Free Answering Brief in Opposition - District Court of Delaware - Delaware

Case 1:08-cv-00292-SLR

Document 13-5

Filed 07/28/2008

Page 1 of 13








! "#!$%%& '(
$))& *+!,* -*!. /,* (#-(0( 12 +34 * $%&52)6 $&%2)5$
7&
! "18 !



Case 1:08-cv-00292-SLR

Document 13-5

Filed 07/28/2008

Page 2 of 13

9 99 999 9@

"#

:1;04(1 -*-<3=+# !1)5 >#3=43?=+##!
-8; ,( 2 >#(9!>!A1(( -(
3>+
1 )

Case 1:08-cv-00292-SLR

Document 13-5

Filed 07/28/2008

Page 3 of 13


"#$%&


"# $ %&
)? 72 )22 6) *$)& 2 ) 5):%%6$:()& 2 6 ) '( $ )#*+ 2:%%25$:()& 2 ) , $ 25:%225 %5)$:(& 2






%2?B 2 6


:! $C&$6&5 2 6 :! $& 5 !1) % 5






?!*% 55 5 ?2 %)5 265 % 5



Case 1:08-cv-00292-SLR

Document 13-5

Filed 07/28/2008

Page 4 of 13



'()*'+",-) 9 "1(8 5 -*- 1 # # #48 0D # E (F
(3 , (=( $E,F& ># ( #48
( 31
1(4 =(1 0D 1( $E/9F& # 3 -*- # =1C8 1 # 14 31
1(/9=( 1 # (
(=( D##=0
C( /9 #C(
8=11=# 0 D DC 4 3#48 # ( 3=D# 9 =(( 4 C(14# C8 # =

# /9>* 91( >#4 33( G HI(4 3A1 $ 8 EF& , D 133(8 J1 #
(4 ( 3
? 2 %)5 265$E# K265&C1 =(# ( # -*- D 14 8 J1(8 ( (3 # # (
(4#(343(4,#4 #
(4 3
# K265 D( J1 # C 8 1
(CD#(=#41(%
# #
(A1(3

# D#(=4 ##=DCC8A1C1
#(3# 3(1D##1(8#3# C
DC
(-*-C4 =(4# ( ##8D(#( (==(#8D(

(3C8#:((1

Case 1:08-cv-00292-SLR

Document 13-5

Filed 07/28/2008

Page 5 of 13

#,( (3
#K265D( 1( # C3 ( (1 D## D

(3 ==
# 3 #D ( D((1C3#=

3
(3 #K265D 18(1 C8#>/?!*% 55$# E!*55 F& :C(1(8 ) ># 33 (A1( 1( (1
# 3 C( 8 D8 # A1
D##( # (1
(4#D(1!*55 9 #( # 31
1(4 =( # -*- 1 30 /9 # C J1 C8 1(
D
(4 = 3 # # C (3 C8 ?(1( #:((1 L(#>/C
(C># D#81-*- 7=D#8#(ECJ 8#4#0# #M-*-HNF=(4# =(E1MN
(43
=F 5):%%6 %)$:()& -*-38
3(D#
#(1 #ECJ 8
(0F# ( =(4# ( ED#(0D(C 1 # #1 # C 0DF C8 -*- :( #4 # 1 4 # -*-=(13C8 =(
(3 C34
,D1 # 1 ( # = #( 4 =(1 #( :1(#( 8 1==( # 1(8 8=8 (A1( 1( = 13( # =(1
(
(3 1 =(=(8 13C( 9 # = 13(
( -*-H/9=(1(#4#8=#=1(#(D#(#3
3( D# # D# D1 # -*- 4 # ==C8
# !*553-*-H D
(



Case 1:08-cv-00292-SLR

Document 13-5

Filed 07/28/2008

Page 6 of 13

9 -*- # C (84 11
18 ( # /9 3(0
( (14#8 2 8( 6 # (38 1 D# =C 4 1==8 J 1( A1 =C =(
# 44 1 -*- =(13C8 # C3 0D4C C1 # = =(
##(=814#9 -*-81(,H (
(H(C1

