Free Response - District Court of Connecticut - Connecticut

;; lllt *4*5 Fled 08/08/2006 F’age1 of 4
.-¤ U l c ‘‘‘‘ H c ‘‘·‘ t ‘‘‘ =F ‘ =·i· ---- ·_-; - ---1 .·A 1
. `, `
.-‘-‘ 1 1 1 1 1 .1. 1 1 1 1 - 1_.1 _.1;
Dl1}1CAE\e {11};.-NEiR1&L MOT()R‘s (URL. 93;) 1_-:.=. ; 1 =“ ’‘·A ‘ "
Eji eztessses md sas (§§1hCir. zoo;} ‘_‘ g§Tj,f
.`=. . . _ -2 .·.= li-?
tgps, leereti et iz;-.1· breasts. sed touched dzd not show e sexually lmrasslng hostile
1 1 1 1 1 1 . . " 1 ,-1.,
._ lee.: arm, lingers, er mzttocits er; tour sees- envzronment suifmerztlyz severe er pervss - g
..._ l I _ ll 2 ll ll 7 ll ll l ll l , _, M. 1. ij; _.... ,, .1,.
si.Qi15}1€f¢‘F"€· @#4-‘f·1¢<1l1 =>-3% l»é1»51 l$’¤?$1 Mil SLT11 sz-ve so te ester tne eondzmons ot her - . 1-
1*** `! r ' ¤ ‘* 1 ’ " . " ,. , f' ,, _ , · · v " l.
‘1i_ 4;:9. L-ili·<}1=l@ 3W? {W9?}. Jiiéf-CK ?»1 ·5l1f¤`¤~ employment, a i:12.1luz·e test dooms Dunw - -
-;;‘ mg He.-tgps, {nt., 1%}-1 I- .36 5212, ?>Z3—£~i1 2>2i¤ oeufs hostile work envxrenment claim. See
" tlviii {1-of-l *V€`*U$U*él‘ NY}- *¤¥`*lKL dm} l—U$d‘ Me-r1t‘m·- 1;w,e. Homie, FAB l»’z.ms . . 1 - 1 1 f ·-‘- ies
I mg behawaor merely otienszve and msufliv {gg 57: 67, {gg; ggyggtl 2;;%.;, gg L_ggd_g{] gig -
cient te support hsstile ezwironment claim glggigg iii .
-"-_ wiaen empleyee reached scross plasntnl, 1
stating "{n§othing I like more in the mo}-n— B. Constz·ueti=1>e Discharge _·
1f _- lllg lllall lélllll llllllh liillllll *’l'§lllll$;§ll lglrl [14+17] GEVEL also challenges the Jsrys 1; ._ _ j .
~ ‘ >* = 1; -· 1 1 1 . 1 . · ‘ --` · -
._-. E, ¤}1E§§€»‘¤Y*`·€ IM "uQ`g€"·l€ mn? dml-li ll ai finding that Duncan was eonstz·1.1et1vc2lj,=
..'1 parcel lll lgllll be llllllrlllll ll`l°lll°llllSlllllll*l discharged An employee is cerzstruetivelv -¤-`- .1
-----3- ""*"i*—*““e" OY ""l"‘-‘~’i¤ P€ekS"$ M asked élgcharélgd 111111 111-ee?111111 1911111111 11-1111 @111. l c ¥z
1 1. 1 - 1 1 1 · — — - 1 - · -=-. 1 I
1 .-1.= W rent Wm there be m‘d· 1 ’ ru ht d·‘nem 1 1 , 1 -
11 ll l an _ l’ _ dl fg °l gl ployeels workmg condatzons so mtelersbie :¤_ ·· -
on the tebles.1 wlule dzscussmg property mat thc (sm 1U._€€_ is fcfbgd to UR Sw _
see.? 21 biker bar}, cc-ri. denied, 522 U.S. ??/déqfsgqii 5 im}? mmm FOLQS (lim; 91,7 l -
SSB; .128 S.Ct. 172, 139 L.3d.2d 114 (1997); F gd 612 617 (gm Cir 2006) AH GAP} -
..11 Wetss ez. Coc:¢:r»~CoZtt Bettlmg C0., 998 Rid , . ’ . 1
=--- - ., 1 .1 - 1 . 1 ce s dtssamsfaction with workin conditions ‘
= 533, S3! {ith C1r.l993) {holdmg ne sexual { t mm- h at ti gd h 1_.
. . . 1 1 toes no es· xs 21 · n` ru tv- 1sc er e.
