Document 27-2
Filed 04/04/2005
Page 1 of 30
Case 1:04-cv-00911-GMS
Document 27-2
Filed 04/04/2005
Page 2 of 30
Case 1:04-cv-00911-GMS
Document 27-2
Filed 04/04/2005
Page 3 of 30
Case 1:04-cv-00911-GMS
Document 27-2
Filed 04/04/2005
Page 4 of 30
Case 1:04-cv-00911-GMS
Document 27-2
Filed 04/04/2005
Page 5 of 30
Case 1:04-cv-00911-GMS
Document 27-2
Filed 04/04/2005
Page 6 of 30
Case 1:04-cv-00911-GMS
Document 27-2
Filed 04/04/2005
Page 7 of 30
Case 1:04-cv-00911-GMS
Document 27-2
Filed 04/04/2005
Page 8 of 30
Case 1:04-cv-00911-GMS
Document 27-2
Filed 04/04/2005
Page 9 of 30
Case 1:04-cv-00911-GMS
Document 27-2
Filed 04/04/2005
Page 10 of 30
Case 1:04-cv-00911-GMS
Document 27-2
Filed 04/04/2005
Page 11 of 30
Case 1:04-cv-00911-GMS
Document 27-2
Filed 04/04/2005
Page 12 of 30
EXHIBIT 1
Case 1:04-cv-00911-GMS
DocumentCo'ndcmsclt 04/04/2005 27-2 Filed
Pat! I
IT TIG UTITED 91AIE5 DI9TRICT C9UiT FOE tflE DTSIFICT Or il&l
f.i
,tBRlw
JAI.I XO?ACZ
ctvl)
lcllon
DEI,S|Ai! lutnonttl
tlwi
ItlD ElI No, 03-cV-{ltl lSSBt
tl.Anerdat"
ttersb ?1, 3004
10
DatoalEloa Dclcf.se Flva( or tAl roPFcl. clksn rl th.
and, E{}. Aulhorlfy, trrlay 0l:0a,
glndnffi Eoultvlfd, on lh! .bev. {tasc,
r3 1r
It t5
xerllt
CrPc !ley, ta, l! 1l:15
biqlnolnE
F.nr.' b3!or
ssrd tElganbarg,
Cousc R.poElar
ltrd loLrry
E\rbllc.
2r
l2 29 2l
BnlD TNATEilIARG CoUtrf n lErtcr 115 cyrrya Ror0, 3str. llt Dolr clnetd, PA lt00a ( 2 1 5 rt 9 6 - 0 l l ! r r r ( 6 1 0 f6 l ? ' 0 5 0 1
Pqge3 with a claim ilrst you've madc I Authority in connection an 2 concerning incident on August 9,2002- Haw you evErSlvendepo$itionEstimony before? 3 4 A Yes. 5 Q On how many occasions? 6 A One,l bclieve. of ? Q Can you tell np tlp circumstances that e deposition? 9 A It was to StaE Farrr. And I'rrc giveir some om l0 &positioas on bchdf of ttr govcrnrnent erylicr tt jobs. for 12 Q And in thoeedcpositions the government as l 3 you werebeingdeposed a wiaess? A Yes. l4 Well,youmaylmowthenrlesandyotu l5 a l 6 attonry may havetold thornto yoq bur l* rn just ttc l 7 lay themout for the tcord' As you can see, l 8 court feporttr ir taking down everythirg u/e saywud harrcto be verbal' l 9 for word' So dl of )'our an$wprs 20 Do you underctlad that? 2 l A Yeswhcm 1ou don't If I a.sk 22 a ]ltlu sny questions just bll rre that od aski4g, 29 un&rstand what I'm bocause you do if 24 I'll try to rrahrasemy question,
Page 13 of 30
J.
