Free Second Amended Complaint - District Court of Federal Claims - federal

Case 1:08-cv-00269-CCM

Document 12

Filed 07/29/2008

Page 1 of 14

)678'94'!:;;:7<2'$!='>?@AB? 01234567289559:8;8<=>3?9/<@2 &6CDE'F4'(G:;7HE2'$!='>'?IBJKA 01234567A3B95:@A;8<=>3?9/<@2 #HLLD:'#4'9HLM2'$!='>'B?N?OP 012345673?9/<@2 F<=>3?9G7*4554328@D7H7*I3JJG7!/K/ !3<>98J7K9DJ9:G7FL4J987%&..1%M.. %,%%7F/*/7N4OJ=7+P9DL9 !@:J53DAG7QR77M',.-1('M) S959T=@D97U).(V7,,,1MMW% N3B7U).(V7'M&1,M.. QO7+JJ@:D9I87O@:7!534DJ4OO8

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
J92T@:3:I7<@DJ:3@:C9:874DJ@7J=97K@22@D>935J=7@O7J=97X@:J=9:D7Z3:43D37_853DA8G7U`KXZ_aV AL:4DE7T3:J7@:73557@O7J=97I93:87,..(7J=:@LE=7,..'G74D<5L84P9/ ,/ "9O9DA3DJ7487J=97[D4J9A7FJ3J987@O7+29:4<3/

!"#$%&'()"%&"&'#$)*+(,%-. /0(%12'"-'(+ 34'54!4 *4!

!"#$%&'()$*++*%,!-.)/)$0%11()23"3 %4456789:);4)+;< 2;=<8:4)"87486()!>?48:)@ABBC@DBB @E@@)!3$3)F?G4H)%I87>8 2564J;7K()-L))DMEBNCOMDP 18J8QH578)RPBOS)EEECDDT@

!"#$%%&'(%$%)&%)&$"*+$,),)-'./&

Case 1:08-cv-00269-CCM

Document 12

Filed 07/29/2008

Page 2 of 14

(/

S=4878L4J7487?:@LE=J73E34D8J7J=97"9O9DA3DJ7LDA9:7J=9753>87@O7J=97_DJ9:D357R9P9DL97

K@A97US4J597,&7[FKV7J@7:9<@P9:7>:@DEOL55I73889889A7F@<4357F99:979::@D9@L85I7T34A7?I7!534DJ4OO87J@7J=97[D4J9A7FJ3J98/77 -/ %(-&U3VU%V/77 )/ S=97:953J4@D8=4T7@O7J=97"9O9DA3DJ73DA7J=97K@22@D>935J=7@O7J=97X@:J=9:D7 YL:48A4
Z3:43D37_853DA87UKXZ_V7487E@P9:D9A7?I7J=97`K@P9D3DJ7J@708J3?548=737K@22@D>935J=7@O7J=97 X@:J=9:D7Z3:43D37_853DA874D7!@54J4<357[D4@D7>4J=7J=97[D4J9A7FJ3J987@O7+29:4<37U`J=97K@P9D3DJaV/77 S=97K@P9D3DJ7>3873TT:@P9A7?I7J=97[D4J9A7FJ3J987K@DE:98874D7!/c/7M-1,-%G7M.7FJ3J/7,&(7U%M'&VG7 <@A4O49A73J7-W7[FK7%W.%/77 &/ +J73557:959P3DJ7J4298G7J=97KXZ_74873DA7>387D@J7T3:J7@O7J=97`[D4J9A7FJ3J98a7LDA9:7

,&7[FK7\7(%,%G7-W7[FK7\7%W.%7F9<7).(U+V]7W7[FK7\7%%.%U(WV73DA7!534DJ4OO7487D94J=9:7:9dL4:9A7 D@:7T9:24JJ9A7J@7T3I7N_K+7J3B987@D7>3E98793:D9A7?I702T5@I998/77+87329DA9A7?I7!/c/7MW1,%(7 T:4@:7J@7J=979OO9@:C9:87>=@7>9:97D@J73A24JJ9A7J@7J=97KXZ_7 O@:73DI7TL:T@8979DJ4J54DE7J=927J@7T9:23D9DJ7:984A9D<97@:7<4J4^9D8=4T7O:@273DI7?9D9O4J7@:7?L:A9D7 LDA9:7J=978@<43578987@O7J=97[D4J9A7FJ3J98G74D<5LA4DE7J=97T3I29DJ7@:7>4J==@5A4DE7@O7 N_K+7J3B98/77S=4879B<5L84@D7O:@27?@J=7J=97?9D9O4J873DA7J=97?L:A9D87@O7J=97[/F/78@<43578987>387<@DO4:29A7?I7!:984A9DJ4357!:@<5323J4@D7),.'74D7%MW-73DA7?I7@J=9:73TT54<3?59753>8/ '/ YL:48A4
<@DO9::9A7?I7F9
3LJ=@:4^9A7J@7>@:C74D7J=97[D4J9A7FJ3J98G73DA7`02T5@I99a7@:7`02T5@I998a7293D87O@:94EDG7 J92T@:3:I7<@DJ:3OL55I73A24JJ9A74DJ@7J=97KXZ_7J@7T9:O@:27>@:C7J=9:9/77

!"#$%&'()"%&"&'#$)*+(,%-. /0(%12'"-'(+ 34'54!4 *4"

