Free Response - District Court of Arizona - Arizona

I -2;.E$E1‘?f?12$:•;!P;:;K*RELi37A IU THE °‘”I"ED STETES DISTRIQT :0uRT
,. r0Ol6'L S. ¤JF|v·¤c+-2
i ;P.O-Bax 3*-I‘·fO{, ¤Is‘rR1:<;1· cp
TMCSOW A-Z— 8S?3°“['|‘P']Ob \ L
‘ ___RECE#\/ED w__r;@pv
my UEC302U05
QWYTOLA 1}; QQ} Cd` (jggnggqy JC C ,
_ PI¤\“HC}é>> DJSYH€é`ipGF?F;\HI—gQA?,;JHT
IA§E_?`Z""`_` "''' T wr
2 v_ Cqgq Ng, CU] O'3·\3‘f‘f—PHX·EHC~M$
RGSPQMSQ -}-0 v¤1\}»€D1>{:|OY}·Y' OEJQQ-hbns +o P{¤.:n+7£·F's
\/Q`u€OP+1l0mS,Inc.,e+ QL, Cpvvi-F0ver+n`v¤3 $·}·q·P<2m2n+ cg Few-}-s
¤e¥er¤J·=rM·.£.
HCM- D¢%'}·r£c.+ C¢>ur+ juclge Earl H. Cam;>U
, P\a;w+·`Cp,5Lqmmm YM:r,]n¤.e| 00.1*%, respcmcls 4-0 deper¢¢{qv1+ \/a,{ueOpt-]¢¤n.S{
';OL_{ec*}—»Z>n$ +¤ Pl¤}¤~f—·'£p°s‘ C¤¤+mven~{-M3 Siaiemeni ap Bac!-S qi poH¤wS$
;Au'H·¤gn{·;(a+E0n up D0¢;umen+§
De£€v¤d¤M+ \/'cx]»¢eO;>¥;¤nS makes c§;;e¢;+•'¤ms.,€cn$F<+qn%Iy,+h¢+ Jvc¢.uM€¤·•·+$
{=lq{n+{@ has suBmH--1·ed kcw@ ·w+ been pr¤»PerI}, ¤Lu¤{#Len+£¢,q+aC{.
T 1%:5 Qp¤,,;r·F·, ¤`•»» elehybvj pF€~'·`¤u5 Mv+rBn.1 Bcf Summary _j¤.u{_j•··1¢M+, éiréd-QJ
c @1c1{»·»+T£p +o ¤.u°H¤en+Fca+•2 Amumcvés. ?\o,E¤·}-»£p AH n¤+ umdersi-and 4%;
hqw?{n¢é*r1-I-{-`c0.·[·E¤vrlr spnxéis cr r‘e ` ClqF:·p•·CQ+:Jw. W4Oa@*`S'}·f`E>\+'€. 5:+VQF \"·€SPC>|··9€5€C% vii'); l¤"H‘|2 ;WS['3L+
, PSG,'1 rn'} {
in As \¢>\m`··.+:£C umdersmwcls IP., Aécm»··¤av1-I-: mw Le. .22u*¥?{.¤}n;>{r2:餥¥2cI" By
.`Jec¥¤u`¢:i·;0n, ¤uH·a.cLe¢S W: °#w_ Jo.·;u·~r€n+ Laahj 71.2 Q ex0.c.—{~(y
;féwk¤,+ P§q{.n+Y-CQ MS cinnz. .
l I-}· 76 ¤W,s¢> P}q§.»»-Hui} ·.méefS+¤¢¤d·:»»j +h¤+ docw»nen+s which have rx
`;3m;e_rM~vng_n+ Seql DF |n20.c{¢'·•1»3 cqyx be q.»Lq*{42n+;¢Cl"·€ ig·\¤[.q·l·fpp ¤.€s»w4QS HMS wqr-|· ·.u¥H do »`.·¤ fzgqrds -1-;: p{¤.1»»HD£§·
Seconé Méenéum A0¤.mew+$.
_ Plq,:n+E¤: be\»`·:w€..S #4m+ ko. Mas qu;°i{;e¤+¤Z¢¢+€={ Ml Jvwménfv ¤m<{
*f’L[$ 3; Znqorr.ec.+, p]a:n+·`€p re¢?;.ge5+5 *1%.3 c¤ur`+ +o simply
g‘_€> Case 2:O3—cv—O1344-EHC-HCE D0cumeqt199 FiIed12/30/2005 Page10f4

