Free Brief in Opposition to Motion - District Court of Colorado - Colorado

Case 1:00-cv-02325-MSK-MEH

Document 333-5

Filed 05/17/2006

Page 1 of 2

EXHIBIT 4 IMPROPERLY BILLED TIME ON EPA AND WQCD MATTERS All billing entries are for Vranesh & Raisch, #314, Exhibit b to Exhibit 3. DATE 10/23/00 10/12/00 10/12/00 NAME - DESCRIPTION EJR - Mtg. w/Health Dept. JWR ­ Conf. w/EJR re: Section 309 Enforcement JSE ­ Conf. w/EJR re: research issue; westlaw search for 309 (g)(6)(ii) cases JSE ­ Conf. w/EJR; Retrieve 309(g) cases EJR ­ PC w/ Jerry G. EJR ­ Mtg. w/State EJR ­ Evaluate NOV option EJR ­ PC w/Jerry G. EJR ­ PC w/Jerry G. EJR ­ Prep. Outline for mtg with State; PC w/Jerry G. EJR ­ Conf w/State people re: permits EJR ­ PC w/ DOJ lawyer EJR ­ PC re: Permit terms EJR ­ PC w/Paul W.(DOJ) EJR ­ Conf w/Dave A. & Doug B. EJR ­ PC's w/ Jerry G. EJR ­ PC w/Jerry G. JWR ­ Conf w/EJR on EPA NOV EJR ­ PC with John M. EJR ­ PC with John M. re: tolling agmt EJR ­ Conf w/Doug B. and Dave H EJR ­ PC w/ Jerry G. EJR ­ PC w/Jerry G. EJR ­ PC w/John M. EJR ­ PC w/Jerry G. EJR ­ PC w/Jerry G. EJR ­ PC w/Jerry G. EJR ­ PC w/John M. EJR ­ PC w/Jerry G. EJR ­ Review Proposed CT permit application EJR ­ PC w/John M. EJR ­ PC w/Jerry G. EJR ­ PC to John M. TIME - AMOUNT 4.9 - $833.00 0.3 - $57.00 1.65 -$165.00

10/13/00 10/31/00 11/13/00 11/15/00 12/08/00 01/05/01 01/09/01 01/10/01 03/15/01 03/16/01 03/21/01 03/30/01 04/09/01 04/21/01 04/06/01 04/26/01 05/01/01 05/02/01 05/03/01 06/05/01 06/14/01 06/21/01 06/22/01 07/02/01 07/11/01 07/26/01 08/08/01 08/10/01 08/20/01 08/21/01

6.65 -$665.00 0.75 - $127.50 7.75 - $1317.50 1.0 - $170.00 0.25 - $42.50 4.8 - $840.00 2.05 - $358.75 5.8 - $1015.00 3.35 -$586.25 4.7 - $822.50 5.3 - $927.50 4.85 - $848.75 5.3 - $927.50 3.6 - $630.00 0.7 - $136.50 7.25 - $1268.75 11.0 - $1925.00 5.9 - $1032.50 0.85 - $148.75 1.8 - $315.00 0.4 - $70.00 1.25 - $218.75 0.15 - $26.25 3.25 - $568.75 0.5 - $87.50 1.6 - $280.00 2.1 - $367.50 0.25 - $43.75 1.55 - $271.25 0.8 - $140.00

Case 1:00-cv-02325-MSK-MEH

Document 333-5

Filed 05/17/2006

Page 2 of 2

08/22/01 08/23/01 10/02/01 10/05/01 10/23/01 10/25/01 12/12/2001 12/13/2001 12/14/2001 12/19/2001 02/01/2002 02/13/2002 02/14/2002 02/21/2002 02/25/2002 07/25/2002

10/01/2002 01/08/2003

02/28/2003

06/02/2003

01/10/2006 01/23/2006 01/26/2006 1/30/2006

EJR ­ Draft confidentiality ltr to Moscato, et al. EJR ­ Ltr to Moscato et al. EJR ­ Review tolling agmt EJR ­ PC to John M. EJR ­ PC to John M. EJR ­ PC w/ John M. EJR ­ phone calls with John M. EJR ­ phone call with Jerry G. EJR ­ phone call with Jerry G. EJR ­ phone call with Jerry G. EJR ­ phone call with Jerry G. EJR ­ phone call with Jerry G. EJR ­ Phone call with John M. EJR ­ Phone call with John M. EJR ­ Phone calls with John M. JWR ­ Conference with EJR re Roosevelt Tunnel permit denial ­review rationale EJR ­ prepare status report re agency settlement EJR ­ Prepare notice of consent agreement and renewal permit (I). SEM ­ portion of time to travel to EPA and Department of Health EJR - review disclaimer for water quality data. Review draft letter to EPA and State re 1998 memo on MT EJR ­ Phone call with Jerry G. EJR ­ phone call with Jerry G.; Email to Jerry G. EJR ­ phone call to Jerry G. EJR ­ Phone call with Jerry G.

1.35 - $236.25 1.85 - $323.75 1.9 - $332.50 2.6 - $455.00 8.0 - $1400.00 6.5 - $1137.50 0.60 - $105.00 5.7 - $997.50 3.2 - $560.00 0.55 - $96.25 0.7 - $126.00 5.25 - $945.00 5.05 - $909.00 2.4 - $432.00 9.0 - $1620.00 0.3 - $60.00

3.10 - $558.00 1.15 - $212.75

1.15 - $28.75

0.7 - $129.50

0.4 - $90.00 7.15 - $1608.75 1.55 - $348.75 7.65 - $1721.25