!"#$%&'()$*++*%,!-.)/)$0%11()23"3 %4456789:);4)+;< 2;=<8:4)"87486()!>?48:)@ABBC@DBB @E@@)!3$3)F?G4H)%I87>8 2564J;7K()-L))DMEBNCOMDP 18J8QH578)RPBOS)EEECDDT@

!"#$%%&'(%$%)&%)&$"*+$,),)-'./&

Case 1:08-cv-00269-CCM

Document 12

Filed 07/29/2008

Page 3 of 14

%./

!534DJ4OO87?:4DE7J=4873
2@:97<5388987@O7T9:8@D87842453:5I784JL3J9A7>=@G754C97!534DJ4OO8G73:97<4J4^9D87@O7O@:94ED7<@LDJ:4987 >=@7>9:9753>OL55I73A24JJ9A7387O@:94EDG7J92T@:3:I7<@DJ:3@:C9:874DJ@7J=97KXZ_73DAG7>=4597 >@:C4DE7J=9:9G7>9:97>:@DEOL55I73889889A73DA79::@D9@L85I7T34A7N_K+7S3B987J=3J7>9:97A9AL3E9873DA7T34A7J@7J=97[D4J9A7FJ3J98/ %%/ !534DJ4OO87899C7J=97:9JL:D7UJ@E9J=9:7>4J=74DJ9:98JG73JJ@:D9I7O99873DA7<@L:J7<@8J87

T:@P4A9A7J@7J=927?I753>V7@O7>:@DEOL55I73889889A73DA79::@D9@L85I7T34A7N9A9:357_D8L:3D<97 K@DJ:4?LJ4@D7+3E98793:D9A7?I7 !534DJ4OO874D7J=97KXZ_/ *+(,%-,RR! !534DJ4OO7#43D547e=3DE %,/ !534DJ4OO7#43D547e=3DE7U`e=3DEaV748737<4J4^9D7@O7J=97!9@T5987R9TL?54<7@O7K=4D373DA7

T:989DJ5I7:984A9874D7K=4D3/77e=3DEb87F@<4357F938753>OL55I73A24JJ9A7J@7J=97KXZ_738737O@:94EDG7J92T@:3:I7<@DJ:3
>@:C9:73DA7>@:C9A7O@:792T5@I9:874D7J=97KXZ_7AL:4DE73557@:7T3:J87@O7,..(7J=:@LE=7,..'/77*=4597 92T5@I9A74D7J=97KXZ_G7N_K+7J3B987>9:97>4J==95A7O:@27e=3DEb8 >3E9873DA7T34A7J@7J=97[D4J9A7 FJ3J9874D73J75938J7<359DA3:7I93:87,..(G7,..-G73DA7,..)/77 %-/ +J73557:959P3DJ7J4298G7e=3DEb8792T5@I29DJ7>387@LJ84A974224E:3J4@D7@:7J3B7

fL:48A4
@:7J@7J=97"9O9DA3DJ74D73DI7:98T94J=7

J=97"9T3:J29DJ7@O7J=97S:938L:IG7_DJ9:D357R9P9DL97F9:P4<97U`J=97F9:P4<9aVG7:9dL98J4DE7J=97:9OLDA7 @O7>:@DEOL55I73889889A73DA7>4J==95A7N_K+7J3B987O@:7<359DA3:7I93:87,..-G7,..)73DA7,..&/77 !"#$%&'()"%&"&'#$)*+(,%-. /0(%12'"-'(+ 34'54!4 *4#
!"#$%&'()$*++*%,!-.)/)$0%11()23"3 %4456789:);4)+;< 2;=<8:4)"87486()!>?48:)@ABBC@DBB @E@@)!3$3)F?G4H)%I87>8 2564J;7K()-L))DMEBNCOMDP 18J8QH578)RPBOS)EEECDDT@

!"#$%%&'(%$%)&%)&$"*+$,),)-'./&

Case 1:08-cv-00269-CCM

Document 12

Filed 07/29/2008

Page 4 of 14

K@T4987@O7e=3DEb87K534287O@:7R9OLDA7O@:7J=97J3B7I93:87,..-G7,..)73DA7,..&G7387O459A7>4J=7J=97 _DJ9:D357R9P9DL97F9:P4<9G73:973TT9DA9A7=9:9J@73870B=4?4J7%/ %'/ Z@:97J=3D784B72@DJ=87=3P97953T89A784D<97e=3DEb87K534287>9:97O459AG73DA7834A7

K534287=3P97?99D7D94J=9:7355@>9A7D@:7A48355@>9A7?I7J=97_DJ9:D357R9P9DL97F9:P4<9/ !534DJ4OO7gL424D7cL %W/ !534DJ4OO7gL424D7cL7U`cLaV748737<4J4^9D7@O7J=97!9@T5987R9TL?54<7@O7K=4D373DA7 /