-*-H3((A1
( H=3(1>-#48 :8 1(4 # =8
# (1 = == D# -*- =1C8 1 30 /9 14 #
(44 ( 7=8
-*- # (1
# 3 # C (A1 *7#C # #( :C(1(8 5
(3 -*- D(
# (0 = C8 # (1 == -*- , ( #(1=(4 #=4=(1==(
#33 -*-,D(11
1 #D ( #>/==( 3D##( 1C 8 # (4 3 D# (= #( ==C8 # (>#(1
#K265D80D#/91(8 14 C -*- ?(( -*- # 1 30 3(01(=(1
C(14#
(44 ( D
( 04
( %8 7 D( (#(D = D#1 =(4 3=8 D# # 3
( (A1(3
!1 )

%

Case 1:08-cv-00292-SLR

Document 13-5

Filed 07/28/2008

Page 7 of 13

-*-#C(14##3 34#1D#834##0 ##D
18
(4#!*55 %-(-./*0#0(1-'*)*#233 !1 ) (A1( 3
( = 3 -*-4#14#3=8D##(A1(3
(# (83= (#-*-4(# !1(13C8 -*-D(41#D 71
(3 3
(C4 C1 3 8 3 31(:! $C&$6&#(
(= H=
(#34 =
(=(1(8=
(
O #( D(
#34O
E1
F-( ( #=(
#=(8(
((
# 3 =
8 (A1 # = (

3(
3 1(!1$& ># D#( 3(8 =04 1= # =# 1 # C##=(# 1(
(3 3=( C
(3#
(44 #( ( C1 # C
( H 4 (C 1(((43=(13C81# C4 #D ( -*- =(#3 #((13=#=#8
E=#
( F D1(#3(
#3
-*-P
(43
#D#(=1#O?6 ) 6) %6 O 4 C D
1 ># = 8 ( (
# !*55 ( D## #A1 0D Q3# 4Q =( 3# 4=(>#P%61
(31
#P=>#==
( P = D =1C# C
( -*- 0 1 #(8 #(
( (48 3
#(4 C D#8-*-0D(#1# 0D##( CCJ 8(CC
(=14##!*55
(4 ==8A18 #PP%6 D##D(1C8#>/
(
11(

#0 4#!*55=((P265




5

Case 1:08-cv-00292-SLR

Document 13-5

Filed 07/28/2008

Page 8 of 13



1#-./*0( **#"#%*0.
/-10'1#*0#45#,(# !1$C&$6& 1(D##-*-3 =( 3#
(#44#

4
3=D##E
31=D##(
C4(F :! $C&$6&:( #3
(3
(=3=#C# =4
(##:(!1
(1( :! :/!-6 $6& 9 '( $ )#*+ 2 :% %25 %22%2 $: ( )& # :((1=
8##:/!-63#=4(
(#C8 #1=(31("# $ %&
)? 72 )22 6) * $)& H 3= # (0 :/!- 6 #(
(3=81

D#!1#4 -( =
8 H 3= 4 #( 1
E=
(43FC8=4J1( #=D##C C
(4 H 71 (4# *H D(#=
# = # 1
-*-D##C C
(44$3=$9& RR2 5 & ># 1

1( # :( !1 3
( =
(43 4 -*- 1

C D## 3 ( 8 # 4 '( 2 :% %2) C8 D#4 4#8 4(13=8 #((S
H4E11181 F-*-;($9&

P 3= 7=8 = =(( D## 4 34 1C 3
#
(433-*-
=1 #4
D
1 $3=$9& RR2 %&( 4#-*-0D(#1# 0D #D
(44# = -*-;($9& % A14 5):%%) !4( #D (
D# 0
(3 # D
1 4 ( #

