Free Reply to Response to Motion - District Court of Arizona - Arizona

l H ` · §g$‘SY$CQ;°;£}2;E+”;`g;7g xw THE uwrffv
I=°§‘»§Lf ;£1’QZ"é'* M -— U --'·°“GE°
émksm Az ssvzw-wok J LDISTR ,.€r.‘?€©E?%’5Z°f_fC¤PY
— l DEC 1 3 2905
, .3 LIQM wow W!¤·cIn¤·.€] C lf-U'E~p CLERK U 5 DISTRICT CQLJRT
?I—=·»+< , msswuzw GF »x¤I::;>m,¤I
_ @f¢___%_;_, DEPUTY
. v. Casa Ng, { ,1-*.} O3·|?J*I“{*PHX—E€HC·MS
U \/¤`M'¢’>DP+T0n5,'IH¢.,¢;aI., cmd O§3·a<1JI-zbw +e> H¤S;s+m·¥€:s Orders De»»y{C5 PIcu}I·F·‘I',s
J’¢ YIAQu+$
-. _.. H¤H¤n +¤ Rwpem Déscouery ¤.»¤l H¤+.`.m ·I¤ ¢IPPé»»¤~} C¤u»s@I
pI¤Tn+T££ kewgky refifes I-c ¤I2E¤nJ¤n+ \fq[ugOf¤+II¤n$,I»¢.‘s Re5{>.¤¤5Q +o PI¤{•»¥·[qs
_ I"#"I¤·H0v¤ Gppaulznj and O1LE•g;+¤`cu 4:; •'Ic;g?S·4-ru'}-@_'s D|"é€"S deny]? pIq¤h+I¤;[s M¤‘H¤»v-I-0
.?€.O{s€V? D:.5CO\!¢r)r ané MG+:OVI 'I··¤ QPf0'lP‘I+` (bw-U?5€(·
; _ I. Mo-I-Ton ig Beupem ]gPscou€r¥
Similqr -I-v M¤g:s-I-r:».+Q S`:·I~v¤;r‘*5 Faqjcwfnj, d.&£aw.=¢:{mn+ \/q[u.€Op+]c·.•··vJ' qgqes
+L.q+ fIq.'.·¤+‘.p·£ :v;+€v‘1c'1S ·L¤ wHl·'z=a Jrscoverly 4-¤ seek A¤:s·:I¤s¤.¢·r·a H: :~¤£¢nu¤+Zo¤
Iavncl J¤cn,;m2v·.·+5 Pm+ec+éc\ uwléer °Hq,a. I-IQQIVII Im5uLf`¤•'1¢Q P¤f`+¤b;L`+)» que]
I
A&C¤u¤+aL'¤|`n+X 4;+ op I‘?'i[p (HTPAP5 mad ARS § $b‘$0°f. AH’L¤¤uj·I·» PIm`n+TCp
` ` **101.5 ng :¢`2q n»J\r;q+' 'Hnp. C.0\n+QYI"t`,S cv'? HH-{PHA" ·}-rujy VQAAS L¢¢¤•,uS€'— LIE. is
:ncarr.e,r¤»+é¢} caué \..::+*¤¤»¢‘I’ couw.se.I ., pI¤u`¤+ipp is cer+c».`m °F“I'-md' L+ clues
` nc'? .Pr€véY‘»+ deié-¥\¢:i¤Lvn‘¥' Rvcm <1VL5vJ2,f`:w•._5 l`\4+QTF03&+0Pc`€S L.»u`v1`¤L1n (XO MD+
Fec?»€1r`€ 0, {>¤+—:G•.v1‘é Hama. or ¤‘$‘L·o.r :¢:Ien+»°£y[»13 :w,·p0fm¤,+;¤n. Exqwiplez
-$q·.MFIe, Im!-erréniic;4-¢>r>;: In 9.00*% , was Vcdu€.Op+I¤nJ,Im;. Canned hoc Inunéreé
. {lnausamd De>II¤,r$ by °H··¤. S4-¤.+-Q au; Arzzcnq cnr °I’L·.¤. gaizqléq ¤\qn_*|·L up »l-wg
I ¤$ Ws c;cv1su·M.2r$ Lear £=¤*»I(·4j 4:: prouuée ·1'I»»¤.m qézguqk lM€\’l+€lt{ I·»&I+¥1
cm’ U •I·I··¢.;¤r v‘>1@<:I`Icq] fétofcjs of` ‘f£¤0. c¢.u+;>Psy reP¤f‘+:. T`? mcs-? »;qr+ql¤\>,
.$\tB\1\A B2 ¢=¢5$uv··1cc` 'H'LG.+ \I¤¤I».¢.2Dp·F¢cv\$ wm} $¤·-Y ¢.m·y?!¤;nj +0 pr,9u·2n+ QH
Ia? W2. przv'¤m,•.: nmé auLs¢.•:·luen+ C¢z°¤II.u*•z5 ·I¤ provkie q¢[eguq·,·I-Q ¤en+¤}
I¤;¢L\•I»I¤ care pmv-I g•.—I~·I~»`»»»j baton-—.e_ +·Liq gpur+. PIc{m+]`¤`? knows °H·»=z+
q$·¥·z,r ¤H¤w, Errs-I ·Pzn or K25;-l»exn \}¤.Iu20p"n·¤m5 c·.·.w:suwr€f`S who •.»·¤€,PQ
Case 2:O3—cv—O1344-EHC-HCE D0cIgment186 FiIed12/13/2005 Page10f3

