Free Motion to Compel - District Court of Delaware - Delaware

Case 1 :04-cv-01494-JJF Document 145-4 Filed 04/16/2007 Page 1 of 4
IN THE UNITED STATES DISTRICT COURT
FOR THE DISTRICT OF DELAWARE

CORPORATION and LAW DEBENTURE )
TRUST COMPANY OF NEW YORK, )
Plaintiffs, l
v. g C.A. No. 04-1494 (JJF)
NORTHWESTERN CORPORATION, g
Defendant. g

MAGTEN ASSET MANAGEMENT CORP., )
Plaintiff, g
v. g C.A. N0. 05-499 (JJF)
MICHAEL J. HANSON and ERNIE J. KH\IDT, g
Defendants. g
gPROPOSED[ ORDER
AND NOW upon the emergency cross motion (the "Motion") of Defendant
NorthWestem Corporation ("No1thWestern") for the entry of an Order truncating the normal
briefing schedule under Local Rule 7.1.2 and setting an immediate telephonic hearing and for an
Order that, pursuant to the Stipulated Protective Order so ordered by the Court on March 21,
2007 (the "Order"), Plaintiffs Magten Asset Management Corporation ("Magten") and the Law
Debenture Trust Company of New York and their counsel immediately retum to counsel for
NorthWestern or destroy the documents listed on Exhibit A hereto (the "Designated
Documents") and sanction Plaintiffs and their counsel for the prior violation of the Order;
3580480vl

J Case 1:04-cv-01494-JJF Document 145-4 Filed O4/16/2007 Page 2 of 4
IT IS HEREBY ORDERED THAT:
l. Plaintiffs shall forthwith comply with their obligations under the Order and
immediately cease making any use of the Designated Documents;
2. Plaintiffs shall forthwith rettun any and all copies of the Designated Documents to
counsel for NorthWestern or destroy said documents and any and all copies thereof and provide
an immediate certification that such destruction has occurred;
3. Plaintiffs shall forthwith destroy any and all notes, memoranda or other work
product based upon or derived from the Designated Documents and provide an immediate
certification that such destruction has occurred;
4. Plaintiff Magten and its counsel are hereby sanctioned in the amount of the costs
incurred by NorthWestern in connection with this Motion, including reasonable attorneys fees.
SO ORDERED this day of , 2007.
Honorable Joseph J. Farnan, Jr.
U.S.D.J.
-5-
3580480vl

Case 1 :04-cv-01494-JJF Document 145-4 Filed 04/16/2007 Page 3 of 4
Exhibit A
Designated Documents
NOR 371624-372806 NOR 063216-7
NOR 413446-413500 NOR 067845-86
NOR 414057—414114 NOR 072813-14
NOR 053296-97 NOR 072815-16
NOR 066670-71 NOR 073773-74
NOR 075185-86 NOR 076260-61
NOR 086411-12 NOR 077858-59
NOR 086481-501 NOR 081375-76
NOR 088303-05 NOR 088910-11
NOR 121152-73 NOR 092308-09
NOR 131455 NOR 087633-34
NOR 135865-67 NOR 117952-953
NOR 142061 NOR 119158-9
NOR 149263-64 NOR 124686-87
NOR 160675-76 NOR 160675-76
NOR 173136-38 NOR 366792-809
NOR 184691-94 NOR 367014-041
NOR 184858-59 NOR 367140-151
NOR 185818-820 NOR 368029-037
NOR 187057-058 NOR 368234-261
NOR 192884-893 NOR 368363-70
NOR 193851-53 NOR 405402-03
NOR 240045-46 NOR 405928-930
NOR 265143 NOR 406074-075
NOR 275785 NOR 406175-180
NOR 371624-2806 NOR 406416-55
NOR 374782-92 NOR 458032-035
NOR 374829-5523 NOR 469466
NOR 411358-1450 NOR 479145-146
NOR 413446-500 NOR 481065-066
NOR 414057-114 NOR 374460-3 74530
NOR 441828-32 NOR 067847-067849
NOR 452810-11 ‘ NOR 086481-086559
NOR 452812 NOR 367071 -367073
NOR 452820 NOR 367124—367130
NOR 458221-26 NOR 368038-368101
NOR 459119-20 NOR 405532-405536
NOR 458213-215 NOR 405683-405684
NOR 463654 NOR 405703
NOR 481063-64 NOR 405713-405718
NOR 481065-66 NOR 405789-405791
NOR 481073 NOR 405850-405851
NOR 482791-93 NOR 405857-405859
3580481vl

Case 1 :04-cv-01494-JJF Document 145-4 Filed 04/16/2007 Page 4 of 4
NOR 405920-405923
NOR 317953-317970
NOR 3 17980-3 17984
NOR 365676-365677
NOR 367925-367929
NOR 352700-3 5271 1
NOR 352712-352713
NOR 352714-352722
NOR 405298-405308
NOR 406097-406099
NOR 406065-406066
NOR 406103-406104
NOR 406165-406169
NOR 4061 70-4061 74
NOR 406759-406797
NOR 440103-440107
-2-
3580481vl