Free Motion for Attorney Fees - District Court of Arizona - Arizona

15.6HT.ER03 REEGUH? QEEIVEYE PEEMTEG: Tue E? San 2005 10:30:01 PQEE: EE
EEGENENB EBERG @0003 3 HILSGN, P.€. RPL DQTE: 0E£01!G2 YHE0 01f1?!05
REPDRT SEEUEHEE: BY ELLEN? E0 10000.530 EILEEU & UNBZLLE0 FEES § CESTE
CLIENT: 10000.530 CHUBB IHSURQNCE GRUB?
MQTTER: 530 K—ZELL HEEQLS 900 TREE EEMFER
CLIENEENQTTEE MQYYEE EQPTEUH HQYFER TYFE £0H?1@EE§7
EESEREPTIUM EQTE HRSSUHETS RQYE BELL QEGUET TRQH H0 SEETQS
BRQFTED EBREEUN UF REPLY TB PL§1N?1FE‘5 09!22!0i 1.70 ?G.00 119.00 204?BOG 3
HBTIGN FUR SEMMQRY SUDSMEHT BESGEQENB
TREDEHQRK EILUTIDH
EOHYIHUEB DRQETINE PGHTIGH DE REPLY EG 09i21f04 1.?0 ?0.00 113.00 200?503 B
PLOIRFIEF’S HGYIUH EHR 5EMH§R¥ QUBEHENE
REBQRDIHG LGEK UE EUIDEHTIQRY SHGRINB EHR?
FL01N1IEE‘S MHRK H00 REQUIRED
DESTINCYZUEHESS GR SEDUNDRRE EERHIHG T0
CEMENSTRQEE PRBTEETQBLE ERQDEERRK
URRETEB PORTEGH UE REELY T0 PLQINTEFFS 09!22£04 1.B0 ?0.00 125.00 2%é?30? E
EDEIGE EGR SEHHORÂ¥ JUDGMENT REGRRSENB LQCK
GF JURKSDIEYKGH TB HEER DEELQRQEDE? QCYIBE
BN PREEHTS
RESERREHEQ STQTE RED FEDERQL EASE L0§ 09fE2!04 0.50 ?0.00 35.00 201?00€ B
REGQRDINE QHQ1 QCTEQLLY EQHSTEEUTEE R
TRQDEHQRK
BRQFTED PGRYEGH DE REPLY REGQRQINE LQEK GF 09€22i04 1.90 ?0.00 133.00 E0€?G0? B
EVIDENCE SUGSESEING PLHEREIEF H00 0
PRGEECTEBLE TEQDEHQRK