_ d¤v¢`¤e.c\ ¤u.{@¢?uq+2 mev¤+¢z] \~.¢<1T*H¤ Care ware. ba¥:¤re, =P£»m. ;¤•.4r+, er-
·l’m¤.\r #12::+ JP km, ··H»·¤. ;¤¤.»r+ would Cdqd more r*eci·.w»¤I¤m+ so
P$¤I·4+{C-P wnbdé n¤+ »¤{s`L -4-¤ go ·=H·.¤.+ r¤u.·\—@,. wi-P!·» TM-e.rv*¤3¤_+-orI€.S
qvlé ¤.c\v»Jss»`ovz5, ·+k¤,·r¤a are cd·|~¤,rnq+Iuzs.
, Even QC p1¤..'¤+1D$ inéandeé +¤ make. recorés reque.s{—s, Mis mn Lz.
idome by rzc\u¢+¥•»ij p¤¥r9,m+ n¤v··1€,S and ¤°I*L¤.r .Pr·:vq,·$-€ `···»p<·rm G, ¢;¤v··»»-mn prud-{ee. YG} qgojw, \/q[ueOP+}on.S p¢ov{<:}?v5; Qin. records
_¤VL.¤;'F {@0.;:; in e. psY¢\·»¤·Hc, rage, vnqréered °H·»v·2z pc;¤F\a Kn `
. ct sk¤PP{·»j m¤.N»" wnmlcl v·=¤+ he in -j;a_f__r~ `··»¤·4·e.r*e$+, so ··l4..¤€ WZ}! say
3-%.+ Hs pr¤4-ec}-eel $».;c~fM¤»+·1:•··:·
AS for \f¤dueOP·¥-{On; :··>¢;¤rr—e_c;4— qsser-4-I¤n +k¤¢+ eve»·»+s ·H·\¤+ ecqurwed
q'$'I"€°f“ 4*1. CF`£Q+{|lj QVEWAF &·r`€ :rI"€I€-V¢LYl+j PlQ.\V|·+|.£p +0
€> \/¤du.eOP+}¤»¤s' consumers piké CTN] +¢»¤¤s¤mé qffaqls .,.,·k(.·,I, were sfmrh,
gdrirowm away LY Yi-s z·~¤F.1¤h·e»€$ and 2.4 3`OO6l M5 2003 One. lm.m¤}raé`
°*’{mc=·L$¤w¢Ch qfpzqk were ¤H·»rcvv1 away, •|·‘H{$ sk¤wS ¤. lcnj-·|-·;»¤-ze
p¤,·H-e·rv1 ox; qpfgqrs •|'i·•r·¤¤»u•rp away. I+ wcukg qfsg skew •f·‘¢L&·+ ;•n
•V·u;s.¢ Your ygqrs \/cJ•.¤2Dp+¤`¤»¤;; has nc`? +·m`ed` +o S`{-ep =H1Zs.Sm;I,
. ·» Img arm, wen se++1¤;\ ",».++@m" can Show Q ",wu·‘cy,.m+¤·~ M
pv·a.·;+€¢,€". -
PL¤·:n+C£p SLQMIA be. jmnké Pecpeé-TAB wp cK¤`.Sc0v¢ry·
;_I. M¤+[¤g 4-:: A[gp<5•n·}— Counsel
U :De£9wé¤m+ V¤e)u€O·P+¤.0n6’ reqfu;c$+ 4-:: »,;P\.-Low 144, 1McLjT$+r2;*Y··¢arS cnler
denying Pl¤.T»q·}—[C£ ;LPpc>]·»zf·mew!·# eg aoumsa} .s*¤¤»de\ ·»¤¢+ Le even
. »;¤··1s{Aereév e>+k¤.r ¤Hwm as ¤m ¤'···1pr¤f·er re·?¤u2s+. V¤.‘ue.OP+¤`¤m$ ·p¤d[e<£
4¤ D»\a cw~}•P|·»$vB ·re,3qr~éC»;5 cm), of pI¤Cm+Z£`·p's www-ubms +0 Q,PP¤:V1'F
Qmmgel, ya+ Apu: +127 ».·¤W.+ +0 ·~€q~.¤·.s+ =+z,,q+ ptq.'.~+;€I? :sn'+ S»'»·e»
_ c¤»·»,F,·;—\-€»L+ ¤~€·P,—e_;e¤+q&¤`¤¤, Pl¤,T..4+f-PP kms pre;e¤+¤.¤i s.¤$1Z·`;_¤’em+ vEc¤;~l·5
Case 2:O3—cv—O1344-EHC-HCE D0cumeg186 FiIed12/13/2005 Page20f3