Page ?
rrprelfilc8s: EgQ. B. ALrruO txlt|, . AtSoclAfgg ot E. ALlilD !ilIth l|c. ttacrl l3!! lll0t F.nnttlvrnll Ehllrq.rPhlr, cousrll lgt Dl|tnellt t|llnl tt ltr tlEVEg, Ege, o! ooxl|A AoELSDEiGAn t r5soclAtls 6 Lyal Av.rua 1903, 6l.nat{4, lcnnsYlvlnia cor.rfrr.l tos Oalana||DB
a I
6
I t ALgO PREs'IT! advc3d. Icdegr
t0
t2 l3 1r lt 16
counrcr ttgnlng. lre rt t! vaivaii co thc ch. (tt tor lt thc !3lPulrtd rstpacElv. by dtd belxeen lhsq InC tll1n9 lxqepl f,etervcd
pirtla
rc{llng' an4 lom clftc
c.rrtllcar,lon Lha!. {ll of cf
ob]tcslonr, rFa
cha quettlon, trirl.l
untll
19 20
,1
.. . rtlll reorn, Dr !il. REgvlS: i.r Lirr rcPactqnt *rr orsl'cd
XOPICZT rfrd
havltrl !9rrllled
b..r r!
duly tollorr:
23 al
Q ar
lty nm you lrnor, I
,le'vc Aecver. Jutl Rieal cht oeltrrrt
rcs rnd
4ll4, Bly
Prye 4 thc I ansurcr, court and anyonoreaditrytln dcposition my z will assure that you'vc understood guestion. Do 3 yorl undsrnandthat? 4 A Yes. 5 Q If you'd like to tatp a brcak at any tirne, 6 just let np know, It's aot rneantto be a marathon, z So if you rncd a brcak,just ell me trat. Arc you on any medicationtoday or is I 9 ttrfic any otbcr rcasotrthat yorr carlnd listen and to un&stand my quectionsand answerttrnr tnrthfully u and accuately? but 12 A I'm on rncdication it wonrt affectthe 13 depooition. t4 Q Whatkind of medicationareyou on? l5 A Ibuproftn aad blood pressult rnedicine. 16 Q Anything else? t7 A Prostabnpdicine. ls Q Anything else? 19 A No, not that I canthink of. I'vc taken zo sttpt medicirpsbut generally2l a What odrr mpdicationsdo you tako? 22 A Lipitor. Phenasteroid. 23 e What is that for? 24 A Prostate.I take a coupleof nrdicines in a
Pagel-Page4
Case 1:04-cv-00911-GMS
I
Document Condenseltru 04/04/2005 27-2 Filed
Page 14 of 30
2
J
4
5 6 7 8 9 10
l l
t2 l3
l4 l5
lo
L7 t8
l9 20 2l 22
ZJ
24
Page12 & Hoffman or anyoneelse. Other than the incident at Vane Brothers, had a you ever had any other problems with your lower back, or your neck for that matter? A With my neck and my upper back due to an automobile accident. I believe it was 1999 and it was either in North Carolina or South Carolina. A truck ran myself and another vehicle off of an interstate highway into tte median, which was being -- the median was under construction. He hit my vehicle, spun it around into the median, which was all torn up. And I injured my neck and my -- because I was holding onto the steering wheel real tight, it injured my upper back betweenthe shoulderblades. And in that case,you made a ptp claim a against ce *len as well, correct? A I don't think cg was my insurancecarrier then. But I did make one with my insurance carrier. It was either Colonial Penn or cE. and they paid my medical becausethey said the other guy was from out of state,he was from Virginia, and they paid 5,00O-something 6,000-somedollars for pain and or injury through my lawyer, of which I got about 38 or 39 hundred.
Page127 A Not that I know of. It's got a fax number on the top. DelawareRiver and Bay Authority Police sick leaveand iqjury report. It's not my handwriting. I think this is a noteof a phone a Down at the bottom,it mentions H. P. conversation. Luther or somebody.Is that the PoliceOfficer Luther you weretalking about before,do you know? A I don't know Luther'slast name. If you could tell me what Luther looks like. I could tell
you if it's the sameLuther. 12 a I don't know what he looks like. II 13 A Okay. I don't know if it's him then. kt me 14 look at my notes and seeif Luther answeredthe 15 phone. No, GeorgeTaylor and Captain Woehlcke is who 16 I talked with. 17 a I think I gave you the wrong document. So let me mark this as 20. (Documeirt marked for identification 19 l8 20 2I as Kopacz exhibit 20.) BYMS.REEVES:
22 a Do you recall if this is the fax that you 23 were discussingwith -- well, it indicats you faxed 24 something on the 20th of August, correct, in the
Page I But that 6,000 was actually from the owner of a 2 the truck? A I don't know. All I know is my lawyer sent 4 me a check.
