Free Exhibit to a Document - District Court of Delaware - Delaware

Case 1:07-cv-00178-GMS

Document 157

Filed 06/17/2008

Page 1 of 14

IN THE UNITED STATES DISTRICT COURT FOR THE DISTRICT OF DELAWARE DEUTSCHER TENNIS BUND (GERMAN TENNIS FEDERATION), ROTHENBAUM SPORT GMBH, and QATAR TENNIS FEDERATION, ) ) ) ) ) Plaintiffs, ) ) v. ) ) ATP TOUR, INC., ETIENNE DE VILLIERS, ) CHARLES PASARELL, GRAHAM PEARCE, ) JACCO ELTINGH, PERRY ROGERS, and IGGY ) JOVANOVIC, ) ) ) Defendants.

C.A. 07-178-GMS

ADDENDUM TO EXHIBIT 6(b) TO THE PRETRIAL ORDER ASHBY & GEDDES Philip Trainer, Jr. (I.D. #2788) Carolyn Hake (I.D. #3839) Tiffany Geyer Lydon (I.D. #3950) 500 Delaware Avenue, 8th Floor P.O. Box 1150 Wilmington, Delaware 19899 (302) 654-1888 [email protected] [email protected] [email protected] Attorneys for Defendants

Of Counsel: Bradley I. Ruskin Colin A. Underwood Jennifer R. Scullion Evan S. Greene PROSKAUER ROSE LLP 1585 Broadway New York, NY 10036-8299 (212) 969-3000 Dated: June 16, 2008

00223904;v1}

Case 1:07-cv-00178-GMS

Document 157

Filed 06/17/2008

Page 2 of 14

Defendants' Statement Concerning Objections and Reservations of Rights The parties have exchanged physical mark-ups of the transcripts and have agreed that those mark-ups may be referred to in the event of any confusion or uncertainty as to whether the page:line charts reflect the intended designations/counters/objections. Defendants have used the following abbreviations for their objections: BE ­ Best Evidence Rule CE ­ Character Evidence FM ­ Form (but objections to form on the record are preserved, regardless of whether noted with an FM abbreviation). FO ­ Foundation HS ­ Hearsay LD ­ Leading LO ­ Improper Lay Opinion NC ­ Not necessary for Completeness (with respect to purported counterdesignations) NR ­ Non-Responsive to the question NQ ­ No Question, or impartial question, designated OC ­ Offer of Compromise PCW ­ Fed. R. Evid. 403 (Prejudice/Confusion/Waste of Time) R ­ Relevance RM ­ Remedial Measures Objections to questions also are objections to the answers to those questions. To the extent that an exhibit discussed in deposition also is listed as a Plantiffs' Proposed Trial Exhibit, objections, if any, to exhibits noted in the designations are in addition to those made with respect to the Proposed Trial Exhibit and without waiver of the objections to the Proposed Trial Exhibit. Defendants reserve the right to seek to preclude Plaintiffs from offering some or all of their designated testimony on the grounds that (1) no designations were provided on April 23, 2008 as required under the Scheduling Order, (2) Mr. Buchholz's designations were provided only on June 2 with the filing of the Pretrial Order, and (3) for many transcripts, Plaintiffs made no good faith effort to specify portions of depositions that Plaintiffs actually intend to read at trial, but instead designated essentially the entirety of the transcripts (see, e.g., without limitation, Drewett, Eltingh, Miles, and de Villiers designations). Defendants further reserve the right to preclude the playback of any video in which Plaintiffs' counsel improperly stood over the witness during questioning and to object to playing/reading any lawyer colloquy or objections. Defendants further reserve the right to object to Plaintiffs offering designated testimony at trial in violation of Fed. R. Civ. P. 32 or otherwise, including where a witness is available to be presented live to assist the jury and avoid unnecessary waste of time or otherwise facilitate the efficient presentation of evidence. Defendants also reserve the right to read or play any testimony designated by Plaintiffs and further reserve the right to withdraw any portion of Defendants' deposition designations.