T:989DJ5I7:984A9874D7K=4D3/77cLb87F@<4357F9
cL7>38753>OL55I73A24JJ9A7J@7J=97KXZ_738737O@:94EDG7J92T@:3:I7<@DJ:3@:C9:7

3DA7>@:C9A7O@:792T5@I9:874D7J=97KXZ_7AL:4DE73557@:7T3:J87@O7,..(7J=:@LE=7,..'/77*=4597 92T5@I9A74D7J=97KXZ_G7N_K+7J3B987>9:97>4J==95A7O:@27cLb87>3E9873DA7T34A7J@7J=97[D4J9A7 FJ3J9874D73J75938J7J=97I93:87,..(G7,..-G7,..)73DA7,..&/77 ,./ +J73557:959P3DJ7J4298G7cLb8792T5@I29DJ7>387@LJ84A974224E:3J4@D7@:7J3B7

fL:48A4
J@7J=97"9O9DA3DJ74D73DI7:98T94J=7J=97

"9T3:J29DJ7@O7J=97S:938L:IG7_DJ9:D357R9P9DL97F9:P4<97U`J=97F9:P4<9aVG7:9dL98J4DE7J=97:9OLDA7@O7 >:@DEOL55I73889889A73DA7>4J==95A7N_K+7J3B987O@:7<359DA3:7I93:87,..(G7,..-G7,..)73DA7,..&/77 K@T4987@O7cLb87K534287O@:7R9OLDA7O@:7J=97J3B7I93:87,..(7,..-G7,..)73DA7,..&G7387O459A7>4J=7J=97 _DJ9:D357R9P9DL97F9:P4<9G73:973TT9DA9A7=9:9J@73870B=4?4J7,/ ,(/ Z@:97J=3D784B72@DJ=87=3P97953T89A784D<97cLb87K534287>9:97O459AG73DA7834A7K534287

=3P97?99D7D94J=9:7355@>9A7D@:7A48355@>9A7?I7J=97_DJ9:D357R9P9DL97F9:P4<9/

!"#$%&'()"%&"&'#$)*+(,%-. /0(%12'"-'(+ 34'54!4 *4$

!"#$%&'()$*++*%,!-.)/)$0%11()23"3 %4456789:);4)+;< 2;=<8:4)"87486()!>?48:)@ABBC@DBB @E@@)!3$3)F?G4H)%I87>8 2564J;7K()-L))DMEBNCOMDP 18J8QH578)RPBOS)EEECDDT@

!"#$%%&'(%$%)&%)&$"*+$,),)-'./&

Case 1:08-cv-00269-CCM

Document 12

Filed 07/29/2008

Page 5 of 14

!534DJ4OO7h3@7iL37i9 ,-/ !534DJ4OO7h3@7iL37i97U`i9aV748737<4J4^9D7@O7J=97!9@T5987R9TL?54<7@O7K=4D373DA7

T:989DJ5I7:984A9874D7K=4D3/77i9b87F@<4357F938753>OL55I73A24JJ9A7J@7J=97KXZ_738737O@:94EDG7J92T@:3:I7<@DJ:3@:C9:7

3DA7>@:C9A7O@:792T5@I9:874D7J=97KXZ_7AL:4DE73557@:7T3:J87@O7,..(7J=:@LE=7,..'/77*=4597 92T5@I9A74D7J=97KXZ_G7N_K+7J3B987>9:97>4J==95A7O:@27i9b87>3E9873DA7T34A7J@7J=97[D4J9A7 FJ3J9874D73J75938J7<359DA3:7I93:87,..(G7,..-73DA7,..)/77 ,&/ +J73557:959P3DJ7J4298G7i9b8792T5@I29DJ7>387@LJ84A974224E:3J4@D7@:7J3B7

fL:48A4
J@7J=97"9O9DA3DJ74D73DI7:98T94J=7J=97

"9T3:J29DJ7@O7J=97S:938L:IG7_DJ9:D357R9P9DL97F9:P4<97U`J=97F9:P4<9aVG7:9dL98J4DE7J=97:9OLDA7@O7 >:@DEOL55I73889889A73DA7>4J==95A7N_K+7J3B987O@:7J=97I93:87,..(G7,..-73DA7,..)/77K@T4987@O7 i9b87K534287O@:7R9OLDA7O@:7J=97J3B7I93:87,..(G7,..-73DA7,..)G7387O459A7>4J=7J=97_DJ9:D357 R9P9DL97F9:P4<9G73:973TT9DA9A7=9:9J@73870B=4?4J7(/ ,M/ Z@:97J=3D784B72@DJ=87=3P97953T89A784D<97J=97i9b87K534287>9:97O459AG73DA7834A7

K534287=3P97?99D7D94J=9:7355@>9A7D@:7A48355@>9A7?I7J=97_DJ9:D357R9P9DL97F9:P4<9/ !534DJ4OO7h3@>947"4DE (./ !534DJ4OO7h3@>947"4DE7U`"4DEaV748737<4J4^9D7@O7J=97!9@T5987R9TL?54<7@O7K=4D373DA7 /

T:989DJ5I7:984A9874D7K=4D3/77"4DEb87F@<4357F9
"4DE7>38753>OL55I73A24JJ9A7J@7J=97KXZ_738737O@:94EDG7J92T@:3:I7<@DJ:3@:C9:7

3DA7>@:C9A7O@:792T5@I9:874D7J=97KXZ_7AL:4DE73557@:7T3:J87@O7,..(7J=:@LE=7,..'/77*=4597

!"#$%&'()"%&"&'#$)*+(,%-. /0(%12'"-'(+ 34'54!4 *4%

!"#$%&'()$*++*%,!-.)/)$0%11()23"3 %4456789:);4)+;< 2;=<8:4)"87486()!>?48:)@ABBC@DBB @E@@)!3$3)F?G4H)%I87>8 2564J;7K()-L))DMEBNCOMDP 18J8QH578)RPBOS)EEECDDT@