RESERRCHED QHEZENE 000 STRTE CQSE LEE BM 09/23i04 0.40 70.00 ES.00 §0€?S1C S
%HOT CGHSTITUTES Q PROEEETQBLE ERQEE SEEEE1
DRQFTEE PGREIDH UE REEL? T0 PLOEN¥1EF‘S 09/23/04 1.50 70.00 105.00 20é?B11 8
HUYEBN FOR SUMEARE SUDEEEHY QDDRESSLNG
TRQBE SECREE VIGLRYIGR
CSHTIHUED DRQFEIEG FOREIGN OF REEL? T0 C?!23f04 0.90 ?0.00 63.00 204?E1$ 0
PLOIN¥IEF‘5 MQEIBN ESR SEMMQRY JUBEMEHE
REQREESIHE TRQDE SECRET GIBLQYIBH
REUIEEEB PLOIH?IFF‘S CUHEEOQERTEQ STRTEHEHE 03!24f04 2.20 70.00 154.00 2G4?S2? B
DE E§C15 QH0 EGMPQREB YG DER SERYEMENZ BF
EQEYS SUBHIYEED IN EGTEGH EGR 5UH§RR?
JUDGMENT
EESEQREHED FEEERQL CGSE LQH RE YHE IESUE GE 10!12/04 0.EO ?0.00 42.00 1445355 H
FREE GE TEOOE§RRK E0 LRQEEMRRK GILBEEEE
ECTION EH SMQLL EQRKET
(PER QPEHGVQL GF E. NEIEQ}
BRQFYEE MEMGRQMDUE RE SEG? QF PRGEEEEZHE5 12§21f0é 0.90 125.00 112.50 20?5EEE B
PENDIEB RESCLULIGH QF RE-EX§§ GE PQTEHT
RESEQREHED EEBERQL LGN RE XMPQET BF RE~EX§h 1Ef21/04 1.00 125.00 125.00 BOTEEEE 5
GF PQYENY QN CURREH1 LITIGQTIGN {PER
QPPEQQQL EF C. HQEERE
FREFQRE HUTIDH FDR STQV 12i21!G4 1.90 125.00 23?.50 20?5&£E B
CUN11NUE 10 PREPRRE HDYIQN 10 S?QY 12!23f04 0.40 125.00 50.00 EGYEE7? 8
LZYZEQTEGN PEHBZNE FQTENT RECGNSIDERQTEBH
FEEER E. DQHGVQN 12/2?!04 125.00 0.00 E0?5530 B
Case2:O2-cv-01109-DGC D0cument223-39 Filed O1/17/2006 Page10f4