.·._ harassment when plsxnuftls supervz-sor Q TE H W my llg I . 3
·... asked §)l2l1I1t1fll for dates, asked1abot1t-her ’;;& é9;l’€49lf giyglfl 9;__€lll$" bll°’
_‘1__ persona? life, cslid her a "dmr;lo §:>lond," " bl “’ ll ( ll lll‘ll lll _O ll lll“‘ll`
`:-‘ put is-is hand on her shoulder several times, llllll‘l ll dll lllllplll} lll). ll‘l‘l‘ °lll Ollllglljlllllll llllll
piacgd 111 ROW was gig?} gi hg WG?}. to assume the worst and not to jump to
stgmon, and attempted to less her twxce at “lll°lllbl°lll‘ lllll qlllCl`ll:l‘ All Qllllllllylrg whe
1 · ‘ · · » 1 1 1 1 1- 1. ·1·1- ‘
wgyk and Omg in ,1 bm., quits wxthout gmeg [her] employ, E1 11 red-
‘ , . . . . SOTl2¢l§JlE chance to work out a problem has .
Booths echoes were boemsh, (Il7Hl}‘vl`1T115'·~ mt h t if i d, E d ,, ez
1 __ . . . een 1 cons rue we isc mr e .
tie, ami deexdediy 1mmeture, but we ezmnot _ 1 ll N { g __ -1·..
·_.._ _: _ . _ . _ 1 Summit tr. S—B Power Tool, $23 E 13d éllb, ‘1’1 3
1,,;;, they crested an obgecttvely hostde 421 (RQ? (V H9? _ t I t _ ._._ _
1 1 1 l 1 ‘ -= · · ‘·‘; 1
s$re1*k envzroentent ermeeted with sexual ll ll {lll Qlllll) {lm éllllllls . 1 _
` omitted) ce-rf denied. 59% US 1004 E18
li_&r;1SsH1ent. Constrtzing the evidence in Q C_ · ji 1 é-OI gi . b Z 1·_» _
the light most llELV€.)]'{:¥,l)l€ to Duncan, site `_‘ 'l‘ ll5`l'°’ l` “‘_ “ Md {lll (lll‘ll°l‘ ll , , ·
presented evitle-mg 01;- {Gu? C&mgmES Of lmlole, (IMC sms; have xntended to toree
§$_aSSmg Conduct bamd GH my mx, 3 Dunesn to quzt ot at least nate zeesonably L_
glnéziie request 5111- 1·ei11ne11slx1»;1. which l°*"**l“l“‘ lll-l"*'*&“S ’-`€$l¥?“*ll‘*m gs 3 C‘*“E=€" ` -
was Mt ,.€p@m€d wmm Sm ;,.Qb¤{fQd in ouentc ot the v1o.r1<;ng <,ond1t1er1s at GMC,. _
{GU? or Eve isolated incidents of Booth SER Pllllllllg Twill Blllll Cmllh lllll Rgll - l
w:¤‘ ·- -1 -, /-· - —s· 1 -1» - $3* 1s'- 1
E§y*i€B§» muchmg hm, ?,_m,d’ 1.,,,11,/,651 m tsérsl, 2r1€)U{_2§tl*1 (111129%;. Dunczm contends .
drew zz paenter, end tessmg an the term et lll-ll elk fe-‘~€<* GV BY €‘~*·‘<-> xfeme U-? h cli gostcr sz-ad laelxers for sn amogmsry eszb. mf-HY DY B0¤¥f·1 \-Yliifll l¤»T¤¤&`i¥1¥l im-1><% -
gg g£I_}E}&·[.E1}·§€_ {Chai; Qlggg Igggggqgtg li:} te Flézsigli li': \;1(2Vv&`tll I
Burtesn uneomioztelcae, amt tides de not lll the Etgnt most rzmsrebie to her, Dum _ _ ; 1-
1 .1=1 -_ iiieet me standard necessary tor stetgnngtiggg csnls veoxiong concimons were toxmsnly not 1 1_ , 1 - - .-11 -1.’
-_1‘ $Q>¢,Ll$£l ltsressmeetl lt wm‘t1l1notmg that l(l€2$l and in mztejy instances the e2wl1"<>H- 1.,.- ‘: .Z_ .=--1.‘
¥ mean fees ts even atdslress tlns compte meet timt Dumezns endured at G11\»§C mts _1_- ; 5 _ 1 _1111-‘ 1
_11. -1 . a, . . . . . 1. 1 1 . - - j__ ·- -
.2 ._.1 Wilt ol iter gsr-one feels case ze her lyrmei. eire;ss:¤:e and dzsrespectisl; laovvevw, ;. _..- -_- 1_ -51; 11
1-is 1.1, 1. 1 , 1- .- 11 1 1. . 1 1. -1 . ,11 --‘-.1-‘ ‘
____ ,:.1.1: .e <,1.oe111._i1<. 11 1r11211t1.z oi. me test set. ,.n<.s<. co:;d1t1e11s were not so 111t1a11ere.i1lt. as nn: ,E..