(433=( C8#
4(
#3=
, $ 25:%225 %5)$:(&$1=#4
4
(1=(1
#
4
3=&





2

Case 1:08-cv-00292-SLR

Document 13-5

Filed 07/28/2008

Page 9 of 13

% #4 -*-H 3 A1 # A18
H 1C
(434 !#( -*-##
A18=E31= D##(
C4(FC1=1(=(8
=E3
(D
1 =
(43F-*-;($9& 2H3= #D ( 0 1

( ED
1 =
(43 F
( # (8 4 ( # 1# 1
7 # 1( D D( =
(43=( 3=(83438C#1=#D4## 7= %2 ? B 2 C
( 1# #D4 38 C =(

D
1
(43 5):%%6># 7= # 3= # 4 # -*-H
(43 D
1 $RR 2 %&#(A1#341(2 $!T*!:/!!* 9*: RR $& $& $#&& :( # ( 1 CD # A18 = # D
1
-*-H
(43 C1 4 #
1( = # =(
( J1#3
34
1( 1
:( !1
(1($C&$6&3=8==C9 H=4# (4( 3( # 1

;8 D8
3=( (8 1 -*-H -8 6 1(3
( 9
(43 4 14# #341(B 2 *7#C ; C13=8#(8 D#8 D # E7=F O 44 4
#14#=C#-*-
3(D##A18:(!1:(3 3D# #( ( -*-P 13C(4 4#
D Q1Q 1(3
( =
(43 D
1 4 (8 1 4 CD # =( *7#C;##( D($((&:(33=1(3
( 9
(43 26'"$&
%



6

Case 1:08-cv-00292-SLR

Document 13-5

Filed 07/28/2008

Page 10 of 13

E
(3C
F#H
(43DD
1O8
#
1(84#4 *7#C ; ! 1#,#%-#%--#6)0,# -0(#'(- ,-70#-,##400(# ((#.#( %-0**4)*#%% >#=(=#(1
-*-H3##1C(A1(= # D
1
-*-H
(43D# 4((
1 =(1(8 >#( A1 #D ( # # 3= =1 -*-
D# = C C
(4 C8 D# 1 H 4 # -*-H
(43D
13=(#==C4(
=(

(# ># :( (1H
( D##( 4 3 # %&
=4 ( D##(# E3= 14# D #
H D(F'( ) 2:%%2)1(8
-*-=3( 8D##(#
(4
(C= =3( 8D##(#D
18>#
-*-448
(43( 8(
(C8 (8448D
1
(439
443
(43 8
(C8 #13D# (0
-*-H31
D##-*-1(8= 3 ( 8 :( # ((D =1(=
J4 1 # =4 4 #4 3((A1( 9
-*- D ( #
1 C
( H 4 -*- # #
1 ==8
(8 #
(3 C44 # 31 # # =(H !1 6
( 1 ?38 -*-
( # C
( # 4 C8 3



)

Case 1:08-cv-00292-SLR

Document 13-5

Filed 07/28/2008

Page 11 of 13

+##( # 4
H 3= ( ( ( (C # =(1( =DC C-*- /##(#
#(44C#(

1=4# -*- D (A1 # #( =(
(3 4
CJ (0 D 1

(=(1(S
14DC(A1( 9
#
(3( 1(D#8 8 C(


(H # 4=# (C
(311(4C8-*-$ E-*-0D(#1# 0D##( CJ 8#4#0###
(4(3(
(C3
H =F& (#( # # (C
(31 18 = $38 H 4
#13
#-*-H
(43DED
1F& 9
=(1(S
1 =4 (A1( # C A1 D 338C3 E =4 3 (414 # 1

8
#
= 1==(2#35>#1(D4( C #((1
C(
4 D( #((1
33;8#3##=(18 4 (4#
=(=(4#
(( 73#D# = #1(H3D# CDD#31==(3(83
D## # 8#4 D# # 1(84 =1C8 A1 1C 3=C8#3=