!"#$%%&'(%$%)&%)&$"*+$,),)-'./&

Case 1:08-cv-00269-CCM

Document 12

Filed 07/29/2008

Page 6 of 14

92T5@I9A74D7J=97KXZ_G7N_K+7J3B987>9:97>4J==95A7O:@27"4DEb87>3E9873DA7T34A7J@7J=97[D4J9A7 FJ3J9874D73J75938J7<359DA3:7I93:87,..)73DA7,..&/77 (,/ +J73557:959P3DJ7J4298G7"4DEb8792T5@I29DJ7>387@LJ84A974224E:3J4@D7@:7J3B7

fL:48A4
@:7J@7J=97"9O9DA3DJ74D73DI7:98T94J=7J=97

"9T3:J29DJ7@O7J=97S:938L:IG7_DJ9:D357R9P9DL97F9:P4<97U`J=97F9:P4<9aVG7:9dL98J4DE7J=97:9OLDA7@O7 >:@DEOL55I73889889A73DA7>4J==95A7N_K+7J3B987O@:7<359DA3:7I93:87,..)73DA7,..&/77K@T4987@O7 "4DEb87K534287O@:7R9OLDA7O@:7J=97J3B7I93:87,..)73DA7,..&73:973TT9DA9A7=9:9J@73870B=4?4J7-/ ()/ Z@:97J=3D784B72@DJ=87=3P97953T89A784D<97J=97"4DEb87K534287>9:97O459AG73DA7834A7

K534287=3P97?99D7D94J=9:7355@>9A7D@:7A48355@>9A7?I7J=97_DJ9:D357R9P9DL97F9:P4<9/ !534DJ4OO7Y454D7iL (&/ !534DJ4OO7Y454D7iL7U`iLaV748737<4J4^9D7@:7K=4D373DA737D@D1:984A9DJ7@O7J=97KXZ_73J7 /

J=97J4297@O7O454DE7J=487K@2T534DJ/77iLb87F@<4357F9
iL7>38753>OL55I73A24JJ9A7J@7J=97KXZ_738737O@:94EDG7J92T@:3:I7<@DJ:3@:C9:7

3DA7>@:C9A7O@:792T5@I9:874D7J=97KXZ_7AL:4DE73557@:7T3:J87@O7,..(7J=:@LE=7,..'/77*=4597 92T5@I9A74D7J=97KXZ_G7N_K+7J3B987>9:97>4J==95A7O:@27iLb87>3E9873DA7T34A7J@7J=97[D4J9A7 FJ3J9874D73J75938J7<359DA3:7I93:7,..&/77 (W/ +J73557:959P3DJ7J4298G7iLb8792T5@I29DJ7>387@LJ84A974224E:3J4@D7@:7J3B7

fL:48A4
!"#$%&'()"%&"&'#$)*+(,%-. /0(%12'"-'(+ 34'54!4 *4&

!"#$%&'()$*++*%,!-.)/)$0%11()23"3 %4456789:);4)+;< 2;=<8:4)"87486()!>?48:)@ABBC@DBB @E@@)!3$3)F?G4H)%I87>8 2564J;7K()-L))DMEBNCOMDP 18J8QH578)RPBOS)EEECDDT@

!"#$%%&'(%$%)&%)&$"*+$,),)-'./&

Case 1:08-cv-00269-CCM

Document 12

Filed 07/29/2008

Page 7 of 14

(M/

+J73557J4298G7iL7=3A7D@7N_K+ @:74D<@297J3B7T3I29DJ7@:7:9T@:J4DE7@?54E3J4@D74D7@:7

J@7J=97"9O9DA3DJ74D73DI7:98T94J=7J=97

"9T3:J29DJ7@O7J=97S:938L:IG7_DJ9:D357R9P9DL97F9:P4<97U`J=97F9:P4<9aVG7:9dL98J4DE7J=97:9OLDA7@O7 >:@DEOL55I73889889A73DA7>4J==95A7N_K+7J3B987O@:7J=97I93:7,..&/77+7<@TI7@O7iLb87K53427O@:7 R9OLDA7O@:7J=97J3B7I93:87,..&74873TT9DA9A7=9:9J@73870B=4?4J7)/ -%/ Z@:97J=3D784B72@DJ=87=3P97953T89A784D<97J=97iLb87K534287>9:97O459AG73DA7834A7

K534287=3P97?99D7D94J=9:7355@>9A7D@:7A48355@>9A7?I7J=97_DJ9:D357R9P9DL97F9:P4<9/ #+(!!'(++"1(-,$%! -,/ +87L89A7=9:94DG7J=97J9:27`N_K+702T5@I9:8a7293D873DA74D<5LA98677iILDf4D7