{00223872;v1}

Case 1:07-cv-00178-GMS

Document 157 Walter Knapper 10/10/07

Filed 06/17/2008

Page 3 of 14

Defendants' Designations 6:24-7:1 7:7-7:11 20:4-20:11 24:10-25:6 25:10-25:16 26:13-26:18 28:7-28:24 29:17-32:2 33:13-34:5 36:7-41:8 43:5-43:12 43:16-44: 1 44:8-45:5 45:7-45:15 45:7-45:15 45:20-45:22 46:10-47:24 48:7-49:5 49:9-51:18 51:24-52:2 52:5-55:6 55:18-55:19 57:15-60:21 64:8-64:11 64:15-65:7 65:14-66:3 66:11-66:19 69:2-70:22 73:20-74:9

Plaintiffs' Objections

Ruling

Plaintiffs' Counter Designations

Objections to Counter Designations

Ruling

24:10-26:7 HS FM HS HS HS R R R

25:17-26:7:NC/HS

R; HS

LO

54:1-55:20

HS; FM HS; FM HS FM

64:8-65:25

65:8-65:13:NC/NR

{00223898;v1}

Case 1:07-cv-00178-GMS

Document 157 Walter Knapper 10/10/07

Filed 06/17/2008

Page 4 of 14

Defendants' Designations 77:21-79:5 80:11-80:14 81:10-82:17 84:14-85:21 86:8-86:13 87:16-87:19 88:10 88:12-93:12 93:17-93:19 93:22-95:19 95:24 96:2-96:17 96:19-96:22 97:5-103:5 103:19-103:24 104:25-107:13 107:23-108:5 108:8-108:16 112:8-112:23 114:13-116:7 116:15-117:9 117:22-118:1 118:5-118:14 120:3-120:7 120:19-120:23 122:3-122:12 126:5-126:7 126:12-126:16

Plaintiffs' Objections FO; FM

Ruling

Plaintiffs' Counter Designations

Objections to Counter Designations 80:15-81:9:NC/NR

Ruling

80:11-81:25 FM FM LE FM FM FM FM; FO FM; FO

FO; FM FM FM FO; FM; PCW FM FM 118:5-120:7 118:15-120:2: NC/HS/FO

{00223898;v1}

Case 1:07-cv-00178-GMS

Document 157 Walter Knapper 10/10/07

Filed 06/17/2008

Page 5 of 14

Defendants' Designations 130:25-131:5 131:11-131:16 133:9-135:16 136:8-140:22 141:9-142:22 146:17-147:7 147:12-147:24 151:7-151:8 151:17-152:2 152:6-153:15 156:16-157:2 157:5-158:10 158:25-159:-6 160:1-160:5 160:15-161:4 161:9-161:15 164:3-164:9 165:20-167:11 168:11-168:15 168:20-171:8 173:12-175:4 180:3-181:10 182:19-183:2 183:15-183:21 183:22-184:15 184:16-185:1

Plaintiffs' Objections

Ruling

Plaintiffs' Counter Designations

Objections to Counter Designations

Ruling

FM; LO FM FM FM FM LO; FO; LE LO; FO; LE FM FM

152:1-154:6

153:16-154:6: NC/NR/FO

158:25-159:25 FM HS FM FM FM FM FM FM

158:7-158:25: NC/FO

FM

184:16-185:25

185:2-185:11 : NC/FO

{00223898;v1}

Case 1:07-cv-00178-GMS

Document 157 Walter Knapper 10/10/07

Filed 06/17/2008

Page 6 of 14

Defendants' Designations 185:12-185:14 185:17-186:4 187:21-188:1 191:16-191:18 191:21-191:25 192:23-193:7 194:1-194:24 195:2-195:22 198:19-198:25 199:14-199:21 200:10-200:16 200:23-202:20 202:23-203:3 203:22-204:20 205:2-205:9 206:22-206:25 208:15-209:3 209:24-210:7 210:11-213:10 215:2-217:4 218:3-219:14 219:18-209:19 219:25-220:2 221:5-221:22 222:7-228:22 229:19-223:22 234:1-236:22 241:1-242:24