I
J
Page128 t diary? 2A No. 3 Q 8:43 a.m., the third note down, "Faxed Dr. 4 Lopz's work excuse." 5 A Well, it's actually dated August 13. So I 6 don't know if this is the sameone. It's good for 7 8/12 to 8/20. Maybe I faxed them anotherone. 8 Q Well, as I said, if you give me copies of r everything, then we'll be able to discern that. l0 A I'm not sure I have a copy. 1l a Ifyoudo. 12 L Obviously I faxed this one to thern becauseit has my computer signature on the bottom where I typed it. And it was typed, according to the computer, which I don't have any accessto change,Tuesday, August 13 and I datedit August 13. So I can't imagine why I would wait until the 20th to do that. It says to call him or send a fax. And as he left that number -- anryay,I don't know. And then on tlre next page,it indicates 5:00 a p.m., you spoke with Jake Shisha and he said he will fax, I guess,the police report to you. And then is this your handwriting on this page down towards the bottom where it says, "Why did captain Woehlcke tell
5 7 8 9 l0 l1 12
I J
a
For$6,000?
6 A
T4 15 l6 t7 l8 t9
20
ri 22 23 24
No. Or for your shareof the $6,000? a A Yes. And somebodypaid my medical bills. I got more on that in that accident becausesomebody fixed my car. Came to somewherearound $3,200. Any other accidentsor injuries? a A No. [rt's go back to your notebook. The next a written page I have is August 20. lt indicates that you faxed a work excuse from Dr. Lopez to the port captain's office? A Yes. MS.REEVESI Can we mark this as 19? (Document marked for identification as Kopaczexhibit 19.) BY MS.REEVES: Can you take a look at exhibit 19? Is that a the document that you're referring to in your diary note of August 20?
Page125 - Page128
Case 1:04-cv-00911-GMS
Document Condenseltru 04/04/2005 27-2 Filed
Q A
Page 15 of 30
J.
Page 1 3 1
9 l0
ll
1 a
l3 t4
r5
l6
t7
IR
l9
ZU 'r1
Page I 29 the police report will not be releaseduntil I rne I make a statement?" 2 Yes. A 3 Did he tell yciu that? 4 a Yes. A 5 Were you asked to make a statement about your 6 a version of what occurred? 7 Yes. A 8 Did you make a statement? 9 a No. A l0 Why not? lt a BecauseI made a statementto Dave Oat before A t2 I left the boat and Jake Shishatold me not to make 13 any other statements. 14 Did you make a written statement to Dave Oat 15 a before you left the boat? 16 A No. t'l Do you recall that Mr. lrdwon wrote you on 18 a several occasions asking you to fill out a statement 19 forth your version of that? setting 20 Yes. A 2t And did you respond to him? 22 a A No. I forwarded it to Jake Shisha. 23 Have you ever given the ferry a written 24 a Page13
Sure. Take your time. What was that? Q Take your time. A Okay. Q My questionwas, you never provided a written statementto the DRBAdespitethoserequests? A My answer is there's two reasonsfor that. One, any corespondenceI got from DRBAI forwarded to Jake Shisha when he was my lawyer. I gave them to Al Smith when he was my lawyer. JakeShisha told me not to answerthem. Number two. this was sent to 4590 Highway l. That's not my residence. Did you ever reside at 4590 Highway 1? a A No. Is it your testimony that you never got any a of those letters? A No. You did not? a A Did not what? Q Do you recall receiving any of theseletters? A Yes. You do recall receiving them? a A Yes. And you allowed your lawyer to handle a Page 732 communications with the DRBa? Whn I finally got these letters sent to this address,which is not my residence,I forwarded them to my lawyer at the tirne and awaited his response. His responsewas, "Thank you for sendingme this." Looking at ttre next written page of your a diary, August 21, am I correct it mentions an appointment with the PSYC?Is that the psychiatrist? A Let me look at it and see. It could be the psychiatrist. It could be the physical therapist. I don't rernember. And the remainder of that page is your note a on your physical condition? A Well, my physical and my mental condition. And how about the next written page,August a
I t statement of what occurred that day? I don't think so, unless Jake Shishatold me , o | l3 to.
I
2 A
J
|+ s I 6 7 8 9 10 II 12 13 t4
15 i6 17 l8 19 20 21 22 23 24
with me that Mr. Ledwon of a Would you agree the DelawareRiver and Bay Authority sentyou four requests an incident report or a written for statement? A I don'tknow. Let's see. Q Okay. Lrt me mark them first. A Obviouslyhe did. You got thosefrom Shisha, didn't you? a No, I did not. I got ttremfrom Mr. [.edwon. (Documents markedfor identification asKopaczexhibits21 through23.)