UF34T3DV7K@:T@:3J4@D]7[/F/1KXZ_]7Si"K$i@DE7j@DE70DJ9:J34D29DJ7UQP9:8938V7_DP98J29DJ7 cJA]7R_N[7+TT3:957K@:T@:3J4@D]7Z3:43D387g3:29DJ7Z3DLO3
U@J=9:7J=3D7J=97[FV7>=@7>9:973A24JJ9A74DJ@7J=97KXZ_7387J92T@:3:IG7O@:94ED7<@DJ:3@:C9:8]7 UhV7>=@G7>=4597>@:C4DE74D7J=97KXZ_7AL:4DE73557@:73DI7T3:J7@O7<359DA3:7I93:87,..-7J=:@LE=7,..'G7 =3A7N_K+7J3B987>4J==95A7O:@27J=94:7>3E9873DA7T34A7J@7J=97[D4J9A7FJ3J987?I7@D97@:72@:97@O7J=97 N_K+702T5@I9:8G7@:7?I73D792T5@I9:7>=@7=387A9<54D9A7J@7<@1@T9:3J97>4J=7J=9792T5@I99b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
!"#$%&'()$*++*%,!-.)/)$0%11()23"3 %4456789:);4)+;< 2;=<8:4)"87486()!>?48:)@ABBC@DBB @E@@)!3$3)F?G4H)%I87>8 2564J;7K()-L))DMEBNCOMDP 18J8QH578)RPBOS)EEECDDT@

!"#$%%&'(%$%)&%)&$"*+$,),)-'./&

Case 1:08-cv-00269-CCM

Document 12

Filed 07/29/2008

Page 8 of 14

<@LD895/77[DA9:84ED9A7<@LD8957358@7:9T:989DJ872@:97J=3D7(G...7TLJ3J4P97<53887292?9:87>=@7=3P97 O459A73A24D48J:3J4P97<534287O@:7:9OLDA73DA73:973>34J4DE7O@:2357A9D4357?I7J=97F9:P4<97@:7J=97 T3883E97@O784B72@DJ=87?9O@:97J=9I7>4557dL354OI7387292?9:87@O7J=97<5388/77 R[c07,(U3V7K53887K=3:345579B<99A7(G...7292?9:8/77+557@O7J=97<53887292?9:8b7<53428G7:3DE4DE7O:@27 k)..7J@7k)G...G73:978@7823557J=3J7 4DA4P4AL3573AfLA4<3J4@D7 487 D@J7<@8J19OO9:@DEOL55I7 3889889A7 @:7 9::@D9@L85I1T34A7 N_K+7 J3B987 @:7 J@7 :98T@DA7 >4J=7 59E357 3LJ=@:4JI7@:737?38487O@:73889884DEG7:9<94P4DEG7@:7:9J34D4DE78L<=7J3B98/77 U3VU,V S=97 <@DJ:@554DE7 488L97 @O7 53>l>=9J=9:7 O@:94EDG7 J92T@:3:I7 <@DJ:3@:C9:87 4D7 J=97 KXZ_7 3:97 8L?f93E97 >4J==@5A4DE7 O@:7@:7 T3I29DJ7@O7 N_K+7 S3B98l487 <@22@D7 J@7 3557 <53887 292?9:8/7 7 +7 <53887 292?9:b87 8J3JL8G7 92T5@I29DJ7 =48J@:IG7 3DA7 J=97 O34557 =3P97 D@7 9OO99A7 J@7 J=97 "9O9DA3DJ7@:73DI7@J=9:78L27@>9A7?I7J=97"9O9DA3DJ7J@7J=97<53887292?9:/7 U3VU(V S=97 <534287 @O7 J=97 D329A7 !534DJ4OO87 3:97 4A9DJ4<357 J@7 J=97 <534287 @O7 J=97 TLJ3J4P97<53887292?9:8/77 U3VU-V S=97D329A7!534DJ4OO873DA7J=94:7<@LD8957>45573A9dL3J95I7:9T:989DJ7J=97<53887 292?9:8/7 7 !534DJ4OO8b7 <@LD8957 3:97 LD4dL95I7 84JL3J9A7 J@7 :9T:989DJ7 J=97 <5388G7 =3P4DE7 O4:8J7 4A9DJ4O49A7J=97>:@DEOL5738898829DJ73DA79::@D9@L87T3I29DJ873DA7=3P4DE7?:@LE=J7J=97@D5I7 CD@>D7<534287@D7?9=35O7@O72L5J4T59792T5@I9:873DA7J=@L83DA87@O7TLJ3J4P97<53887292?9:87 ?9O@:97J=97F9:P4<9/77 !"#$%&'()"%&"&'#$)*+(,%-. /0(%12'"-'(+ 34'54!4 *4(
!"#$%&'()$*++*%,!-.)/)$0%11()23"3 %4456789:);4)+;< 2;=<8:4)"87486()!>?48:)@ABBC@DBB @E@@)!3$3)F?G4H)%I87>8 2564J;7K()-L))DMEBNCOMDP 18J8QH578)RPBOS)EEECDDT@