1E.6H1.ER03 QCCBUH1 0E11011P PR101E0: 1ue 17 Jam 2006 10:30:01 PQEE: 55
BQEEPEHG BBERG 50005 0 P1LSOH, P.C. PF1 001E: 0E!01!02 FHPU 01i1?!0E
PEPUR1 EEGUENEE: SY CLIEN1 10 10000.530 BILLEE 0 UNBELLED PEES 0 £0S13
ELIEN1: 10000.530 CHGBB INSURQHCE SRQUP
0011ER: 530 1-EELL ME10L5 000 TRUE CEP1ER
CL1EN1i0011EH 0011EP EOP110H H011EH 11PE E0§1100E01
DESCREPTIGH 001E HREiUN11S RQTE BILL 000001 1RQP N0 3101US
PESEQREPED FEDEPQL C0§E L00 (0LL EEOEOOL 12f27f04 0.30 125.00 32.50 20?5EE1 0
CIRCUITS} RE S10? 0E EHKIEE LZ11G0110N
BECQUEE 01 E0§00NOL11P BF ELQIESIISSUES
LNUOLQEB PER QPPRUUSL 01 C. HQZER
COP1IOOE 10 PREPGRE N0110H 10 $10Y 12!2?!04 0.40 125.00 50.00 2010312 0
LI11E0110N PEEBZHS 0E~EX00100110N UF 201
PQTEM1
EOH1I§UE 10 PREPRPE REPLY 10 SUPPGPT 01 01f05/05 2.00 125.00 250.00 20?2153 0
H0110H FUR SUMHQRY JUDGMENT — FQLSE
RBUERTESING ELQEM — N0 EVIBEHEE BE 00101
0£1I011Y, N0 FQLSE S101EOEH1S, N0 MEN
H01ERIOL, NG EVIDENCE 01 DQMEEES
EGHTEHUE PREPQRRTISM GF REPLY IR SSPPGP1 01f05f05 0.50 125.00 52.50 2025495 E
UF 001100 EUR 50000HY JUDGQEN1
PEPLP 10 PGR110N UE TPQBENGPE 01LU110H 01f05!05 0.10 125.00 07.50 2020095 0
CLGIMS
REPLY 10 PQRTIGH GF 1ROOEHORK ELQIH 01f05f05 0.40 125.00 50.00 2028058 0
QEBPMERCEQL LQRE
REPLY 10 PGRTIGM GP 1ROOE SECRETS CL015 01!05/05 0.20 125.00 25.00 2028500 B
REPL? 10 POR1100 GF P01E01 1NOOL10I1Y £L01M 01f05f05 0.20 125.00 32.50 Z0?0502 0
PE1ER 1. DGHGPGH 01f05f05 125.00 0.00 2020505 0
SELOEROON, M.0. RE 0. HGUPN 01!05/05 125.00 0.00 2200212 0
CGMIMUE Tn PREPARE PEPLP 50PPGR’€ OF 01.105/05 1.80 125.00 225.00 B
00110N EGR SEMEQRY JUDSPEQ1 0N ELL
PL01H11FF‘S CLRIHS 000 00050 SEETEBN
000RESS1HS SLQHDER QN0 BOOF10EH110L11Â¥
RSREEEEH1
000ED REPLY 10 PL0101IFP‘S CL010 BF 01/0?i05 0.60 125.00 75.00 2080205 0
EUMSPIRQEY 10 1HE REPLY 10 00110N FUR
SUEMQRY JBDEMEH1
PE1ER 1. 0000000 01i0?!05 125.00 0.00 200020S 0
PE1ER 1. 0GN0000 01f12!05 125.00 0.00 2055005 B
BRQF1 00110N EGR LEQUE 10 EXEEE0 PQEE 01f12/05 0.10 125.00 12.50 2005E00 0
LIHIT
0ROF1 0ROER F00 LEQVE 10 FILE REPLY 10 01/12/05 0.10 125.00 12.50 2005511 0
EXCESS 01 PQGE L1M1T
REUIEEEU PLOI011FE‘S RESPDNSE 10 001100 10 02f02i05 0.50 125.00 @2.50 2102190 0
S10? L111001ION RS HELL 05 REPEEPED 000
PLLLE0 PLé1N1IFF'S CITED CQSE LQH EN
PREPQHQIIGN DE RESEQREH
PE1EP 1. 0000000 02!04!05 125.00 0.00 2101201 2
PESERECH FEBERQL L00 REGQEQIHG 01911HC110H 02/00/05 0.80 125.00 100.00 2101202 0
2E1REEH RE~EXOM1N0110N QH0 0E—1S50E REGUES1
RESEQRCH FEDERAL L00 REEQRDIPE E0£100S 02!00/05 1.20 125.00 150.00 2101203 0
Case 2:02-cv-01109-DGC Document 223-39 Filed O1/17/2006 Page 2 of 4