BYMS.REEVES: Let me show you what we've marked as 27, 22 a and23. These are Mr. Ledwon's letters requesting a statement from you in reference to the incident in accordance with the onge incident reporting process and stating that he enclosesa blue injured, slash, witness statementcard for you. A Okay, you're going to have to let me read theseand then I'll look at you when you talk to me. Okav?
4
f
6
l n
ll0 I ll l3 t4 l5 16 l7 12
22? A Let me finish this one. l8 a Certainly. Takeyour time. r 9 A You haveto uncovervour mouth. 2A a Takeyour time. al A All right. I was still wearingthe neck 22 braceat this time. I wokeup with a headache. At 12:75| hadbackspasms headache. and Wentto sleep around 24 again 12:30.Wokeup again 3:45with back at
| I I I I I I I I
Page129- Page132
Case 1:04-cv-00911-GMS
Document 27-2
Filed 04/04/2005
Page 16 of 30
E X H I B I2 T
0 4 / 0 4 / 0 5 U O N0 9 : 2 9 F A X 9 0 2 5 7 1 0 3 0 5
Case 1:04-cv-00911-GMS
Document 27-2
DRBAEXECOFFICE
Filed 04/04/2005
Page 17 of 30
ooz @
AFFTDAYTTBONNTE OF MTLLER OF STATE DELAWARE :
OFNa)Cnc+-ln-COUNTY
l, Bonnie Miller, hereby depose and state as follows: 1. I am the insuance naflager forthc DRBA, andin that capacityl handleall marinoaud otherinsrranceclaims against DRBA. the JobnSchafferof Larnorte,Burnsassists Sy adjustingmaritime olaimswhich arebelow us onr deduotiblE, to pnrvideus with adviceon the hauiling of all maritime claims. and Although he doesnot respresent DRBA directly iu thesE the orlsos, do take advantage we of his legalandmaritimesr(pe,rtise advising onhowto handletbesoclaims. in us are Accordingto DRBA polioy, iucidentrcporb andwitless statements requiredIbr all accidcnts incidetre which occuronboardanyof our ferries,whetheror uot they are or expected result in claims. to but I do not nodfy Lamorte,Burns of all incidentsor accidents, only fonrard thosethat I bolievearelikely Loleadto a claim or litigution oomaritimeclaims The DRBArelies on Johr Schaffertoprovidcadviccandguidance lhat arelikoly to leadto litigatiou,however, counsel retained outside is whenclaimsare put into suit. Given the natr:reof the claim andthe fact that it was disputed Mr. Swettandthe by oyowihessos, forwardedthis claim to John Schaffen August 14,2002. At that time, I I on was awaretlat I[r. Kopaczhad an attorney,andthat his intial intention was to prusuea olaim agairstMr- Swettandhis insruauoe carrier,StateFarm. I by Shortlythereafter, was contacted a claimsagentfor StateFann- It was obviousto nre that this oase would likely result in litigation onoway or the other. I havealwaysexpected my communicatiorxwith JohnSchaffer,our underwritcrsand that otherDRBA managers would remainconfidential.
2.
3. 4-
5.
6.
7.
8.
9.
I
lN WITNESS WHEREOF, havehereunto my handandseal I set
0 04/04/05 MON 9:24 FAX902 571 6305
Case 1:04-cv-00911-GMS
DRBAEXEC Document 27-2 Filed 04/04/2005
OFFICE
Page 18 of 30
ooc @
tnis 4K
e dayof lW Q-t .-
, 2005.
geXUu^
BonnieMiller
beforeme this
tJh
oay
of
fWstr-
,2005.
