Free Motion for Leave to File - District Court of Federal Claims - federal

Case 1:92-cv-00580-EJD

Document 304

Filed 02/04/2008

Page 1 of 17

IN THE UNITED STATES COURT OF FEDERAL CLAIMS ______________________________ SPARTON CORPORATION, ) ) Plaintiff, ) ) v. ) No. 92-580C ) Chief Judge Edward Damich THE UNITED STATES, ) ) Defendant. ) SPARTON CORPORATION'S MOTION TO FILE ITS LIST OF EXHIBITS Sparton Corporation ("Sparton"), in compliance with the Court's June 20, 2007 Order, paragraph 2ci(4), (Doc. 290), moves for leave to file its list of exhibits and witnesses provided below. LIST OF EXHIBITS EXHIBIT Exhibit 1 Exhibit 2 DESCRIPTION Intentionally Deleted Selected portions of Contract N00019-69-C-0465 dated March 5, 1965 (B0031, A000026-29) P2.1-.4 PAGE(S)

Exhibit 3

Selected portions of Sparton's P3.1-.16 Response to Navy solicitation N00019-69-R-0075 dated January 3, 1968, incorporated within Contract N00019-69-C-0465 (B0035, A000034-49) Mod. P00004 to Contract No. N00019-69- C-0465 dated July 13, 1971 (B0051, A000022-25) JX exhibits P4.1-.4

Exhibit 4

Exhibits 5-8

Exhibit 9

Sparton Internal Memo to A. Knoll P9.1 From N. Devereaux dated October 19, 1970 (B0073, SPA 02782)

1

Case 1:92-cv-00580-EJD

Document 304

Filed 02/04/2008

Page 2 of 17

Exhibits 10-11 JX exhibits Exhibit 12 Sparton Internal Memo to C. Bush P12.1 from D. DePew dated January 22, 1971 (B0082, SPA 02791)

Exhibits 13-17 JX exhibits Exhibit 18 Progress Report for Job No. 7400-1003 dated March 30, 1971 (B0113, SPA 02822-823) P18.1-.2

Exhibits 19-28 JX exhibits Exhibit 29 Sparton Internal Memo to R. Hungerford from J. Widenhofer dated August 18, 1970 (B0157, SPA 02866) P29.1

Exhibits 30-41 JX exhibits Exhibit 42 Sparton Internal Memo to R. P42.1 N. Devereaux from C. Huntoon dated January 18, 1972 (B0206, SP 02915)

Exhibits 43-56 JX exhibits Exhibit 57 Declaration of Gerry Martin (B0285) P57.1-.3

Exhibits 58-61 JX exhibits Exhibit 62 Gerry Martin competitor P62.1-.4 contract Summary report (B0301)

Exhibit 63 Continuation Sheet for P63.1 Supplies/Service and Prices for Contract N00163-79-C-0166 (B0305) Exhibit 64 Continuation Sheet for P64.1 Supplies/Service and Prices for Contract N00163-80-C-0215 (B0306) Continuation Sheet for P65.1 Supplies/Service and Prices for Contract N00163-81-C0291 (B0307) Continuation Sheet for P66.1 Supplies/Service and Prices for 2

Exhibit 65

Exhibit 66

Case 1:92-cv-00580-EJD

Document 304

Filed 02/04/2008

Page 3 of 17

Contract N00163-82-C 0070 (B0308) Exhibit 67 Continuation Sheet for P67.1 Supplies/Service and Prices for Contract N00163-82-C 0115 (B0309) Continuation Sheet for P68.1 Supplies/Service and prices for Contract N00163-83-C0068 (B0310) Continuation Sheet for P69.1 Supplies/Service and Prices for Contract N00163-83-C 0066 (B0311) Continuation Sheet for P70.1 Supplies/Service and Prices for Contract N00163-84-C 0003 (B0312) Continuation Sheet for P71.1 Supplies/Service and Prices for Contract N00163-86-C-0008 (B0313) Continuation Sheet for P72.1 Supplies/Service and Prices for Contract N00163-87-C0155 (B0314) Continuation Sheet for P73.1 Supplies/Service and Prices for Contract N00163-88-C0003 (B0315) Continuation Sheet for P74.1 Supplies/Service and Prices for Contract N00163-89-C0013 (B0316) Continuation Sheet for P75.1 Supplies/Service and Prices for Contract N00163-89-C0012 (B0317) Continuation Sheet for P76.1 Supplies/Service and Prices for Contract N00163-90-C3

