Free Response in Opposition to Motion - District Court of Arizona - Arizona

, . J / A c T ii `: ` .. . . Q :· . [Q . r J
»» » » gssasssi J J J S -» W ».— i ,.... I ... .. .. ; » . ' .Q;Q§1l;I ;i - i 2 . ..§ rataa . i =
__ *· _··A g _ A Y ·* Y _;. tz _._ :;_j._}.,,;g“._.·; »_‘— jg;.‘._;,€_j_i;;.,_·;Tj·.i,-gn,;:5.;-%1Q,;.;‘i··;;‘;;·;;¤,;,;`·
Q _ iA». an · ’ · _._.,. c ...P
-_·.;._ L_ , , THE y .»-W —`_=-’` L -·»·; Q_ _` Qi ‘_*.· g _*_v Z‘_;_; __A_v 5 ‘_.` C
J·;·;·§i.__. . . Z . . ,.. , _>___ __ il UA
, · - · . .. J . ..`VV: _ _ -- V°"` .;} ° . ' » `
T REPUBLIC ‘ ..1·· -.=. M » — V » z - ~
. ·· r -·’22;3:2;e=5z,2i;E·r,‘··`5~,&i;%·—=- 12.;;.; ·;-l · · _ · ’ . e
;. . . . *21 - —: . . ‘ .
’ S -· .».· · : .
" ‘‘‘‘ “ ‘‘ ’ ;‘· C c T
_ . -. .___/£t.•:J· 5. I 3;%;,. S
" 2.:; .‘_=.‘. .A,:.—,,.·y-=~:,` ,.V`; ». : — ¤: 7 ~~ » .A· S ` T. ~.·.».. . .. ATJ, » »\.;» . i ; ,$:z; , A, ,¤. . .
Co st b e is rt ' I Justic Co t s ffl
By Brent Whiting Canez and another black eye for the guilty in June 200 to federal
The Arizona Republic — ¤ others claim county’s beleaguered Justice charges of selling bogus in- _ __ ..
that Andy Court system. The string of surance policies to truck ;`€jF1i·»=*
It was a courthouse scuffle Gastelum, the scandals include the follow- drivers. ‘
worthy of the World Wres— Maryvale jus- ing: lMark Hamblen, a·former Q
tling Federation. g tice of the lMark Dobronski, the west Tempe constable who"
l All that was lacking were peace, insti— Scottsdale JR who was tem- admitted in court in May 2000§ .-
flying drop kicks and combat- gated the fra- porarily stripped of duties that he had failed to serve?
V ants getting cracked over the . .· cas, then this_month due to 37 allega— court papers for a six—month _
head with folding chairs. prank stood by do- tions of misconduct in the period. __ .
The melee occurred March Cane; ing nothing as courtroom. I John M. Carpenter, a for- ;‘
9 at the Maryvale Justice Canez, 58, »·-.· Joe Murray, a former merJPin East Phoenix No.1 -
Court, 4622 W Indian School was taken down by a younger Peoria constable who was Justice Court, who was re-
Road, during a confrontation and bigger man. sentenced March 1 for per- moved from the bench last
between Frank Canez, the Police and prosecutors are jury and stripped of his year after a hearing on nu- ` _
Maryvale constable, and attempting to sort out the $45,000—a—year elected job. merous allegations, including .
Roger Hefner, 38, a security mess, authorities said. ¤Brian Lamb, a former 'J ~
guard for Maricopa County. In the meantime, it’s yet Chandler ,JP who pleaded Sec COURTzPage5 _‘_, ,
. A e `~ A i
-‘», — .· .-.» — »- - P -ti.-` — -·i-: _-.~ - .¢i—. ·‘·.l `
if n S · He1ofl2l A
Case 2:O2—cv—O1387-I\/IHI\/I Document 135-2 Filed O2/17/2006 PGQ