Public Notary
A Aj,rwr,r_u Wnn"?u1"
CHRISTINE JOHNSON D. NOIARYPUBIIC STATE OFDELAWARE , MyCommtssion SepttZ 2OOS Ercrres
Case 1:04-cv-00911-GMS
Document 27-2
Filed 04/04/2005
Page 19 of 30
E X H I B I3 T
A P R.,Case 1 21 B P M 2 0 3 ? 6 1Document 27-2 l 2 0 0 1:04-cv-00911-GMS 6 0 0 ? 5 :
I ASSOCIATES Apr-01-05 Fron-D$lllA ADELSBERER l0rS8am
+l?155768695
Filed 04/04/2005
T-502 P,glllg F0?5
N 0 , B 0ofP , V ? B Page 20 0 30
AFFTDAVTT JOHN SGHAFFER OF STATEOF CONNECTICUT COUNTY FAIRFIELD OF : t
,
l, John SohEffer, herebydepose and stata as follows: 1, 2. in I arn a partherin LamortaBurns& CO.,and afn currentlythe Vice Preeidcnt chargeof maritimepersonal injury mstters. I hsve been a maritimeattorneyfor over thiny years,and am admittedto the Barsof the SupremeCourt of the UnitedStates,the UnitedStetes Coun of Appealsfor the SecondCircuit,New Jereey,New York, tha Federol District Courtsof New Jersev and of the Southernend EasternDlstrictsof New York. of I am a memberand directorof the MaritimeLaw Assoclation the United Committee, States, and serve as chair of the MarineTons and Casuafties personal injurylaw. whioh includes maritime vitae is attached. A true and correct copy of my curriculum injury claimsfor the DRBA,includingthoso I handleall maritimepersonal This includes analyzing claims{rom a legal belowthe $10,000 deducrible, practicalstandpoint,rendering opinionas to the DRBA'spotential an and liabilityand exposure. I to Whero poasible, endeavor settl claimswith the claimantor his attorney, and when casescannot be settled,I advisethe DRBAas to when outside counsel shouldbe appolntEd. insuranco companyof any claimswhioh I also informand adviseths DRBA's I believemight result in litigation. I by On August 14, 2OOZ, was edvlsecl BonnieMillerof the eventsof August had thst Mr. Kopecz 9,2OOZinvolvingJan Kopaoz.At the time, I learned reteinedan attorney. already I passedthe claim onto the DRBA'sunderwriters, and advised them that the by claimantwas represented counsel.
3.
4. '5.
5,
7.' 8.
9,
A P R Case l1:04-cv-00911-GMS 0 1 6 0 0 ? 27-2 2l 1,2 0 0 5 : B P [ , I 2 0 3 7 Document
e ASS0CIATES IELSBERGR Anr0l-05lgrS6an FronNilllA
+1 | 55768E95 ?
Filed 04/04/2005
T-502P.03/03F0Z5
N 0 , 8 8 ofP , 2 / 2 Page 21 0 0 30
t;
l O.
driver and numerous Giventhe nature of the clalm,th fecr thst the Vehicle witnessggdeniodthat Mr, Kopaczhad beenstruclt or iniuredby the Swett vehicle,I anticipatedthat suit would eventuallybe filed againstthe DRBAby Mr. Swott, Mr. Kopaczor bolh indivlduals. lN WITNESSWHEREOF,I have hereunto set my hand and seal
thia i-
day " or
Atr",L
' 2005.
Swornto and subecribed
beforemethis- I.
'9f
day
a A,pril Wan
, 2ooo.
'q)aa
Case 1:04-cv-00911-GMS
Document 27-2
Filed 04/04/2005
Page 22 of 30
E X H I B I4 T
Lt/04/02
(Jr:t"Z9-Oa
Case 1:04-cv-00911-GMS t'
10:42A
1 0 : 4 5 F A X 3 0 2 s7L 6367
Document 27-2
DE.RIYER& BAY AT]TS.
Filed 04/04/2005
Page 23 of 30
t4oo2
P-(]f
LAW OFFTCF.S
TABAK & UETLLSI
s'tRCET ?l Ht.l)s()N NFW YORK.NUw YOAK l00l3-: t(X) $d2 1590 TEl.,ri (113) FAX f {zl1) 3t-1'0020
TAFAE IHCTL\C,N RALPtI J. lt{LLLuSl
E 9TEPTIEN ROgEtrI$ l^coB sHttHA
19,3002 October
vI A FAx 110-2^L-!11:f{39
River& BaYAuthorttY Thc Delawsre Box 7l OfFlcc Post I Delau'are9720 NowClestlo, LindaH. MurPhY Attcntlou: fJirectorof HumanRcsources
Re: JAN KOPA{IZ
MV-DEI.AWARE
D/l: Et9t0?