1‘- ·‘’1 ‘ l ‘-.-
1 =-_ : r _ - Q. L- 11l= Z-
J - 1-`‘
.1-‘ 1
f- 1 - _. 111 --1: .---
-·-- =-- ·; ---1- c1‘1 ‘1g=2

‘~..‘= 5 -·r‘ - 5 '
Z22 1 24-WIG Document 147-5 Fnled 08/08/2006 Pa e 2 014 ·-····
:-5 5 s 5--i5;=5¢§§%
@35 ' ’" 1 ` " a K 5* bkgms
5255- - ‘-‘1‘ ·‘·1.· -
;5¤ - *.--· - ::5 ,-.. 5 5S ._.-
ees.--5 .;.·= -·.1 . =‘‘:‘
$55: `·:. .._.5 T.- an aauaa a raaauaahia param an ramgn and ?:araa§.i'}. Duncan’s aunsxtmcaiva di-s¢}g5
5255 -i‘ 55 <5¤¤¤<>5 awww we swan 5-n¤%¤¤2;s *50 ian gum aa.- B. mm- qa aa-. ..--
§5j`= 1.·· i em aww- "fx ~5-;-· ai . 8- . - - ·.-·¤
2}. 5 ..-’=‘ =.== ji =; ‘ ‘ . 5` 5m"‘ QC vg mx fjygg W Bac:-nm;2 wa held thai Duncan
525 5- 5- .. rguunas crinszziwably mare prac? ahau an ~ 5 .» . . -.=1
-.·.· .- 1 v 5 _ - myth méizczané av1dana·a in
_-Q. ..._. . unplaasanu and unpz5<;>iaaa1ana1 anvzmn- ma i.__Ci,§ (wg iw? Qi? V Q Q .5, __;_
gi-.- .-;-`_.5_.__5.r..-. .5 if- ’‘.* .. Q m at »> J€,_,y2é.Q :2; F6 cl ii éuwf, S w 3* 81 L . an M, K. 2 . \-HJ AI _;5g5g€’ .·._
5 ¤‘- - . ·---. ._ 5. G. I5 . .5 5*9*/’”5555j* gw md M5 {aaa- a imma -1-1--H-;-{ ammm-a
Q- ` 5- `5 W6 a&5¤¥»?¤ CHQQUZ). - . . ._ ._ ..-. E? - ...-. E
5 5 - ·- I ii. . D Y __ aha was c —‘·.‘ ·5 .- --5 ·· , · i - 5 _» - . . . . .. T .- -5
if . . - $3 M §mm· ";C‘“j`t ‘ lf mn g LQ C‘M{*_ & emma, vnihuuz daczcimg, {OY pa1z·pu;;g2q-5 -··· gg¤gi_ ; -‘-· 3
- raaacsnn 8 8 B1 um v 0 · 5; 5 · . 5i 5---·i
·.-- 5 - - 5 "’ . pp ~ .° "`5‘5`*` GH? FTE 5555555 aaaaa-5 5*55555 @55¤€55¤ G-M5*$’S ‘`1-
_ . pruhlam mth Bunch prmr La aubmxmng -5 { .. - ;
-· ·- · . ~ - 1 · · 5 l¥”‘??’Y*‘$€· .I¥” ¢d -- 5 ha? z·<2s=_1gna1;2aa-. After: me Apmi 1 mezaétxig . , . - ...-·.._¤
5 5 5 with Pjikmgion Bwxwyigh gmé Bama thai Duncan S ciamas Ea}? I-2.8 a m8t€€;r. . -.-- .
if- · 5 `· ’ ‘ ’ ` -- 5 and juggqqgm; {gun; hg qgg'{gy€§ in nv ‘‘='·-·‘
Q5 P5“555*”g’“’“ ‘““““’“*“5*5“iY *`*"”55“‘*"**“i mg pm;5 Gmc 1-E mea-i mt adam-- 1-aa ( ue;
‘.. er from Bnuiifs office and raquas-aaé that .’ 5 ’ W ·..‘
.._. FED C E. __ _ . . . . mama advanced bv GMC. 5 5
I--_ _; _ O£3I'C12“1e1$0l MOQ£I€HhG£f iD€g'1Z"1 H.?} 11% “ 4 5= - _ .‘‘_ _:_._;_;.-§
- - MESLIQQZEQR. Thzit Apr-;} I m£i€£1I'1g 3%*% {X16 -15 $2;; =-.--ze;
=-· 5. .. - - . . IEE, -- 5. =‘‘ 5
5-; firs; tame chat- Duncan had cumpiamad tu _ · 5 5 .2 -2.;
,-·= . . . 5 L a -- W5-il-e`·5.= ·».-`·
:-·_. GMCES.-Inzmagcmant Of§.{€13lS who had the BOY ibn f0}”€*.>‘%Umg Y`€&$€*?1S, we
· ·. . · 5, _ · _ -»u -{ · -5 ---»-- .5 --·=.-_·=
piggug, ;\§€,q;1i€ph_qg‘f:;;,gk€;; Bugiggyg {-0 pm,. mam-2r uf iaw.5 Because GMC sh50uI§5f§§i’§.§-:.-;5_---:5_
35.55 - zvara 55 writcan summary nf Mr aiinaauam-5, pfamiéd 0551 585 uvafifiai mai-i<>¤» fha :5-
-- . .- . , . ..__ _
- · 5 aha agreed to do gs, bu; sha navar fulicwcd OE-3*>*$0¤"¤·@}FS’ @*28 IS ;*k€““$G V3‘mt‘=i"}» -.-·.‘
5_ through and had nai; submiitzeci any writ- · *5 ` .'"`
tan aliagaisiuns at aha time af har raaigna- RICHARD S- ARNGLB, Cmzmt -_‘-_
5-:5; {ion. Given that tha "p01iciass underlying d1$S€‘m-wg- . 5 .- ‘:_-
.. ................ .... . .... . _ . F · , . . ¢ - . I I r { I_; ;.;.éA;;_·_ -:55:;:
Txtia XII wxli ba best at-zryad [when] The- C<;·5mu·‘z concludes zha1;·ihe5 ..·_
-‘·- 5 -'` ' 5 ‘ ‘ `- 5 . ' *5 - . . ‘’'‘ y .‘``
;- unlawful dzscr1m1ua1;1un_ as attacked uuthm mgm; Sugfm-Ed by gx/§S_ Duggan was H,g,§*§§-5 --_..
