Free Answer to Crossclaim - District Court of Delaware - Delaware

Case 1 :04-cv—00955-GIVIS Document 108 Filed 05/29/2007 Page 1 of 4
IN THE UNITED STATES DISTRICT COURT
FOR THE DISTRICT OF DELAWARE
DENNIS J. BUCKLEY, AS TRUSTEE OF
THE DVI LIQUIDATING TRUST,
Plaintiff, C.A. No. O¢l—~955 (GMS)
v.
MICHAEL A. O’I-IANLON, STEVEN R. DEMAND FOR JURY TRIAL
GARFINKEL, RICHARD E. MILLER,
JOHN P. BOYLE, ANTHONY J. TUREK, _
RAYMOND D. FEAR, WILLIAM S.
GOLDBERG, GERALD D. COHN, JOI-IN E.
MCHUGH, HARRY T.], ROBERTS, and
NATHAN SHAPIRO,
Defendants.
JOHN P. BOYLE’S ANSWER TO CROSS CLAIMS FOR CONTRIBUTION ASSERTED
AGAINST HIM BY MICHAEL A. O’I-IANLON, STEVEN R. GARFINKEL,
RAYMOND D. FEAR, ANTHONY J. TUREK, WILLIAM S. GOLDBERG, GERALD L.
COHN, JOHN E. MCHUGH, HARRY T..I. ROBERTS, RICHARD E. MILLER, AND
NATHAN SHAPIRO
Defendant John P. Boyle, by and through his attorneys, Duane Morris LLP, hereby
answers and asserts affirmative defenses to the Cross Claims tiled by defendants Michael A.
O’I-Ianlon, Steven R. Garfinlcel, Raymond D. Fear, Anthony J. Turelc, Williams S. Goldberg,
Gerald L. Cohn, John E. Mel-{ugh, Harry T.J. Roberts, Richard E. Miller, and Nathan Shapiro in
this action as follows:
I. Denied. By way of further answer, Mr. Boyle denies that he is or may be in any
way liable to defendants Michael A. O’I··Ianlon, Steven R. Gariinlcel, Raymond D. Fear, Anthony
5. Turek, Williams S. Goldberg, Gerald L. Cohn, John E. McHugh, Harry T.J. Roberts, Richard
E. Miller, and Nathan Shapiro (the "Cross—Claim Ptaintiffs") for contribution and/or indemnity.

Case 1 :04-cv—00955-GIVIS Document 108 Filed 05/29/2007 Page 2 of 4
In addition, to the extent that the Affirmative Defenses contained in Mr. Boyle’s Answer to
plaintiff Dennis J. Buckley’s complaint are or amy be appiicable to the cross—claims asserted by
the Cross—Claim Plaintiffs, Mr. Boyle incorporates those Affirmative Defenses by reference as
though set forth at length herein.
WHEREFORE, defendant John P. Boyle respectfully requests that this Court:
1. Enter judgment in his favor on the Cross-Claims asserted by the Cross—Claim
P1aintiHs;
2. Award him his costs and expenses incurred in defending this action, including his P
defense of the Cross-Claims asserted by the Cross—Clairn Plaintiffs; and
3. Grant him such other and further relief as the Court deems just and proper.
DUANE MORRIS LLP
Date: May 29, 2007 /s/ Kathaleen S. McCormiclt
Kathaleen McCormick, Esquire (1.D. No.4579)
1100 North Market Street, Suite 1200
Wilmington, DE 19801
(302) 657-4930
Patrick J. Loftus, Esquire
Robert E. Kelly, Esquire
Kelly D. Eckel, Esquire
30 South 17th Street
Philadelphia, PA 19103-4196
(215) 979-1000
(admitted pro imc vice)
C ozmsei for Dekrrdarir
Jo/in P. Boyle
2

Case 1 :04-cv—00955-GIVIS Document 108 Filed 05/29/2007 Page 3 of 4
CERTIFICATE OF SERVICE
I hereby certify that on May 29, 2007, I electronicaily filed the foregoing document with
the Clerk of the Court using CM/ECF, which wili send notification of such filling to the
following:
Francis A. Monaco, Ir. Peter B. Ladig
([email protected]) (banl Joseph J. Bodnar ([email protected]) The Bayard Finn _
Monzack & Monaco, P.A. Arrorneysfor Dejendcmr Harry T./T Roberts
Attorneys for Ploiittyf
Gregory Miller (gniiller@mar—law.com)
David E. Brand ([email protected]) Stephen G. Stroup (sstroup@mar—law.com)
Prickett, Jones & Elliott, P.A. Miller, Aifano & Raspanti, P.C.
Atiorizeys for Dejiendont Ric/mr·dMil/e1· Aitorneysfor Defendom Harry TJ Roberts
David A. Felice ([email protected]) Martin James Weis
Cozen O’Connor ([email protected])
Atrorneys_for Dej%*r2dorrtA1rI}1or1y J Tzzrek Dilworth Paxson LLP
Airorneysfor Defendant Steven R. Goifinkel
I hereby certify that on May 29, 2007, I mailed the foregoing document to the following
nornregistered participants:
5. Andrew Rabi, Ir. Arthur G. Connolly, Jr.
Mark L. Weyman Connolly, Bove, Lodge & Hutz
Michael 5. Venditto The Nemours Building
Mcierson Kill & Olick, P.C. i007 North Orange Street
1251 Avenue ofthe Americas P.O. Box 2207
New York, NY 10020 Wilmington, DE i9899
Artorneysfor Ploiritif Anorneysjbr Defendants Wi/fiom S
Goldberg Jo/in E. McHugh, ondNc1r/acm
S/rczpiro
3

Case 1 :04-cv—00955-GIVIS Document 108 Filed 05/29/2007 Page 4 of 4
Kellie Marie MacCready Laurie A. Krepto
Steven T. Davis Montgomery, McCracken, Walker &
Obemiayer Rebmann Mazweil & Hippel Rhoads, LLP
LLP 300 Delaware Avenue, Suite 750
3 Mill Road, Suite 306A Wilmington, DE 198014607
Wilmington, DE 19806 Allarneysfar Defendant Michael O ’HanIcm
AlroriieysfarDej%11darzl Gerald L. C0/in
Richard L. Scheff William P. Quinn, lr.
Jeffrey Feldman Karen P. Pohlmann
Noel C. Burnham David W. Marston, Jr.
Montgomery, McCracken, Walker & Morgan Lewis & Bockius LLP
Rhoads, LLP 1701 Market Street
123 South Broad Street Philadelphia, PA l9l06 .
Avenue ofthe Arts Atlarrreysf01· Defzridaiits William S
Philadelphia, PA l9l 09 Goldberg, Jo/in E McHugh, and Nathan
Aaorneysfor Dajhrzdaiit Michael A. Shapiro
O Hanlon
Julian W. Friedman
Patricia M. Hamill Stillman & Friedman, P.C.
Vincent T. Cieslilr 425 Park Avenue
Conrad O’Brien Geliman & Rohn, P.C. New York, NY 10022
1515 Market Street, Sixteenth Floor Al{Oi'l?€jlS_fO1'D€](l?l?ClGl2l G'erala' Calm
Philadelphia, PA 19102-19},6
AHOi·neysf0r Defeirdaizt Richard E. Miller
William .l. Taylor
John Bamoski
Cozen O’Conuor
1900 Market Street
Philadelphia, PA 19103
Atlarireysfor Dejlzndant Amhoiry .1 T urek
l @ tear., at r@ 4 @
athaleen McCormick (Del. I.D. No. 4579)
4