.
qq.F. t:ll-ENO:52128-02
Dear Me. MrrrPhY:
9,2W2' .{rl.v":1111b,t^.:Ii::'.fifttnttt the wo*ing aboard MV Delawueon Ausu$t fit ltil dut'varld hackcdhis carrntotheilir. I{ipacz, fie tral 6gsn{qqlareddt't the aboard vessel 4' on Nov-tjrnber 200?at He haqb*n undergoinfpnytit-f therapy, is ducto seehis physici*n will cvBluated. imc whiohtimc his rluty stetus becvBluated' I
i
tharolunxJ*t{lclt" Jan wc r-cprcscnr Koproz. with respectto an sccic'ent
*tr*
Act this accidcnq, claim c('mesouderthe Jone*f nndlhe Sincethis is a work-related
LL/44/02 ot*.e9
10:45 FAX 302 571 6367 ao :,4A ,'
Case 1:04-cv-00911-GMS -oa
Document 27-2
DE.RIVER & BAY AI.I:IE.
Filed 04/04/2005
I I I
I
Page 24 of 30
1 40 0 3 t-oe
29,2042 '" October 2 Pugc ol'2
'
I
:
I
I
yriiur venitlncc and We thank you for your CCrnsidcrations rcquesttrat you call me at I c:c)n I to diacussthis matter.
Very firly yo lrs, .TABAK & NELLUSI
cc:
Jan Kopacz
Case 1:04-cv-00911-GMS
Document 27-2
Filed 04/04/2005
Page 25 of 30
E X H I B I5 T
Case 1:04-cv-00911-GMS
Document 27-2
Filed 04/04/2005
Page 26 of 30
J
r r'l
A
E*r
E W
: 1
XE
r'5
d
H.=
-
=v . iq
,i
b
J
x , i
U
frl fr"l
o = o0.:
( q X O ( )
V (A v . d s ' o o E i toi . E 6 a
J
E g g E E9 3 .. E 9 F:. E3 9 $ ; E F s H E
H
F
f rc. rE x c i3FEFO .3.9il 3r 8 iol E E F E E tx r( lal co t Q F o x
FQ B 6o
O ; ; C B t s t i 0 0 ( E c c t
L
gilBf
E E.H
stF c
XE
oisd tr bon o
+1 d =.-
J
iE
h0;i
SB
'i-r (J
o q g E o o-n' E '5 F tb E $8. 5o E 9 r 8 " o -'E
o
ciF s
XE
x.-
d
J
qtF s bon o
xSEt r o s
H.=
a
5 8.9 **rH
Li
. H ( g c
-o ri .Y **lH
t r Q O . 9 i t c 3) tr.:
38il
. : ( ! c _(J tr.=
i r d
F g o
* |*) r H , ( 9 0
A
A
9
.
-
H E ' 6
cd Od
(B o.d
F E
g E.E
DdE"
( J
rYl
F<
F<
()
(H
ta rr'l
H
b0
tt) q)
tr
()
v)
L
F
F
I
U)
(J
()
cn
cl o
C)
(,)
c\l
rY)
F
ca oo
ca
afl
r\
o\
t-
ct
ea
r-
\o
c)
(l)
e\t \o
vt
k .(l) )fi
cn \o c\ oo
E
c{ {
{ oo
(E
()
O ri rl)
(D q l.r a
'o { ) -#
() a
C' o
= -a,q =v
Y " ' g
.9 a
Fi
+ (n
rYl ,;r ,i. rYl
)f
,c)
f r'l k
+ v)
f Y'l
o o c)
c)
HE E
d C ) : t
,a 'F
a
G o
a
U' ,g)
)?"!
.9) )n
c I (n
tr
tgaNr
0.)
o
(
^ 7 t >
y C q
*'F N
d.9
.q(.)
H . lF Cl r
.bs
? f i v) d,
'-:
, i 6E =
-i
z
,t4
F
z
rrl
Fl
F i O
o o
() a
ts
F
tr>
(rr
bO
b o
d) {'
,P<
.E A4
,F
U
6 Z
l H
u) C)
g E (l)
.,
a (.)
cg
I f r'l
4
>
z
,.Jr H
E F i
g . u ?() >=s Fp EEE {) 3rSU
:-t ts
.g<.4
o o a a
F
(.) () c)
U' q) lr
L.