!"#$%%&'(%$%)&%)&$"*+$,),)-'./&

Case 1:08-cv-00269-CCM

Document 12

Filed 07/29/2008

Page 9 of 14

R[c07,(U?V7K53887+559E3J4@D8 -&/ S=97R9OLDA7K53887299J87J=97:9dL4:929DJ87O@:7<53887<9:J4O4<3J4@D7LDA9:7NRK!7

,(U?VU%VU+V73DA7UhVG7,(U?VU,VG73DA7,(U?VU(VU+V/77 -'/ !:@89
<53887292?9:87:9T:989DJ9A7?I7<@LD8957O@:7J=97!534DJ4OO8G7>4557<:93J9737:48C7@O74D<@D848J9DJ7@:7 P3:I4DE73AfLA4<3J4@D87J=3J7>@L5A798J3?548=74D<@2T3J4?5978J3DA3:A87@O7<@DAL@L5A7?97A48T@84J4P97@O7J=974DJ9:98J87@O7 D@DT3:J4<4T3J4DE7TLJ3J4P97<53887292?9:873DA7>@L5A742T9A973DA74D<:93897J=97<@8J7J@7J=927J@7 T:@J9
!534DJ4OO873DA7J=97TLJ3J4P97<5388/77"98T4J97A923DA87?I7TLJ3J4P97<53887292?9:873DA7J=97!534DJ4OO8G7 387>9557387@D97@:72@:97@O7J=97N_K+702T5@I9:8G7J=97"9O9DA3DJ7=387:9OL89A7J@7:9OLDA7>:@DEOL55I7 3889889A7@:79::@D9@L85I7T34A7N_K+7S3B98G7=387:9OL89A7J@7:98T@DA7J@7!534DJ4OO8b73A24D48J:3J4P97 <534287O@:7:9OLDAG7=387:9OL89A7J@7:98T@DA7J@7!534DJ4OO8b73DA7TLJ3J4P97<53887292?9:8b7<@LD895b87 :9dL98J87O@:7J=97"9O9DA3DJb8759E357T@84J4@D7@:73DI7?38487@:73LJ=@:4JI78LTT@:J4DE7J=974559E357 38898829DJ8G73DA7=387L89A7J=97"9O9DA3DJb878LT9:4@:79<@D@24<759P9:3E97J@7A9O93J7J=97<53887 292?9:8b7:4E=J8/77N@:73J75938J7J=9897:938@D8G7<53881>4A97A9<53:3J@:I7:9549O74873TT:@T:43J9/77 -M/ N@:73557T:373DA7O3
!534DJ4OO8b73DA7J=97TLJ3J4P97<53887292?9:8b79DJ4J5929DJ73:97<@22@D7J@73557<53887292?9:8/77 "323E98lJ=97<35:@DEOL55I13889889A7@:79::@D9@L85I7T34A7N_K+7J3B98G7 4DJ9:98J7J=9:9@DG73DA7J=97"9O9DA3DJb87:98T@D84?454JI7O@:7O99873DA7<@8J8l3:97:93A45I7A9J9:24D3?597 O:@27J3B7:9<@:A874D7J=97T@889884@D7@O7J=97"9O9DA3DJ73DA7:93A45I73P3453?597J@7J=97TLJ3J4P97<53887 292?9:73DA7J=97N_K+702T5@I9:8/77+7<538873 !"#$%&'()$*++*%,!-.)/)$0%11()23"3 %4456789:);4)+;< 2;=<8:4)"87486()!>?48:)@ABBC@DBB @E@@)!3$3)F?G4H)%I87>8 2564J;7K()-L))DMEBNCOMDP 18J8QH578)RPBOS)EEECDDT@

!"#$%%&'(%$%)&%)&$"*+$,),)-'./&

Case 1:08-cv-00269-CCM

Document 12

Filed 07/29/2008

Page 10 of 14

R,Q!-'#+(,)'R$Q'Q"+,"R !"#$%&'()$(*+)&,$%--.(/00#00#'()+(1++)&#)%0-.(234'(567/(839#0: )./ J=:@LE=7-%/ )%/ !534DJ4OO8G73DA793<=7@O7J=92G7>@:C9A74D7J=97KXZ_7O@:7@D97@:72@:97@O7J=97N_K+7 !534DJ4OO87:913559E973DA74D<@:T@:3J97?I7:9O9:9D<97J=973559E3J4@D87@O7T3:3E:3T=87%7

92T5@I9:87AL:4DE7<359DA3:7J3B7I93:87,..(G7,..-G7,..)G73DA7,..&73DA7>9:97T34A7>3E987O@:7J=94:7 89:P4<98/ ),/ "L:4DE7@D97@:72@:97@O7834A7J3B7I93:8G7!534DJ4OO8G73DA793<=7@O7J=92G7=3A7N_K+7

S3B987>4J==95A7O:@27J=94:7>3E9873DA7T34A7?I7J=94:7:98T96

_DA4P4AL357!534DJ4OO #43D547e=3DE

S3B7m93: ,..( ,..,..)

N_K+7S3B987!34A kM.,/W) kM)'/M( kW%-/W& k%G%%, k%G%W( kM.' k'.(/M' k'M./&( k&,'/(& k%M,/(' kM'-/,) k&M)/)%

gL424D7cL

,..( ,..,..)

h3@7iL37i9

,..( ,..,..)

h3@>947"4DE

,..) ,..&

Y454D7iL

,..&

!"#$%&'()"%&"&'#$)*+(,%-. /0(%12'"-'(+ 34'54!4 *4!*

!"#$%&'()$*++*%,!-.)/)$0%11()23"3 %4456789:);4)+;< 2;=<8:4)"87486()!>?48:)@ABBC@DBB @E@@)!3$3)F?G4H)%I87>8 2564J;7K()-L))DMEBNCOMDP 18J8QH578)RPBOS)EEECDDT@

