing curriculum vitae, fee schedule and list of testimony and receive and review same (.5); telephone conference with Mr. Curry's office re providing curriculum vitae, fee schedule and list of testimony and receive and review same (.5); receive and review fee schedule from Mr. Mayer (.2); revise draft [REDACTED] (.5); prepare notice of service of 4th supplemental disclosure statement (.2); calendar deadline to file response to Chemical Lime's request for scheduling conference (.1). Voice mail message from Chuck Onofry regarding case status (.1); review correspondence from Chuck Onofry enclosing signed stipulation (.1); review correspondence from G. Brugess enclosing signed stipulation (.1); review letter from Larry Mayer enclosing fee schedule (.1); memo to R. Murphy regarding [REDACTED] (.1); edit [REDACTED] (1.3); review Chemical Lime's request for scheduling conference (.1); memo to/from S. Rivera regarding [REDACTED] (.2); memo from S. Rivera regarding [REDACTED] (.1). Prepare for telephonic meeting with [REDACTED] (.1); prepare for meeting [REDACTED] (.1); draft and revise [REDACTED] (.7); telephone conference with [REDACTED] (.3); draft memorandum outlining [REDACTED] (.3). 32

2.20

275.00

2.20

308.00

1.50

270.00

1928756.1/83510.398

Case 2:04-cv-00619-RCB

Document 132-4

Filed 06/22/2007

Page 32 of 168

03/04/05

Murphy, Ruth

03/04/05

Rawlinson, Melissa

03/04/05

Thorpe, William L.

03/04/05

Rivera, Sal J.

03/07/05

Murphy, Ruth

Review court's order re extending deadline to depose plaintiff's expert and calendar same (.1); receive updated curriculum vitae and list of testimony for expert Dr. Fernando and bates label for expert witness disclosure statement (.4). Memo from R. Murphy regarding [REDACTED] (.1); memo from S. Rivera regarding [REDACTED] (.1); memo to R. Murphy regarding [REDACTED] (.1); memo from S. Rivera regarding [REDACTED] (.1). Review and respond to email from S. Rivera [REDACTED] (.2); review and revise BNSF's fourth supplemental disclosure statement concerning expert witness disclosures (.2); review Chemical Lime's request for a status conference to set new dates and email to S. Rivera about [REDACTED] (.1). Prepare for conference with [REDACTED] (.2); lengthy telephone conference with [REDACTED] (.4); memorandum regarding [REDACTED] (.5); review and analyze plaintiff's answer to third party complaint (.2); review correspondence from opposing counsel regarding depositions and answer to third party complaint (.1). Review tape of plaintiff's recorded statement and [REDACTED] (.1); review conditions of use of medical authorizations and contacting plaintiff's pulmonologist re testing methods (.3).

0.50

62.50

0.40

56.00

0.50

90.00

1.40

252.00

0.40

50.00

33
1928756.1/83510.398

Case 2:04-cv-00619-RCB

Document 132-4

Filed 06/22/2007

Page 33 of 168

03/07/05

Rawlinson, Melissa

03/08/05

Murphy, Ruth

03/08/05

Rawlinson, Melissa

03/08/05

Thorpe, William L. Thorpe, William L. Murphy, Ruth Rawlinson, Melissa Rawlinson, Melissa

03/08/05

03/09/05 03/10/05 03/11/05

Review correspondence from G. Brugess regarding Frank Burg's expert report (.1); memo from S. Rivera regarding [REDACTED] (.1); review F. Burg, plaintiff's expert file (.1); memo to S. Rivera, R. Murphy regarding [REDACTED] (.1); memo from R. Murphy regarding [REDACTED] (.1); memo to/from R. Murphy regarding [REDACTED] (.2); telephone conversation with Larry Mayer regarding expert report (.1); draft joinder in Chemical Lime's request for a scheduling conference (.2). Prepare correspondence to Dr. Fernando enclosing audio cassette of plaintiff's recorded statement. Memo from S. Rivera regarding [REDACTED] (.1); edit joinder and prepare for filing (.1); review court's order extending deadline for expert disclosure (.1). Review additional correspondence and stipulation regarding expert witness disclosures (.1). Review Order from Court extending time for expert witness disclosures (.1). Review expert Burg's file and arrange for bates labeling (.2) Telephone conversation with [REDACTED]. Memo from R. Murphy regarding [REDACTED] (.1); memo to/from R. Murphy regarding [REDACTED] (.3); memo to S. Rivera regarding [REDACTED] (.1); review letter from R. Murphy regarding outstanding medical authorizations (.2).