Q
Case 1:04-cv-00911-GMS
Document 27-2
Filed 04/04/2005
Page 27 of 30
-i{ c =.-
-! I,i
XB
cilBtr bon o
e.cg=
# 6o 'o > b o
t r ! 2 0 -(J tr.=
* f,-sgf,ggf,g
bon o
s' t!r c d
e< .=
J
x.= FE
a
- V a
x.=
aiF c
ciF c
XE
{.E
tr =.9
((l()
sI
J
'tr al a i o
3r 9) iol 3 8 i l 3 g E t ! F g o F g o
-c) tr.y
$ f , g S-s f
. x c g d
oilq tr
e) - ct!qtr bo:l o
=.: 5 t ;r
a
-
bI)
* *qr o s tq
E='5
o x'5
d Q d
E 8.9 **rH
i P q
O
a
3r 8 ti o 3 S i l l t q F g o
F,*lH 9 9 4
. : ( 6 c _() Si .:
a.: (.)o o x o0.:
*
8g EdE c O.
E :T
*,*rts
9 9 o
cg A.d
E E E E
C$
b ; E aF.;
v t = h {
Y A X
L . : O 0
5 8.9
I 6'.5 5 b0=
EE
d
A'd
-9.
't-1
{ts9ts
o.(d
F:g
O
(o=
O
'r9 c r
( d( )
L.
L
} E
r J q tsl*
I q., Ctro
} E ; 2
L d
o o
6 o
F C !
a4
c d X tr c.= 9 F E
a
; 8 F
tr
16 Gl Cil
GI
o
c.l
E5S
ca C\l c\l
F F 9 tr
a
o
o
o
s, A E t $ |'
cn
PtrE
6l
ca
c.l oo
rn oo
ca oo o\
c.) t+
O
r\
N
r-
o\
(|i
' F s q N a+<( ) H F Lr
hoE0
E tV.
(D
l-< q)
I
k
.gF.U
0.)
'l'
()
(u
5> & s
O c g ;5 a)
tr
Jd
f{ I
lrl
B
o)
g = E sE o
>F
r E
b d;"E = >r!9
,!) F
l.r
.s)
a
cg (J i: q)
l-r
,!)
}F
h
x >
o + j
c) o c) ,p) )?!
(q
1..
5= c-9
B 0.) El v ) rt) -
-
v)
,H q)
Q
a () o
.r1 q) o q)
i>
'o
< d
a v
h .o l Q
(l)(D
s s"T U +'E N
o - Q 4
,lr E
q d E c l
O P
E H a5
# E
:,
() o ,F
J
F: O{)
-EtrE Ht * 3: ' 8 A s O
F : P F '"#a#
V * H H
o
8>
x h
o 0.) o = orn
tua c) q 5 ter
P c a
H g
>
c) ()
6)
q.)
* i ; - a
) < L
q)
!)
o0;
h
a
I
E>
X J i;'=
v) q)
li
(.)
O
g H -)a E l o
H.lg
OiE ! 2 5 0 x
- o -.t
caE
Y a q o
E>
d ( o
a !) F
Y?< =*.
U
dr I
Case 1:04-cv-00911-GMS
Document 27-2
Filed 04/04/2005
Page 28 of 30
q-{
(+r
+r 'trd 0 ) A rd()
d c q
Q a Q
qi
(ri
E HnZ E HN< F 5 Xx x v : F;lrc
c
A
v
9x ? iF. G ho. ;t?e Et?e
a *
( l-i (5t
*
'E (d q ) g C S O C ) a
'tr(s
a ) Q ((l()
' t d i D A cl()
O a
'trd
0 ) g ((l()
b ;5.
16 c)
Q a
= E t v
r \
H h
O
a
a
A
-
-
.= tsArh
HETHE EIH H9 i l > E 9fiD
.= tserh
v,
(A
-
!9
lr
III
- V N C B
x, tE' 5 5 xF 'E= 5 x !9 .E5 F r * . r*. E
Xo E j. ! P < j
> b0= -v ;i cB ! ; i b 0
O il.n
-V
>
3 XoE
H0 E . g P < . ) + J
h0:,=
fi
(g
is$
< ( l ) i j
oF.;
aF.;
-Y 5 :i 63 b0=
x o E .j g p t s E+. j9 9 < a < Q )
5 bo=
* !!'5 - V n c d
.. ?e>g i \
(.) ti:
E o
B.*
^ C ) .:
o-f
Q N
c o
.q
F 8 . X o a f )
EV:I
-q)'= q
.F E Xx
b 'E 0 N C) (/t 6 c)0.