5 · · . . 5 · · 5 -. . . . ··.=5
aha °°“*°{“ gf *=><5=555¤a .‘5’5“¥’*°Y”"5"¤’5 55*513* Swain an parvanvn as 5¤¤ ain-=r 5255
_. £*€”`*=h1P$» W? €f’**€1“d€. thai Du“€‘=m faimd cnud1t1c>u, an pznalaga of har ampl0@ma§£$5--·.. .4-‘ i
.--·- 5 · ·5 5 -. - · _ . . . . . 5
Y5° p’.‘Y"*d€ G?Y“5 "m‘.& ‘“&*"mb1?-“m" ***5 and *55355- ¤h€Y<5f¤m» GMC 5S a¤5¤n1aq1..5-4.§a.5 . -5·..‘·
&55€aa5-5% juugm-ma as a mm- of uw an -ha- Z5-55 /5‘5
$-525- · 5 · » ·; —* 5 ·‘ · · . . . ‘`---· i
15.0 sgzgaiamani -b1g"211H(`Z?.Hi, ghangas in har ;HE_wOrk_EHV11_OHIU€nt and. €UHSi;@€§§§§_. ....
I ‘ ‘ ‘ , . · 5 — · ·‘ . - ei .‘·` ”
Q"}? 5 "°;f€“.`*“;*T§“;41 dCf£g‘“;,/gf; d1S¤h¤?a¤ ¤iB-5=¤S- K 559-=2¤€¤5f¤!¥5si wilbaaitéa.
``‘` W-? ‘€?`i @5***28, - ·, . ‘5 - _. .
-5 mi)- gg.-; greg; pg-pay 4. gegmyég C;w.m.£ €~€1“%€S @..1:1;: ants a saxna1hara*%sn2@!3;§eQ<;I¥-_ 55.. .= -.‘=-=.
5- · 5 - » =— 555- ' ’ ` "‘ xm · » 55
· 1-mx., 1:26 ma 1019, uns mu ca-.1997) ha5~5¤¤1‘k¤5&<¤<5- €¤555€ far béym "a&553*5ia5;-5-55.55:
_- _ __.. ._-. i‘ {Uhuass cund1t10ns are beyond ‘u1~<:I;hary mlamd J°k°S_ md °CC&b’{m·a1
55; ’._. --... ...-.`.-- -5 --.- <%is~cz··imina%.i -- _ cxpactaca to ramam un the gah \&·’;'l1i<2 seek- ‘7G> {885 HS SEV- 2270- 141
E.? mg mdmSS_»>' Wg aim mmjigdg ghgt {1998} icrkaigxun amittad}. When
5 Duncan mia uu.-Q taken steps ai-wrt uf ¤Si<1€5"¤ - 5- . . . . . . » - . . . · . --·-5-
- 5 5- ra$1g5n:1€5zun as nnpmva ha;-· ‘»’£7{}l`§{1D§ cond}- Qbhi in Emi`- k-HU *5}*9 ES .€%W€¤ $19 b€H 5 mma, but sha dachhw iu cm so: Dzxncan 35} 1”€€~¤50¤¤bi¢5f €¤f€¥'<·3f5€€S5 KIWFQ-
Y mjacraci the C<>}}aga’a <;»f`1“8r in iransfar har Sf»4=¥1€iH? éévidcnw *:.0 ausaain the ca5u$s23&5Q§
. gg? - an an aEta1·na;iva wuvk Eneaiian. Amag, acii0n." S;0c!c·n·:.a-a Li-zmsiucéi ;’vfL!»%°?¢?$
- 1 4 »~ .- . . - - . . Y .. . - .. -. - ‘.·-=
- -5 236 i`--Ed 2% r}ii·5{d1acuaszng altarnat-1ves tu {nc. 2:. évu-rweaé Rami: 035 Sams; {Big, 5}Q~§§
. ,. ......`- 5. _ . , _ _ .7 . . , G ., E Y _ ` _ _ _ ._ .