A ‘ A` A ·‘ ’’‘*°‘` ‘ _‘‘- ‘‘`- - eww ·..» »A v-·‘ -¤-- · fr¥¥:·;i=`A*‘ i;
SAAZQ; _``. Av - A`— i¥¤f¥AA Y`AT ':N A A’·?A? 5 AAAAAAA ‘;—: A1 '.`·· A '·»‘ - ”-v— =A * ‘’-· AA·‘' Z¥.A;f
II ._., ·.`_ I I I A -
AA ‘‘‘ rz ’··?’ ¤Y*¢·¤-Ai A. I A = ‘;Vq ·‘i`»" EA?:‘é€%!E‘¤A$iéAf3‘ _`»; V____ .___ A · - ; _ ._-_
- A A ·.v. · ~····· · ··~=·=_-·· AAA $,1 AQ ,_-» —_=·v ...‘ AI; _ _ _A -».;;. i -_-_
· `.`_V.
A _V·. A ._ A A ‘ · »`»V A- · · A AA;ZAAA I `A‘‘‘ ; ·»-= ¤;1 ;`‘ ·`‘. ZA r·*A
·‘.-._ I - _ - _ _ I I II AA I· I.IAI AI
1 A ' ; · A A ' A A i;1Ai?"AAF16¤1 P¤8¢iTA’j '; -` 3 AA--¤ `Z A
A A A A ‘ A» '· - '“`»`’ AA ’·AAA; AATQ AA ;
SA ~ A A A ; 7* ° AA -A ¤Si1i€*¥i¤i€th¤mDh€t¤i¤i¥¤€$ ’éA A ’
A-~· AAI >A;A ..@ A ·.¤· ‘ A istav awake ¤¤th¤’b‘¢¤¢bi·` `A‘AA
;.;;f¢=>;¤eriiiAe.;.·-iif’:Az€2·;;A2i‘§§;‘ié;;i.‘iZ;2;f;;’A€;iL ‘‘¢;- i¥?¤ ·:-= In AMawv¤1¢»A A A ·v¤‘· 1A
=;-A;AA’AQ`§if¥` IA§iiAAi;A-; .-‘` A ·_... ,_V. AAAAAAAAAAAA-AAAfYA?]AAA"T'A‘1 ‘4‘~ constable f0r_more than ff6u1j .'`' ‘;iIGa§§e1uni‘·Aftefdse§IT»I;o{{*co¤i$’}E1r;A&1é‘·_’r§"Ae`·‘>·‘i* -A··» ;__»_;A<-;
Q; "``· A ‘W ' ‘ A A ·; ·· ; · :1;* ‘¤A—¢ "{LA AAP __yeai·s,A Ahe was attacked _II1§I){·bI€C2ll1S€A·‘Of thgéiA§p0S*.gibi1—A’; —1Yf;;;~f.j*~·-·;;;Ag-4¢A{—LA—f£c
I2I§I;_Aj&gA;_¥—· · AIA ~4_- Q AA AA AI A; ,;,: after_Gaste1um,AAthe_J?R_issued _}ity~’·¤AofA_;1ega1_A ` A* ’AY·§"A`A‘A_I
A$$$A$¥A§AjAjA‘A·=J;·’*A*;?¤AAAA?AAA?A?AAré=-2;: .V;v. 2 .; - ¤¤AA¤dmi¤i$¤`¤¤V€— 0Yd€FA bef:. .V?*£J?i$ii¢é A
II I _ .... A 3- AI; A; . I fI_OII_DIIIC1€I_ica1 I · II I. II I . II
‘ ’ ` ; 0f ¥h€AA¢¤¤fU10¤$¢·A Ca¤€2`said ·‘V.. 2 A V`’"‘` *
- ` A -.—h¤’SA-Ahad"=¤¢¤¤SS»16 ·Ath¢.1¤ié¤Si ‘`~A fA
f¤Y ¥¤91“€AU?€i¤°f0*lF Y€?¤”$¥; E? ·’A·i`@$11%7FA?€€>’¤A€?ijhY$i¢a}AAYAA;U¥i15JA§?@r“?;? A A
_ j ··`` I _Gaste1um‘iiséued _ the Eqrqer :Ineiiisthxckj?AhiJii?*AaI_A_I`coi1pI€€A_§Aii? A
Aj; A A A A .b¢é¤¤"S¢‘C¤n<2zA;héd s¤mi¤rtcdA=A;1J—·tir¤¤$;-é¤r¤="¤D¤2¤¤0r;_`AAt1ia$iT€¤§i»
.AAAA,,A.A,_g_AA.I_A;A,A_.__ ____ `gar1Au11succe$sfo1Iriva1io.Gas#‘ A_.=, enéz sttenuou51$iAde11iedQI;
·~·. ;A; :23;; ·.;_A·>A-A7A§j?—’-‘ASaT‘AFAiA‘.j2f;gg‘·j;‘·‘=`·`r»f¤¤ ‘te1u¤i¥ AinIAI1as€_AAYeax’s·A_pri;néfY’aAAA=§AI?·A·;;H¢fB€¥'$.A`3A_A,Afo1j;xier“_A,{?;p(f],ig;€§Q_ ____ A _A A_
- T 3 A; AA ‘ A "‘'·" F Ac1<=c1i¤¤,‘-_i1i¢?>¤¥?$€3b1$? séidst; A‘¤ffiééfA§EA.‘fQai1dAiQ’;·2"c0ri$fab1éZE§;"ME$$€`A·FA*Z?
