Free Claim - District Court of Delaware - Delaware

Case 1 :04-cv—00955-GIVIS Document 1 1 1 Filed 06/06/2007 Page 1 of 4
UNITED STATES DISTRICT COURT
FOR THE DISTRICT OF DELAWARE
OFFICIAL COMMITTEE OF UNSECURED
CREDITORS OF DVI, INC., gt _a_l,, Debtors and
Debt0rs—in—Possession,
Plaintiff] _
·—against— C. A. No. 04-955 (GMS)
MICHAEL A. O’I~IANLON, STEVEN R. JURY DEMAND
GARFINKEL, RICHARD E. MILLER,
JOHN P. BOYLE, ANTHONY J. TUREIC.,
` RAYMOND D. FEAR, WILLIAM S. GOLDBERG,
GERALD L. COHN, JOHN E. MCHUGH,
I-IARRY T. J. ROBERTS and NATHAN SI-IAPIRO
Defendants.
ANSWER OF DEFENDAN TS NATHAN SHAPIRO, WILLIAM S. GOLDBERG AND
JOHN E. MCHUGH TO CROSS CLAIMS FOR CONTRIBUTION ASSERTED
AGAHWST THEM BY DEFENDANTS MICHAEL A. O’HANLON, STEVEN R.
GARFINKEL, JOHN P. BOYLE, ANTHONY J. TUREK, RAYMOND D. FEAR,
GERALD L. CORN, HARRY TJ. ROBERTS, AND
I ` RICHARD E. MILLER
Any and all allegations in the cross claims for contribution against Nathan Shapiro,
William S. Goldberg and John E. McHugh ("Direotor Det`endants") are denied.
Prayer for Relief
WI-IEREFORE, Director Defendants pray for judgment as follows: that the cross claims
asserted against them by Defendants Michael A. O’HanIon, Steven R. Gartinke}, John P. Boyle,
Anthony J. Turek, Raymond D. Fear, Gerald L. Cohn, Harry T.J. Roberts, and Richard E. Miller
be dismissed with prejudice, and that the Defendants / Cross Claimants take nothing thereby, and
that Director Defendants be awarded their costs of suit, including reasonable attorneys? fees, and
all other relief that the Court deems just and proper.

Case 1 :04-cv—00955-GIVIS Document 111 Filed 06/06/2007 Page 2 of 4
Incorporation of Affirmative Defenses
Director Defendants adopt and incorporate by reference any Affirmative Defense asserted
» in their Answer, or by any other Defendant to this action, to the extent the Affirmative Defense
applies to the cross-claims against them.
Dated: June 6, 2007 w Q { E E
OF COUNSEL: Arthur G. onnoii IH (1.1}. #2667)
William P. Quinn, Jr. Arthur G. Connolly, Jr. (LD. #496)
Karen Pieslak Pohimann CONNOLLY BOVE LODGE & HUTZ LLP
MORGAN, LEWIS & BOCKIUS LLP The Nemours Building
1701 Market Street . 1007 North Orange Street
Philadelphia, PA 19103-2921 Wilmington, DE 19801
Tel. (215) 963-5775 Tel (302) 658-9141
Fax. (215) 963-5299 Fax. (302) 658-5614
Attomeys for Nathan Shapiro,
William S. Goldberg and
J ohm E. McHugh

4 Case 1 :04-cv—00955-GIVIS Document) 111 Filed 06/06/2007 Page 3 of 4
CERTIFICATE OF SERVICE
I hereby certify that on May 7, 2007 a true and correct copy ofthe foregoing Answer,
Affirrnative Defenses, and C1·oss··Claim of Defendants Nathan Shapiro, William S. Goldberg and
John E. McHugh was served electronically or via First—C1ass Mail on the following counsel:
Francis A. Monaco, Jr.
([email protected])
Joseph J. Bodnar GbOdH3f@mDHi&W.C0m)
Monzack & Monaco, PA.
Attorneys for Plaintyf g
David B, Brand (de'[email protected])
Priekett, Jones & Elliott, P.A.
Attorneys for Defendant Richard Miller
David A. Felice ([email protected])
Cozen O’Connor
Attorneys for Defendant Anthony J Turek
Peter B. Ladig
(hankserve@,bayardiirm.com)
The Bayard Firm
Attorneys for Dejendant Harry Ti Roberts
Gregory Miller ([email protected])
Stephen G. Stroup (sstroup@1nar—law.com)
Miller, Alfano & Raspanti, P.C.
Attorneys for Defendant Harry Ti Roberts
Martin Eames Weis
([email protected])
Dilwoith Paxson LLP
Attorneys for Defendant Steven R. Gczijffnkel
Kathaleen S. McCormick
kmcconnicl<[email protected]
Attorneys for Defendant Raymond D. Fear

Case 1 :04-cv—00955-GIVIS Document 111 Filed 06/06/2007 Page 4 of 4
I further hereby certify that on May 29, 2007, 1 mailed the foregoing document to the
following non-registered participants:
J. Andrew Rah], Jr. William 1. Taylor
Mark L. Weyrnan John Barnoski
Michael I. Venditto Cozen O’Connor
Anderson Kill & Olick, P.C. 1900 Market Street
1251 Avenue ofthe Americas Philadelphia, PA 19103
New York, NY 10020 Atrorneysfor Defendant Anthony .1 T urek
Attorneys for Plaintnf
Kellie Marie MacCready Laurie A. Krepto
Steven T. Davis Montgomery, McCracken, Walker &
Ohermayer Rebmann Mazwell & Hippel Rhoads, LLP A A
LLP 300 Delaware Avenue, Suite 750
3 Mill Road, Suite 306A Wilmington, DR 19801-1607
Wilmington, DE 19806 Attorneys for Defendant Michael O Hanlon
Attorneys for Defendant Gerald L. Cohn
Richard L. Scheff William P. Quinn, lr.
Ieftrey Feldman Karen P. Pohlmann-
Noel C. Burnham David W. Marston, I r. .
Montgomery, McCracken, Walker & Morgan Lewis & Boekius LLP
Rhoads, LLP 1701 Market Street
123 South Broad Street Philadelphia, PA 19106
Avenue ofthe Arts Attorneys for Defendants William S.
Philadelphia, PA 19109 Goldberg; John E. McHugh, and Nathan
Attorneys for Defendant Michael A. Shapiro
O Hanlon
Julian W. Friedman
Patricia M. Hainill Stillman & Friedman, P.C. .
Vincent T. Ciesiik; 425 Park Avenue M
Conrad O’Brien Gellrnan & Rohn, P.C. New York, NY 10022
1515 Market Street, Sixteenth Floor Atrorneysfor Defendant Gerald Cohn
Philadelphia, PA 19102-1916
Atrorneysfor Defendant Richard E. Miller
Arthur G. Co§l1y, lll . No. 2667)