Exhibit 68

Exhibit 69

Exhibit 70

Exhibit 71

Exhibit 72

Exhibit 73

Exhibit 74

Exhibit 75

Exhibit 76

Case 1:92-cv-00580-EJD

Document 304

Filed 02/04/2008

Page 4 of 17

0033 (B0318) Exhibit 77 Continuation Sheet for P77.1 Supplies/Service and Prices for Contract N00163-90-C0001 (B0319) Continuation Sheet for P78.1 Supplies/Service and Prices for Contract N00163-91-C0081 (B0320) Continuation Sheet for P79.1 Supplies/Service and Prices for Contract N00163-91-C0080 (B0321) Continuation Sheet for P80.1 Supplies/Service and Prices for Contract N00163-88-C0004 (B0322) Continuation Sheet for P81.1 Supplies/Service and Prices for Contract N00163-88-C0014 (B0323) Continuation Sheet for P82.1 Supplies/Service and Prices for Contract N00163-81-C0370 (B0324) Continuation Sheet for P83.1 Supplies/Service and Prices for Contract N00163-81-C0372 (B0325) Continuation Sheet for P84.1 Supplies/Service and Prices for Contract N00163-81-C0392 (B0326) Continuation Sheet for P85.1 Supplies/Service and Prices for Contract N00163-82-C0175 (B0327) Continuation Sheet for P86.1 Supplies/Service and Prices for Contract N00163-83-C4

Exhibit 78

Exhibit 79

Exhibit 80

Exhibit 81

Exhibit 82

Exhibit 83

Exhibit 84

Exhibit 85

Exhibit 86

Case 1:92-cv-00580-EJD

Document 304

Filed 02/04/2008

Page 5 of 17

0080 (B0328) Exhibit 87 Continuation Sheet for P87.1 Supplies/Service and Prices for Contract N00163-83-C0008 (B0329) Continuation Sheet for P88.1 Supplies/Service and Prices for Contract N00163-85-C0007 (B0330) Continuation Sheet for P89.1 Supplies/Service and Prices for Contract N00163-85-C0121 (B0331) Continuation Sheet for P90.1 Supplies/Service and Prices for Contract N00163-86-C0010 (B0332) Continuation Sheet for P91.1 Supplies/Service and Prices for Contract N00163-86-C0202 (B0333) Continuation Sheet for P92.1 Supplies/Service and Prices for Contract N00163-87-C0006 (B0334) Continuation Sheet for P93.1 Supplies/Service and Prices for Contract N00163-87-C0007 (B0335) Continuation Sheet for P94.1 Supplies/Service and Prices for Contract N00163-88-C0009 (B0336) Continuation Sheet for P95.1 Supplies/Service and Prices for Contract N00163-80-C0016 (B0337) Continuation Sheet for P96.1 Supplies/Service and Prices for Contract N00163-90-C5