ji-EZ -Z A A A A0nA‘%M¥if¢hfA’9;~E$Wh€¤AA.A€@fi€Zi·F AAY¤i11@¥Q¤1iiitY;’Saids?h€£AE<1idA;-ii¤¥;Z¥
Cn 1 ; A 1 A_ A ° r A A · A1?1'if~ir`i1i¤A·`€€2ii¥é1i“ :·=` 1héA ·`A·‘A 3f?3_7Yt<>AQC*A¤6AWA%}?6fAP6$$ib1€A?5€@`{§b19¤@»A‘·1 - A AY
Q A; A _ _ ‘ P 1 IA ` A`A- 4 ·_make·AA ‘ph¤tbc0piesAA_A_ijHé;nér,nibejeween ‘‘-° canez A ; ‘
1; A A A ·11hQAA‘S€¢¤1?i€YA€¤5fd; v‘"’ €%VQAA@m;:1W1ié¤AA-hir:1e`WéSA¥?&$A$iST¥€@iQ1§§A‘?€}$$AAAE A » A AAA
‘-¥· i A; AA A A A ~ A Aé‘A$h¤vé,AAAwi¢SfJédA €` A
*52%-A‘1*‘A’;i’ -AZ;iY{;-1A¥A;T€;géA}=;‘prA‘ V ‘Z AY-Af `?·??A‘¥¤’-:Ai=’z°; ;i -A.' A? AAA- A- '·A€?@{1¤dQYA.-$11%
?€?€A F? ‘_A_ ATA;A`$%?? ¤¢·A `;-AA.-‘ AAA- QATi‘;"A*A914ffS_;6}1Ahiiii,AA.C$¥T€ZAA{Sé1i<}§gTb€iA]§A1QTA‘EEMik§AA‘}OSA€éff€l@}?€YiBii¢K€Yé§Aj‘Afz‘ - AAA, A
*1.% AAAA » Y ';`‘ lA 'V‘’‘‘ ‘ *‘·· ifi * ·— ·- ? A?AA-siufféFiwéféfeéAZ%¤€ii16vA€s1*·’§ .``‘ 1 AA ?`
A ”·`‘ ` ‘‘“‘‘ T i -·»‘ ·A -A;A ¥AA Ai A V —
A A ··A;V — A»_A A‘A`A AA . ‘
IA » AA A IAAI II._ _A;A_.AAI A;.§A: II {;—: III. Ig; A__A §A;Q;IQAAI.I`. ZAI I A I
§?%:k:€;€‘fiE‘.= -° - :· · AIA ‘AA» _— A AQ::*A<‘ 3); A I ,1 Q‘A3?cA·A Aléé?}21ii;i¤1fi 2$;;;I¥??A%¢AiA‘1~ i {-*:'*A ‘·V‘. A?*2iA- A K-
A¤AA ;?A;f‘AAAki1<>W1éA¤€€d
ij€AE€T§TZ*f1 `"”`’`"`` i ;A; ¥ffl!§»’<-i -·‘·
*·—‘ ‘ A ·A·->; A A·_
if A A ·Y— A A ; with‘>A?€m6'i0iY·A-AAA.$ATh€f"°A‘Wh¤}€AA-EA;AA}@0$iéTf€ldSAA$¥%Y¢‘TAH€ff¥€E§LYK§$$ ————
QA; A A .A _ A A· things;wasfvery-=_AAemb21TassiAAAl A;
‘>": AAAA A A A AA A `A ~ A‘AA ;-A‘; ·°? ’-A>; ~=»;AA AA·— €EE*;=:AC¤\4F€"·b¢¢¤ii·SéAAAA6fA:h¢i§}iE€¥¥§@§A ` 3
AAAAAAAA . ;.A·A—~A·A A-? A~A-A— AA AA ·A*?“YAAfi?1éhd6‘L$¤1d€¥€; 1h€;AC<·>¤·AA A A °‘ A i
~{iT·;?£;?AZA??-`*;.EACTA!"}TA2_··;i;i};=€?=‘5;A;f;A;ifA;‘AL·1i’;¥>éA¥€§i*;A’i*?;·‘;AfAiii¤i*:*;¤-=<‘¥*=;;A;2¢sA;2¤;Z¤E?Z:rA`ei¢§ZQL=‘;Y mil; Phoénix ‘¢ ‘ I I. II
“ A A A—Av * *' ‘ ‘A A Ca1iez,_I said that. based 6t1Ithe·__ I"Reac|1the repoyiéiat T?=i£A?€&ffiF"A{*":‘:4A.5.`Ai?;
"* A I A ; Q A ; ‘ A _ evidence;-.Hefher acted on _ jbredilwhhing@an§z¤¤arepU1¤lih§’gcg}Ei§A1?A!?ii1"‘A"AAAA";Q$iiAAgA_g A ;Ag:{AA
I A _ ordei‘sAfromGaste1um. A AA’(602)444¥6925i= A*g‘§,`;*A’ A7 {AFA
°;` A ‘ A · A - “ AAAA - AA·· A A · - —` *‘ A' ATC-Ari A
A A_ · - A A»¤· · · .A ` ; ‘ A A ‘
I I Case 2.02 cv 01387 I\/IIjII\/II Document 135e2 Fnled 02/17/2006 Page 2 c§1°2°Z00385“ ‘

Case 2:02-cv-01387-MHM

Document 135-2

Filed 02/17/2006

Page 1 of 2

Case 2:02-cv-01387-MHM

Document 135-2

Filed 02/17/2006

Page 2 of 2