Plaintiffs' Objections FM; LO FM; LO FM; LO FM; LO FM; HS FM; HS HS

Ruling

Plaintiffs' Counter Designations

Objections to Counter Designations

Ruling

191:16-191:25

NC

194:1-195:22

NC

FM

202:1-203:3 204:1-205:9

NC 204:1-204:20:NC; 205:2-205:9:NC

FM R R FM FM FO; FM

FM FM FM FM; FO

{00223898;v1}

Case 1:07-cv-00178-GMS

Document 157 Walter Knapper 10/10/07

Filed 06/17/2008

Page 7 of 14

Defendants' Designations 243:14-245:21 252:5-252:7 252:9-255:12 255:15-255:18 255:25-257:11 257:16-257:17 257:22-262:14 264:23-265:15 265:25-266:5 268:11-269:20 270:1-271:6 272:18-273:12 274:4-274:15 276:1-281:11 281:15-282:25 283:2-284:21 284:24-285:18 287:12-290:16 290:21-291:11 293:3-293:12 295:2-296:2 296:6-297:19 297:24-298:21 299:5-299:11 302:21-303:2 303:6-304:9 304:11-304:22 305:6-309:3 310:8-310:19 FM FM FM FM

Plaintiffs' Objections

Ruling

Plaintiffs' Counter Designations

Objections to Counter Designations NC

Ruling

252:5-253:25

FM FM FM FO; FM; HS HS FM FM; HS HS; FM FM FO; FM FM

262:1-263:9

262:15-263:9:NC

284:1-285:18

NC

290:1-291:11 HS; FM HS; FM

NC

FM 304:1-304:22 FM NC

{00223898;v1}

Case 1:07-cv-00178-GMS

Document 157 Walter Knapper 10/10/07

Filed 06/17/2008

Page 8 of 14

Defendants' Designations 312:1-313:4 313:23-314:2 315:7-317:21 318:2-318:14 318:20-319:4 319:15-320:7 320:17-321:5 321:8-323:3 323:19-323:21 323:25-324:25 331:2-332:23 333:6-334:4 334:10-334:14 335:3-335:24 339:4-340:1 340:11-340:22 342:5-342:23 344:25-346:3 346:8-346:19 347:25-348:2 348:7-349:21 350:6-353:15 353:19-353:24 365:20-365:23 366:3-366:4 367:5-367:17 367:24-368:16 369:1-369:7 369:9-370:10 FM FM FM HS

Plaintiffs' Objections

Ruling

Plaintiffs' Counter Designations

Objections to Counter Designations

Ruling

FM; FO FM; HS HS; FM FM

334:1-334:14

NC

FM

FM FM FM FM FM; FO

370:1-371:25

NC

{00223898;v1}

Case 1:07-cv-00178-GMS

Document 157 Walter Knapper 10/10/07

Filed 06/17/2008

Page 9 of 14

Defendants' Designations 371:4-372:16 378:14-378:17 379:9-380:11

Plaintiffs' Objections

Ruling

Plaintiffs' Counter Designations

Objections to Counter Designations

Ruling

FM

380:1-380:23

NC/FO

{00223898;v1}

Case 1:07-cv-00178-GMS

Document 157

Filed 06/17/2008

Page 10 of 14

Walter Knapper 10/11/07 Defendants' Designations 389:17-390:21 391:2-391-9 391:12-391-18 391:24-391:25 392:10-393:10 397:22-401:5 401:10-401:12 401:16-404:13 404:24-406:14 408:23-409:2 410:11-413:16 414:8-415:12 415:15-415:17 416:7-418:3 419:3-419:8419:18-421:22 422:20-425:10 425:13-426:11 427:14-432:11 432:14-433:7 433:11-433:22 434:13-434:16 434:21-436:7 441:10-445:6 445:22-447:21 447:23-448:10 449:10-450:24 452:7-454:3 454:18-456:18 FM Plaintiffs' Objections Ruling Plaintiffs' Counter Designations Objections to Counter Designations Ruling