5.‘_ ¥`&M£*?*-Y-i<5¥`¢ i>YWi12ch gziamznf dui nai avau Edu 12.30, 3240 {uhh €Tu~·.19E58) {caanum
_.._ `; 5;-_ - .5- ; · .. .- ..- 5 -
.; 5·‘= : -·--.·· ==i.i*:L¤
.-;. = ..... 5-.
.5-5 I 5 -555
Q 5=.- ;
.5; 5 55 55 55 5555 5 ..... 5 ...... . .... . .. .... .. ..... ..=..5 ...... . ..... . . .... . ...... A.... ..... . .... ....... .. .... . . . . ... - ...... 5555
5-5-=

· E=; ‘-·-Q -· ‘’
ii. =.· _£.‘ 4
·j‘= ‘
‘- n `’·`
i3t?3~ECAE•{ v. GENERAI, MOT(`3RS CORP. 937 ln H
cue as soo me we ments:. zeozg ig-zi .`-’_ ’
-fz;-¢»;‘ .. s eee! .3 "‘-
···- . 4 .4 4. . . . . . 4 4
·-_- §;ma;;.g;d,:. le Ms. Ijtmcans case, 21 ger}: romneht elssms premlsed upon iacts that 5. _
peselxed the (?tlIEii§’tESl()IE that hir. Booths {hi} Letuct detezxmnes te be equally or j ="= -.: 1->~;¤s -»=¢ ·---
_- gqgg..g;£ens1ve behavtor created a hostue work more e;>;reesotts" [Hill; the conduct st. ISSUE gy -
. . . - - t - -- x ` ```' . -·
sm:11-o11naem.. .l heheve tins (§€3z,{?I`}'Xl]I'l2iU€>il jqigre i (io gmt agree; 5;-,;;;. ljsygekm
_ _ f. _ 1 . . ,. _ , . . . ` . -`·‘
2‘f¢k¥-bilwbisf sl-il ¤=Ul?¥“~*¥V-d li} emelv experxenced less sevc-re harassment than 5-;;
e$·Hl€11u?- those plalzztuts. E er example, 111 Weiss cy. - g;
Ms. {Duncan wes stxbgecteo to at sexsaa C-GC€t~(.-Ole Htsiilt-Hg L-0., 990 F`.2.d ds-Se (sth
3,gx-ance oy her supewzsor w";th1n of t.-tr.1EéEJ.3), the plamtlil dtd not allege that _
.·.‘ beginning her job. This ;.u·opes§tion oc- her wtyrk duties or evaluations were ditter- .
·;;erre . .. . . . . . . Q _.‘-_ .· _‘ ` "·"‘ ""
request ior a sexual relstzehslup. The sztuatton Ms. Duncan faced. Smhe was gw- _- =
(hurt charactezmes th1s mczdent ss a sm- eu speculc tesks ot s sexuahy charged ‘-
z·eqaest,“ ante at 935. Thus descrlpttos mature, such es typing up the remotes oi . H
·-.‘· ‘- ‘- · - » - » · ~ E§-iZ‘§.`€*'*Y%`.- ~,··
rnmlmzzes the efi-ect of the sexual advance the "He—~Ma;’1 Women I-leter’s bleh? Per- .
-`·` *' . -. ,. ·. , . .· : · . . - - .- .·
-.£:¤¤ Mb- DUN?-dn e `~‘~0Yh-U15! € Q th th- im 1 >diatel follnwln this - - · · ‘
@2 9 mm? ‘¤ Q €- -.Y L g — her es a requtred duty of her Jeb.
incident, Mr. Booth became hostile to Ms. c . . 1
. . . . . Also Ms, Duncan wes subjected to alle-
; Dumzazs, mcreased h1S erttmclsm of her . ‘ _ . ‘
- _ ,. -. . . . . - gzttmes that she was professlonaliy mcom- ’
_=-..-. work, and degraded her protesswnsl eepa- __ -_ _ ,, Q V r f
E..‘ sees in em or as- pcm. semleeely, bff"“*J‘i gf ijfx 2;* 4;;
" . . . . , t 1 TO me o tt tc ceour .t
there xs so suggestzon that tlus hostde 81 ISM -?_ {wth C_ ) 7* °d’ TL 28
. ’ t ‘x . ’ — o tv xr. cen. eme af
.¢`-. . hehevsor occurred before Duncan re- .; __ _. ’ , ._[ . _ . 4
_ . _ I . ·. , U5. EB63, 120 S.Ct. 395, ]-ie L.}1ld.:Zr§ :3%
fesed hts request for sex. Prem th1s eu- ( _ _
'.·' Hesee. a. §ury couid easily drew the infer- QQQ`3? (1 gym; ee the lac? ef Such Hlyigav
-`‘· em eee ws. ems Changed his mtime mnt m ‘““’“"“g g"""" ‘” *“‘“"*“"°’ ·'““*%‘
:`Z;@3“.`-ebtaut Ms Duncan’s work because she re- mem fe Gmploymll She uddmgd EW- ‘
»-::2f - · · L * - t t ~ -. · - .. - "é:-€¢¥-ix-? -
.§é€t@d me qexmli gdmmg dence oi tlus factor when she testuzed thet
=;‘ .- .. . after she rejected hls sexual advance, Mr.
l=.- lrurther, thxs sexual overture was not an . _ , . .
