Free Motion for Summary Judgment - District Court of Arizona - Arizona

1 ANDREW P. THOMAS
MARICOPA COUNTY ATTORNEY
2
By: DENNIS D. CARPENTER, JR.
3 State Bar No. 019422
JOSEPH I. VIGIL
4 State Bar No. 018677
Deputy County Attorneys
5 MCAO Firm No. 00032000
6 CIVIL DIVISION
Security Center Building
7 222 North Central Avenue, Suite 1100
Phoenix, Arizona 85004-2206
8 Telephone (602) 506-8541
9 Attorneys for Defendants Joseph Arpaio,
Bill Williams, Tracy Haggard, Linda Velasquez,
10 Sgt. Olsen, B.H.O. Tademy, Lt. Barcelo,
Sgt. Conn, and H.O. Spencer
1 1
IN THE UNITED STATES DISTRICT COURT
12
FOR THE DISTRICT OF ARIZONA
13
Jesse Cabana, NO. CV 03-1971-PHX-JAT (JI)
14
Plaintiff, DEFENDANTS’ STATEMENT OF
15 FACTS
v.
16
Joseph Arpaio, Bill Williams, Tracey
17 Haggard, Linda Velasquez, Sgt. Olsen,
B.H.O. Tademy, Lt. Barcelo, Sgt. Conn,
18 H.O. Spencer,
19 Defendants.
20
Defendants Joseph Arpaio, Bill Williams, Tracy Haggard, Linda
21
Velasquez, Sgt. Olsen, B.H.O. Tademy, Lt. Barcelo, Sgt. Conn, and H.O.
22
1
Cas :03-cv-01971-JAT-ECV Document 18-2 Filed 12/30/2005 Page 1 of 4

1 Spencer ("Defendants"), by and through undersigned counsel, hereby submit
2 their Statement of Facts in Support of Defendants’ Motion for Summary
3 Judgment pursuant to Rule 56 of the Federal Rules of Civil Procedure and Local
4 Rule 1.10(l)(1).
5 1. Plaintiff Jesse Cabana was arrested and booked into the Maricopa
6 County Sheriff’s Ofhce ("MCSO") Maricopa County Jail System on December
7 14, 2002. (See Exhibit Affidavit of Margaret DiFrancesco, 1] 5.)
8 2. On October 10, 2003, Plaintiff Hled a Complaint in the Federal Court
9 for the District of Arizona. (PIaintiff’s Complaint, Pg. 1.) The Complaint alleged
10 six counts of constitutional violations by the Defendants in overseeing the
11 operation of the Maricopa County Madison Street Jail. (PIaintiff’s Complaint.)
12 However, the Court dismissed Counts l, II, IV, V, and VI of the Complaint on
13 March 29, 2004. (Order of the Honorable James A. Tielborg, dated March 29,
14 2004).
15 3. In Count lll of his Complaint, Plaintiff alleges that the Defendants
16 violated his Fourteenth Amendment rights on three separate occasions when
17 they placed him on the nutraloaf diet. Plaintiff alleges that placing him on the
18 diet constitutes punishment for which he was not allowed a hearing nor an
19 opportunity to appeal. (Complaint, Page 6, 1] 3.)
20 4. Plaintiff seeks injunctive relief in the form of an order by the Court to
21 Defendants to do a variety of things. included in the request for injunctive relief
22 is a request to the Court to order the Defendants "to refrain from placing
Cas 2:O3—cv—O1971—JAT-ECV Document 18-22 Filed 12/30/2005 Page 2 of4

1 detainees on the loaf diet as a sanction for punishment without due process and
2 for violations not related to food infractions." Additionally, Plaintiff requests the
3 Court order the Defendants "to refrain from depriving Plaintiff of his religious diet
4 as a sanction for disciplinary punishment while also denying plaintiff out of cell
5 time for weeks and months without due process." (Plaintiffs Complaint, Pg. 7.)
6 5. Plaintiff was released from the custody of the Maricopa County Jail
7 system on March 31, 2005. (Affidavit of Margaret DiFrancesco, 1[ 5.)
8 6. Plaintiff is currently sewing a life sentence in the Arizona
9 Department of Corrections prison system. (Exhibit "B", March 18, 2005 minute
10 entry of Maricopa County Superior Court Judge Gary E. Donahoe, Page 2.;
11 Exhibit "C", Arizona Department of Corrections Inmate Detail of Jesse Cabana.)
12
13
14 RESPECTFULLY SUBMITTED this 30"‘ day of December, 2005.
15 ANDREW P. THOMAS
MARICOPA COUNTY ATTORNEY
16
17
BY: s/Dennis D. Carpenter, Jr.
18 DENNIS D. CARPENTER, JR.
JOSEPH I. VIGIL
19 Deputy County Attorney
Attorneys for Defendants
20 Joseph Arpaio, Bill Williams, Tracy
Haggard, Linda Velasquez, Sgt. Olsen,
21 B.H.O. Tademy, Lt. Barcelo, Sgt.
Conn, and H.O. Spencer
22
3
Cas 2:03—cv—01971—JAT-ECV Document 18-2 Filed 12/30/2005 Page 3 of 4

1 ORIGINAL of the foregoing E-FILED
and copy MAILED this
2 30"‘ day of December 2005 to:
3 Honorable James A. Teilborg
United States District Court Judge
4 Sandra Day O’Connor U.S. Courthouse
401 West Washington Street
5 Phoenix, AZ 85003
6 Honorable Jay R. Irwin
United States Magistrate Judge
7 Sandra Day O’Connor U.S. Courthouse
401 West Washington Street
8 Phoenix, AZ 85003
9 and copy mailed to:
10 Jess Cabana, ADC #194035
ASPC-Florence
11 P.O. Box 629
Florence, Arizona 85232-0629
12 Plaintiff Pro Per
13
14 s/Elizabeth Jordan
15 CJ04-080
S:\COUNSEL\Civll\Matters\CJ\2004\Cabana CJ04-0B0\Pleadings\SOF.doc
16
17
18
19
20
21
22
4
Cas 2:03—cv—01971—JAT-ECV Document 18-2 Filed 12/30/2005 Page 4 of 4

Case 2:03-cv-01971-JAT-ECV

Document 18-2

Filed 12/30/2005

Page 1 of 4

Case 2:03-cv-01971-JAT-ECV

Document 18-2

Filed 12/30/2005

Page 2 of 4

Case 2:03-cv-01971-JAT-ECV

Document 18-2

Filed 12/30/2005

Page 3 of 4

Case 2:03-cv-01971-JAT-ECV

Document 18-2

Filed 12/30/2005

Page 4 of 4