16.6HT.ERO3 OCCOUNT OCTTOTTY POTOTED: TOO E? Gan EOOE E0:30:O1 EOOE: SO
OROEOIOO OBERE HOOOS O OILSOO, P.€. OPT OOTE: OEJOL/O2 THRU OL§17!OE
REPORT SEOOENCE: OY CLTEOT TD 2ODOO.53D OTLLEO O OHOELLEO FEES O COSTS
CLIENT: 1000O.53O COOOO TOSOROOCE OROOP
MOTTER: EEO R-EELL HETOLO OOO TRUE CENTER
CLTEHTTOOTTER OQTTER COPTIOO OOTTER TYPE COOTTREEHT
DESCOTPTTOO OOTE HRSfONTTS OOTE DTLL OUOUNT TOOO NO OTOTOO
OOSTTETTOO STOY OE LTTIOOTION PENOIHO
RE-ISSUE OY U.O.P.T.O.
PETER T. DONOVOH OE/OOJOS 125.00 5.00 BEOTOOP O
PETER T. DONOUOO G2iO?fO5 125.00 0.00 ZEGEOOE O
PETER T. OOHODOH OEEOFXOE 125.60 0.00 2162208 O
RESEORCH EEOEROL COURT OTH ETOCOTT OOO OOIOFIOE O.?O 125.00 O?.5O 2131454 O
OTHER CODES EOCUETHO OO OOOOOEOT THOT STOY
HELL OOT PPEOOOTCE PLOEMTTFE OO COORT
RESEOROH EEOEROL OTH COURT OTH CIRCUIT OOSE5 O2!O7fO5 1.3O 125.00 252.50 2102éEO O
FOCOSTNO ON ORODOEOT THOT DEFEHOONT‘S OID
HOT OREPOO DISCLOSURE OEOOTREHEHTS TO THE
USPTO
PEEEORCH FEOERQL COUOT BTH CIRCUIT COSES O2/OTKOS 0.00 i25.00 iO0.00 EQOETEO O
FOCUETOO OH OROUMEOT THOT OEPTO OTLL
PROVIDE O PROOOTTOE OOLTHO OH OOLIUTTY OE
201 POTEOT
DROET REPLY TO SUPPORT OE HOTTON TO STO? O2!O?/D5 2.5O £E5.00 $O?.5O 2101%O3 O
POOCEEDTNOS
RESEARCH FEOEOOL COURT OTH CTOCOTT COSES OEJOOIOE 3.00 125.00 40?.5O QEOLQFE O
EOCOSINO ON OEOEFTTO TO COURT TO STOYTOO
LETIOOTIDO, R~ZELL‘S DUTY TO OZSCLOSE OOO
LOCK OF PREOOOTOE TO PLDINTTEE BY OTOYTOO
LTTTOOTEON
PHONE COLL HETH JOHO TTTOS, OTTORNEY FOR OEJOOJOS O.LO 225.00 12.5% E§Oi405 O
SOOOROO, REOOROTNO PLOTNTTEE‘S REPLY TO
SUPPORT OF MOTION FOO STOY
DOOFTED OOTTCE OE EOROTO CDOREOTTOO O2!14fO5 D.;O 125.00 22.5O ETOXEEE O
STOTEHENT TORT PLOINTTEE EILEO MOTION FOO
SOOOORY JOOOHEOT OOD STOTEOEOT OE FOCTO
UNDER SEOL
REVIEOEO PLOIOTTEE‘S HOTTOO TO MODIFY THE OBIOE/O5 @.40 125.GO 50.00 BZEOLSL O
OCOEOOLTUO OEOEO TO FILE PORTTOL HOTTOH POR
SOHOORY JUOOOEHT OO CLOTH OE EOEOOTTOOLE
CONOOCT ONO ON·SOLE BOO RULE. OLSO
REOEEHED COURT OOCRET OZSCLOSIHE HISTORY OE
COSE OOD STIPULOTTOOO BETWEEN TOE PORTIE5
RE TIME PERIOD TO FILE VORZOOS OOTTOOS.
REUTEHEO IH PREPOROTTON OF RESPONSE TO
PL§TRTTEF'5 MOTION TO OOOTEY THE SCHEDOLTHO
OROER
DEOON OROFTTNO REOPOOSE TO PLOIOTTEE‘5 O3/OLIOE 1.2O 125.%% 250.00 EZEOEEE O
HOTIOO FOR LEOVE TO ETLE PORTTOL OOTTOO FOR
SUOMRRY OUDONEOT EOCOSTNO OO FOCTOOL
OOCROROONO ONO PROCEDORQL HISTORY OF TOE
Case 2:02-cv-01109-DGC Document 223-39 Filed O1/17/2006 Page 3 of 4