Exhibit 88

Exhibit 89

Exhibit 90

Exhibit 91

Exhibit 92

Exhibit 93

Exhibit 94

Exhibit 95

Exhibit 96

Case 1:92-cv-00580-EJD

Document 304

Filed 02/04/2008

Page 6 of 17

0139 (B0338) Exhibit 97 Continuation Sheet for P97.1 Supplies/Service and Prices for Contract N00163-92-C0078 (B0339) Continuation Sheet for P98.1 Supplies/Service and Prices for Contract N00163-93-C0087 (B0340) Continuation Sheet for P99.1-.7 Supplies/Service and Prices for Contract N00019-79-C0220 (B0341) Continuation Sheet for P100.1 Supplies/Service and Prices for Contract N00019-79-C0593 (B0348) Continuation Sheet for P101.1 Supplies/Service and Prices for Contract N00163-82-C0230 (B0349) Continuation Sheet for P102.1 Supplies/Service and Prices for Contract N00163-83-C0082 (B0350) Continuation Sheet for P103.1 Supplies/Service and Prices for Contract N00163-84-C0006 (B0351) Continuation Sheet for P104.1 Supplies/Service and Prices for Contract N00163-85-C0005 (B0352) Continuation Sheet for P105.1 Supplies/Service and Prices for Contract N00163-83-C0007 (B0353) Modification P0010 to Contract N0016390-C-0004 (B0354) 6 P106.1

Exhibit 98

Exhibit 99

Exhibit 100

Exhibit 101

Exhibit 102

Exhibit 103

Exhibit 104

Exhibit 105

Exhibit 106

Case 1:92-cv-00580-EJD

Document 304

Filed 02/04/2008

Page 7 of 17

Exhibit 107 Exhibit 108 Exhibit 109

Declaration of Henry Melvin Delete

P107.1-.4

Attachment to Melvin P109.1-.45 Declaration (Bid Package PTP, B0378) Attachment to Melvin P110.1-.3 Declaration Sparton Loss Under Mod. 4 to Contract N00019-69-C-0465 (B0424) Joint exhibits

Exhibit 110

Exhibits 111-120 Exhibit 121

Selected pages from William P121.1-.16 H. Graff Deposition dated November 2, 1993 Tr. 7, 8, 36-38, 43, 46, 67, 91-93, 95, 101, 104-105, 107-110, 122-125, 149-150) Amendment PX0007 to P122.1-.3 Contract (N00019-69- C-0465 dated April 19, 1972 (SPA 2355-57) Amendment PX0008 to P123.1-.3 Contract N00019-69- B0548 C-0465 dated June 8, 1972 (SPA 2349-51) Joint exhibits P123.1-.2

Exhibit 122

Exhibit 123

Exhibits 124-127 Exhibit 128

Navy Budget Report for 1994-65 (017088-89, B0577) Joint exhibits

Exhibits 129-134 Exhibit 135

Selected Portions of NAVAIR P135.1-.3 Acquisition Guide, Seventh Edition (016311, 016349, 016350) Joint exhibits P151.1-.2

Exhibits 136-150 Exhibit 151 Exhibit 152-154 Exhibit 155 Exhibit 156

Declaration of Charles Boyle Joint exhibits Declaration of Charles Boyle Deleted 7

P155.1-.19

Case 1:92-cv-00580-EJD

Document 304

Filed 02/04/2008

Page 8 of 17

Exhibit 157

Deleted Joint exhibits P160.1-.7

Exhibits 158-159 Exhibit 160

Description of the Deep DIFAR Sonobuoy B0816 Deleted Joint exhibits

Exhibit 161 Exhibit 162-164 Exhibit 165

Selected portions of P165.1-.9 Deposition transcript of Don Pickrell, Jr. (Tr. Cover, 54-57, 94-97) Joint exhibit Selected portions of Deposition transcript of Karl Kuhn (Tr. Cover, 64-67) P167.1-.5

Exhibit 166 Exhibit 167

Exhibit 168

Selected portions of P168.1-.44 Deposition transcript of Stuart Logan (Tr. Cover, Table pgs. 1-3, 1-3, 9-24, 37-40, 49-60, 65-68) Joint exhibits

Exhibits 169-170 Exhibit 171

Selected portions of book P171.1-.13 entitled "Modern Submarine Warfare" by David Miller and John Jordan dated 1987 Joint exhibit Rockwell Pickrell deposition P173.1-.8 exhibit 9: Wheat First Securities Investment Research dated July 7, 1986 Joint exhibits