. . . . . Booth became more cratxcal of her work. .
esoleted mcxdeht. it was only the begin- ,_ . . .
. . _. . . Vmth the request for her to drew the plant-
.=.;_ t meg of s stung of degtradmg echoes that { t_ NI D ‘ i, G -
‘ . ' f er or ·1 rome sou, s. unesn uigo acc
.-.. Mr, Booth dzrected toward Ms. Duncan _. (E Ypth , I EL h “f`
'=~- . . . l cn uc ··t wo-tz > r .- - -..‘;z;?"1”
_;j 4·.· . hesed on her Tlus 1nspprepmate he- {ii. 1°_ dh Lgrgvqlt NU fm} it?
ez. 2:- . . . . c-:e4 ¤ -7 · · * 1·‘ · - - - - ------
h2‘LVi(]I’ took many lorms, lrom physmai i?1g§?€ (1; Gl I) JLL- ‘3 ‘*°i1;“H'H b -4...
i4>u¤;*bime; to socaal lmznzlletmeh to exuetienzti ;;’mfP1( Hwuu mm? puml fw m L (°m“ - . .
S -` - - ~ . ` " l- ;‘. -· L " s'-
@55;;; ._-- iii-ilrntdetaen. For example, Booth re- ‘I (d"L“m‘* y* L` Dumm mq pmpfm .
= ‘- .. . . . . *_'- A “ ‘_ ~ » { ; — --3 Y-A - I . ‘ .-;gf~Lj___
.. ‘;§e&tedE_5J touched Ms. Dunceu meppropre Lwmod EU :“i€‘Gp W th es *‘mpE0}"l= “d‘ dt
‘ ig:.;.` :_. _ _ _ `“-W6 . . ‘ Y . _ é Q v ._, ., .. -- I _
éiiely on her henci. He puhhely smgled her 5*;* 3 mum JUL mddc by MM Sh°phmd'
set heiore. he? eoileagees ss at Man He- Pmally, we note that tn Ms. Dtaneems - -
i .§;;¤:·§ i-*`?2‘” who "m-dst. always be as control ol” case the acts were dtrecteu spe- - .
$éX- ile reaguned her to choose Lnetweeh {;m;;;;ily Eu my Tim Mmm in HH-Kei: ._;..=. -
-. 1---_. dmm1lg tt valleys- planter tlxsplalyteti tn ms je.m·l.g .[{tm-tes. IU-1 ined 622. 8:21; (sth _; -.
..-. 2- . - . - . - .- . . . , ,.4. , .,, .. -‘·= . .
-[;_ Qi;;i‘ §mm"? UT mi mins! CGm*“§€l'€(i iw? it ll}? (.11*.3. ce-lt. ciemed. z>22 Uh. Seo, iles ;t>.(...t. . .
’? “"=‘ Z` : · · — w L ¤ · . . " `/’ · ‘ ` `
.%??§t;<.>n, as uniazr ehotee tnet woetd lzkely jeg, gggg L_gtj(g_gd 114 {wg?} Seats.; {hm ..
._-. -.-. . . ’ - ‘
·-.·- -=;-€lYf1i :.. in F ...¤ . . . , = --.- J ‘
*B¤¤‘--‘i` CMM-*l" ?¤€l‘¢m¤¥*I??€l*¤- tut se‘p;..aort4ed the conc2ltasa . z . - - · - » - . . =‘- 2 -.-· - ‘ .- -‘
·.=»l`¤e- Loort tutes cases ua whach our sister ten:-lam.s eoedttct. het. severe enough i' n `T ` -‘ `. ''`..' *
_._- -{e1Y‘<·u1ts have 2-etectee lEOHtll(·?—\-\“€..>?.`h~tElEVI~ ts create iiCE1(}lE&l?i§3 heme. bv cohtrztst. m ;. . _ ,_
lr . y M tw .
.; ‘ --.-- _-._.
?`.’.:: 1 . T-? 1 `‘‘.
‘.=: I`-.- 2* -...=· i .Q:i€Z
. -== `.--. .-...o_
’ " .-’.
-.:- ‘ ·-
¥ --`‘
‘ ` `

- .. Q4 .- . -. - ,.,vr Q- -; .