1.00

140.00

0.10

12.50

0.30

42.00

0.10

18.00

0.10

18.00

0.20 0.10 0.70

25.00 14.00 98.00

34
1928756.1/83510.398

Case 2:04-cv-00619-RCB

Document 132-4

Filed 06/22/2007

Page 34 of 168

03/11/05

Murphy, Ruth

03/14/05

Murphy, Ruth

03/14/05

Rawlinson, Melissa

03/15/05

Murphy, Ruth

03/15/05

Thorpe, William L.

Review status of receipt of plaintiff's medical records and authorizations (.2); prepare follow-up letter to Mr. Brugess re obtaining signed medical authorizations (.1); review court's order re extension of deadline for BNSF to disclose expert witnesses (.1). Prepare correspondence to Apex Documents Solutions enclosing payment for audio cassette duplication (.1); work on scheduling depositions of plaintiff and plaintiff's expert Frank Burg (.3). Voice mail message from Chuck Onofry's office regarding case (.1); memo to S. Rivera regarding [REDACTED] (.1); telephone conversation with Renee, Chuck Onofry's office regarding pleadings to date, deposition deadlines (.2); memo to R. Murphy regarding [REDACTED] (.1); memo from R. Murphy regarding [REDACTED] (.1). Prepare 5th supplemental disclosure statement and notice of service of same (.7); update case summary (.2); review correspondence from Mr. Onofry's office re providing additional documents (.1); organize plaintiff's medical records and disclosure statement and arrange for copying and billing to Mr. Onofry's office (.4); work on scheduling plaintiff's and expert's depositions (.2); telephone conference with court reporter re canceling plaintiff's deposition (.1). Review and revise BNSF's fifth supplemental disclosure statement (.3).

0.40

50.00

0.40

50.00

0.60

84.00

1.70

212.50

0.30

54.00

35
1928756.1/83510.398

Case 2:04-cv-00619-RCB

Document 132-4

Filed 06/22/2007

Page 35 of 168

03/15/05

Thorpe, William L.

03/15/05

Rawlinson, Melissa

03/15/05

Rivera, Sal J.

03/16/05

Murphy, Ruth

03/16/05

Rawlinson, Melissa

Review letter to Mr. Onofry, Chemical Lime's attorney, about tender of defense and indemnity obligation and telephone conference with Mr. Rhoden about [REDACTED] (.3). Memo from S. Rivera regarding [REDACTED] (.1); memo from S. Rivera regarding [REDACTED] (.1); edit fifth supplemental disclosure statement (.1); memos from S. Rivera regarding [REDACTED] (.2); memo from S. Rivera regarding [REDACTED] (.1); edit letter to G. Brugess regarding plaintiff's ability to return to work (.1); memos from R. Murphy, S. Rivera regarding [REDACTED] (.2); memo from S. Rivera regarding [REDACTED] (.1). Review and analyze issues related to BNSF's [REDACTED] (.2); draft letter regarding same (.1); draft letter to opposing counsel regarding positions available to plaintiff (.2); analyze issues related to [REDACTED] (.1); memorandum regarding [REDACTED] (.1); memorandum regarding [REDACTED] (.1); telephone conference with S. Rhoden regarding [REDACTED] (.2); analyze supplemental report and comment on same (.4). Work on scheduling depositions of plaintiff and expert Frank Burg (.4); prepare deposition scheduling chart (.1). Voice mail message from [REDACTED] (.1); voice mail message for [REDACTED] (.1); telephone conversations with [REDACTED] (.3); review report of Larry Mayer (.2); memo to S. Rivera regarding [REDACTED] (.1).