Exhibit 172 Exhibit 173

Exhibits 174-176

Exhibit 177 Selected portions of the P177.1-.51 (But delete 177.9,.11, .15, .18, .19, .21-.24, .34-37) deposition of Navy employee William Graff (Tr. Cover, 17, 31-34, 41, 42, 44, 94, 96-116, 119-139) Exhibits 178-201 Joint exhibits

8

Case 1:92-cv-00580-EJD Exhibit 202

Document 304

Filed 02/04/2008

Page 9 of 17

Selected portions of P202.1-.19 deposition transcript of Raytheon employee Ouellette (Tr. Cover, 5-6, 12-14, 15-18, 26-32, 107109) Selected portions of P203.1-.27 deposition transcript of former Hazeltine employee Kuhn (Tr. 1, 4, 7, 57-80)

Exhibit 203

Exhibit 204 Selected portions of P204.1-.41 (But delete 204.35-.38) deposition transcript of former Rockwell employee Pickrell (Tr. Cover, 10-16, 28-58, 69) Exhibit 205 Selected portions of Rockwell's Pickrell deposition exhibit 4 Selected portions of Rockwell's Pickrell deposition exhibit 8 Selected portions of Rockwell's Pickrell deposition exhibit 20 Supplemental Declaration of Gerry Martin Supplemental Declaration of Henry Melvin Declaration of Charles Boyle Joint exhibit Infringement Chart For P214.1-.8 Magnavox AN/SSQ 53A Sonobuoys Under U.S. Patent No. 4,029,233 (Under Contracts 79-0166; 80-0215; 81-0291; and 82-0070). Infringement Chart For P215.1-.15 Magnavox AN/SSQ 53A Sonobuoys Under U.S. Patent No. 4,3,921,120 (Under Contracts 79-0166; 80-0215; 81-0291; and 82-0070). 9 P205.1-.21

Exhibit 206

P206.1-.3

Exhibit 207

P207.1-.7

Exhibit 208

P208.1-.3

Exhibit 209

P209.1-.5

Exhibit 210 Exhibit 211 Exhibit 214

P209.1-.24

Exhibit 215

Case 1:92-cv-00580-EJD

Document 304

Filed 02/04/2008

Page 10 of 17

Exhibit 216

Infringement Chart For P216.1-.8 Magnavox AN/SSQ 62A, 62B and 62C Sonobuoys Under U.S. Patent No. 4,029,233 (Under Contracts 79-0593; 81-0345; 82-0230; 830082; 84-0006, 85-0005; 88-0007; 90-0004; And 92-0016). Infringement Chart For P217.1-.5 Magnavox AN/SSQ 62A, 62B nd 62C Sonobuoys Under U.S. Patent No. 3,921,120 (Under Contracts 79-0593; 81-0345; 82-0230; 830082; 84-0006, 85-0005; 88-0007; 90-0004; And 92-0016). Infringement Chart For P218.1-.6 Magnavox AN/SSQ 77B, 53D, 53E, and 57B Sonobuoys Under U.S. Patent No. 4,029,233 (Under Contracts 89-0016; 90-0139; 92-0078; 93-0087; 89-0012; 90-0003; 91-0081; 91-0244; 88-0004 and 89-0014). Infringement Chart For P219.1-.13 Magnavox AN/SSQ 77B, 53D, 53E, and 57B Sonobuoys Under U.S. Patent No. 3,921,120 (Under Contracts 89-0016; 90-0139; 92-0078; 93-0087; 89-0012; 90-0003; 91-0081; 91-0244; 88-0004 And 89-0014). Infringement Chart For P220.1-.13 Magnavox AN/SSQ 77A Sonobuoys Under U.S. Patent No. 3,921,120 (Under Contracts 800457; 81-0370; 82-0175; 83-0080; 84-0008; 85-0007; 86-0010; 87-0006 And 88-0009). Infringement Chart For P221.1-.6 Magnavox AN/SSQ 77A Sonobuoys Under U.S. Patent No. 4,029,233 (Under Contracts 800457; 81-0370; 82-0175; 83-0080; 84-0008; 85-0007; 86-0010; 87-0006 And 88-0009). Infringement Chart For P222.1-.3 Raytheon AN/SSQ 62 And 62B Under U.S. Patent No. 4,029,233 (Under Contracts 77-0224; 790220; And 81-0346). Infringement Chart For P223.1-.5 Rockwell AN/SSQ 53B Sonobuoys Under U.S. Patent No. 3,921,120 (Under Contracts 810115 And 83-0068). 10

