Free Objections - District Court of Delaware - Delaware

Case 1:04-cv-01339-SLR

Document 172-12
EXHIBIT K Expenses
prepared from D.I. 169-3

Filed 05/20/2008

Page 1 of 2

Date

Attorney

11/10/2006 Hirzel 11/30/2006 Hirzel

12/14/2006 N/A 12/14/2006 Hirzel 12/18/2006 N/A

12/18/2006 N/A

12/18/2006 N/A

12/18/2006 N/A 12/18/2006 Hirzel 12/19/2006 Hirzel 1/20/2007 Hirzel 1/23/2007 Hirzel 1/31/2007 Hirzel 1/31/2007 N/A 3/8/2007 Hirzel 3/12/2007 Hirzel 4/25/2007 Hirzel 4/25/2007 Randall 4/26/2007 Randall 5/17/2007 Hirzel
264931

Description Computer Research - Westlaw Search Performed by: HIRZEL, SAM Computer Research - Westlaw Search Performed by: HIRZEL, SAM Photos/Art/Spec Duplicating -Out of Office PARCELS INC. CONVERT TO XLS FORMAT OCR / EMAIL Computer Research - Westlaw Search Performed by: HIRZEL, SAM Court Costs - WEST PAYMENT CENTER FEDERAL RECORD CENTER FEE Photos/Art/Spec Duplicating -Out of Office WEST PAYMENT CENTER COPY FEE MEMORANDUM OPINION Miscellaneous - WEST PAYMENT CENTER COURT STAFF TIME -SORTING THROUGH CASE FILE AT THE FRC Facsimile - WEST PAYMENT CENTER - FAX DELIVERY CHARGE - 35 PAGES FAXED TO WESTLAW COURTEXPRESS FOR PDF CONVERSION & EMAILED TO CLIENT Computer Research - Westlaw Search Performed by: HIRZEL, SAM Computer Research - Westlaw Search Performed by: HIRZEL, SAM Computer Research - Westlaw Search Performed by: HIRZEL, SAM Computer Research - Westlaw Search Performed by: HIRZEL, SAM Computer Research - Westlaw Search Performed by: HIRZEL, SAM Pacer Online Filing/Research Charges Computer Research - Westlaw Search Performed by: HIRZEL, SAM Computer Research - Westlaw Search Performed by: HIRZEL, SAM Computer Research - Westlaw Search Performed by: HIRZEL, SAM Computer Research - Westlaw Search Performed by: RANDALL, KARL Computer Research - Westlaw Search Performed by: RANDALL, KARL Computer Research - Westlaw Search Performed by: HIRZEL, SAM

Amount $133.97 $37.66

Quantity 1 1

Total $133.97

Objections

$11.36 $26.10 $159.00

1 1 1

$37.66 Unrelated to Motions because no corresponding time entry for research Insufficient description/information to determine if related to Motions; not reasonable to charge Defendants for work not reasonably $11.36 necessary $26.10 Insufficient description/information to determine if reasonably related to $159.00 Motions Insufficient description/information to determine if reasonably related to $26.25 Motions Insufficient description/information to determine if reasonably related to $37.50 Motions

$0.75

35

$18.75

2

$1.00 $42.55 $29.65 $48.75 $181.08 $4.11 $17.60 $4.64 $20.30 $47.36 $583.37 $164.58 $9.28

35 1 1 1 1 1 1 1 1 1 1 1 1 1 of 2

Insufficient description/information to determine if reasonably related to $35.00 Motions $42.55 $29.65 $48.75 $181.08 $4.11 Insufficient description/information to determine if reasonably related to $17.60 Motions $4.64 $20.30 Unrelated to Motions; corresponding time entry is for research $47.36 regarding "affiliate", which is unrelated to Motions. Insufficient information in corresponding time entry to determine if $583.37 related to Motions; excessive cost Insufficient information in corresponding time entry to determine if $164.58 related to Motions; excessive cost $9.28

Case 1:04-cv-01339-SLR

Document 172-12
EXHIBIT K Expenses
prepared from D.I. 169-3

Filed 05/20/2008

Page 2 of 2

Date

Attorney

5/18/2007 Hirzel 5/22/2007 Hirzel

Description Computer Research - Westlaw Search Performed by: HIRZEL, SAM Computer Research - Westlaw Search Performed by: HIRZEL, SAM Photos/Art/Spec Duplicating - Out of Office PARCELS INC. SHAMROCK PRODUCTION/SCAN REDWELDS/CAPTURE HOT DOCS INFO / OCR COLLECTION Photos/Art/Spec Duplicating - Out of Office PARCELS INC. DATE CODING FOR SCANNED SET / BLOWBACK SET OF ENTIRE COLLECTION

Amount $4.64 $126.59

Quantity 1 1

Total $4.64 $126.59

Objections

5/22/2007 N/A

$189.91

1

Insufficient description/information to determine if reasonably related to $189.91 MTC

5/22/2007 N/A

$233.80

1

Insufficient description/information to determine if reasonably related to $233.80 MTC Insufficient description/information to determine if reasonably related to MTC; Defendants sent Plaintiffs copies of documents; unreasonable to $18.20 charge Defendants for additional copies after Motion was complete Insufficient description/information to determine if reasonably related to MTC; Defendants sent Plaintiffs copies of documents; unreasonable to $6.40 charge Defendants for additional copies after Motion was complete $125.04 Unrelated to MTC because no corresponding time entry for research

5/24/2007 N/A

In-House Duplicating

$0.20

91

In-House Duplicating Computer Research - Westlaw Search 4/3/2008 Kishpaugh Performed by: KISHPAUGH, AMARYH Transcripts - WILCOX & FETZER, LTD DEPOSITION OF: SHALOM E. LAMM ORIGINAL AND MIN-U-SCRIPT/WORD INDEX/EXPEDITED, E-TRANSCRIPT, AND HANDLING/POSTAGE 4/8/2008 N/A Invoice - WILCOX & FETZER, LTD DEPOSITION OF: Avie Arenson (68 pp.) ORIGINAL EMAIL SAME DAY DELIVERY 4/15/2008 N/A Total Costs 5/24/2007 N/A

$0.20 $125.04

32 1

$742.64

1

$742.64 Excessive for 2 hour deposition

$700.12

1

$700.12 Excessive for 90 minute deposition $3,767.45

264931

2 of 2