!"#$%%&'(%$%)&%)&$"*+$,),)-'./&

Case 1:08-cv-00269-CCM

Document 12

Filed 07/29/2008

Page 11 of 14

)(/

+87E:@LDA87O@:7:9<@P9:IG793<=7@O7J=97:98T9
:9O9:9D<97J=973P9:29DJ87<@DJ34D9A74D =487@:7=9:7K534287O@:7R9OLDAG70B=4?4J87%7J=:@LE=7)G7=9:9J@/ )-/ S=9738898829DJ73DA7<@559
!534DJ4OO87O@:793<=7@O7J=97J3B7T9:4@A87A98<:4?9A73?@P97>9:979::@D9@L873DA74559E35/ ))/ 03<=7@O7J=97:98T9D9:7@O7=48 @: =9:7K5342873DA7=387

23A97D@73884ED29DJ7J=9:9@O/ )&/ 03<=7@O7J=97:98T9
"9O9DA3DJ7@D7=487@:7=9:7>3E987T34A7AL:4DE7J=97:98T94J=74DJ9:98J7J=9:9@D73J7J=973TT54<3?59759E357:3J98G73DA7J@E9J=9:7>4J=7J=94:73JJ@:D9Ib87O998G7 54J4E3J4@D79BT9D89873DA7<@L:J7<@8J8G7387T:@P4A9A7?I753>/ !"#$%&'#+(,)'R$Q'Q"+,"R !"#$%&'(7-300(7-34;0: )'/ J=:@LE=7-%/77 )W/ S=97:953J4@D8=4T7@O7J=97"9O9DA3DJ73DA7J=97KXZ_7487E@P9:D9A7?I7J=97`K@P9D3DJ7J@7 !534DJ4OO87:913559E973DA74D<@:T@:3J97?I7:9O9:9D<97J=973559E3J4@D87@O7T3:3E:3T=87%7

08J3?548=737K@22@D>935J=7@O7J=97X@:J=9:D7Z3:43D37_853DA874D7!@54J4<357[D4@D7>4J=7J=97[D4J9A7 FJ3J987@O7+29:4<3D7U`J=97K@P9D3DJaV/77S=97K@P9D3DJ7>3873TT:@P9A7?I7J=97[D4J9A7FJ3J987 K@DE:98874D7!/c/7M-1,-%G7M.7FJ3J/7,&(7U%M'&VG7<@A4O49A73J7-W7[FK7%W.%/77+87329DA9A7?I7!/c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

KXZ_7387O@:94EDG7J92T@:3:I7<@DJ:3@:C9:873DA7=3A7N_K+7J3B987>:@DEOL55I73889889A73DA7 !"#$%&'()"%&"&'#$)*+(,%-. /0(%12'"-'(+ 34'54!4 *4!!
!"#$%&'()$*++*%,!-.)/)$0%11()23"3 %4456789:);4)+;< 2;=<8:4)"87486()!>?48:)@ABBC@DBB @E@@)!3$3)F?G4H)%I87>8 2564J;7K()-L))DMEBNCOMDP 18J8QH578)RPBOS)EEECDDT@

!"#$%%&'(%$%)&%)&$"*+$,),)-'./&

Case 1:08-cv-00269-CCM

Document 12

Filed 07/29/2008

Page 12 of 14

9::@D9@L85I7A9AL3E9873DA7T34A7J@7J=97[D4J9A7FJ3J987AL:4DE7@D97@:72@:97@O7 <359DA3:7I93:87,..%7J=:@LE=7,..'/77S=9738898829DJG7A9AL
292?9:8G7J=97N_K+7S3B987>4J==95A7O:@27J=94:7>3E9873DA7T34A7J@7J=97[D4J9A7FJ3J98G7J@E9J=9:7>4J=7 4DJ9:98J7J=9:9@D73J7J=973TT54<3?59759E357:3J98G73DA7J=94:73JJ@:D9Ib87O99873DA7<@L:J7<@8J87387T:@P4A9A7 ?I753>/77 -0,Q&'#+(,)'R$Q'Q"+,"R !<#=-3+3>)+.(?%',;#&>: &%/ !534DJ4OO87:913559E973DA74D<@:T@:3J97?I7:9O9:9D<97J=973559E3J4@D87@O7T3:3E:3T=87%7

J=:@LE=7-&G73DA7)W7J=:@LE=7&./'' &,/ !534DJ4OO873:97OL:J=9:79DJ4J59A7J@737fLAE29DJ73DA7A9<:997A9<53:4DE7U%V7J=3J7O@:94EDG7

J92T@:3:I7<@DJ:3@:C9:87>3E9874D7J=97KXZ_73:97D@J78L?f987@O7J=97 [D4J9A7FJ3J98]73DA7U,V7J=3J7N9A9:357_D8L:3D<97K@DJ:4?LJ4@D7+9A7?I7@:7T:@T9:5I73889889A73E34D8J7J=97>3E987@O7O@:94EDG7J92T@:3:I7<@DJ:3@:C9:87 >=@7>9:973A24JJ9A7J@7J=97KXZ_73DA7T9:O@:29A7>@:C7J=9:97AL:4DE73557@:73DI7T3:J7@O7<359DA3:7 I93:87,..(7J=:@LE=7,..'/ *i0R0NQR0G7!534DJ4OO87T:3I7O@:737fLAE29DJG7A9<:9973DA73>3:A87387O@55@>86 U3V ,(U?VU,V] U?V g:3DJ4DE7fLAE29DJ7O@:793<=7@O7J=97!534DJ4OO874D7J=9732@LDJ7@O7J=97N_K+7 K9:J4OI4DE7J=97R9OLDA7K53887TL:8L3DJ7J@7NRK!7,(U?VU%VU+VG7UhV73DA7