10.0H1.EOG3 0E000NY 00110115 PR101E0: 10E 27 San 2005 10:30:01 000E: ii
BRDENIHE SEERG 50005 0 0ZL50N, P.5. RF1 00?E: 00i01!02 $000 01!1?!00
REPGRT 5EOOEOCE: 50 CLIEH1 10 10000.530 BILLEB 0 UHBZLLEG FEE5 0 505TS
CLIENY: 10000.530 00000 IMSURQNCE 0000P
HQTYER: 530 K—ZELL MEFQLS 000 TRUE CE01ER
CLIEHY/0011EE 0011ER EQPYIGH 0011ER T??E 50HT1HOE01
DESCEZFTEDH 00TE HR5!00I15 001E 01LL 000001 1000 00 510105
ERSE
0001100ED 10 ?0EF§RE RE5?005E 10 001100 EER 03502/05 3.10 125.00 357.50 2110104 0
LEOOE Y0 0001FY SEHEGULIHB 000ER, F00051N0
QH PL01011FF‘5 QRGUMENT YHO€ HR.
K000ER2ELL'5 BECLQRETIBH RQESE0 0EH ISSUES
THEY COOL0 001 HQVE BEEN RRGUED BEFGRE
BISPBSITIUE 00110N 0EOOL10E
COHT1HOE0 T0 ?REPORE HESPDNSE T0 PLOIN11FF'5 03f03/05 1.00 125.00 125.00 2210273 0
00110N 10 HGDZFY 1HE SCHEDULING HRDER,
FBCUSIHE 00 PL01N?IFF‘5 00000EHT 1001 IT
EXER015E0 00E DILEGEHEE 10 BRIHGINS {HE
00110N T0 HGDEF0 YHE 0ROE0
EBNTINUED EESEQREH Y0 PREPQRE RESPGNSE YD 03i04!05 1.00 125.00 175.00 2110252 0
PLOI011FF'5 501100 10 0001FY 5CHEOOL1NE
ORDER ~ EUCUSING DH QRGUHEHT THRT PLQIHTIFF
CQHHGT SQYISFY YHE FOOR EQCTGRS 0F: 11)
PREJEDIUE IF 001100 0E01E0; 12) PREJUDEEE
10 000-000001; (3) JUDICIQL EFFICIERCY IF
GRQNTEB; 000 141 EXISTEHCE 0F EXHUSQBLE
NEBLECY
EON?1HOE0 10 PREPQRE RE5FON5E 03£0?/05 0.50 125.00 112.50 211031é 0
PEEE0 1. 000000N 03/07/05 125.00 0.00 2110315 0
CGHYINUED RESEQRCH T0 50PP051 RESFDMSE 10 03i07/05 1.60 125.00 200.00 3110320 5
PLOINTZFF’5 001100 I0 0001?Y SCHEDULEHG
GRBEH ~ FGEUSIHE 00 IHQBILETY 0F FLQINYIFE
Y0 ESTQBLISH 0000 D005E BECQUSE 0F LQCK 0F
DILIEEHCE IY EXEECISED
0E1E0 T. 0000000 05!05i05 125.00 0.00 2110525 B
FETE0 T. 0000000 03f08/05 125.00 0.00 2110525 0
COOTINOE0 RE5E000C0 T0 PREFQRE RESPQHSE T0 03/09/05 1.90 125.00 237.50 2110540 5
001100 T0 000IFY SCHEDULINB ORDER ·
Â¥0EU5I05 GN 51000000 000 0PPLIE001L1TÂ¥ 0F
0000500 0. 0000010 10 P010110E MGTIDHS FUR
SUMHQRY JUDEMEN1
EGNTINUED RESERRCH UF 510 5100011 000 03!09i05 0.00 125.00 100.00 2110542 0
FEGERQL LRE RE 0000 CQUSE 51000000 T0
0001FY SCHEOOL105 000ERS
PREPQRE0 QUTLIHE QF RESPBNSE 10 ?L01HT1FF‘5 03!17i05 0.70 125.00 07.50 2110543 0
001100 FUR 500011005 000 10 0I5000L1FY
CGUNSEL
BE500 RESEQREH 0F 910 CIRCUIT QH0 FEDERQL 03/17105 0.70 125.00 02.50 211054é 0
C05E L00 RE 000 FQLYH REQEIREMEH1 10
REEUVER SRHCTIGNS QGHINST 01HER 00010
£0N11HUE0 RESEQRCH RE 000 FRIFH NECESSERY 03J21f05 1.50 125.00 157.50 2110547 0
Case 2:02-cv-01109-DGC Document 223-39 Filed O1/17/2006 Page 4 of 4

Case 2:02-cv-01109-DGC

Document 223-39

Filed 01/17/2006

Page 1 of 4

Case 2:02-cv-01109-DGC

Document 223-39

Filed 01/17/2006

Page 2 of 4

Case 2:02-cv-01109-DGC

Document 223-39

Filed 01/17/2006

Page 3 of 4

Case 2:02-cv-01109-DGC

Document 223-39

Filed 01/17/2006

Page 4 of 4