Free Response in Opposition to Motion - District Court of Arizona - Arizona

l . . Q . ‘ _ ‘ 1
11 I EXHIBIT G *
Case 2:04—cv—00408-SIVIIVI Document 103-8 . Filed 12/18/2006 Page 1 of 4
` V ._ ` V I . .· .- ·;- .,.. .. .`‘- -. . .. . ., . . . I ......

1 I .IN_THEjUNITED sTATE§HDISTRICT COURT ‘`` - I f,i_{ -
_ 1 2R FOR_THE DISTRICT OF ARIZONA fl, n QR ·r I R _ 1, ‘R I
§ I_i__+__,_______;_;____T_g?__e`_r____t__;__.________-______,__€,--;-;..--QX
1 V" V- 7 ` - l V `\ 3; ‘ IJ A V ` . ` I · -` `_ - - ` A-
E,‘ 4- KENT A. DYER and SUSAN DYER; _ _‘ R _ F , I-
; _‘; husband and wife, `_Q _ f' I 2. ._ A_
1 R CERT1FlE D 00PY
_ L 6 Rus n - - ‘._ ¤ . , Q ‘ ., ., _ " ‘
R l ,7_ 1 JASON; N1-IPIER and DANIE-LLE;'NA1$IER, _ ` R I ] __
R · 0 ¥ husband and`wife{ NAPLER SCULPTURE - 0 · l.?
‘ 8 GALLERY, INCL, a Washingfgn corporation, ·0_ ; 1·
9”‘ Qi _ Y .- D=efen&an1:$_.` 2 - `
I V—·-···¥—.-+-······_···-—_··t····_`··.·iZ-?r1·""?"‘UU""‘*U""'_”;""`T"U'T‘TX- ’ _ V U -il l
n . Ill 1 .`, 2 1 Y·,, »VIDEO¥CONEERENCE ’ _.;Y
‘ i {jg, 1 , ‘ ' 2 I ‘ DEPO$ITION0 1x l 2 _. ‘ RE?
1 _- f13 i ‘ I ‘L ‘ · R `OF I l · R `I -`’.' {di -_IR` Y
- L='14; * ‘, _ _’ ` iJANEdS.`KINNE. `A h· ` lj.`, f(._j?
. R *-15- j ·` - SiT;AMT5‘-OPOD,-'CONNECWTICUT " l T In ‘'`. ‘- ·I-
_ 1 I- is l " 'AlTGUS'If'-'2’,- ,2005 , i R ‘’0_ » ..},1;
_ l' _0 2 OR. R._· 2lTK_INSON-BAKER,.` me., A in ·’ _ . " · ` ` . , ‘R0. ‘ f
__‘ `—‘y I COURT REPORTERS‘ _ ·__ _‘ _` _ 0 - . ~,
‘ I =211h500 North Brand Boulevard, Third Floor f` _ ‘r0; -‘”0 {
Q - ·w Glendale, California 91203-4725 I €= _` -2 _ _§y *
`¤ R __ 0‘,22 (800} 288-3376, .1 R. 0. -, ·.- ‘Q
,‘_:,y·23_ REPORTED.BY: NancygAnne Flynn, RPR I - j_0,/ _` { ,_,-
_ ;% FILE NOJ: 9F064E2 _ . . ‘-0, , , , I ·-
l -. _ . V ._ n 7 , _ I ` 7 7 I` I_ -‘ --rr ‘.V
I` ROAR . Ga$e 2:O4—0v—OO408—S|\/IIVI DOcu_ment_103—8 Filed 12/18/2006 Page 2 Of4· 3 yj .V - `

