Free Answering Brief in Opposition - District Court of Delaware - Delaware

Case 1:04-cv-01523-JJF Document 34 Filed 11/14/2007 Page 1 014
3,,, ma q),,»·¤.·¤~ab &·r·m·&J& `D'7-·E:»`\'*— ¤<:-V C.=>xJ£?.T
Pee. \w..s,—:·¤2.-z,c,-r cn`? b€·*-·¤~—··°*"~*-E‘ I
2¤€¤&.—x. B. 1'.'3"é»,.a·a,s, . l
‘q·\,,,4,·z,_¤»·Ls;x:l C..I>.. #0. cv-\— \53_g~ IK?.
*v~ L
(;cv-h·&¥.€»2>1..;,\,.;»‘=.;L. €:•‘F’A.•-1 'T4=•,-11.::0.. _ an 1
wmbeu $2.:.*-,u. \!.e=;>—•L»-J’€rf W
¢,5e¤T. ¥>¢·.c.a—1 Y>-¤.¤..·a<;; AA:) ‘ Q , ’ [
z NOV 121 2007 1
'¥‘·¥—=~·=»—¤- ?>=·~¤*—¤=‘= 1 ,.aa. 1,
. 1*102 ‘a/a 0u 0
h&¥·a·=¤>A·-we. 1 _ 4__ ____ j; ._ j a.».1..a.:. 1
n
?\·—v~z.A··:·z\;¥&,' L.-s·:¤»¤es2. vg B‘E..¥‘&,»..1b.L.q·r&'
l
'r£¤=r·z.¤»..; ¥<>¤- %»..u·u·m.¤:f 1
1
D
'i>a¥&»—-\\=·A».1~{€>' e.a··n.·w€»—q,,.;·¤- ex ¤Si.M.,`-E, A.¤·:e.;1E-...» ku. l~.c.·¤~¤¤~·-·‘4’-·‘r`{,
,36;- {Tae.-fév JM-.1}-; _L_q_L‘ `Fu¤.<¤.3(·£.?-—m1c>2.E,| Z.-1 C;-;»·a*:‘E.»;*r·z2.c.s~A. &•\PE»c.¥]:Lc,A»»*!`
°* ?°·“—‘°·"’°—•°*P‘*\ 'I , L-.z...a&x> L1 £;t°P4>.e.»\cg2.1¤~¥·~\ :2. , \-1-•—=E»‘&· €1D'T*·`€-Q Q).
"k ?»=»9.#~¤¤¤.p-.‘P»\{‘> ¤.=...»···.-za, iw-»¢\e.q Q-,\ ?¤~¢-¢~.¢pa;·.\=a\ 5 } ;_,A&& 1-,,;\q_`_, 3 _
Lmeaauamv
Bw 1¤-\€» ¥>'="J¤°6·—’•b°~·—¤’€>i he ·==·-\€»@:¢. 2.:;. A c::a~m—:-..;-2, Kwai v-{AY x—¢¤·4.¤,,..·.¤-
:E`€·“E’ "·‘°‘·"‘“ EL Basr P"€“E’°""E‘b 5* `“\*’-9 <`··==—·¤ *5, Zi- »\¤~e. ‘Z·..m:,·~a.b
L <,E_,.,.._»—,_,._,a, tezua `“·\**·" c¤.».¤ ¤$.s»-H BE- Y0-¤~:<`¤·-3 2., €.c—·.c¤e»&> €¤L¢\\·'l1'.¤.\k"\'·g;_c,..§
OI v-Qa. \>c¥5».¤1>A...ws_`,, Lau L ‘F¤·v.L ra.!¤. `31u>.—: ·..,_b_·.,_ —g_,__·,*T-¤~·¤..~v‘ 5e.-;
qa E.0-¤.\>e.·-M.; be e,uwe·g,~r·z.·»=a 1-., H; LAB pu; c_R$&_
K }‘·`€·*’•’¤€- '*l¤`°"?· VAA.»`e»L;~.\>A$.¤ ,-1, it 15, *6 LaFz.¢».*¤·¤ P».e.¤.¤a;;.a.¤>».\s¤ Ne. A M -7
Case 1:04-cv-01523-JJF Document 34 Filed 11/14/2007 Page 2 014
‘i>»~eaH1
}.».:~¤:7·.·.‘:s·a|!. ‘n:> f.b€»c.-‘=¥‘·:..c»J 'Z?-.