FM FM FM FM 408:23-411:25 FM

418:1-419:8 FM HS; FO; FM LO; FM; FO FM

LE LE; FM FM; HS

Case 1:07-cv-00178-GMS

Document 157

Filed 06/17/2008

Page 11 of 14

Walter Knapper 10/11/07 Defendants' Designations 459:5-459:8 460:13-460:20 461:6-461:9 461:13-461:23 461:25-464:16 465:7-468:5 468:18-468:23 470:8-470:22 471:1-471:6 472:3-474:10 474:24-475:5 475:11-478:15 482:22-483:19 484:8-484:18 485:20-486:20 489:8-490:14 493:25-494:16 495:4-495:20 496:12-500:15 500:18-505:14 512:9-513:19 514:12-517:10 519:6-524:15 525:5-527:6 527:24-528:6 528:10-529:13 530:9-530:12 532:24-533:18 534:8-534:16 Plaintiffs' Objections Ruling Plaintiffs' Counter Designations Objections to Counter Designations Ruling

FM FM

FM

FM FM FM FM FM FM FM

HS; FM; LE FO; FM FM HS HS

FO 534:8-535:1

Case 1:07-cv-00178-GMS

Document 157

Filed 06/17/2008

Page 12 of 14

Walter Knapper 10/11/07 Defendants' Designations 534:23-535:1 539:1-539:21 540:21-544:6 545:16-547:14 548:7-549:13 549:17-550:19 550:22-551:19 552:15-552:22 553: 5-553:24 554:7 554:19-555:4 555:14-556:8 556:13-557:11 557:22 558:4 559:3-559:7 559:12-560:4 560:7-560:18 568:14-570:7 570:10-571:13 571:17-572:13 572:16-573:13 573:16-574:14 574:19-575:18 576:19-577:7 581:13-582:23 583:24-587:5 587:22-588:2 588:6-588:25 Plaintiffs' Objections Ruling Plaintiffs' Counter Designations Objections to Counter Designations Ruling

HS

FO HS

FM FM FM FM FM FM FM 570:1-571:25

FM

Case 1:07-cv-00178-GMS

Document 157

Filed 06/17/2008

Page 13 of 14

Walter Knapper 10/11/07 Defendants' Designations 590:2-591:2 592:21-594:4 595:3-595:22 596:8-597:15 597:19-598:21 600:19-600:21 600:24-600:25 601:5-601:21 602:1-602:19 603: 8-606:9 606:13-608:15 610:9-610:13 610:15-611:21 613:25-619:11 620:1-620:17 621:21-626:7 626:12-628:16 629:23-630:4 631:6-633:20 634:1-634:22 635:6-635:10 635:17-636:21 639:16-639:22 647:7-647:14 652:3-652:11 653:1-653:11 653:23-653:24 654:1-656:3 Plaintiffs' Objections Ruling Plaintiffs' Counter Designations Objections to Counter Designations Ruling

FM FM

HS HS FM FM FM HS

FM

652:3-653:11

652:12-653:1: NC/HS

656:1-656:9

656:4-656:9:

Case 1:07-cv-00178-GMS

Document 157

Filed 06/17/2008

Page 14 of 14

Walter Knapper 10/11/07 Defendants' Designations Plaintiffs' Objections Ruling Plaintiffs' Counter Designations Objections to Counter Designations NC/NR Ruling

657:8-658:3

658:1-658:7