. I · - E
Qdi. .· · ‘ 1 .- A `I have it in front of me. _ 1
1 _ .2 - I Q ` Based on what_you've just said, isn't
_i3i this image then copyrightable the very same way the I
d _ 1 4 rimage on Napier number is is copyrightable, since we- -.
I 1 5 have all or the same elements, not same elements, but- `
n 5.__ *` 6 same kind of elements present in this photograph?
_.- · 7 A Certainly the entire image is U j`
t 5 8~ copyrightable. “i 1 ‘ U g ‘
. _, '3- k - 1 n Q _Which would include the mother 5
-1 1Q mountain lion with the baby in the mouth, right? 1 i
mg,· .11 _ g _· A - In this scene, yes. _ . n I
{_ _ 12- n l Q 5 Right, the only scene I'm_talking‘t 5
&__-n 13 .about is the one in Exhibit Number 3 that you are I
U - ` -14k looking at. i g 5 e llr n n 1
- .115 l it " n g 1 MSM ZEMAN: Ilm going to object as to I ` l;
_.,`g 16 n form.- You need to clarify the question. ·
ig 1 i7Mi 55 — Are you asking_her if·the elements of the
1 ·` 18 -_ 1 _ mother mountain lion with kitten itself-is I _ _ .
_u t. 19 g °_ copyrightable with respect to this_ _ I
` _ `20i t Q_ photograph, or are you asking whether it's n
_. i_gj1_ . part of the entire copyright on the · 1 I i
1* ___3Q ; u photograph? g.gt V t
__ ° an , · 23 U _ Q? an Leijme try to clarify that, J&I1€, SO 1 i
(Nk},_ 524 you understand exactly what Ifm asking.- Earlier 1 _ 1 l
..5k n 25 lbelieve you said you‘ve never seen a photograph _ · .
n 2 t·-`. _-— . _ _ , _ _ _ 5 A74
. _ I __Case 2:04-cv—OO408¥SIVII\/I -Documenti103—8 _ FiIed12/1_8/2006 Page3of4 ·`

(·M nlnn l exactly like the one in Exhibit Number 3. That's
A't.. 2 still true, right?' if _ ` A 2 y
I-. 3 A Exactly like ity no, I can‘t claim to . n
` n ‘A=4 have seen another. - i 2 _ [tl
l A if · 5.y `. 2 tQ -Ohay. So, but you have seen other
t ~._’2 I 6 Vphotos like in Napier is of a mountain lion-with a n I
t 2 an n 7 kitten in the mouth?. A-.. --y_ _-
ga _.-2 8 p A n Absolutely, ‘ _ ` A A _
·t .2 2 an 9- Q` So-we.can agree that not all pictures ‘
· h` _lO2 of a mountain lion with a baby in its mouth are the _
I __ 11 same, because there are all sorts of different mays_
h_ I 12 of depicting that image; is that fair? " `
l©» I I 13 A 2 That is correct? _ I n H ,
an it 14 y 2 Q - So with regard to Exhibit Number 3,
ihii, 2- l5' I'm talking right now everything mithin the borders --
fn l6. of Mr. Dyer*s photograph, will you agree mith as that i I
_.y‘ “l7 everything mithin the four corners of that photograph
ih. _- .18, including the mother mountain lion with the baby in
,';— -19. its·mouth, has copyright protection? r l ` i_ y
· 20 · - A W- Yes, _ l I
j A · 21 _Q _ 2And is that because it's yauf y t I
-»2 y 22 'understanding that Mr; Dyer went to Montana to take_ _ E
t I ,23 this photograph, selected his film, selected the I I I
{mi- 24y2camera, used animal trainers, made sure the light was- n
Qjfhe 25 right and so forth? I l y f ·
--._ · J p · _ W n l" I ‘ f75 _-
n . Case 2:O4.—cv—QQ408gSIVII\/I Document 103-8 ‘ FiIed12/18/2006 .Pagel40i4. y

Case 2:04-cv-00408-SMM

Document 103-8

Filed 12/18/2006

Page 1 of 4

Case 2:04-cv-00408-SMM

Document 103-8

Filed 12/18/2006

Page 2 of 4

Case 2:04-cv-00408-SMM

Document 103-8

Filed 12/18/2006

Page 3 of 4

Case 2:04-cv-00408-SMM

Document 103-8

Filed 12/18/2006

Page 4 of 4