Free Motion for Leave to File - District Court of Delaware - Delaware

Case 1 :05-cv—OOO22-IVI PT Document 22 Filed O4/08/2005 Page 1 ot 2
IN THE UNITED STATES DISTRICT COURT
FOR THE DISTRICT OF DELAWARE
ST. PAUL MERCURY INSURANCE )
COMPANY, aud )
PACK & PROCESS, INC. )
)
Plairrtiffs, )
) Case No. O5~OO2.2 (KAJ)
v. )
)
MALY YAN, )
)
Defeudantr )
PLAI.NTIFFS’ MOTION FOR LEAVE TO FILE SUR-REPLY IN FURTHER
RESPONSE TO DEFEN})ANT’S MOTION TO DISMISS
NOW COME piaintitts St. Paut Mercury Insurance Company aud Pack and
Process, Imc. (the "Plaiutit`t”s") by and through undersigned counsel, and move this Court
pursuarrt to Rule 7.t ,2(c) ofthe Local Rutes of Civil Practice aud Procedure to permit
them to tite a Sur-Reply to Cl€f€i"lCiE1l'1lL’S Response to PIo.t:1rjg% ' Mentomrrcium ofLmt¤ in
Oppo.rition to De/`endcmr Marty You ’.s Motion to Di,rmi.s.s (the "Deteudaut’s Reply"). Rule
7. 1 .2(c) ofthe Locat Rules ot`Civil Practice arid Procecture provides iu pertinent part that
no aclditioual papers ‘“in support of or in opposition to...[a] [fulty—briet’ed] motion shall
be tiled without prior approval of the Court .... " As set torth more fully in the brief
accompanying this Motion, because ot, inter czlia, the gravity of Def°eudar1t’s uew
atlegation that St. Paul acted iu bad faith Err tiling this action, and because i)l'l€fiI}g, on the
Defendant’s Motion io Di.smi..sxs has czoucluderi, Piaiutiffs now seek Eeave to have the
Court consider the actditiouat factual issues raised for the tirst time in the Defendar1t’s
Repiy, and to consider Plaintiffs respouses thereto.
WHEREPORE, Plaiatift’s respectfully request that the Court enter au Order

Case 1:05-cv-00022-MPT Document 22 Filed O4/08/2005 Page 2 of 2
granting them leave to file a sunrepiy in the form attached hereto.
DATED:Apri1 8, 2005 BIFFERATO, GENTILOTTI & BIDEN
Wilmington, Delaware
ilan C 11101* ifferato (#3273
Jose h K. Koury (#4272)
Bif rato, Gentilotti & Biden
1308 Deiaware Avenue
PO, Box 2165
Wiiznington, Delaware 19899
(302) 429-E 900
~and~
Francis .1. Deasey, Esq.
James B, Burns, Esq,
Deasey, Mahoney & Bender, Ltd,
1800 John F. Kennedy Blvd., Suite 1300
Phiiacielphia, Pennsyivania 19103-2978
(215) 587—9400
Attorneys for Plcrim.f[j3‘