J3B987>4J==95A7O:@27J=94:7>3E9873DA7T34A7J@7J=97"9O9DA3DJ7AL:4DE73DI7<359DA3:7I93:87?9J>99D7 ,..%73DA7,..'G7J@E9J=9:7>4J=7T:9fLAE29DJ74DJ9:98J7J=9:9@D73J7J=978J3JLJ@:I7:3J987O:@27J=97A3J987 8L<=7J3B987>9:97T34A7J@7J=97"9O9DA3DJG73DA73JJ@:D9Ib87O998G754J4E3J4@D79BT9D898G73DA7<@L:J7<@8J8738 T:@P4A9A7?I753>]

!"#$%&'()"%&"&'#$)*+(,%-. /0(%12'"-'(+ 34'54!4 *4!"

!"#$%&'()$*++*%,!-.)/)$0%11()23"3 %4456789:);4)+;< 2;=<8:4)"87486()!>?48:)@ABBC@DBB @E@@)!3$3)F?G4H)%I87>8 2564J;7K()-L))DMEBNCOMDP 18J8QH578)RPBOS)EEECDDT@

!"#$%%&'(%$%)&%)&$"*+$,),)-'./&

Case 1:08-cv-00269-CCM

Document 12

Filed 07/29/2008

Page 13 of 14

U
+>3:A4DE7J=97292?9:87@O7J=97R9OLDA7K53887fLAE29DJ87@D793<=7@O7J=94:7

:98T9:@DEOL55I7>4J==95A7O:@27J=92G7T:9fLAE29DJ7 4DJ9:98J7J=9:9@D7O:@27J=97A3J97@O7T3I29DJ7J@7J=97[D4J9A7FJ3J98G73DA73JJ@:D9Ib87O998G754J4E3J4@D7 9BT9D89873DA7<@L:J7<@8J87387T:@P4A9A7?I753>] UAV "9<53:4DE73DA73AfLAE4DE7A9<53:4DE7U%V7J=3J7O@:94EDG7J92T@:3:I7<@DJ:3
>@:C9:87>3E9874D7J=97KXZ_73:97D@J78L?f987@O7J=97[D4J9A7FJ3J98]73DA7 U,V7J=3J7N9A9:357_D8L:3D<97K@DJ:4?LJ4@D7+9A7?I7@:7 T:@T9:5I73889889A73E34D8J7J=97>3E987@O7O@:94EDG7J92T@:3:I7<@DJ:3@:C9:87>=@7>9:973A24JJ9A7 ?I7J=97KXZ_7J@7T9:O@:27>@:C7J=9:97AL:4DE73557@:73DI7T3:J7@O7<359DA3:7I93:87,..(7J=:@LE=7,..']7 3DA7 U9V +>3:A4DE78L<=7@J=9:759E3573DA79dL4J3?597:9549O738723I7?973TT:@T:43J97J@7

<@2T9D83J97J=97<53887292?9:873DA7388L:97J=979OO9
!"#$%&'()"%&"&'#$)*+(,%-. /0(%12'"-'(+ 34'54!4 *4!#

!"#$%&'()$*++*%,!-.)/)$0%11()23"3 %4456789:);4)+;< 2;=<8:4)"87486()!>?48:)@ABBC@DBB @E@@)!3$3)F?G4H)%I87>8 2564J;7K()-L))DMEBNCOMDP 18J8QH578)RPBOS)EEECDDT@

!"#$%%&'(%$%)&%)&$"*+$,),)-'./&

Case 1:08-cv-00269-CCM

Document 12

Filed 07/29/2008

Page 14 of 14

,%&"S'$R'"S0,=,-! e=3DE7K534287O@:7R9OLDA7O@:7J3B7I93:87,..-G7,..)73DA7,..&G7387O459A7 >4J=7J=97_DJ9:D357R9P9DL97F9:P4<9 cL7K534287O@:7R9OLDA7O@:7J3B7I93:87,..(7,..-G7,..)73DA7,..&G7 387O459A7>4J=7J=97_DJ9:D357R9P9DL97F9:P4<9 i97K534287O@:7R9OLDA7O@:7J3B7I93:87,..(G7,..-73DA7,..)G7387O459A7 >4J=7J=97_DJ9:D357R9P9DL97F9:P4<9 "4DE7K534287O@:7R9OLDA7O@:7J3B7I93:87,..)73DA7,..&G7387O459A >4J=7J=97_DJ9:D357R9P9DL97F9:P4<9 iL7K53427O@:7R9OLDA7O@:7J=97J3B7I93:7,..&G7387O459A7>4J=7J=9 _DJ9:D357R9P9DL97F9:P4<9 0B=4?4J7% 0B=4?4J7, 0B=4?4J7( 0B=4?4J70B=4?4J7)

!"#$%&'()$*++*%,!-.)/)$0%11()23"3 %4456789:);4)+;< 2;=<8:4)"87486()!>?48:)@ABBC@DBB @E@@)!3$3)F?G4H)%I87>8 2564J;7K()-L))DMEBNCOMDP 18J8QH578)RPBOS)EEECDDT@

!"#$%%&'(%$%)&%)&$"*+$,),)-'./&