csPPO;v»·\· sgmelrwchf who c,¤m+0 p¥¤]»·¤+C£D.
I+ shuulé be »w+e¢\ BY an war-} ·Hm-r ML ·»¢¢¤_f¤•~€+y up wk.;
Z é0C.\·¢v•‘L€.P1+S A€'c€|'lé¤V1+ 'ID JFLE. {O ¢';""lf|"UP€F C\.U.@€H+¥,CQ+rbH·'
were ·`»»Pm:.+ frpéuceé by sqié cJeCené¢m1~ +¤ pI·uZ»¤1~C»O-P ¢{».·..,43\ Jirceoery
{ re7;;¤s+s. For- "Hw+ ée£enc§¤»·»+ +0 <~··`··» cx summary _]·.¢Jg¢···c¤n}‘ bqsfcf ¤»·>
A ¤\o<;umen+s *H·» l¤¤_Q~¤s+ ¤m& ___[¤s4 cm¤°#~¢r axqv-1fIe up- N/¤Jw;{?,¤{—}¢>ms,Inc· ·F-ezkhaj
. .. , i;·q¤`N¤w+a.&e. p-P Wha. lcs; for-r»m¤.{—er..r.undrrr¢lis ¤zLu¢u4a3eJ·» L 4
A DeCQ¤&¤¤+‘s 0;,·E£+:¤¤§
De£e¤¤|¤n+ v·»·q\ceS knskalfy Wu. same s=£amdo.rd army wp oU¢c+e"¤ns I-br
all ¤L_}¢c+e¢} ·i<:. C¢°•'l‘LfO\}£.T`+r‘¤?’ s+cz+€men,+s .9; gud-I a.u°1*{¤en+·E¤+¤bn, hearsay,
ccnclxscry, experi- ¤pYn·1¢>n and :rr<2!e=vcm+.
?L.Tq+'.YP pfppges dilse. ¤B_IYz.·,+F¤¤s and ¢e.?..¤es+s ¤#·¢~.¤_ ;.¤.,.r+ jfve
imk anal Mr, S+q¢m€.»+ r+s aw, ¤mJae¤—q+;¤n. F1¤J»+.1`P Aves w+
\.mAers+¤v»A cieienéanps cL_g give elmse w.»¤s·2:l eqgk s+¤+eme»+ $.1 Ag+erm}mTqj. w}w. WL ¤\$ec·1-{gn; Kava w¤er.'+.
r ‘i”\¤:¤+·.££ wwlé me +0 ,30:.1+ mr 4c M m.»+ mr p»q:,,+·.rc ems
i§;¤L+qf.·.¤A an experi-, bur because kv, is ¤'¤é€5e»·z+,~·T¤r··-pvkm and ·...·{44w».L+
Emunsef M; has exi-rev··¤e. ¤§$£·p·`eu[+Tes c¤v>·:m.¤¤»'¢a+Tn3 wsié LM; in
¤¤-·»~1.,mH->,. p'1¤.J.`+!FP‘g exPe¤—+ prwicleé an qlipdquiy- wL.·`•;I·»
;.imZa+TW fvpk-mded +0 vyppse sqmmqry _,‘uAg·Me»·¢+ ···»T=Ha, b¤.d— H- was
s+r}c.ke»q LY Mm mQ3Is·I·ru{~e ¤,+ ¢£e£en5¤wr}'s reyuesi- because $1- was
•w+ p:—¤P¢r}7 c,rea-RJ by °f-hu. q·C£n`¤.m·I·, ¢>.<;c_0rcI·i»j J-0 ¤F;£eru£qn‘I· qvnd
_·H¤L w.¤,3:s+¤—a+@. HGDJQVQI", C+ fs p}¤,·;»·F.pp3' .¤f».’»».:¤»v ¢¥·w. Mr- R¤>BInsc:•w'S
;j¤.¤}(¤}¤~il· ·~.»¤s w+ Safely cm exper-} quiiéqvlh. bu-!· one cp q farmer
§‘e.~»··¤p|o3e4 J ·=l~k¤. Ae¥`c=.¤J¤m+. Plqf.»,+.‘DP l¤·al?¢uzs =r·¢·4. ¤;¤».¤r+ .sh¤¤.fJ sh'!}
irqcngfcizp ¤¤¢.2_ qP£TA,¤¤.‘-I-, cmd u,r;$+r:k( I+ for $¤•~»»···=¤r*y _3LqlgM@n+
Qase 2:O3—cv—O1344-EHC-HCE D0cumengg99 FiIed12/30/2005 Page20f4