Exhibit 217

Exhibit 218

Exhibit 219

Exhibit 220

Exhibit 221

Exhibit 222

Exhibit 223

Case 1:92-cv-00580-EJD

Document 304

Filed 02/04/2008

Page 11 of 17

Exhibit 224

Infringement Chart For P224.1-.5 Rockwell AN/SSQ 53B Sonobuoys Under U.S. Patent 4,029,233 (Under Contracts 81-0115 And 83-0068). Infringement Chart For P225.1-.4 Sippican AN/SSQ 36 Sonobuoys Under U.S. Patent No. 4,029,233 (Under Contract 800134). Infringement Chart For P226.1-.13 Sippican AN/SSQ 36 Sonobuoys Under U.S. Patent No. 3,921,120 (Under Contract 800134). Infringement Chart For P227.1-.4 Sippican AN/SSQ 77A Sonobuoys Under U.S. Patent 4,029,233 (Under Contracts 81-0372 (Novation From Hazeltine); 84-0117; 85-0121; 86-0202; And 87-0007 (Novation To Hermes). Infringement Chart For P228.1-.12 Sippican AN/SSQ 77A Sonobuoys Under U.S. Patent 3,921,120 (Under Contracts 81-0372 (Novation From Hazeltine); 84-0117; 850121; 86-0202; And 87-0007 (Novation To Hermes). Infringement Chart For P229.1-.4 Hazeltine AN/SSQ 53B And VLAD Sonobuoys Under U.S. Patent No. 4,029,233 (Under Contracts 79-0591; 81-0391 And 81-0392). Infringement Chart For P230.1-.13 Hazeltine AN/SSQ 53B And VLAD (SSQ 77/77A) Sonobuoys Under U.S. Patent No. 3,921,120 (Under Contracts 79-0591; 81-0391; And 810392). Infringement Chart For P231.1-.12 Hermes AN/SSQ 53B, 53D, 53E And 77B Sonobuoys Under U.S. Patent No. 3,921,120 (Under Contracts 86-0008; 87-0155; 88-0003; 89-0013; 90-0001 And 91-0080). Infringement Charts For P232.1-.4 Hermes AN/SSQ 53B, 53D, 53E And 77B Sonobuoys Under U.S. Patent 4,029,233 (Under