. d2v·#r0v¤$+1—:¤•}-·]·»j =\··kp.. Ifcxaephlowqf C{rcuv··r$+qv1ce$” f‘€?u.{?€¢I by qpfsgrkqbre
{Q5; [GLM;) ,,.a\M}_,1q aL].p,r Q review gv? ¤H»m. 214+Er-Q recarci +‘G»;i cover-}-
4*:}}/ sec.
PlqI»»+1$·\’: 3\».p..JJ he ¢·,PP¤7u»··n·?—2c[ c¤¤4··:seI·
, °l·*·•
1 R¢9._5Pec:}’·p¤_.;NY SMLMIHQA Hus 8 Jp `]?e,c.ev»1I¤er·1., ROOF,
I
. V'
5 · M °‘·*—€1qr—¢¤ —l°¢¤é··»+¢
OrQ>‘»`»-»q| L O4e cmpy ·~»¢»}}eJ *6L{9}0I -/-0; C1ar\<, l1.€-D:;+r‘%d~ Cond-,S¤n¢§f‘¤¢
Day D'Ccnwc:>r* US. C]_puf+L¤¤.r.$@,S4¢.!30, ‘·JO1 W. Wushimj-I-w S+.,5PC`:¥
` ?£¤:>enT.>< ,1q·r‘·`a0nq QSOOETPJIQ
1O•·1€ copy v··»c$•[eJ fil/BIG? +0; Nvf‘¤;5,K01sr¤u;S»,5r¤erm¤q ¢¥#¤D¤vZs, P‘.L.C.
.:I(e>“[&'? v. S¤¤++.sJqle. @.,5+2. &r0\..$w+1¤A¤Ie AZ. Ssxsv
Case 2:03—cv—01344-EHC-HCE D0cur;rg:nt186 Filed 12/13/2005 Page30f3

Case 2:03-cv-01344-EHC-HCE

Document 186

Filed 12/13/2005

Page 1 of 3

Case 2:03-cv-01344-EHC-HCE

Document 186

Filed 12/13/2005

Page 2 of 3

Case 2:03-cv-01344-EHC-HCE

Document 186

Filed 12/13/2005

Page 3 of 3