g pwrpcses. Plq»'n·F.`l:l;l Bu: no wqnsel uml ls unqble 40 ”e;re.¤¢+eq an
l ¤£-lxdaufl Ter" VVl¢~,"l?c>lo•l¤s¢>n` like ..&zPen¤l P\¤Zm+-Ic? bgow qpppiyéaé counsel, 9+2; wml} w+ be q pmlylem, Burk
l :+ rs cwné ,,m¤,.·.,,+;lP slwulcl M he ,eml,‘u&. tls CN A¤!l€¤J;m+u-
wJs6‘l¤2—le»·v»em+ ·+lml· =1-fw, w¤¤··+ s+m¤k 4%, ·=l£¥TJ¤~2~l— Leequse Ji- was
pl¤C.·»+`.·l;lJ1>" ¤+-I·e~»»»?+ 4p olilier edclengg ¤L·li·}·¢r`éLl»sc:¤ver), clc>s·zcl· °?‘Z».T.¢ Z`.:
€¤ls<-2.°l°C¤. w·.m+ never sim! ¤H»»3s.l:°l¤.$.¤~Hlll? ima vw: Aw!-y 4..9 .;1l`s·l;l¤se·_
lllp¤,u"su¤m‘l’ #9 Ruje 3[ml, De-l:en¢lan+ made §1_____§_J; d•§wvel`y r~g;t»u,•g,¢:-l—5“___________ ____
am! pl¤,:n+‘.lI will make; °|'l-ze, qH¤r¢`¤¥`¢l¢:l·€ p¢‘e··l-r{·¤.,l cllkclasuf-e.S
Din cffru. q,pProPf`l¤•.+€ lime, —l2e—av··¤ca$.
Some alt A2C€¤‘!é¤T.H+l5 ¤l¤_{`¢d—»'¤··».< are sp .»[J§¢;ul¤u_5 +{m+ 1+ I;
. qppqrenf wunsel $¤·`lqd 4v even renal Wu. s$¤l—e»·¢€··¤l·» Exnmplej UG.
_ Wis ¤L_1`e.;+H0.q ¢—¤lYer; 44; ¤,¤ ¤Ql?·2[¤u.'+ gl? O.·;+¤Ler l‘l,£lOO°I, wlwlcll
_ I:. w+ referrecl 44: ln ¤#·L¤. .w·»>+mugr+£¤j s+q+c.MeM-.
\/¤l¢¤Op+;¤.».5’ qlsp Makes ¤L_;`¤_.;J-»'¤·»¤_s wp ~•·»,·¤u‘i'*BL€»»»·+i¢c>.l—ecl q{¤·:u»»¤e¤+S
T in :>¤l-Cer s+¤-\-e·~=e¤+s ».··'hEc.ln +l·uL rel?€Prey»;e• 4-¤ ¤~l»u2. •—·e<;¢>|`cl
4; pl¤,£»l+.‘l?£"s cum <=l¢cl¤m·l-Ion,
,Cc>·n£lv~S1};:»v¤
l lll Pla·l·»+·‘l:$ has p¤»¤l`JeJ ¤H-··`i<: »;¤·.m+ ·..»Z·H» venlcxwoncugs ¤.··~»mm+s up euiéencq
lrfwaclqclllng \/ql¤,eOP+l¤n5' ol¤+¤.`·n•l·5 4 sumnavy J·».éjMeml· and pmu·'U
élpl¤Lln+`»$l:ls c.l¤zlM5. Plqlnllfpls ln¤·.la$l?+y —l»¤ e€£ecFweLy Presen+ I-uk
.`_C¤LS€ +¤> 'Hv. ¤,¤u•—+~ because al: legcxl +2<;lmk,qlIHeJ cmé l•»·`$
_al¥n¢qrCer¤+·`¤n amcl lack ell legal counsel Should ·w+ be ¤·.s2¤l
.+¤ dlsmlsi his casa.
Uzl\a¤cl·2v;·l·l$ v*’2¤+»lm ’l:¢‘>¥` $~¤~¤=M·¤»¢`y ._|l»¤cl_gM&¤·} Slwulcl lee
fd2¤led,
l ‘l·‘ie_j¢C+.‘w cl? c1el;€nA¤··a+`s »w+·1m rs Fw 44.,; .l»l+,D~€;+
gal; _j.L;—+·'¤e cmcl ·C¤Jmess.
Case 2:O3—cv—O1344-EHC-HCE D0cumeng199 FiIed12/30/2005 Page30f4