Exhibit 225

Exhibit 226

Exhibit 227

Exhibit 228

Exhibit 229

Exhibit 230

Exhibit 231

Exhibit 232

11

Case 1:92-cv-00580-EJD

Document 304

Filed 02/04/2008

Page 12 of 17

Contracts 86-0008; 87-0155; 88-0003; 890013; 90-0001; 91-0243; And 91-0080. Exhibit 233 Infringement Chart For P233.1-.3 Hermes AN/SSQ 53B Sonobuoys Under U.S. Patent No. 4,029,233 (Under Contracts 760507; 83-0066; And 84-0003). Infringement Chart For P234.1-.13 Hermes AN/SSQ 53B Sonobuoys Under U.S. Patent No. 3,921,120 (Under Contracts 760507; 83-0066; And 84-0003). Two accounting base charts P235.1-.9 identifying the applicable patent in suit, the contractor manufacturing the accused sonobuoy, the designation of the accused sonobuoy, the contracts under which the infringing sonobuoys were procured by the Navy, the contract value for each contract and the delivery period for the accused sonobuoys procured under said contract. Deleted A three-page analysis of P237.1-.46 fifteen Sparton contract bids showing profit requested for sonobuoys corresponding to those accused in this litigation, together with the Sparton contract business records evidencing these bids. Deleted USS Indianapolis narrative P239.1-.14 history from internet website ussindianapolis.org. Bates numbers 500,000013. The USS Indianapolis at P240.1-.5 Indystar.com/library/factfiles internet website. Bates numbers 500,014-016. Excerpts from "ASW versus P241.1-.56 Submarine Technology Battle" by Louis Gerken (1986). Bates numbers 500,019-074. Captain Peter A. Huchthausen P242.1 U.S. Navy (Ret.) at peterhuchthausen.com internet website. Bates number 500,075. 12

Exhibit 234

Exhibit 235

Exhibit 236 Exhibit 237

Exhibit 238 Exhibit 239

Exhibit 240

Exhibit 241

Exhibit 242

Case 1:92-cv-00580-EJD

Document 304

Filed 02/04/2008

Page 13 of 17

Exhibit 243

Excerpts from book entitled P243.1-.50 "October Fury" by Peter A. Huchthausen. Bates numbers 500,076-124. Logan deposition transcript P244.1-.16 pages 37-44, 49-52 and 149-152. Hudson deposition transcript P245.1-.224 pages cover, 1-87, 124-137, 146-173 and second transcript cover, 4, 7-8, 41, 42, 4549, 59-63, 66-80, exh (1) cover, pgs. 1, 1113, 20, 21, 27, exh (2) B1012-1051, exh (3) pgs A181-195. Expert report of Gerald Martin. Expert report of Douglas Johnson Expert report of Donald Martin Expert and rebuttal expert reports of Charles Boyle. P246.1-.5

Exhibit 244

Exhibit 245

Exhibit 246

Exhibit 247

P247.1-.3

Exhibit 248

P248.1-.30

Exhibit 249

P249.1-.17

Exhibit 250

Abella deposition transcript P250.1-.120 pages 1, 5-7, 10, 13-15, 18-63, 66-70, 7390, 94-108, 114, 118, 123 and deposition exhibits 2, 3, Bates page numbers 157-159, 166-170, 172, 175-180, 184. Lewis deposition transcript P251.1-.82 pages 1, 11-17, 19-55, 65-74, 80-81, and deposition exhibits 1-3, 8, Bates page numbers 163-170, 175, 188. Logar deposition transcript P252.1-.114 pages 1, 5, 6, 11-13, 28-72, 74-76, 79-80, 82-104, 107-115, 147, 149, 153, 155, 158-160 and deposition exhibits 1-3, 6-7, 9-10. Deleted Oullette deposition P254.1-.78 Transcript pages 1, 3-6, 12-32, 40-47, 6467, 107-111 and deposition exhibits 14-16. Carrera deposition transcript P255.1-.52 13

Exhibit 251

Exhibit 252

Exhibit 253 Exhibit 254

Exhibit 255

Case 1:92-cv-00580-EJD

Document 304

Filed 02/04/2008

Page 14 of 17

pages 1, 7, 8, 10, 11, 19-20, 31-68, 70-73 and deposition exhibits 2, 5, 10. Exhibit 256 Balboni deposition transcript P256.1-.128 pages 1, 3-8, 11-15, 24, 27, 28, 76-179 and deposition exhibits 2, 2A, 3, 4, 4A, 8. Kuhn deposition transcript P257.1-.81 pages 1, 4, 5, 7-11, 15-47, 49-51, 53-83, 89-90, 96 and deposition exhibits 2-4. Logan deposition transcript P258.1-.122 pages cover, 1-3, 9-34, 37-44, 48-68, 86100, 102-105, 116-133, 136, 138-144, 146152, 159-162 and deposition exhibits 6, 7, 12. Joint exhibits P261.1-.4

Exhibit 257

Exhibit 258

Exhibits 259-260 Exhibit 261

The assignment of the 120 patent in suit. The assignment of the 233 patent in suit.