Y’u..¢·:·L..x‘<"a’.3*F~Z'J`E¤¤¤·'&»¤"> chu £&—;·¤.v;,~..z..<&,»·.\ b~·.» €—z.¢¤=\¤·q Lv-re nZ•>M®~=>T c.x...¤:2.c·\· l
bakgbkmve "*“»*·*f¤-cna }>~·..»b Z.'€·ps.2.»S€‘»`I gan.; .$¤·rz§—g..a,b Bw »».\·¤1»».»t>~·=¤ ua.v—r;,.2, v·gAv L. q,».,¤.—¤.¤ c..¥ E.»<..c.a$s,=·.~:·‘=.`%`-»>¤.·:.·.:,·..a. 1Ja‘<2b&.\> vv Ea, x..¤¤w..·e.‘¢:» 1
ma vc Lab euwl I>.x.u€.¢:¢\>‘¤¥=bx-‘/ r=3‘·>~=·¤2.&.¤.¤1~¤.w»\*‘¤%g&, •a.n¤¤..¤·-peas L.·-4;; rdmv L
\-t‘·!b‘·E,x..`F. }D‘€-`;&·¤\>&·~1‘¤' Y>r.u3€·& v‘é.»=5 E4u.·.as5,·g.`aa. `¥¤¤z.¢:.,. b&·`%·5¤—¥b#-•—W' $—z..¤..=5&
Legg P£P.¤”uc.&,b x\·:.;·1·s;¢,x.¥ , T··»-n NA Lf-i>`$ ;wb.¤.~.¤·z:V ` dg;. 4,·.,,a.·w.¤-<$» ··n..\A'<‘ `X- 1
c:.·¤.v·vE. vo ~\·z.-5, ¤,¥¥·s:..<·.2. "f'c»u¤.~i··¤:.·, V6? CNC-- `bA·-=v:.s ·;*;:=~·—¢b 51.-\€. ·‘-\°~"·=• '$° 1
'~2_;g,¤u,;;,C,-q~,_,,,a. are n-kms “£·=·¤é~¤r-¥=··'€-·—=‘T- ¥°‘=`-"‘·\E'-**¤ la, `€>€¤"`- Y>z.x2,$ , 2>»`·.,·_¤;,
AE. BL-‘Le><·r·c.A.=··2\E`)> '¤-va L,...v.·;. mai g-aa ‘¤··=> #*%:5*., ‘·\<>·-·¤-E-·~E»¤— L‘¥·¤-av. ¤`Fc...
bevzb €>©,•1·x¤.;a_¤¤x-·\> ‘r¤ ·-?=·‘¤·¢~=¢·, •.\a wav mz, cw Anb %¤e.¤*r na E,A¤..¤.
».:§·e>·rA—r.L=;» 1,q,n§E»E.£» c>$¢-.bA.»~w.&1[M, vg m,·;,·;· vte, bb.¢~.~g,. mh; ·~r¤ 11-QE.