==- 1 24-WIG Document 147-5 Fnled 08/08/2006 Pa e 4 of 4 -=-·‘
-4,. . . . ..4.%.2 QA .,4%
;2 ggg sm 21¤‘1-;m·:-R.4.1,- -121-;}-·<,»1zTE1-2, sm Seimas ;._‘
-·-· .. -- - .
-4-I *:é 4 2 2 .2 -.‘`:
¤‘-- --. . . Q ·...~ -
_§2: .4’‘ -``.. gh m·€$eni cgse, a 3813- ca-sazlzi remanablgg my cri ism zh:-at zhe jury dui mi acigqqém ··-·
*‘- ;.. ; . C . . - ` ~ - . ~ Q . 2; =‘- 2
-_ ..:1;i _·:_ mmguég {lam;-3-ig. Dimmu felt pamauleu-lg; zmly m cm-.ciu8z.mg thm Ms.
:=’= . . . . . . . .2 . 2. ·:·-:. - =--->
-__.; ymmiilgmegi zaml-de;g12·8,d&é by Bam-lm swam §]€}`\F§.l51V€`HHT€iS$m€Ht
?;_- _..Q.` _;=j ._` . iggiqmd 8;- ipecmzse aim aime *2228.8 singled Gut, ed ez, h-m$¢;éle· wcsrlc anvimnmezzek
2 ·- i- --‘=‘· .1-. l- . · .. - -. . ..
=2_- ____ -4 -‘4*’“ wg h‘“`°‘*2bm‘**`4“;· . 4 T;-;g;·¤;i'8;-lg, I {amen; from lm-; ..':
2 252{ 2 ‘ UHF <¤‘~*-”f1 C€‘»*~¤“’€’$ TNEQ wi 3¤?l”$?TUd€*-gg eonelusiwn zlmr Ms. Duncan liid
- Q, - . Q . - .— Q . . . . ., _- ..--- .=.- . -
4-- - - _ ¤¤§§€=~% 2 ¥»h% MS- Dénlml ‘?X¥’€*‘€“€@d a-ml; su-ffzczaam @$1-dance tu aurwva
4 ---2 - 4 - - Q , ·, -_ - . 2, Q --.==.‘ --·-¤‘-·
. --_ _. . . _ mmzgiz Elf]?-.B$1\€ canuuct *c0.c<>§¤t1f;u£@ 583.- ag E Hggtigy Qi mw Og my hOSt}i@.$§§§%_-.2 ......
2 . EZ ` ug] h&m$Sm&m2· FOP éxamiig 1; gmgdmg aawirazzmeni and
-- _ 8,4 Awww JQ Gaéézgiezw al -0. we re- Q · -5 -..‘-- j
‘--. .. -- Q- - - ‘i&“"“S4 QQ Q .~._
.:24 _ ze VE-31‘S€(§ B. g?8.I1£ OI Summafy _}L16g¥‘!l€H`£ {Q ER —_-. . _-__
E-. 2 2 - ` gm lu -81* awning that 3‘S¥.i]}€I'V'iSOI` who . :- ‘._.
- . p 3 ’ _ Q Q , , w 2 -2...
_4 __ _ gg "fgmilgd his geznmals 1:1 from <2f’ 8 Iwléilé - 8 gxevw-·»wsvs1¤M 4 -
Q2-; - . employee and "us€d EQWG BHC? -S€Z·G32iEy in- ‘ Y-. 2 -
-- 2 2 ---- . . . -2
4 appmprmze ianguagw could create. an an- . . - -._._
. . _ 4 Q . . Q_-_; .·--
;-.- _ mgnmanz sm-az·e emgugh m be aclncnabla .
;.§-CQ under Title: VH- 164 F-ik? 1351, 559 (gtk 2
Z E-? _ . . ` '
Cu~.199€—3). in Rom v. Um-fed Pcwwi Sw- - _ . . ,. ,
.2‘- Q . _ ·2-- -- 4- . ‘ - - 2 Shawn C. SHARES; W ayme
.-- ?,>’5¢;‘&:, Wii COI'1Cl;`£§d€€i JC;l&l} 3 WUYLZ €UVU"`9¥`¥‘ 4° Pi 4. ff A éu. ‘
. 2. Q -- 4 - - am 14 s- . as- - _._..Q-_ -
mm m much ‘3 S¤P¢mS.¤*2 { l pam 3 - pp 4 -2
`4--2 female ampiaayee cm the back, b12*ushéS up - 4 v. 4 . 22
- 4 - . - . Q ._=;2
&gm¤$'> my- 3¤¢1-EHS *‘“"F`?*€ Smells-g"°’d” ALLIEDLIFE i->z81;xANcE244-22?$2?2: =.-
cejzzlé bs; found by :1 jury E0 be 8 h08ti§8 2 COMP Dgfmdém
- . . . -4 - 1 · > ‘° ‘22.
‘·‘-2 work mwu·¤mmemt. 151 F.3d 75*2, 762 (Sth Appeigmt _ - 4 _--.__
2 :1 .--=, _ Q - - ._ -, Q -_ 4;. _-__ i
ss {jiy 1998} Es it, elem thi: the woman m -.