Exhibit 262

P262.1-.4

Exhibit 263

Letter dated April 1, 1981 P263.1-.126 from DOL Administrator to the Navy Department with attachments IND 10181 and Supplements thereto (Bates 23368-407, 23367, 23704-721, 23546-564, 23528-38, 23500-07, 23539-41, 23459-63, 23508-27) (Proprietary) Navy memo dated July 2, 1986 P264.1-.95 (Bates 23481-99, 23326-39, 23675-703, 23340343, 23627-642, and 23313-325) (Proprietary). October 4, 1983 Magnavox P265.1-.3 Request For Deviation (Bates 22837-39).

Exhibit 264

Exhibit 265

Exhibit 266 Magnavox' Failed Item P266.1-.14 Analysis Reports dated September 21-22, 1983 (Bates 2284053). Exhibit 267 Navy memo dated May 21, 1982 (Bates 23255-56). Exhibit 268 Magnavox letter to Navy dated March 19, 1982 (Bates 23214-22). P267.1-.2

P268.1-.9

14

Case 1:92-cv-00580-EJD

Document 304

Filed 02/04/2008

Page 15 of 17

Exhibit 269 Amendment P00004 to contract N00163-89-C-0012 (Bates 23054-61). Exhibit 270 Exhibit 271 Enclosure (1) (Bates 23367). Enclosure (2) (Bates 23453-58)

P268.1-.8

P270.1 P271.1-.6 P272.1-.4

Exhibit 272 AN/SSQ-77A Historical Prices Adjusted For Inflation (Bates 23309-312). Exhibit 273 Navy document entitled Hazeltine (Bates 23084-87). Exhibit 274 NAVWEP letter to NAVAIR dated October 19, 1979 (Bates 23987-88). Exhibit 275 Navy memo dated February 16, 1984 (Bates 23014-22).

P273.1-.4

P274.1-.2

P275.1-.9

Exhibit 276 February 2, 1984 Notes on P276.1-.3 F/Y' 85 Q-77A Production Contract (Bates 23023-25). Exhibit 277 NAVAIR memo dated April 25, 1984 (Bates 23026-31). P277.1-.6

Exhibit 278 Sippican Statement Of VLAD P278.1-.19 Program Plan Development And Objectives dated October 30, 1984 (Bates 23032-50). Exhibit 279 Hermes Request For Results Of Tests (Bates 22854-56). Exhibit 280 Amendment P00007 to Contract N00019-76-C-0507 (Bates 22068-70). P279.1-.3

P280.1-.3

Exhibit 281 Hermes letter to Naval P281.1-.10 Avionics Center dated September 24, 1985 (Bates 23066-75). Exhibit 282 Navy Request For Authority To Negotiate (Bates 22290-302). P282.1-.13

Exhibit 283 Navy memo regarding P283.1-.11 Production Sonobuoy Monthly Status Reports For March 1985 (Bates 22588-98). Exhibit 284 Navy memo regarding P284.1-.14 Production Sonobuoy Delivery Trend Analysis dated June 4, 1985 (Bates 22684-97). Exhibit 285 Navy document entitled FY87 15 P285.1-.10