‘T‘·.~;E,¤_) ¥m¤¤-ww ·¤1-\=¤=.. 3·~¤·~¤·—¤%·me·=¤—·a1·\<:.z¤·a.=¤:» § ugeqe. mevmmpq. Lak
\..A£§'F'*·-·`·f ·'=¤-=·"7 Yr:-¤s».€> E-·~¤%°—~'€·*==· vw v··z.e..2.( \>» Tnae. x~xa,b¤·.»1—x§ ..:»—m-.,\
cig; 1;, 5&.1vw·.m. 1‘.l'£.¤..»;s;¤;,,.> ,J§»¤»—»'<><.-»>¥`¥€»b vu;. Len, Mau Réacaahab
‘r¤ £s·=,c>Q_—r \-*\E.· ws Ke*.¤..1x . €>·-*<:J=T= }».<;·»:·.·z¤ '?¢z.¤w¤Su.¤· ma ‘Z.·~\¤..¤··~x&~Ls.=>‘·1z*€»~.ac.*z&*.»E>
.;,.*41 mgzab. ‘··¤·2e»w·Z.-·¤¤».;—!.
A».>sw:>a.2. vo €b··?..<·.:v··z.¤h> 6...
E>¥-Q,. %¢~•.3¥.g bah ¥‘·é¤1*;..\.» "¥¤ °¤..¢.·q··;:,q;_,'q' ¥L.»A‘r...x·v~g§
c,'$€.,. Ew.a~¢.sa. '€.·::n-\··a.t·. ~¤»\€..¢·<2.b HE ‘fE,··..uz..:.u¤ pm B1-,.b‘ ·~.w· +\&.A.£,, f
`$FAr.¤.‘€.b W `PW-¤*·r€·¢-Pi" via b~»s> .1\a.a. CQ-- »~·>z.:»¤.v:.ae. . ga.¤.~.>e$.. wr:-Y;.
.$\>».q_;, ¥.<;, am. as-u>·.u.. »\¤.\> Z- E•'€»‘€A 7'a.·.v&·J<.·> Lag, c.,¤0..¢.¤—z.q¤=, m.\;,q_g
‘:°~¤*-\> Ba $0 v».~! $·¥\·i ~·.·>¤m_.·»¤.\>»~a‘ T *\¤~~¤'€=- H5 , &i.c-#.~¤*5~?, nys. ..>P:>··=r¢»z.£$
lEc.¤1.ua.<;~= 1·.¤,-A GX \\·;.·e.,`¥l:¤=-¤.\·e,e.\‘*¤>¤.E. ’?¤=-¤·.m».¤cp Y·•·.\C.€>a.\$.52.5;°‘1'E¤··\ 32; we b&`¥E»¤b.¤.m·& ‘v$&w‘.x:...u:>¤-:—/.
1
1
1

Case 1:04-cv-01523-JJF Document 34 Filed 11/14/2007 Page 3 014
l L•·‘•25~·.5`€»P- W E3·a.<;:vr.¤·:.1~x K
`€>·e.71'¥e.».>t>¤...yr Bu-.1.ae* .L·:~..·¤-=.¤1.ve. ..:>a¤.e. Enuaaeavé 1
qa bzjrggbhgvtgzeasé vasab 2-¤ ‘¤·}€ v~>¤.c»u·;;» Lab EL.; €.&.c£»&%`i=> cri?