-‘2 4- chase Qcgse-S suffer--4 harassment gmwr - N¤- {*1*34*% - 2-2- -
-’‘. Q -- . - - *2 . 2 4 1 ` " `2 42 Q - - .
-.-- °h‘2*“ D““"3“2- i t-mk “T”‘i - 2 ¤¤14-ed S$&t€$ G<>¤-4¤ ¤f
We W 4¤k¤¢Wl¤dg¤2d **-44* "i*lm4- 8 4 2 E'ig¥¤1¤h G4-cum 4
rw bright Hm b-¥¤~€€¤ S€>#¤1¤&J.l¤¤-1222-==%r¤:=>¤t 2 2 - -· -=-
._ and memlv 11rmIaa.s;2.nt ctrmduclz, so :1 _`ll1?'yS U * *4 -· 4} 1 · ¤· - ¤+=
4 ‘-‘2 decision mm généfall-Y Si-and l-@1653 ihéfé 2 F1le2d2: Aug. 23, 280.2. 2·.-._.
=2..-. . Q . - 2- - 4 . .. .#-» 1 ..-·
;_Z 2 IS wml 81·z·01·," Hczéfmwcny ju. Ramgqan, 232 - - _ . - ---:_-
YE 1 1214 122i gah Cix'1998. We haven - - '22.4
.- *43*1 Q 5 . Q,( - 2 -.) . - . ;n-ur.-me QQ mg Sued Hyg.
._._. - so rule z a 8 nee. @11-212 ew mace-c - - - --=·-- _ --4- .-_-Q._ ;
- the deteymimgzilln of ‘Wh'ET3l‘i€`I; the comducz VV¤~§€ Falfmfint C0H€2<¤*»I¤“ LH`·‘=-
- - . -- . - ·. 4 1 2 - ---2-
.4 mm an nhl; lezvezl af abuse IS largely IH Ellfi ¤€¤1¤i¤ °€i"l&$» *51% UNIYBGE bl3<*W$= ;-.=__
....Q QQ hxmls of the jm~y." Hcwmd v. Bums CONN- for ‘¤h€-4 ·`.>0UZh8r‘i1 Dis?-Hist .2 U----- ; .2__
---· . 2 - - - .- - - — ~- Q- _2*= - -_·. ---·Q
1;-mgv 149 Fgq 835, 548 {gm {JH; Ruben W. P1 mz, J., 188 1?·.8upp.3d §& _. __1'_; 1
-. -. -. - Q Q - . . - 2 4 — ·22- 2-·- =
2. - 1%}- '1`14-E <-08121 Mlmis that MS- D4-¤¤¤¤·¤ 8“*4md #“‘*gm*’“* fm -4-%`*4’“‘*· ;‘m""" `gg?24 --Q-·-..-..--. s
_-‘` 1-wk S-¤b.1€¤¢2i2¢<> <>1`i`¢¤S<~3 io Mr- B<¤>¤“¤’== be- Pgéwl- @*2 €¤¤Y“1 G? *"~PIm?=”*· _·:.-_’
Q --=. . hgvégr ami `;1lq,»¤.;·;¢.<;t;—>1-izzas Mr. Be-¤;_§1’;=; be- Gull? Judge, held than {1-) lows; drueéwlié-j-.___.gj Q_-_
. . Q . - - -- Q , , , · . , Q Q Q Q _ - 2··2 -2 ‘`-’=
. 2- hzmsgr as ‘b<>-mush, chaazvznxsmc, and <,le<;1;l— c0¤.8tz~uct1w2 clzs-chaxge vmulcl um., ;._.. . _-._
‘ ` @{1%;,- immaw1·@." Ame mg Thus, the iesndéed €0_§1:$iii’y p0s¥;—£e=rmir1a1ti<&¤ ".-.
. Cmgrt zigygmzzrs $0 ilgrczaz that EVIY. B0a>th’$ F0? §2t‘ia1r2 mwéiatiicl l·’J?`€£aCll uf) 8g€1"1€?3¥; `-_‘=
‘ .1 begiqavmr ‘:m-gzrupcr czmmluca, I z28~ imcisg Ld; wen 12 al€>•::1;1’m<¤2 CO€.€ilYi' bf -=-- ..-.
- .- . . . . _ Q - - 2 ·22:2 __.2..
.2_. = have they (10111*1; erm 12”l éacaclmgj a mem exiaxzdgsi, zagams were 1101; c0n8trHLK¥V@;?
42 2‘‘‘ L-- --.‘2-- :..-:2 ----- i -2-
4 e Q l -QQ-QQ
2- -.--
2 - -2-. 2
--...- .- Q F2 l. EE -4‘-.
- .2-..
4 : -2‘ 2
2 .-- i - 2--‘2- ‘44’-‘ -_
-24 --‘.-- .--- ---_. .-- __ Q
44- ‘-‘ ...
2‘Q2