E " ,u* 'o d =
. = d 0 )
E"o
I bbE
> o .E\l
co
tr ()
c!
d
()
C\l
o
(\l
O
()
c! ca (\t oo
()
ol aa
N
q) 'd
f\
ot oo
v) tr G) C.) (.)
c{ \o
c.l oo
ao
tn
()
frl
d
o
$ (*) x
o E ci
.IJ F cl
5
b0
b0
+r h
bo
oE) ._()
m t
E't
Gl l{ . ( J
E b s vo Q r
r-\ i
tr;
Fg - q > E>
:-l
> E
qig O X s bI) ( ) C
E
: : H
. q c opo
H E i
F S c X
$
,x=
b0
. E B E.0l
-v tq H
'-l E {tr q E
!
c)
Fl
F
{)
ts]
"o iI co
H E
(E cg q2 u)
F;
9i ..tr I
>5
q !
= . e L < =
6 N
'F
K r YF E l
. =s A
F o o
n F .tr c)
:>
o6 o > .li .i
= o
t> rl
E O h0:=
9F
O O r
-l(J
,t4
8 5
.
o0
. l
E
F
()
l
bo
. ' l
Eg
.|<
.t<
d>
H E
F>
rir 8
'EX FE f! -l
, l.<
cl
I frl I rY'l
I frl
Case 1:04-cv-00911-GMS
Document 27-2
Filed 04/04/2005
Page 29 of 30
. l l (H
J
q-r
+r
(+<
xB
q ) ! s c
q t d 5 'E tr +r
XB
o ! q t r b0ii o
.F
x a. =
bii
( g o O -
'tr c0 (1)a
( g o
'C ct q.)o. c t o
( J d
'tr
O
crl
Q
(uL)
O a
( J a
# f F's *B 3Eo E R g E f r i; E F
I
()
I
\'l J
q)
H
*
O
- v h E ! : b 0 P 6.F > b0=
- v n ( t
,:
!g'.5
*
! ; i b 'F-( o
-vFi(c
B 5og
b }
H : 3H : 3 H . 1 0 E H . g O E . E g p ' E (ad HbE B HbE
!q'5
H. !q .E - y H c ,
E ( ) x
x*rH
cg Ard
tr.:
9 tr.y >.*;E
5
Q
A
3
^n -t
at
X .Y b l--1
6 th
i
d:E
8Es
(.) ()
'13 a
E 8 B
I Ed
. , : F l E
* ii X'Ij ( ) J " d = c r O -O O v 6 .
sf eg
d l L
v
X
Q
F
a
()
6 e g
3A'i
H g F
O
c)
Ti
g
|.r
o.
(\I
E.E E
aa o\
cl C)
E;ET?
d d ? t Y
r t 5k b5E;p
S*,Ei
F E d 9 E t F : Y . J
a-.1 r+ oo
ot
(\l (\t
.+ oo
oo
f-
u) )
!
HI c iH '? H i : E.g?H
'6
bi i r ^u- : E N ii # { - .
r\
oi
Fl
l-{
ga r t
f r.a= d t -..= E E t t
o
r-i (.)
ii I
j
t q 'tr|. v
O .
L
O
X
tr ()
.E
o
tr
o{)
() ()
tr 04v
o : t
,;
* ts N <3 h E i t p
E.EFg
E a
rrt E h d
a(tr
q ! 9 E.E
q
a
U)
J
o)
k
Li d
>G ; ft a
ott
d
h
()
I
gd
6 F
9 c) ; ll
O F ?
- 8e F F ^
o > d'i
= q
B
a
al
. ' l
F
Q) . l
C)
H ^ v
.5 g'S # r
.-\ E V H ^,() ri) H rrl
EEEEE Esitt
F ; ?r {
{)
q.)
utt g [rl
. g ta 'HEE=I 6 u q 2 E
-E
O
, t-!
.F
F i
ct
{=i
E> ri.rI
d I r r'l
?
fY)
tr=
bI)
E >-6 o s * F = g F ii.q EE E # : > E I . T
:
.E ; gf i jI Y & b o t
E S P A EF ' O ve>>
Case 1:04-cv-00911-GMS
Document 27-2
Filed 04/04/2005
Page 30 of 30
s
E
S
a
E H e g E
g_.8 E ;
h . +
A
e g EE.g't.Fs E = t g s ; T E s ? A ,g ;
;EHEE5$qiEE
fiEiigEEigEEg
United States Free Forms
Canada Free Forms
United Kingdom Free Forms
Australia Free Forms