5

># 08
# = ( 8
( 9 # QCJ Q (0
#
(43 (8#( (1(C==

(U+#(
110D4U+# #1
(18 # 0D

(43 D# 3(8 44U 1# 1 (8 DC=(
#13(3
D
1 C1#( D#=1(= ( C8 44 #3 # =4 4 (#( #
( (8 # =(3 # =( =
1
1((





Case 1:08-cv-00292-SLR

Document 13-5

Filed 07/28/2008

Page 12 of 13

># :( (1H # 8( 9 ( # (
=(
D
1 8 (3(0 C1 =4 ( 3( 1( ( D4 D
1 =4 D0 # # =
(4 1
1
714 C(0
( 1 4
D
1
(43(

=4=1#D8C4D=4 D# ( ( (=
18 1(4 # 1( ( -*-H = # ( 1(
1 8 # 3 (A1( -*- D( ( #(D = D# 8
8 (( =4
# 39#(
#1(#3(=(1(
#1C= =(8
(
33= "18 *+!,*
-*!. /,*



-- . / "#!$%%& '(
$))& (#-(0( 12 +34 * $%&52)6 $&%2)5$
7& /
1 ,(4+1($;;/%665& -=($;;/5)262& ;(-,

$;;/65)& *+!,* -*!. /,* <14 1 ; - $6)&5%5555 $6)&5%5)$
7& -#;(8 +9>/.>!+ %2++0(( #4 966 $%&2226





Case 1:08-cv-00292-SLR

Document 13-5

Filed 07/28/2008

Page 13 of 13

,# #!83 +9>/.>!+ %%%1#,( 1 4
( ) $%&62) -(1< +9>/.>!+
(( :(
(5 $55&2 "#(0D +9>/.>!+ (0 1 DT(0 T66 $&56)



Case 1:08-cv-00292-SLR

Document 13-6

Filed 07/28/2008

Page 1 of 2

Case 1:08-cv-00292-SLR

Document 13-6

Filed 07/28/2008

Page 2 of 2

Case 1:08-cv-00292-SLR

Document 13-7

Filed 07/28/2008

Page 1 of 13

Case 1:08-cv-00292-SLR

Document 13-7

Filed 07/28/2008

Page 2 of 13

Case 1:08-cv-00292-SLR

Document 13-7

Filed 07/28/2008

Page 3 of 13

Case 1:08-cv-00292-SLR

Document 13-7

Filed 07/28/2008

Page 4 of 13

Case 1:08-cv-00292-SLR

Document 13-7

Filed 07/28/2008

Page 5 of 13

Case 1:08-cv-00292-SLR

Document 13-7

Filed 07/28/2008

Page 6 of 13

Case 1:08-cv-00292-SLR

Document 13-7

Filed 07/28/2008

Page 7 of 13

Case 1:08-cv-00292-SLR

Document 13-7

Filed 07/28/2008

Page 8 of 13

Case 1:08-cv-00292-SLR

Document 13-7

Filed 07/28/2008

Page 9 of 13

Case 1:08-cv-00292-SLR

Document 13-7

Filed 07/28/2008

Page 10 of 13

Case 1:08-cv-00292-SLR

Document 13-7

Filed 07/28/2008

Page 11 of 13

Case 1:08-cv-00292-SLR

Document 13-7

Filed 07/28/2008

Page 12 of 13

Case 1:08-cv-00292-SLR

Document 13-7

Filed 07/28/2008

Page 13 of 13

Case 1:08-cv-00292-SLR

Document 13-8

Filed 07/28/2008

Page 1 of 1

CERTIFICATE OF SERVICE I, Denise Seastone Kraft, hereby certify that on this 28th day of July, 2008, a true and correct copy of the foregoing SOITEC'S BRIEF IN OPPOSITION TO MEMC'S MOTION TO DISMISS OR IN THE ALTERNATIVE, FOR A MORE DEFINITE STATEMENT was electronically filed with the Clerk of the Court using the CM/ECF system and a copy was served upon the following counsel of record in the manner indicated: VIA HAND DELIVERY and CM/ECF Patricia Smink Rogowski, Esquire Connolly, Bove, Lodge & Hutz The Nemours Building 1007 North Orange Street P.O. Box 2207 Wilmington, DE 19899 /s/ Denise Seastone Kraft Denise Seastone Kraft (No. 2778)

WLM 514324.1