0.30

54.00

0.90

126.00

1.40

252.00

0.50

62.50

0.80

112.00

36
1928756.1/83510.398

Case 2:04-cv-00619-RCB

Document 132-4

Filed 06/22/2007

Page 36 of 168

03/17/05

Rawlinson, Melissa

03/17/05

Murphy, Ruth

03/17/05

Rivera, Sal J.

03/18/05

Rawlinson, Melissa

03/18/05

Thorpe, William L. Murphy, Ruth

03/18/05

03/18/05

Rivera, Sal J.

03/21/05 03/21/05

Murphy, Ruth Rawlinson, Melissa

Draft additional discovery requests to plaintiff and Chemical Lime (.6); memo to S. Rivera regarding [REDACTED] (.3); email to D. Cleveland regarding [REDACTED] (.1); memo from S. Rivera regarding [REDACTED] (.1); draft letter to Brugess (.6); draft supplemental discovery requests to plaintiff (1.0). Work on scheduling depositions of plaintiff and expert Frank Burg (.5); prepare first amended notice of deposition of plaintiff (.2). Draft letter to opposing counsel regarding expert report (.2); draft letter to opposing counsel regarding discovery responses (.2); outline [REDACTED] (.1); memorandum [REDACTED] (.1); revise letter to opposing counsel regarding return to work issues (.1). Email from Don Cleveland regarding [REDACTED] (.1); memo to S. Rivera regarding [REDACTED] (.1); edit letter to Brugess regarding IME (.8); memo to S. Rivera regarding [REDACTED] (.1); edit letter to Brugess regarding outstanding discovery (.2); memo from R. Murphy regarding [REDACTED] (.1). Review series of emails and notices scheduling plaintiff's liability expert for deposition (.1). Final arrangements for deposition of plaintiff's expert Frank Burg and prepare amended notice of deposition. Draft subpoena and prepare notice of deposition for plaintiff's expert (.2); draft letter to opposing counsel (.2); review and analyze plaintiff's criminal documents (.2); Work on supplementing disclosure of expert witnesses. Memoranda to R. Murphy and S. Rivera regarding [REDACTED]. 37

2.70

378.00

0.70

87.50

0.70

126.00

1.40

196.00

0.10

18.00

0.30

37.50

0.60

108.00

0.50 0.20

62.50 28.00

1928756.1/83510.398

Case 2:04-cv-00619-RCB

Document 132-4

Filed 06/22/2007

Page 37 of 168

03/21/05 03/22/05

Rivera, Sal J. Murphy, Ruth

03/22/05

Thorpe, William L. Thorpe, William L.

03/22/05

03/22/05

Rawlinson, Melissa

Analyze [REDACTED]. Telephone conference with [REDACTED] (.1); work on scheduling plaintiff's independent medical examination (.2); review file re plaintiff's statements concerning fall from asthma attack (.4); assist with preparation of supplemental expert disclosure (.3). Review and respond to memorandum from S. Rivera about [REDACTED] (.2). Study letter to plaintiff's counsel about repeated failures to comply with discovery, BNSF's supplemental disclosure statement and BNSF's supplement regarding expert witnesses (.4); email to S. Rivera and M. Rawlinson about [REDACTED] (.1). Memoranda to/from S. Rivera regarding [REDACTED] (.2); telephone conversations with [REDACTED] (.5); memos to/from S. Rivera regarding [REDACTED] (.2); edit letter to G. Brugess regarding outstanding discovery (.7); edit supplemental disclosure statements (1.0); draft notice of service of sixth supplemental disclosure statement (.2); edit letter to Brugess regarding scheduling of plaintiff's (.3); memos to/from W. Thorpe, S. Rivera regarding [REDACTED] (.2).

0.30 1.00

54.00 125.00

0.20

36.00

0.50

90.00

3.30

462.00

38
1928756.1/83510.398

Case 2:04-cv-00619-RCB

Document 132-4

Filed 06/22/2007

Page 38 of 168

03/22/05

Rivera, Sal J.

03/23/05

Murphy, Ruth

03/23/05

Rawlinson, Melissa

03/23/05

Rivera, Sal J.

03/24/05 03/24/05

Thorpe, William L. Rawlinson, Melissa

D