Free Other Notice - District Court of Arizona - Arizona

1 Paul M. Levine, Esq. (#007202)
McCARTHY Q HOLTHUS O LEVINE
2 3636 North Central Avenue
Suite 1050
3 Phoenix, Arizona 85012
(602) 230-8726
4 plevi11e@mcccrrt‘/igy-iiolrlzzzs.com
5
Maria Saiapska (#0195 85)
6 PERKINS COIE BROWN & BAIN P.A.
2901 North Central Avenue
7 Post Office Box 400
Phoenix, Arizona 85001-0400
8 (602) 351-8000
msalczpska@pe:~kir1sc0ie. com
9
Attorneys for Plaintiff/Couiiterdefendazat
10 Martyn Nutraceuticals, Inc. and Third Party Defendant Craig Knobloch
ll
UNITED STATES DISTRICT COURT
12
DISTRICT OF ARIZONA
13
14
MARILYN Ntirnacaoricars, nic, No-i CIV 024876 PHX-HRH
15 an Arizona corporation,
16 Piaintiff,
17 vs,
18 w1Lt.1A1v1 wom mia JANE nos wono,
iiussana and wife; 1¤Ara1c1<,ees1»n. asa JUDGMENT AGAINST
19 JANE noe eosin, husband ala wire; WORLD NIITRIIION ING
woken Nuiramon, inc., an Maxam WILLIAM AND MICHELLE
· 20 corporation; ABC Corporations 1-X; XYZ WONG AND PATRICK BUEHL
1 Partnerships 1~X; and J OHN DOES I-X and
21 JANE DOES I—X, husbands and wives,
22 respectively,
Defendants.
23
24
WORLD NUTRITION, INC, an Arizona
25 corporation,
26 . .
Third Party Plaint:t`f`/Counte1·olannant/
27 Defendant,
28
Case 2:02—cv—01876-HRH Document 323-2 Filed 10/26/2007 Page 1 014

l
vs.
2
3
MARLYN NUTRACEUTICALS, INC., an
4 Arizona corporation; and CRAIG
,5 KNOBLOCH,
6 Counterdefendant/Plaintiff/Third
Party Defendant
7
8 This matter having come before the Court on Plaintiff Marlyn
9 Nutraceuticals, Incfs Motion for Award ofExe1npla1y Damages and for a Permanent
10
Injunction and the Court having read and considered Marlyn’s Motion, Defendants
ll
I2 Responses and Marlyn°s Reply, and the Court finding that World Nutrition wiilfully and
E3 maliciously inisappropriated Marlyn’s Customer List and that Marlyn is entitled to
It exemplary damages pursuant to A.R.S. § 44-·403(I·3), and good cause appearing;
15
IT IS THEREFORE ORDERED granting Plaintiffs Motion for Award
16
17 for Exemplary Damages pursuant to Arizonafs Trade Secrets Act, A.R.S. § 44-403(B);
18 IT IS FURTHER ORDERED granting judgment in favor of the Plaintiff,
19 Mariyn Nutraceuticals, Inc., an Arizona corporation, against Defendant World Nutrition,
20
Inc., an Arizona corporation, as foitows:
I 21
22 Coinpensatory Damages: $ 25,575.00
Exemplary Damages: S 5i.l50.00
23
24 TOTAL JUDGMENT AMOUNT: § 76,725.00
25 IT IS FURTHER ORDERED that interest shall accrue on the total
26 judgment amount at the rate of 424% per annum from the date of judgment until paid in
27 full.
28
Case 2:02-cv-01876-HRH Document 32322 Filed 10/26/2007 Page 2 of 4

1 IT IS FURTHER ORDERED that World Nutrition, Inc,, William
2 Wong, Patrick Buehl, and their officers, agents, servants, employees, and ail persons
Z acting in concert or participation with them or any of them who will receive actual notice
5 of the C0ll1‘“€’S order by personal services or otherwise, are enjoined for a term of tive
6 years after the entry of judgment from using the attached customer list to send direct
7 mailings and from using the attached list to contact directly, by telephone, in person, via
; facsimile, or any other means of communication, any person on the attached customer
10 list;
1] IT IS FURTHER ORDERED that World Nutrition, Inc,, William Wong,
12 and their officers, agents, servants, employees, and aii persons acting in concert or
13 participation with them or any of them who will receive actual notice of the court’s order
by personal services or otherwise, are permanently enjoined from stating in any form of
16 advertising or customer contact that Wobenzyrn has been infected with or quarantined
17 because of "inad cow disease" (bovine spongifonn encephalopathy) or any simiiar
18 characterization of Wobenzym;
· IT IS FURTHER ORDERED that World Nutrition, Inc,, William Wong,
‘ 2] and their oflicers, agents, servants, ernpioyees, and all persons acting in concert or
22 participation with them or any of them who wiii receive actual notice of the court’s order
23 by personal service or otherwise, are permanently enjoined trom making any false
statements with respect to comparisons of Vitalzyrn to Wobenzym.
26
27
28
Case 2:02-cv-01876-HRH Document 32332 Filed 10/26/2007 Page 3 of 4

l IT IS FURTHER ORDERED that there is no just reason for delay and the
2 Clerk is directed to enter this Iudgment forthwith.
3
DONE IN OPEN COURT .
4
5
6 iionoraiile H. Russel Holland
7
8
9 I hereby certify that on August 24th, 2007,
I electronically transmitted the attached
W Document to the Clerlds Office using the
ll CM/ECP System for filing and transmittal
Of a Notice of Electronic Filing to the following
12 CM/ECP registrants:
33 Maria Salapska, Esq.
14 PERKINS COIE BROWN & BAIN PA.
2901 North Central Avenue
15 Phoenix, Arizona S500}-0400
16
17 Stephen D. I-loftinan, Esq.
Lewis Brisbois Bisgaard & Smith LLP
li? 2929 N. Central Ave., Suite 1700
19 Phoenix, Arizona 85012
Attorneys for Defendants, Counter-
, 20 Claimant and Third Party Plaintiff
V 21 Pete Boyle, Esq.
22 Jones, Skelton & Hochuli
2901 N. Central, Suite 800
23 Phoenix, Arizona 850l2
24 Attorney for Defendant Patrick Buehi
25 /s/ Linda S. Ream
26
27
28
Case 2:02-cv-01876-HRH Document 32342 Filed 10/26/2007 Page 4 of 4

Case 2:02-cv-01876-HRH

Document 323-2

Filed 10/26/2007

Page 1 of 4

Case 2:02-cv-01876-HRH

Document 323-2

Filed 10/26/2007

Page 2 of 4

Case 2:02-cv-01876-HRH

Document 323-2

Filed 10/26/2007

Page 3 of 4

Case 2:02-cv-01876-HRH

Document 323-2

Filed 10/26/2007

Page 4 of 4