WE 1.-¤.~.:> gh v-\e.¤-€·`» wee Qc Aaah ’T¤¤P. 1>·.t·¤1—».·:.¢.1¤`—=r~¤»¤»»¢;~. QTY- `¥¤c>.¢.a Ear `
cA_,b__.;’ qa b;,¥E,,_·;},A,_·,—`- 5»`~.re» -51;; ‘?·°L-¤·.·z..¤··r*zI‘?4‘- 1-lA—sr...r1·x¥.•—\t> T*·\_*c""' °
nS(¤u;‘,e~v=Ep.1:·A*z.q¢» Ki-ixkvgna was ¤J€%··1"¤JL E»<..»·\z.5.aLTvEJ:>. *7******2-'*€~ "~(5"°‘*`*·*·‘
up `£.-wemazawapev use U5-~—¢e>·.1~=a>—:v-»`1—a.¤.. *X?—·*·€» bw" ?>¥'-Ki-5* JI
q'_Ar.¥_H_5 K __¤_M> yawmwlobuw w_c;,`..¤;~<~¢ é Eamon; OH e¤¤v€,v.¤.vaz¤1z,' J
Var ,4.;, —¤—<-·.y-aa. c>`*'€·Y-·z.¤2.m LAB} »·a;¤.··z§~: Viv-Eq I·~¤ ¥*'·°—"* ~ `“·\"€*" 6*** "—·’
`.`_\z_Ei¤__ #¥¥z_‘bA__`_J-¢___¤{·g; 1*1*akT 'n·`€."f c-Pu-R'? *0-\E-*5 MGB? .X.PLYO@`¥`Ah\T
p_,_,__,-* -;·_ ,\,,__,E__.,.1\;; Oy-·.ga¤; ¥¤..>·¤.. ·5~`-4».,..¢>11.e..h=» wavl ·r¤-\‘=‘i- 1‘·*""1-w:;=· 1*;.-.;,
OP.s\a~..\z>_ *2..; m-\—z.& c>A:é¤'€· `K‘¤’ 2-‘°=$*¥"'·
1
1
q-—,\e_ bij-`·E_;`J\>A`_3·r=;> AAVE \2JN__&—;;_¥_;-';_·,g}\; `b¤¢..¤.>\··t"`5•.:»*¥"&• vc: YQL¤‘<€ cp`?
cm-E__ G? w~\ze,2. ¤1_,;;..~.1. ’¤-\€»~r •\AvE. Legg 1.;_·;,¤, X-·—¤ *¤—\t:€.$2- LJQSI-¤.‘b·&¤w.vs_-,
Lab *¤\‘z’.‘€..L b‘é.¥c»·e>·z..~:‘z:.¢;~,¤.x$» . LV .30;- hgm.-Y »¢‘>¤t.·<\·\ *rq_»·z.$ Y¤.¤Q,u...·a,\·\ ~.¤—z.M1\··
1..4 mgaei. ....¤·»=-·.¤..1..r—&» »c>z.x..x.. ¤».:1u·¢ €=F€¤=r v::»¤,@.•E>‘·E.., \»C)‘&-*¤-\¤»`.>Y \¤·\‘E» E»L-c»<;>ur&.»$*F
~‘,,£C,,¤..,£,—;.;z.‘{‘t.. ¥&·,.;;»., '¤—¤\·•>-#6 ‘b·-.=¤Jé·S‘S’F1.>¤..»:f ?¤z.-¤~<·e..b ewr *··¤-Ka Z..1¢,¢,..1~.·
5—;,.<,;,·1*1r>·.n~>·=-··¤*.’~L‘b`£-·—» "°>\€· *i‘€i‘>"¤·"¢.¤c>»·a~¢ L»·¤‘t» bag-·\,¤·.»·.\% H1 omg @.‘¥-fw-\T
TQ L. 11€’:r:·¤·¤.- Bw `€-'TL»e.·—1__
/~1/a ·»·1·~· cme
1
1
1
`

Case 1:04-cv-01523-JJF Document 34 Filed 11/14/2007 Page 4 014
G`} "U U1 I·1
1 QPEF
1 Ezgfw
A E Z S Q?
; 8 §
H
Z 1
§ E UU
5 E E 1
1
§ C $ %* & 1
Z3 5 m - Ag 4
H .¤ +1 C ,6 Q
ii'? ,.; · 1
an ‘ E L g 1;: S1 E 1
C7 ' 1
,::1. (11 F (3 0 c1 1
1'x§ 0 1
E A H I
G O I 117
2.. _ 1 ·1 ga
E: ` ,9 1 1
S` 1 P1 ”
:.. O Y (I 1
- (2 1 01 #1*1 1
gc: F Yi.; YES? 1
%= ·~1 ,»q 7. Iii. '._` 1 1 1. 1
Z22 O 4 11-if ·1a· .?*1-15 16a!.-1 1
A 11e·` 1 1
5 g@§@»”1g2%§ a111 a» 1
=
_ 1
'.f"' 1 1`=..E `
fig {-jj 1
., 1 11 1
1
1
1 I