Case 1:92-cv-00580-EJD

Document 304

Filed 02/04/2008

Page 16 of 17

Sonobuoy Award Totals By Contractor (Bates 22494-503). Exhibit 286 Excerpts from Naval Aviation P286.1-.32 Systems Team Competition Handbook (1994) (Bates 22317-322, and 22361-86). Exhibit 287 Two page Chart Listing The P287.1-.2 Sparton Sonobuoy Contracts for the AN/SSQ-53, AN/SSQ-62, AN/SSQ-77, and AN/SSQ-57 type sonobuoys. Exhibit 288 suit patent to the Navy 7473, 8129, 4496, 6770, Exhibit 289 suit patent to the Navy 7473, 2698, 7778, 6770, Claim chart comparing both P288.1-.28 claims to Sparton's AN/SSQ-53A sonobuoys sold and depicted in attached drawing Nos. 8131, 9866, 7750, 8128, 7421, 8160, 8117, 8129, 7778, 7221, 7480. Claim chart comparing both P289.1-.29 claims to Sparton's AN/SSQ-53A sonobuoys sold and depicted in attached drawing Nos. 2687, 3196, 3085, 2689, 2690, 9855, 3014, 2688, 2687, 4496, 2684, and 7480.

Exhibit 290 Claim charts comparing both P290.1-.25 suit patent claims to Sparton's AN/SSQ-62, 62A and 62B sonobuoys sold to the Navy and depicted in attached drawing Nos. (for the SSQ 62) 7438, 7494, 7696, 4496, 5000, 7699, 6497, 7698, (for the SSQ-62A) 5684, 5652, 5653, 5636, 3867, 6265, 6770, 3045, 3866, 5000, (for the SSQ-62B) 6262, 6606, 6280, 6339, 3045, 5000, 6265, 6260, and 6770. Exhibit 291 suit patent to the Navy 3559, 3293, 3576, 7381, Exhibit 292 suit patent to the Navy 3559, 3460, 3256, 7778, Exhibit 293 suit patent to the Navy 7778, 6647, 6464, 6468, Exhibit 294 Claim chart comparing both P291.1-.31 claims to Sparton's AN/SSQ-41B sonobuoys sold and depicted in attached drawing Nos. 3250, 3540, 3446, 7000, 3382, 9855, 3253, 7778, 3294, 3217, 7035, 7146, and 5067. Claim chart comparing both P292.1-.32 claims to Sparton's AN/SSQ-57A sonobuoys sold and depicted in attached drawing Nos. 3300, 3458, 3540, 3536, 7000, 3446, 9855, 3294, 3459, 3576, 3217, 7035, 5067, and 7146. Claim chart comparing both P293.1-.31 claims to Sparton's AN/SSQ-77A sonobuoys sold and depicted in attached drawing Nos. 6450, 9337, 6451, 6435, 9561, 6437, 6461, 6121, 6471, 9181, 7146, 3217 and 7298. Chart showing Sparton's P294.1

16

Case 1:92-cv-00580-EJD

Document 304

Filed 02/04/2008

Page 17 of 17

Foreign Sonobuoy Customers for the years 1980-1994 and the sonobuoy models purchased by each foreign customer. Exhibit 295 Cover letter dated P295.1-.15 December 15, 2006 and Defendant's Second Amended Answers To Interrogatories 1-6 Exhibit 296 Defendant's Service of P296.1-.15 Response Charts In Accordance With The Court's Order Of May 6, 2005. Exhibit 468 Navy memos dated February 25, P468.1-.4 1977, March 1977, March 30, 1977 and May 5, 1977 referencing the supply of Sparton's SSQ-53A sonobuoy to Hermes Electronics Ltd. (Bates pages 021225, 021228, 021230 and 021227). Exhibit 469 Excerpts from Magnavox contract N00163-87-C-0006. Exhibit 470 Excerpts from Sippican contract N00163-84-C-0117. Exhibit 471 Excerpts from Magnavox contract N00163-88-C-0007. LIST OF WITNESSES 1-9. Sparton has already identified its list of witnesses in its pretrial submissions and rebuttal submissions and incorporates that identification herein by reference thereto. Respectfully submitted, Sparton Corporation, Plaintiff P469.1-.5

P470.1-.15

P471.1-.43

Dated: Febuary 4, 2008

s/Steven Kreiss Steven Kreiss Attorney for Plaintiff 1120 Connecticut Avenue NW Suite 433 Washington D.C. 20036 Telephone: (202) 347-6382 Facsimile: (202) 347-7711

17