R€5P€C+'Fv¢.HY °H1:$ QQ mg clay O.? D€C€|·‘*1L€[`°
Shannon M- G{¤.l"l< ·Pl¤.Znh
OT`;5:`•¤q, $0nQ cor.? VR/RRIOS +9; Chrk] Qur}, Sqnérq
Day Otc-GYWICJI" Cc¤ulI"'H»t0M’5€, U}. ‘}L)‘4_,$`q¤”rL3+pYI 5+- )
p)Lf9€VL;X A·r:zOr1c»` YSDOB ·3.`\|§
1 1 /9 rr - — 4 Y - ------ --»—--»-~»4 4 i V .... .2 222 eeeee
E One Qcfxy Malia; 'R}9~a)O`$ +05 H0h.j)rg+\"¤.€`.·{— C0¢.AF+ judgq Eflfl CAFPDU)
Sendm Day Ofonner W5- C¤¤r+L¤~;se, VO! W. \A}q,sL.'¤j4On 52}-. ., mac an Fx
Af¤Lz6v1q» ?$`DO3
0*12 LBP? ¤"I¢2*r|€C{ ’\.)@\"}'v!j .} KO1SfMJ)S|I·pQVVWQH 4=DC£V;5 , p.L.C,
1 F/WR7 M S¢¤»++sdq\e RA. ,5+% &_I.; 4,,—,5D¤q Qsasy

Qafse 2:03—cv—01344-EHC-HCE Documerglt 199 Filed 12/30/2005 Page 4 014

Case 2:03-cv-01344-EHC-HCE

Document 199

Filed 12/30/2005

Page 1 of 4

Case 2:03-cv-01344-EHC-HCE

Document 199

Filed 12/30/2005

Page 2 of 4

Case 2:03-cv-01344-EHC-HCE

Document 199

Filed 12/30/2005

Page 3 of 4

Case 2:03-cv-01344-EHC-HCE

Document 199

Filed 12/30/2005

Page 4 of 4